Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you allow your 17-year-old to…

379 replies

Topray · 24/02/2024 18:29

Have completely unrestricted and unsupervised phone access (so not even having to leave phone downstairs at nighttime)

Work part-time if still at school or college.

Learn to drive (either self-funded from wages or with parental help)

Travel in a car driven by a 17-year-old

Stay overnight at the home of a friend you do not know

Use public transport alone at night

Regulate their own sleep, even if this means getting out of bed at 3pm on a weekend

Stay home alone overnight or for multiple days

Be out and about without you know really knowing exactly where they are at any given moment

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 24/02/2024 20:51

Topray · 24/02/2024 18:29

Have completely unrestricted and unsupervised phone access (so not even having to leave phone downstairs at nighttime)

Work part-time if still at school or college.

Learn to drive (either self-funded from wages or with parental help)

Travel in a car driven by a 17-year-old

Stay overnight at the home of a friend you do not know

Use public transport alone at night

Regulate their own sleep, even if this means getting out of bed at 3pm on a weekend

Stay home alone overnight or for multiple days

Be out and about without you know really knowing exactly where they are at any given moment

My dd is 15.

She’s had unfettered access to her phone since lockdown. Sensible girl, never any issues. Now has tv and console in her room too but doesn’t game often.

She doesn’t work but I’m fine with the principle.

Learn to drive. There is a question as to whether she will legally be allowed to drive. I fully support her learning if able.

Travel in a car driven by a 17 yo. Hasn’t come up yet, I’m sure it will soon. Nervous but I have to accept she’s growing up so yes.

She has already stayed the night at people’s houses I don’t know and has been doing so since secondary started.

Public transport alone especially at night is a touchy one for me due to medical condition.

Staying at home for multiple days and some overnights. Theoretically fine. I’d want to be able to check up on her due to the medical condition.

She is already out and about with me not knowing exactly where she is. I do use the tracker really mostly to check where her school bus is as I collect her from the stop.

duvet · 24/02/2024 20:50

@Tayegete - my 18 DD who has ADHD &ASD confessed to me today that in the last 3 months she has sent nudes of herself to 6 different people, including a 32 year old and that she felt sick about it. She's done this at least a couple of times in the past and school/college intervened, we didnt know til then. It tends to occur in the evenings she said and in the past we restricted overnight access to her phone but now that she is 18 that feels more difficult. We could turn the wifi off earlier, so there's less temptation. She says she wants help but then she doesn't comply. I suppose but I could be flamed for that as she's 18 but then she is not like other 18 year olds I know including my own older DC at that age, she would struggle to be left alone for a few days, maybe for one night. She talks to strangers online when she knows she shouldn't so I feel nervous when she's out.
So in answer to some of those questions I guess it depends on the child? But also not meaning to hijack but what would you do in my situation??

TotoroElla · 24/02/2024 20:49

My DS is almost 17.

He has unrestricted phone use.
He works part time and is at college
I'm getting him driving lessons for his birthday
Travelling in the car of another 17yo wouldn't fill me with joy but unless I had reason to believe they were a bad driver, I'd not say anything beyond safety reminders
I'd let him stay over night with a friend I didn't know as long as I could get hold of him on his phone
Public transport I'd be fine with although he usually walks home from his job
I let him regulate his own sleep. I mean honestly, if you never let them, they never learn. He's always up for college/work/social plans
I've not let him stay home alone overnight yet but, it's not come up. I'm sure he'd be fine. I'd probably rather he had someone over for company. I'd not do multiple days at this stage - I'd want to build up.
I don't need to know his every movement. Just ask him to let me know when he's on his way home.

LarkspurLane · 24/02/2024 20:49

It's a long wait for driving tests round here so not that many 17 year olds have cars. I'd be really nervous about that one, but as a woman in my 50s I really wouldn't want to get into a car with a 17 year old either.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 24/02/2024 20:45

One of my daughters has not got in a car with a 17 year old yet.

ElizabethCage · 24/02/2024 20:45

Yes to all

IloveAslan · 24/02/2024 20:45

I was living in another town, staying with a friend and in full-time work at 16.

Wigtopia · 24/02/2024 20:44

I was did almost all of that at 17. The last one, I would keep my mum informed if I was out late. She always knew where I was, and what time I anticipated would be home. If plans changed - for example unexpected a house party/ staying out at a friends house or that I would be home closer to midnight rather than 9pm etc, I would drop her a message to update her of my plans. Same for my teens. But to be honest, I think this is fairly standard “good form” for adults/teenagers living together to make sure people are not worried about each other.

Me and DH will update each other of our whereabouts if our late/plans change and we are in our late 40s!!!

Carpediemmakeitcount · 24/02/2024 20:44

Mostly yes but they haven't stayed over a strangers house and I know where they are going when they go out. I want to teach them to let someone know where you are in case anything happens .ore of a safety thing. Yes to everything else.

YouJustDoYou · 24/02/2024 20:43

I did at that age, because I had no choice. Dad dead .Stepfather dead. Alcoholic mother of no use. Did and organised absolutelt everything myself.

LessOfMe99 · 24/02/2024 20:34

Yes to everything except multiple nights home alone. But probably because this just hasn't come up. They do stay multiple nights away from home with friends/partner.

Hiddenvoice · 24/02/2024 20:34

Yes, when I was 17 I worked part time, I used my pay to pay for my own phone and for driving lessons. I supported myself as much as I could. I checked in when I was going out at night and would stay at friends houses regularly. I wasn’t asked to check in but always felt it was kind to let my parents know if I was going to be out most of the night.
Only thing that really bothered my parents was staying in bed most of the day but I quickly grew out of it.

Startingagainandagain · 24/02/2024 20:32

At 17 I was already at university and living on my own...

Baguetted · 24/02/2024 20:31

Yes to everything apart from the first the wifi switches off at midnight

I can’t cope with bad tempered teens who didn’t get enough sleep

we do all have find my friends for each other for safety it’s just what we do

Eze · 24/02/2024 20:28

Yes.

However I’d be very worried about this one “Travel in a car driven by a 17-year-old” because there was an accident about a mile from here where a 17 year old lost control of his car and killed a 17 year old passenger and seriously injured another.

All lovely kids too.

CrikeyMajikey · 24/02/2024 20:28

Yes.

Growlybear83 · 24/02/2024 20:20

Oops I didn't read the final couple of points when I posted earlier. Whilst I was fine with everything else, I would never have left my daughter at home overnight on her own. I wouldn't have trusted her to lock up properly or set the alarm, but most of all, I wouldn't have trusted her not to have had a party. Once she was old enough to go more or less where she wanted, I always asked thst I knew roughly where she was going and to let me know if she was going to be home much later than expected so thst I wouldn't worry.

I can remember one of my daughter's best friends being terrified in school on the day of all the terrorist attacks in central London many years ago because she knew her mum was in the area of one of the incidents and she couldn't contact her. My daughter and I both agreed then that we would always find a way of contacting each other if there was an emergency that one of us could have been caught up in. I was so relieved that we had that agreement as she currently lives in Turkey and travelled to Gazientep regularly, which was one of the areas badly affected in the earthquake last year. Almost as soon as the news started to come through about the earthquake, she was in touch. She's also got in touch quickly with the two more recent , but much smaller, earthquakes in Istanbul.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 24/02/2024 20:05

Yes to all of the above.

HelpMebeok · 24/02/2024 20:04

Yes to most.

I like to know where they are staying. And at least speak to a parent if I don't know them.

Wallywobbles · 24/02/2024 20:03

Yes to all.

jimmymcg · 24/02/2024 20:03

Yes to all - Dd17

LBFseBrom · 24/02/2024 20:03

It's a long time since mine was seventeen but i remember it well and the answer is, "Yes", though I don't remember us going away and leaving overnight, in fact I'm sure we didn't. However, everything else was the norm.

Kalevala · 24/02/2024 20:02

Tayegete · 24/02/2024 19:46

Would be interested to hear from parents of ND children whether their answers would be the same. Mine would be yes to unsupervised phone access, regulating own sleep and staying over with a friend I don’t know but would take her there and back and meet parents that way. No to everything else.

I'm autistic and did everything on that list. I even stayed at a YH alone at 15 after my parents lied about my age!

SunflowerSeeds123 · 24/02/2024 20:01

Yes to all of them, except the transport one. Either get the bus/tube home with a friend, or get a black cab. No going home by yourself at night.

Kalevala · 24/02/2024 20:00

Yes to most.

Travel in a car driven by a 17-year-old
It hasn't happened yet as none have their own cars, one has passed. I would not like it during night time hours, say 11pm to 5am.

Use public transport alone at night
I would offer to collect late at night, or would collect from the station. Nothing to do with being 17, I'd offer for adults travelling alone.

Regulate their own sleep, even if this means getting out of bed at 3pm on a weekend
Sleepovers or occasional gaming sessions can mean an 11am wake up, followed by an early night. Never a day/night switch. I usually cook us both breakfast on other days so he will get up for coffee and eggs!

Swipe left for the next trending thread