Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest they ban this child from the SEN session

111 replies

Heartofglass83 · 24/02/2024 16:06

DD3 attends a weekly SEN gymnastics session which she loves. It’s got a big inflatable assault course / slide which is obviously really popular. The average age of the kids is probably about 5/6. Occasionally there’s an older child but they would normally have two parents walking round holding their hands etc.

the last few weeks there’s been a boy probably about 12 or 13 with quite visable learning difficulties who is very excitable and climbs to the top of the slide and stops children from going down the slide the supervisor has a few times had to ask his parent/carer to get him down as he jumps about so much the whole inflatable knocks all the other kids down. The parent / carer sits away on their phone the whole time.

DD went into the assault course and I normally follow her down and as she climbs up the ladder I walk back down to the bottom of the slide. As I was walking the boy ran up the slide and sat at the top. DD said “excuse me please” and he grabbed her by the pigtails and yanked them really hard before dragging her by the hair to throw her down the slide. I bellowed at the adults who were with him (who were all slouched away on their phones) and one jumped up the slide to get him off her.
DD has spent the last few hours really shocked and upset. I’m really angry because this is one of her favourite spaces where she can be herself.

i want to flag this to management - am I being unreasonable to say they need to give a warning and then ban this child from attending the session? I don’t blame the child in anyway, I blame the complete lack of supervision and care from the adults in charge of him. He is too big, and too excitable to be playing with small children without an adult constantly being with him. I dread to think of what could have happened as he is already quite a big lad.

OP posts:
NoOrdinaryMorning · 24/02/2024 22:46

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 17:27

Just to play devil's advocate if I was the older child's parent and they banned them I would be rasing hell in terms of discrimination. It is a general sen session with no age range. They cannot say x child can come but y child can't especially if the behaviour is directly related to their disability.

If they now impose an age range I'd be asking what reasonable adjustments the venue could make in order for my child to attend and I'd be suggesting the existing sen session.

This doesn't mean I agree with the lack of supervision of the older child but as it Is an sen session your child should also be supervised. If as you say she was and you couldn't stop the incident from happening how would the older child's carer/parent be able to?

I have a child with SEN and attitudes like yours that INFURIATE me. Just because a child has SEN, does not mean they do not need to be disciplined and redirected! Like any other child, if they're doing something unacceptable then something should be done. The SEN means that the 'something' is just different to what would be done if the child were neurotypical.

It's this "but, but he's got SEN so he can do whatever he likes" attitude which causes this sort of thing and causes such widespread misunderstanding of SEN for the rest of us. Far too many people associate SEN with bad behaviour & exclude kids like my DC. This kind of approach is precisely why!

Ulysees · 24/02/2024 22:38

If he is supported by a company I'd be finding out which one and complain to them too. Plus soft play management.

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 24/02/2024 22:38

Your poor dd l hope she is ok and not too traumatised xx

indianwoman · 24/02/2024 22:37

Why didn't you tell the carers/parents at the time it happened and say you've noticed you are not watching him and you need to. I would.

Flyeeeeer · 24/02/2024 22:32

TheSnowyOwl · 24/02/2024 17:00

I think banning him is wrong but management and his parents need do ensure it’s a safe environment for all.

This!

Our gym has a small soft play area and the other week a mother was ‘supervising’ her toddler in there. Well, she got her arse there but her eyes were down in her phone. They were really strict and said if you don’t put that away your kid will have to leave.
How this feckless excuse of a mother thinks it’s ok to have a phone out while her almost teenager almost harms another much younger child is beyond me. Oh I’m sure some will say the poor lamb probably needs a break as her son is hard work and that might be the first chance she has had to check her messages - eye roll time.
Hope your kid is ok and isn’t out off going to the sessions.

MamaSnaill · 24/02/2024 21:07

He didn’t just knock her over by mistake, I wouldn’t report for that, but he grabbed her by the hair to THROW her down the slide by her hair!! I cannot imagine the mindset of seeing your child so violently assaulted and not wanting to report it. She is going to remember and be affected by that for the rest of her life. She must have been petrified. What if he wasn’t stopped in time? Her neck could have snapped, he could have killed her. And you don’t want to report it?!

He sounds extremely dangerous and on the track to seriously hurting someone. Who knows, early intervention from police and them talking to carers could stop him seriously hurting someone some day. Maybe your daughter is that someone.

The police will likely talk to parents/carers, it’s all going to be about early intervention. Not locking up and throwing away the key.

You should think a bit more about whether or not you want to report it. Are you perhaps in shock?

BruFord · 24/02/2024 21:04

Someone used the word “safeguarding” and I think that’s the right word to use. Just outline what happened to your DD and let the management decide how to address it.

GinForBreakfast · 24/02/2024 21:00

@Baileyscream nothing trumps safety. Making a bit of noise in the theatre isn't the same as small children being hurt.

But as I said, the issue seems to be about supervision.

Spanglemum75 · 24/02/2024 21:00

I've taken my children to similar sessions for SEN children in the past. The children need to be properly supervised. I would complain to the management and if you could find the name of the agency the staff worked for, I'd complain to them to.

momonpurpose · 24/02/2024 20:54

Elecrricmaracas · 24/02/2024 16:08

YANBU at all. You've acknowledged that it isn't the child's fault but equally it's not safe for other children. Shame on those who should be supervising him!

This. It sounds like that child's needs are too advanced for the other children to be safe. You should definitely complain. It isn't fair to the others especially since he obviously isn't supervised and violent . I realize it is not his fault but safety first

Heartofglass83 · 24/02/2024 20:47

i don’t think it’s appropriate to report to the police. I don’t blame the child for his actions I blame the carers and the centre supervisors as they know what the child is capable of and tnat he’s unsupervised.

but as many PP have pointed out, his size makes him a danger. If a smaller child attacked DD it’s not really going to damage her physically. A large 12ish year old can, whether he means to or not. He accidentally ran into me earlier in the session and gave me a little push (just to move me out of his space) it was enough to almost knock me over so Christ knows how poor DD feels.

OP posts:
MamaSnaill · 24/02/2024 20:12

Lovemusic82 · 24/02/2024 20:09

Really? He’s a disabled child, what do you expect the police to do? He was allowed to be there, it’s a SEN session. The fault is with who ever was supposed to be supervising him and partly the venue for thinking it’s safe to allow children of all ages to attend at the same time.

Are you suggesting that the victim should not have her assault reported because the child has additional needs?
Let the police determine what response is appropriate! You can’t just ignore assaults because the guilty party has additional needs. The police will take into account all factors. OP should obviously report her daughter’s assault.

JMSA · 24/02/2024 20:10

Oh wow, at first I thought this was going to be a YABU. But it's totally not!
Hope your wee girl is ok.

Lovemusic82 · 24/02/2024 20:09

MamaSnaill · 24/02/2024 20:07

Your poor daughter. It doesn’t sound like you’ve reported the assault to the police yet? Non emergency line is open 24/7 I believe if you don’t want to wait until morning.
Right thing to do by your DD, he is above the age of criminal responsibility. The police will determine what further action is necessary. I’d also question if you’d have grounds to sue the place if they knowingly allowing children to be put in danger and harmed.
Report. Pass on crime number and ask what action will be taken to ensure your DD is not assaulted there again.

Really? He’s a disabled child, what do you expect the police to do? He was allowed to be there, it’s a SEN session. The fault is with who ever was supposed to be supervising him and partly the venue for thinking it’s safe to allow children of all ages to attend at the same time.

xyz111 · 24/02/2024 20:09

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 17:27

Just to play devil's advocate if I was the older child's parent and they banned them I would be rasing hell in terms of discrimination. It is a general sen session with no age range. They cannot say x child can come but y child can't especially if the behaviour is directly related to their disability.

If they now impose an age range I'd be asking what reasonable adjustments the venue could make in order for my child to attend and I'd be suggesting the existing sen session.

This doesn't mean I agree with the lack of supervision of the older child but as it Is an sen session your child should also be supervised. If as you say she was and you couldn't stop the incident from happening how would the older child's carer/parent be able to?

I agree to some extent (have a Sen child myself) but there has to be a line somewhere. If a child was hurting every other child, they deserve to be protected and if that means the other child can't attend, then that's the way it has to be.

MamaSnaill · 24/02/2024 20:07

Your poor daughter. It doesn’t sound like you’ve reported the assault to the police yet? Non emergency line is open 24/7 I believe if you don’t want to wait until morning.
Right thing to do by your DD, he is above the age of criminal responsibility. The police will determine what further action is necessary. I’d also question if you’d have grounds to sue the place if they knowingly allowing children to be put in danger and harmed.
Report. Pass on crime number and ask what action will be taken to ensure your DD is not assaulted there again.

Lovemusic82 · 24/02/2024 20:03

I agree with you OP. We have a similar set up at a local leisure centre but they have 2 sessions, one for younger children and one for age 10+. My dd is 17 and would love to go to this type of thing, I would t feel safe taking her if there were young children there that she could easily knock over.

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 20:00

@GinForBreakfast I agree about the supervision, I haven't said otherwise but they cannot ban a child for behaviour linked directly to their disability thst is discrimination. A good example of this Is involuntary noise in places like theatres where theatres now have to have a policy for this. I'll find one and link it.

Isthisexpected · 24/02/2024 19:55

I would say that your daughter was assaulted because of the carers failing in their duty of care. I would ask for their ID and contact their regulator if a provider rather than a parent. I would also complain to management about the poor supervision of a child causing high risk to others.

GinForBreakfast · 24/02/2024 19:51

@Baileyscream that's not how legislation around discrimination works. This child is being failed by his carers. It's the lack of supervision that is causing other children to get hurt, not his disability.

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 19:48

LydiaPoet · 24/02/2024 19:23

My child is SEN but An SEN diagnosis is not a blank card to abuse another child. If they are at risk of hurting themselves or others they must be closely supervised at all times. This boy is allowed providing his behaviour does not put others at risk or harm others - if it happens once his carers must be told they must supervise him very closely so it doesn’t happen again.

I agree they should be supervised but if he gets banned he's getting banned through something (I'm assuming) is related to his disability which is discrimination. You can't have a general sen session and say this type of disability is ok but not this type.

It could well be that the OP's child is overly sensitive to touch, doesnt react appropriately emotionally or socially, the parents of either child have needs themselves around social interaction/ interpretation etc. There is only one side to the story detailed (Not saying this is the case but it could be from the business point of view).

The organisation would be taking one parents word over another if they didn't witness the incident themselves. It's really difficult for them.

It's unlikely from Op's post that an older sen session would be financially viable given the low numbers of older children attending.

Op, if another child does the same but is younger what would you do then? If the organisation puts an age range on the session and the boy is within that range? Children get hurt by other children during normal sessions due to lack of supervision, how would the centre deal with that?

If you write a letter detailing the supervision of this child and the other where their parents go our for a cigarette what would you be asking the centre to do? They can't police all the parents that attend.

GinForBreakfast · 24/02/2024 19:34

He needs to be looked after during the session and if that's not enough to keep all children safe then alternative provision should be found. His carers are failing him and that is unfair to him.

bryceQ · 24/02/2024 19:25

that actually sounds quite dangerous. My son is five, he can on occasion be aggressive towards other children, if they enter his space, I would never in a million years leave him unattended as I know I need to intervene if he feels that someone has invaded his space and lashes out physically. I do my best to explain, but he cannot grasp these concepts at the moment. That means I am literally glued to him. It's really irresponsible of those parents.

LydiaPoet · 24/02/2024 19:23

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 17:27

Just to play devil's advocate if I was the older child's parent and they banned them I would be rasing hell in terms of discrimination. It is a general sen session with no age range. They cannot say x child can come but y child can't especially if the behaviour is directly related to their disability.

If they now impose an age range I'd be asking what reasonable adjustments the venue could make in order for my child to attend and I'd be suggesting the existing sen session.

This doesn't mean I agree with the lack of supervision of the older child but as it Is an sen session your child should also be supervised. If as you say she was and you couldn't stop the incident from happening how would the older child's carer/parent be able to?

My child is SEN but An SEN diagnosis is not a blank card to abuse another child. If they are at risk of hurting themselves or others they must be closely supervised at all times. This boy is allowed providing his behaviour does not put others at risk or harm others - if it happens once his carers must be told they must supervise him very closely so it doesn’t happen again.