Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to go for a meal

62 replies

HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 16:15

...and day out with childless sister and partner who I've only just met.

To cut a long story short, me and my sister were estranged for 6 years. During this time she made absolutely no contact with my children, no cards, nothing. My dm felt this was taken out on my dcs, and repeatedly asked my sister to make contact, as she was missing out on seeing them grow. If it was my nieces/nephews I wouldn't do that, but me and my sister are very different people. We went no contact when my oldest child was 2, and my youngest who is now 4 she has never met until now.

A close relative passed away. This brought us back together. She apologised for the awful things she had said at the time, and we got back in touch. Since then we have had them around twice at our home, during the visits they were very awkward with my dcs, and didn't really know what to say to them. I had never met her partner of 4 years until now as well. One of my dc's is on the spectrum, and already gets quite overwhelmed to begin with.

During the second visit of meeting my dc she sort of put me on the spot. She tried to arrange a meal with me, my family, her and partner, and my dm for Mother's day. I said I wouldn't want to do that, as like to spend my mother's day basically being a bit lazy. She reluctantly said okay after abit "I thought it would be nice as you are a mother etc etc." I thought yes, I have been Mother for 6 years, and haven't suggested anything like that before apart from the very first one thay didn't go well. It would be no fun at all for me navigating overwhelmed children etc.

Then a day out and meal was suggested, quiet bookshop etc. This wouldn't suit my dcs at all, and tbh would be far too overwhelming for dc1.

Me and dh both feel this was all far too soon given the situation. We haven't even been over to where they live yet. They can't have dcs, and it feels very much that my sister is trying to fill a 6 year gap in a matter of weeks.

They have a very extravagant lifestyle, no experience with children which is fine. Bit my sister has already asked numerous questions relating to things she hates about her childhood, and were we doing those things with ours. For example "I hate ipads," "children should be visiting museums/national trust/arty places every weekend, I never ate out as a child or had friends over, went to extra curriculum activities, do yours do that."

We feel very much that our parenting is under a spotlight, and that they are moving at far too fast a pace.

What is your view on this?

OP posts:
adriftinadenofvipers · 24/02/2024 17:54

I wouldn't have known how to behave around children until I had my own. Plus your children are strangers to her. Give her a chance.

Bubblybooboo · 24/02/2024 17:46

Wstpi · 24/02/2024 17:44

Precisely. If her child sees and hears her being discriminatory to other people with similar behaviour, e.g being overwhelmed in social situations, they may internalise this and fear other people will refer to their behaviour in negative ways causing them significant anxiety when they encounter similar situations.

What has op done/said that is discriminatory?

Wstpi · 24/02/2024 17:44

Bubblybooboo · 24/02/2024 17:36

You say you child gets overwhelmed. Your sis and her partner were overwhelmed but this isn’t ok. Adjustments should be made for your children but (black and white thinking) DSis and her partner should mask and follow social norms.

It’s Ops responsibility to manage her child’s needs not to manage her DS needs. If DS is overwhelmed she needs to take responsibility for managing that. Also that was about a visit to Ops house. Her child couldn’t leave their home DS could and it was her who wanted to visit with the children present.

Precisely. If her child sees and hears her being discriminatory to other people with similar behaviour, e.g being overwhelmed in social situations, they may internalise this and fear other people will refer to their behaviour in negative ways causing them significant anxiety when they encounter similar situations.

Bubblybooboo · 24/02/2024 17:36

You say you child gets overwhelmed. Your sis and her partner were overwhelmed but this isn’t ok. Adjustments should be made for your children but (black and white thinking) DSis and her partner should mask and follow social norms.

It’s Ops responsibility to manage her child’s needs not to manage her DS needs. If DS is overwhelmed she needs to take responsibility for managing that. Also that was about a visit to Ops house. Her child couldn’t leave their home DS could and it was her who wanted to visit with the children present.

DeedlessIndeed · 24/02/2024 17:35

HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 17:32

As for awkwardness, meeting altogether was ds's idea. I suggested to meet without dcs, just her etc. It was refused.

To me this shows her commitment. Even though she feels awkward she is trying to build a relationship.

Also one-on-one might feel very intense for her given your history. Hence why she's trying to involve wider family. Of course, it is up to you whether you accept or decline the invitations etc, but she is trying. And her requests haven't been ridiculously unreasonable that I can see.

HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 17:32

As for awkwardness, meeting altogether was ds's idea. I suggested to meet without dcs, just her etc. It was refused.

OP posts:
HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 17:31

I do agree about the difficulty of nc with dcs etc. She was welcome to contact me at any time, I wouldn't have stopped contact. When I gave birth to my 2nd child I sent picture, name, weight etc. No response.

OP posts:
DeedlessIndeed · 24/02/2024 17:29

Just putting it out there, a lot of people without children can find them a bit awkward to be around at first.

The fake laugh, the refusal to engage in role play "games" and the ignorance of what would be child friendly all seem to be very normal behaviours for some people who have spent very little time around them.

Also not defending DSis, as she was in the wrong originally, but it takes some guts to try to build back a relationship after acting badly. Lesser people would continue NC to save face. But it does seem that DSis is trying to make amends. Even if it feels awkward and stilted right now.

HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 17:28

Thank you @Wstpi but alot of what you said wasn't correct. Maybe I didn't explain my posts well, I apologise for that.

OP posts:
Wstpi · 24/02/2024 17:25

To cut a long story short, me and my sister were estranged for 6 years. During this time she made absolutely no contact with my children, no cards, nothing.

Black and white thinking. If no contact with DSis this means no contact with her family.

Same with you. V.black and white, DSis can go no contact with me but can’t go no contact. Strong sense of right and wrong - DSis didn’t do what I thought was right, she is wrong.

Since then we have had them around twice at our home, during the visits they were very awkward with my dcs, and didn't really know what to say to them. I had never met her partner of 4 years until now as well. One of my dc's is on the spectrum, and already gets quite overwhelmed to begin

She said she wouldn't be comfortable with this, and wanted to come over with her partner. It almost made me feel like I was being unreasonable about her partner (who I had only met in the hospital acouple of times). I felt my dcs being comfortable was the most important thing

they didn't really seem interested with my dcs, when they were visiting us. My sister's partner didn't speak at all to them, and awkward faint laughed.
My sister seems like she couldn't really be bothered to play with them. My dcs tried to role play with my sister, and she wasn't very interested. It became almost like my dcs were just there in the background.

You say you child gets overwhelmed. Your sis and her partner were overwhelmed but this isn’t ok. Adjustments should be made for your children but (black and white thinking) DSis and her partner should mask and follow social norms.

Above is just two examples, you might think you’re NT but the way you present and the way you talk about your sis you both come across as though your ND.

If you sis has had a lifetime of you dismissing her needs and painting her as the bad guy when she needs help (such as social support) or when she’s overwhelmed and struggles to role play, it’s not surprising she eventually lost her temper with you (aka had a melt down) and then went NC with you

sprigatito · 24/02/2024 17:22

I think you need to do some soul-searching and decide whether you really want to be back in contact or whether you are still too angry, because at the moment it sounds like you've got a foot in each camp.

You're resentful that she didn't contact your children while you were estranged. To a lot of people this isn't strange at all, she had no access to them while you had no relationship with her and many people would consider it inappropriate and confusing for the children for an estranged relative to send cards etc. If you really want to repair the relationship you will have to let that go.

You resent that she suggests things that may be unsuitable for your children - she doesn't know them, and doesn't have any of her own, so of course she won't always get that right. If you want a better relationship with her you will need to communicate your/your child's needs and find compromises; at the moment you're still so angry that you're interpreting everything she does as evidence that she's horrible and doesn't care about you.

She probably has her own grief and hurt about the estrangement, the time she's lost with her sister's children and not being able to have children herself. She's putting that aside to try to repair things and has apologised. I think you really need to think whether you truly want this reconciliation - you don't have to, you can decide that the damage is too great - but make your mind up and commit to either drawing a line under the past and building a new relationship, or not. Being half-hearted, suspicious and resentful is just going to lead to more hurt.

Tashface · 24/02/2024 17:18

MentalLoadOverload · 24/02/2024 17:00

Just leave DCs with your DH and go to the day/meal out. You need to rebuild the relationship with your sister; leave the DC out of it until that’s done.

This.

EmilyTjP · 24/02/2024 17:17

Slobberchops1 · 24/02/2024 16:42

Give her a break . She’s trying to be nice and obviously thinks she’s doing the right thing . Yeah she doesn’t get the difficulty of taking children out but there’s no need to be so arsey about it .

you obviously don’t want to stay in contact with her

This.

You sound hard work and like you think you’re superior because you have kids.

HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 17:11

Oh but admittedly stubborn!

OP posts:
HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 17:11

@Wstpi we are both NT.

OP posts:
HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 17:09

@Bubblybooboo very much so, it was always "oh that's just the way she is." I have always been reprimanded for anything, she has gotten away with everything pretty much. Even with no contact it was always me that was made to feel in the wrong. Dh thinks my parents, and I walked on eggshells around her, for fear of her reactions.

I am hoping ds has mellowed abit in 6 years, being happy with her partner etc.

OP posts:
Wstpi · 24/02/2024 17:06

Sounds like your sister might feel uncomfortable around you and is using her partner and family for social support.

Have you considered that yourself and your sister clash because your both ND and have conflicting needs/struggle with rigidity of thought?

Bubblybooboo · 24/02/2024 17:06

HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 16:56

@Bubblybooboo thank you. I have given ds another chance, and I'm trying for the sake of my dcs, and my dm who doesn't like us not speaking. I am trying to not offend ds while also staying true to myself, and safeguarding my dcs. I don't want relatives in and out of their lives.

Given that you sister is borderline rude about your parents and largely ignores your children. I wonder what value having her in their life will bring for your Dcs? Not a lot I’d imagine. Or is it that you have an idealised view of what it could be like if they have an aunt they had a lovely relationship with? Is it likely she will be a positive person in DCs lives or will she start making sly comments about them, and will everyone be expected to accept that too?

Bubblybooboo · 24/02/2024 17:03

HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 16:53

@PonyPatter44 I did which is the strange thing. I don't know why ds didn't. Alot of the hangups on the childhood she has I don't have. She has a lot higher standards and expectations than I do. My parents always passed it off as "she has no tact, doesn't mean it etc."

So your parents enable her negative comments to you? She’s allowed to “get away “ with saying passive aggressive sly comments?

MentalLoadOverload · 24/02/2024 17:00

Just leave DCs with your DH and go to the day/meal out. You need to rebuild the relationship with your sister; leave the DC out of it until that’s done.

HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 16:58

I also agree with saying no. I said no to mothers day, and now will to the day out/bookshop/food, with it being far too much too soon. Ds is used to most ppl doing what she wants, so I'm not sure how this will go.

OP posts:
HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 16:56

@Bubblybooboo thank you. I have given ds another chance, and I'm trying for the sake of my dcs, and my dm who doesn't like us not speaking. I am trying to not offend ds while also staying true to myself, and safeguarding my dcs. I don't want relatives in and out of their lives.

OP posts:
HateConflict22 · 24/02/2024 16:53

@PonyPatter44 I did which is the strange thing. I don't know why ds didn't. Alot of the hangups on the childhood she has I don't have. She has a lot higher standards and expectations than I do. My parents always passed it off as "she has no tact, doesn't mean it etc."

OP posts:
PonyPatter44 · 24/02/2024 16:49

Did you really not have friends over, or go out for dinner when you were children?

Bubblybooboo · 24/02/2024 16:44

Sounds like you just have to be very strict with your boundaries with your DS. say no to whatever you’re not comfortable with and take things slowly in relation to contact. 6 years is a long time of not contact to be seeing each other a lot so soon.

Just get comfortable with saying no. Ignore her comments about the kids and iPad and I’d simply not respond or say something like “We do what work for us” then change the topic. She sounds like a bit of a wind up. Maybe just have very limited contact. Is there any value in seeing her more?