Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To charge family for baby bits

395 replies

Cymruhills · 24/02/2024 23:13

My brother and his wife have recently discovered they're going to be parents for the first time and we, as well as other people have offered them baby things we no longer need.

So far I've mainly gifted them blankets, clothing and smaller items such as a steryliser and a bottle warmer.

We saw them today and they began listing some items they still need to get. Some of which they know we still have as our youngest is still using them/will be growing out of them soon. They were more expensive items (think £100+ to buy new) and things which I would have sold on, to try and make some money back in order to buy things which my children need.

I mentioned that we have some of the items they are looking for and explained that I'd happily pass them on to them but because they're slightly more expensive, I'd just like the amount for them that I would have sold them for (item dependant, but around 25% of the RRP).

My brother looked shocked that I'd mentioned buying them instead of them being gifted, like the other items I've previously given them. My DH says I should just loan them the things and when they're done, sell them then. Things felt a bit awkward and they left soon after.

I'm reluctant to loan the items as they will be in worse condition than they are now and also, it would be quite nice to have the money to spend now, for things that we need for my DC's, not in a year or so.

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
Zone2NorthLondon · 25/02/2024 12:13

It’s fair enough you want to sell on, that’s ok,but not ok to sell to family
so politely explain you’ll resell the items and they’re unavailable to them
that way you get the resale and no strained familial relationships

QuickFriday · 25/02/2024 12:10

I would give to them free or sell to somebody else - but now that you offered to sell to them it looks bad on you

They are 1st time parents to be and can’t yet understand where you are coming from

Theoware · 25/02/2024 12:05

Your brother is being unreasonable - as PPs have said, it was good for you to make the situation clear now as otherwise they sound like they would be looking to get everything else handed down over the years too.

I remember another thread where someone had loaned their pram/bed/other expensive thing for a time to friends and then the friends wouldn’t return it and probably would have sold it on without a thought. OP should not have to subsidise her brother just because she had kids first.

wronginalltherightways · 25/02/2024 12:03

YANBU

If you could afford it AND wanted to, great, give the stuff to them.

But there are a lot of posts on MN these days about families struggling to afford to have children, make ends meet, etc, and the suggestions about buying second hand and selling on your own things on to save money. Rather contradictory for posters to insist on this thread that the OP should just be handing over their expensive baby items 'because family'.

'Because family' doesn't pay the bills for OP. 'Because family' doesn't help OP sell off old baby things to buy new to them child things for their own child. 'Because family' doesn't magically mean an arm's length relationship with her brother entitles him to save his family money at OP's family's expense.

Sell the stuff on if you need to, OP. YANBU.

Readytoevolve · 25/02/2024 12:02

I am with you OP. It’s CF to expect those big ticket items for free.
No way would I “give away” my silvercross pram, my top of the range next to me, my baby bjorn bouncer. At the end of the day, you can resell these items, and it takes the bite out of the initial purchase knowing you might get it back. I suggest pausing Amy further “giving” or “selling” conversations. Just discreetly stick to your own plan.

You’ve made your position clear.
Please don’t “lend”, either, you’ll never get them back in same condition because some people just don’t respect items they haven’t worked hard to pay for.

LakeTiticaca · 25/02/2024 11:56

Perfectly acceptable IMHO to sell large items. Why should you give them away for nothing?

FuzzyManul · 25/02/2024 11:54

Cymruhills · 24/02/2024 23:26

It was all said in a sort of 'we still need x, y and z. You still have yours, don't you?' so I sort of had to acknowledge the fact that yes we do and I'm happy to pass them on but unfortunately, unlike the smaller bits, I would have liked some money for it as I had been planning on selling them anyway.

All you need to do is to tell your brother and his wife that your priority is money.

828Pax · 25/02/2024 11:53

I don't think that YABU. I did give my brother all of my baby bits at no charge...I was happy to help them and also it is lovely to see DN get use out of it all. I could have done with the money myself but I was happier to see them get use out of it. That being said, I don't see anything wrong with you asking for a bit of money towards it if you were planning on selling it.

Princessfluffy · 25/02/2024 11:52

You have already given them some baby stuff and doubtless will buy a present when the baby is born.

I think this is enough and it's up to you whether you sell the pricier items or give them to your bro. It doesn't sound like they are struggling for money and it does sound like you would miss the money yourself.

Stay away from "loaning" things at all costs, it's too easy to come unstuck with this.

QueSyrahSyrah · 25/02/2024 11:51

Shinyandnew1 · 25/02/2024 11:38

I’ve had friends say to me, ‘ooh, I love that-let me know if you’re selling it at any point’ which I have.

I've done this too. I've got 'first dibs' on my friends' little boy's amazing Jumperoo when he grows out of it and the conversation was very clear that I'll pay whatever she'd look to sell it for.

anothernewstart9 · 25/02/2024 11:45

YANBU

You've kindly gifted him the smaller items but quite rightly want to sell the more expensive ones so the money can be put towards future purchases for your own DC.

Since you are in roughly the same financial position you need to be firm from the beginning otherwise you'll have years and years of him expecting a free supply of your DCs clothes/toys at your expense.

Floralnomad · 25/02/2024 11:45

IMustDoMoreExercise · 25/02/2024 11:39

Great, but perhaps you are in a better financial position than the OP?

She was asking if she was being unreasonable and of course she isn't if she needs the money to buy other things.

She has at no point said she needs the money , she said she would like it to buy other stuff for the kids . I suppose it boils down to whether you value your relationships more than money .

bumphope2020 · 25/02/2024 11:43

@Cymruhills I don't think asking for money is unreasonable at all. My sister in law offered us clothes etc, but some things she said I'm going to sell x,y,z, but I'm happy to sell to you if you want. Only difference to you is we didn't ask or expect anything from anyone. Babies are so expensive, seems unfair they get everything for free and you aren't allowed to recoup any of your costs just because they are family

TheWayTheLightFalls · 25/02/2024 11:42

Your brother walked into this situation with his question. You’ve done nothing wrong imo.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 25/02/2024 11:40

Shinyandnew1 · 25/02/2024 11:38

I’ve had friends say to me, ‘ooh, I love that-let me know if you’re selling it at any point’ which I have.

Exactly. That is the way to ask for expensive things, not the way her brother did, just expecting them for free.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 25/02/2024 11:39

Floralnomad · 25/02/2024 11:36

I didn’t charge friends for our old baby stuff ( twice) so certainly wouldn’t charge family .

Great, but perhaps you are in a better financial position than the OP?

She was asking if she was being unreasonable and of course she isn't if she needs the money to buy other things.

Shinyandnew1 · 25/02/2024 11:38

I’ve had friends say to me, ‘ooh, I love that-let me know if you’re selling it at any point’ which I have.

Bundeena · 25/02/2024 11:38

We gifted baby stuff to a relative that included some items we could have sold for decent money (e.g. a next to me). In total we probably could have made at least £250 selling everything second hand. But I figure what goes around comes around (they may never give us any hand me downs for our child given ours is older, but they have helped us in many other ways). But I appreciate it depends how much you need that £250 (or however much yours is worth). What I would say is to make sure they actually need/want the items you are gifting - I didn't give them a couple of items that they were unlikely to need and I will sell them privately.

Floralnomad · 25/02/2024 11:36

I didn’t charge friends for our old baby stuff ( twice) so certainly wouldn’t charge family .

IMustDoMoreExercise · 25/02/2024 11:36

Cymruhills · 25/02/2024 08:25

Brother does indeed have form for being a CF and in life generally just expects things from people, without giving the same in return.

I'd say we're in an equal financial position.

I didn't specify an amount I'd like for each item (as I'd hoped to breeze over the conversation) and used 25% as a ballpark figure for the purpose of this thread, to show that I wasn't (in my opinion) being cheeky with my expectations of what I could get for the items.

We had been talking about the new baby and so I guess was relevant to what we were talking about when DB said "we still need to get this, this and this" there was a pause, I think in anticipation for me to offer the things and when I said nothing, he said "you still have yours, don't you?" hence why I was taken aback and wasn't sure how to respond.

I think this says everything:

Brother does indeed have form for being a CF and in life generally just expects things from people, without giving the same in return.

I agree that he should give you the same amount as you would have sold them for if he is like that.

Shinyandnew1 · 25/02/2024 11:36

’DParent says you have X to give us'

How rude! What did you say to that?!

diddl · 25/02/2024 11:35

If it's "grim" to charge family, isn't it equally "grim" to expect to be given just because you are family?

melj1213 · 25/02/2024 11:27

Janetime · 25/02/2024 11:17

Well you went off on an unnecessary rant. 😂 she said she needed the money for her kids and they’d do without otherwise . That’s why the convo is where it is.

Yes, I'm aware of that but my point still stands.

If I have an item I want to sell I should not have to justify why I am selling the item rather than giving it away to family by explaining "We need the money".

The fact I have an item in my possession, that I own but no longer need/want and that has resale value should be justification enough. I earn just over NMW, one of my brothers is on £80k a year, we both know this fact but our daily finances are totally private, if he was selling something that I wanted/needed I wouldn't just assume that because he earns so much more than me that he would give it to me for nothing, but I also wouldn't expect him to explain why he was selling an item for £50 when he has so much disposable income compared to me that he doesn't need £50.

Why should people have to tell others about their financial position in order to justify selling their own items? I could give things away on a daily basis and not be left destitute but selling them instead gives me a bit more money in my budget and parents shouldn't have to justify why they don't/won't give baby/children's things away.

LolaSmiles · 25/02/2024 11:27

How very Mumsnet for so many people to be telling OP she should give away potentially £100’s worth of stuff for free.

Some people just have no idea what it’s like to need the money.
This, and it's not just a case of need the money for bills/food, it's just not having the disposable cash to given hundreds, if not thousands of pounds of kit away.

I accept hand me downs and pass things on, but higher value items are sold so DC can have nicer things.

Then again this is Mumsnet where people wonder how anyone can afford children on under £50k a year and there's dozens of threads from people who've chosen to have a huge mortgage for a nice house in a nice area insisting that they feel really poor because £80k a year doesn't go that far.

WeightoftheWorld · 25/02/2024 11:20

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 24/02/2024 23:53

I’ve never heard of anyone being rude enough to outright ask a sibling for baby big ticket items.

The brother started any awkwardness by being rude and presumptuous

Tbh I agree with this. We had this in our own family recently except the sibling clearly knew they were being a CF and used to get parents to ask us for them instead, or say things like 'DParent says you have X to give us' etc! Was so rude and they did it loads of times. In our case we did gift some items (without being asked for them) but the rest of the stuff we were keeping as we were still thinking we may expand our family further and would need them. Which we didn't want to say to people (why should we?). As it happens I am now pregnant again so pleased I didn't feel pressured into giving all the stuff away.