Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest they ban this child from the SEN session

111 replies

Heartofglass83 · 24/02/2024 16:06

DD3 attends a weekly SEN gymnastics session which she loves. It’s got a big inflatable assault course / slide which is obviously really popular. The average age of the kids is probably about 5/6. Occasionally there’s an older child but they would normally have two parents walking round holding their hands etc.

the last few weeks there’s been a boy probably about 12 or 13 with quite visable learning difficulties who is very excitable and climbs to the top of the slide and stops children from going down the slide the supervisor has a few times had to ask his parent/carer to get him down as he jumps about so much the whole inflatable knocks all the other kids down. The parent / carer sits away on their phone the whole time.

DD went into the assault course and I normally follow her down and as she climbs up the ladder I walk back down to the bottom of the slide. As I was walking the boy ran up the slide and sat at the top. DD said “excuse me please” and he grabbed her by the pigtails and yanked them really hard before dragging her by the hair to throw her down the slide. I bellowed at the adults who were with him (who were all slouched away on their phones) and one jumped up the slide to get him off her.
DD has spent the last few hours really shocked and upset. I’m really angry because this is one of her favourite spaces where she can be herself.

i want to flag this to management - am I being unreasonable to say they need to give a warning and then ban this child from attending the session? I don’t blame the child in anyway, I blame the complete lack of supervision and care from the adults in charge of him. He is too big, and too excitable to be playing with small children without an adult constantly being with him. I dread to think of what could have happened as he is already quite a big lad.

OP posts:
LakeTiticaca · 24/02/2024 19:21

Yanbu. Children should be supervised at all times by their parents/carers and if that child is unable to respect that others are entitled to use te equipment, they need to be removed.One child's rights should trump everyone else's, special needs or not

GG1986 · 24/02/2024 19:12

I would speak to management and ask them why they can't do sessions with an age limit. It's sad as it isn't the boys fault, he should absolutely be being supervised, but it also is not fair at all that your daughter got hurt, she is only little and also has her own additional needs. If management don't address it, then I probably wouldn't go again, which isn't ideal, but I wouldn't want my child getting hurt.

Fionaville · 24/02/2024 19:12

Heartofglass83 · 24/02/2024 19:02

I said to my DH the same thing that’s it’s probably really hard to find activities for him to do that are safe so I would much rather he was looked after but honestly I’ve watched one of the carers just shrug at the manager before when she asked him to get off the slide again. I can see them just not having the inflatable there tbh.

smaller kids can’t access other Softplay sessions either so it would be better I think if they did age split it - they do that with the regular sessions! I guess they presumed Sen kids wouldn’t need the split

Edited

It's not fair on any of the kids is it? I think I'd have to speak to his carers myself. Are they his parents or paid carers? I don't know what would be worse though.

Heartofglass83 · 24/02/2024 19:02

Fionaville · 24/02/2024 18:52

My first question is if there are enough older children to make two sessions viable? If so, push for that.
If not, then strict reminders need putting in place that all children need to be supervised.
It's really hard finding SEN sessions like that. I wouldn't push for him to be banned at all. It would be harder for him to access play sessions like that otherwise. Purely because of his age and size, he wouldn't be able to go on the soft play in usual times. Whereas the younger ones could.
I hope your DD is OK. That must have been really upsetting for you both.

I said to my DH the same thing that’s it’s probably really hard to find activities for him to do that are safe so I would much rather he was looked after but honestly I’ve watched one of the carers just shrug at the manager before when she asked him to get off the slide again. I can see them just not having the inflatable there tbh.

smaller kids can’t access other Softplay sessions either so it would be better I think if they did age split it - they do that with the regular sessions! I guess they presumed Sen kids wouldn’t need the split

OP posts:
Fionaville · 24/02/2024 18:52

My first question is if there are enough older children to make two sessions viable? If so, push for that.
If not, then strict reminders need putting in place that all children need to be supervised.
It's really hard finding SEN sessions like that. I wouldn't push for him to be banned at all. It would be harder for him to access play sessions like that otherwise. Purely because of his age and size, he wouldn't be able to go on the soft play in usual times. Whereas the younger ones could.
I hope your DD is OK. That must have been really upsetting for you both.

RM2013 · 24/02/2024 18:47

It sounds like a supervision issue so should be raised with the management. All the children have the rights to use the facility but for it to be safe for all too

OhcantthInkofaname · 24/02/2024 18:43

Many 13 year olds are larger than me. They shouldn't be with small children.

Heartofglass83 · 24/02/2024 18:38

Thanks for the responses all. One of the reasons we love SEN sessions is the lack of judgement and lots of understanding and generally 9/10 parents are brilliant and it does afford people some much needed rest to give their kids a safe space to play. Tbh the problems seemed to start when they extended the session and put in later in the day.
There’s also a family who leave their kids including a two year old to go outside and smoke - remembered to pop that in my email to the centre about ensuring supervision!

OP posts:
Frenchmartini02 · 24/02/2024 18:33

I don't think you're being reasonable to some extent. As a mum of a boy with suspected SEN which often manifests itself with him being unpredictably aggressive (99% of the time he's lovely 1% he's a loose cannon) I would hate to be excluded from the SEN session BUT there's no way I'd leave him unsupervised, I'd be shadowing the whole way so that I could stop any undesirable behaviour.
I do think it's not appropriate to have 5 year olds and 12 year olds together in the same session and would propose if possible separate classes. I'd also flag to management safety concerns and that the parent of the 12 Yr old needs to shadow their kid at all times, I'd ban phones too, so many parents at classes/park on their bloody phones not watching their kids. Drives me mad.

Beetham · 24/02/2024 18:32

Really sorry that happened, really awful for your daughter.

I don't think it's an issue at all about age/height and think that's be a red herring, instead focus on safety: the child's behaviour and lack of supervision caused harm to your child and that can't happen again.

I say this as the parent of an SEN child who displays v challenging behaviour and the manager of a care agency, if the adults were support staff then lodge a complaint directly with them (obviously I appreciate you're unlikely to know who they were for but you could ask in the future, either outright or surreptitiously) if they are direct payment staff employed directly by the family then complain to the local authority with the concern being the safety of the young person and others. I do appreciate this might not be easy, I am quite bolshy and I know it can be hard. But my service would be very keen to know and take it very seriously, we do alot of unannounced observations, audits etc. but it's really hard to know what's really going on when staff are out and about.

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 18:08

@JudgeJ that would be great especially if you could put that in writing, thanks

JudgeJ · 24/02/2024 18:00

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 17:27

Just to play devil's advocate if I was the older child's parent and they banned them I would be rasing hell in terms of discrimination. It is a general sen session with no age range. They cannot say x child can come but y child can't especially if the behaviour is directly related to their disability.

If they now impose an age range I'd be asking what reasonable adjustments the venue could make in order for my child to attend and I'd be suggesting the existing sen session.

This doesn't mean I agree with the lack of supervision of the older child but as it Is an sen session your child should also be supervised. If as you say she was and you couldn't stop the incident from happening how would the older child's carer/parent be able to?

Before acceding to any of your demands I would, as management, be demanding that your got off your derriere and supervised your violent child. It is discriminatory to allow one child to be the universal bully, whatever the disability.

Bubblybooboo · 24/02/2024 17:58

I agree with suggesting sessions for older and younger children or asking the organisers to remind parents/caters about their responsibility to supervise. Regardless of needs children cannot be harming other children, so something needs to happen to prevent that. Separate age seems sensible given , regardless of intent, a larger excites child could hurt a smaller child.

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 17:56

I now there are spelling mistakes I'm juggling mentioned teenage child atm and I'm sure you can decipher.

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 17:54

I know you were supervising. I'm just trying to show a different side ad what may come.

As a parent of a now teenager with complex needs I've been in similar (my son isn't violent in anyway) situations. One was very similar in that it was an open age range sen session. The outcome was that the younger child if they wanted to could attend non sen sessions with a closed age range while the sen session remained open. Whether the older child's parent persue this is another issue.

Play centres do allow adults on equipment with their children to supervise them so the argument of weight is more an argument of the child not having the understanding of the situation and what could happen (this I'm guessing would be attributed to their disability).

I'd be careful how you treat as the situation could backfire. I'd be tempted to raise it as a safeguarding issue with the centre rather than ask for them to ban the child (of the parents/guardians have it in then they'll fight it in terms of discrimination). The centre should have a record of who attended. The LA could be notified.

BruFord · 24/02/2024 17:41

Ah, I didn’t realize that other older children were also using the equipment.

Personally, I still think that the age/height restrictions angle should be considered. If any of the older children accidentally fall onto a smaller child, they could hurt them. It’s just not safe to have such a wide age range, imo.

ShugarTits · 24/02/2024 17:40

CCLCECSC · 24/02/2024 16:15

This needs flagging. The idea of sessions for older and younger children has merit too

I was just going to suggest this.

Heartofglass83 · 24/02/2024 17:37

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 17:27

Just to play devil's advocate if I was the older child's parent and they banned them I would be rasing hell in terms of discrimination. It is a general sen session with no age range. They cannot say x child can come but y child can't especially if the behaviour is directly related to their disability.

If they now impose an age range I'd be asking what reasonable adjustments the venue could make in order for my child to attend and I'd be suggesting the existing sen session.

This doesn't mean I agree with the lack of supervision of the older child but as it Is an sen session your child should also be supervised. If as you say she was and you couldn't stop the incident from happening how would the older child's carer/parent be able to?

There is no age range which tbh is maybe the issue. Like others said - height and age limits exist for a reason.
that being said, as in my OP there are other older children there but they are normally supervised by two parents who are constantly managing behaviour. This child has zero management.
i was supervising my child - that’s why I stood at the bottom of the slide after following her the whole way round to make sure she climbs up the stairs ok. So my child was supervised. That’s why I was able to step in. My child has pulled another girls ponytail before but I was able to quickly step in and deal with it. This lads carers do NOT watch him in the slightest. That’s where the risk is. They should have been with him at the slide and getting him off it like they’ve been asked to several times when he just sits at the top. They should be ready to grab like how they did today after I yelled at them.

OP posts:
BruFord · 24/02/2024 17:36

@Baileyscream I appreciate what you’re saying, but if a 12/13 -year-old goes down the slide and lands on a small child, for example, they could seriously injure them. That’s the main reason why adults often aren’t allowed on equipment with children, we can literally kill them with our weight!

I don’t see what adjustments could be made to prevent such injuries unless older children have separate time on the equipment, I.e., a separate session.

The OP needs to raise this with the staff and they can get some heath and safety advice. It could affect the venue’s insurance as well if they’re not following guidance.

Popetthetreehugger · 24/02/2024 17:34

This makes my blood boil ! Your poor DD and that poor lad ! If he has people with him who are paid to look after him their failing in there job and he’s going to be deprived of an activity because they are to lazy to just do there job !! You must flag , and keep flagging till the people responsible for his care are looking after him properly. I hope your DD shakes the incident off and can go and enjoy herself x

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 17:27

Just to play devil's advocate if I was the older child's parent and they banned them I would be rasing hell in terms of discrimination. It is a general sen session with no age range. They cannot say x child can come but y child can't especially if the behaviour is directly related to their disability.

If they now impose an age range I'd be asking what reasonable adjustments the venue could make in order for my child to attend and I'd be suggesting the existing sen session.

This doesn't mean I agree with the lack of supervision of the older child but as it Is an sen session your child should also be supervised. If as you say she was and you couldn't stop the incident from happening how would the older child's carer/parent be able to?

TheTimeIsNowMaybeNow · 24/02/2024 17:14

Sounds like the age range is too big, they should do sessions for older children but most places don't
Unfortunately it sounds like he's getting to old for the session . Lots of places have height restrictions and unfortunately by the time most dc are 11 it's no longer suitable for them to use

Sirzy · 24/02/2024 17:10

I would love it if more places did do sessions aimed at older children. Locally at least there seems to be a gap between people offering general sessions for children with SEN - which are understandably dominated by younger children and sessions for adults with SEN. Ds is 14 so although generally placid I wouldn’t risk taking him to a session full of little ones (and he dislikes children!) but there isn’t anything sadly.

BruFord · 24/02/2024 17:05

Sirzy · 24/02/2024 16:10

If he can’t be suitably supervised then as hard as it is for him he shouldn’t be at the sessions.

if there are a few older children accessing them then maybe having the session split for younger and older children would be an option.

I agree with @Sirzy , it’s not safe to have this activity for such a wide age range. Children above primary age are typically so much taller and stronger than 5/6 year olds. It could result in some serious injuries.

Hankunamatata · 24/02/2024 17:04

I’d be formally asking management to ensure that older dc is properly supervised and explain exactly what happened to your dd - in writing

Swipe left for the next trending thread