Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest they ban this child from the SEN session

111 replies

Heartofglass83 · 24/02/2024 16:06

DD3 attends a weekly SEN gymnastics session which she loves. It’s got a big inflatable assault course / slide which is obviously really popular. The average age of the kids is probably about 5/6. Occasionally there’s an older child but they would normally have two parents walking round holding their hands etc.

the last few weeks there’s been a boy probably about 12 or 13 with quite visable learning difficulties who is very excitable and climbs to the top of the slide and stops children from going down the slide the supervisor has a few times had to ask his parent/carer to get him down as he jumps about so much the whole inflatable knocks all the other kids down. The parent / carer sits away on their phone the whole time.

DD went into the assault course and I normally follow her down and as she climbs up the ladder I walk back down to the bottom of the slide. As I was walking the boy ran up the slide and sat at the top. DD said “excuse me please” and he grabbed her by the pigtails and yanked them really hard before dragging her by the hair to throw her down the slide. I bellowed at the adults who were with him (who were all slouched away on their phones) and one jumped up the slide to get him off her.
DD has spent the last few hours really shocked and upset. I’m really angry because this is one of her favourite spaces where she can be herself.

i want to flag this to management - am I being unreasonable to say they need to give a warning and then ban this child from attending the session? I don’t blame the child in anyway, I blame the complete lack of supervision and care from the adults in charge of him. He is too big, and too excitable to be playing with small children without an adult constantly being with him. I dread to think of what could have happened as he is already quite a big lad.

OP posts:
Baileyscream · 25/02/2024 09:01

@Squirrelsonthescaffolding removing people with autism from society is actually a national scandal that has been reported on quite widely over recent years. The use of atu's and mental health facilities in their care isn't something to be championed. Nobody should be locked away because of their disability.

You talk about people being unable to be educated but seem to support their removal as an easy solution?

You may want to watch this:-

https://www.channel4.com/programmes/locked-away-our-autism-scandal-dispatches

Watch Locked Away: Our Autism Scandal - Dispatches | Stream free on Channel 4

Autistic patients trapped in mental health units tell their stories, revealing a system of poor treatment, abuse and long stretches inside with their symptoms only getting worse

https://www.channel4.com/programmes/locked-away-our-autism-scandal-dispatches

Baileyscream · 25/02/2024 08:51

Just to add, it was me that suggested going down the safeguarding route for the very reason that he isn't being adequately supported.

Sirzy · 25/02/2024 08:47

It’s also about protecting him, one day this young man may go out into the “wider world” and if he starts pulling people out of the way like he did here he could find himself in a lot of trouble. If he isn’t capable of understanding then he needs a level of supervision high enough to protect him and others

Baileyscream · 25/02/2024 08:46

There's a lot of gymnaatics on these posts.

  1. Please read my posts. I have repeatedly said he should be supervised.
  2. No one has said anything about autism?
  3. I have repeatedly said view it from the venues point of view. They cannot and should not take another person's word for it.
  4. We're talking about two children in a play centre. Sen session.
  5. I have never said let him do what he wants/ don't teach him.... I have said some children need more than discipline and redirection and for some children this doesnt work. Non of us here knows what his needs truly are or how best to communicate with him or teach him.

As I have previously stated yes I would raise merry he'll if my child was banned from something they enjoyed because of something to do with their disability.

@GinForBreakfast you really think comparing a blind adult driving a bus to a child in an sen session at a play centre is the same thing and demonstrates the health and safety principle your trying to convey?

I'm aware people can be excluded for health and safety reasons and it not be discrimination but think about how this would play out in reality. It's a sen session for children. He's a child with sen.

MariaVT65 · 25/02/2024 08:45

cansu · 25/02/2024 08:43

Tbh it sounds like you supervise for the safety of your child ie by watching she climbs the steps OK and standing at the bottom of the slide. If your dd grabbed another dc at the top you would not be able to intervene either. That said they should be watching him.

The answer could be that a member of staff is stationed at the top of the slide to supervise or one at the bottom allowing only one child up at a time.

You cannot expect them to ban this child.

I have a question then as I’m unsure of the rules/laws tbh.

If there is a member of staff stationed at the top of the slide, and witnessed the same thing, are they allowed to manhandle the offending the child to make them let go of a kid’s pigtails?

cansu · 25/02/2024 08:43

Tbh it sounds like you supervise for the safety of your child ie by watching she climbs the steps OK and standing at the bottom of the slide. If your dd grabbed another dc at the top you would not be able to intervene either. That said they should be watching him.

The answer could be that a member of staff is stationed at the top of the slide to supervise or one at the bottom allowing only one child up at a time.

You cannot expect them to ban this child.

Updownleftandright · 25/02/2024 08:36

I have a child with ASD and LD who doesnt have any sense of danger or social rules, so may well be like this at 12 or 13. He rarely hits out, but I still follow him closely everywhere we go and he is 5. I would do this more so when he's older as the risks are much higher.

The parents should be with the child not on their phones If he is a risk to others. The organisers can't physically stop him, although they can change the age ranges of kids attending. It's a difficult one though as it's very hard to find activities you can do as a family when one of the kids has complex needs. I think the organisers need to have a word with the parents.

MariaVT65 · 25/02/2024 08:34

Op I have to still disagree with everyone saying he shouldn’t be banned.

I keep reading your post and picturing what he did in my head. Yanking someone by their hair and using their to throw them down a slide is extreme behaviour on another level and I think that should warrant an instant ban.

Supervision may not resolve his behaviour so I wouldn’t risk that happening to another child.

Groovee · 25/02/2024 08:31

I would flag with management that he's not being properly supervised and hurting others. He has the right to be there but those with him should be supporting him not sitting on their phones.

Squirrelsonthescaffolding · 25/02/2024 08:27

@Baileyscream
reasonable adjustments are meant to be reasonable. It is not reasonable for other children to be injured when this is predictable due to past observed behaviour and lack of close supervision to mitigate it. Autistic young people and others have been subject to hospital orders or jailed when they need to be removed from society for other’s safety eg the tragic case of Matthew Selby. Protecting others , even if the behaviour is related to disability, is not necessarily discrimination. I do know that autistic people are of course also often abused themselves and that by far the majority of disabled people are not dangerous.

Of course we have no way of knowing if supervision would work in this case, but it should be tried, and/or separate sessions, which might splitting the session and making it shorter for each height/weight range if there was no funding for anything else sadly.

Also, for his future best chance of a life with more choices, the older child is being failed by his parents/carers for not at least trying to use these incidents of his anti social behaviour to teach him to keep his hands to himself and treat others gently. Who knows if he is capable of learning this but surely we have come a long way from when many disabled children were automatically considered ‘ineducable’?

Dancerprancer19 · 25/02/2024 07:52

I think YABU to ban him but the centre should remind carers to supervise their children.

I also think realistically it’s much easier for a younger child to access mainstream sessions than an older child, so if the age range is too wide I would provide for the older ones.

Ideally they would split the age range.

GinForBreakfast · 25/02/2024 07:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What0nEarthIsThis · 25/02/2024 07:19

Hi,

I think just putting it in writing would help management to be able to take action. They will not know that it happened and cannot act until they have that information to act on. I think it's really fine to tell them and then they can sort it out.

OCDmama · 25/02/2024 07:11

@Baileyscream

You'd raise merry hell? Have you read what the older child did? He hurt the OPs daughter very badly and it could have been worse.

Regardless of why he did it, it's clear he shouldn't be in this session. He's a major risk to the other children, and the venue has a duty of care towards them.

It is a fact of life that children age out of things. This kid has aged out of this session. I disagree it's the venue's responsibility to provide provision where health and safety would be massively compromised and the enjoyment of the smaller children. Are you going to say the same when he's 13,14,15?

MariaVT65 · 25/02/2024 06:50

Absolutely raise it with management.

The session should be run separately for older/bigger kids.

And tbh yeah i’d ban him anyway. What exactly does ‘supervision’ mean? Do you think that boy wouldn’t have assaulted your DD if he was being watched more closely?

Sapphire387 · 25/02/2024 06:48

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 23:06

@GinForBreakfast no it isn't exactly the same but the principle is. A person with a disability cannot be excluded because they do something in relation to their disability which makes others uncomfortable. Try to see it from the point of view of the venue. They cannot say his needs are too much for an inclusive sen session without being discriminatory. At what point do they decide someone is too disabled for the session? How would they word that without getting themselves into trouble?

While there is no need to question the OP's account here, it cannot just be taken as gospel, it's only one side of the story. What the boy did was a form of communication it could have been that he thought he was helping the girl and didn't understand his actions, it could have been that something she said or did aggrevated him.

It's an sen session and not every child has the right type of sen, behaviour is going to vary with each child. If this child did get banned another child could go that throws things or another that has tourettes. I'd imagine many children attending sen sessions at soft play like to bounce or crash.

You really need to stop spouting misinformation. A disabled person absolutely can be stopped from accessing something if it makes them or another person unsafe. This is more than 'making people feel uncomfortable' - he dragged OP's child by the hair.

Sapphire387 · 25/02/2024 06:43

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 19:48

I agree they should be supervised but if he gets banned he's getting banned through something (I'm assuming) is related to his disability which is discrimination. You can't have a general sen session and say this type of disability is ok but not this type.

It could well be that the OP's child is overly sensitive to touch, doesnt react appropriately emotionally or socially, the parents of either child have needs themselves around social interaction/ interpretation etc. There is only one side to the story detailed (Not saying this is the case but it could be from the business point of view).

The organisation would be taking one parents word over another if they didn't witness the incident themselves. It's really difficult for them.

It's unlikely from Op's post that an older sen session would be financially viable given the low numbers of older children attending.

Op, if another child does the same but is younger what would you do then? If the organisation puts an age range on the session and the boy is within that range? Children get hurt by other children during normal sessions due to lack of supervision, how would the centre deal with that?

If you write a letter detailing the supervision of this child and the other where their parents go our for a cigarette what would you be asking the centre to do? They can't police all the parents that attend.

It's not 'discrimination' if he's genuinely dangerous to other children. It's a proportionate means to achieve a legitimate aim. Just as it's not 'discrimination' to not allow a blind person to drive a bus. If the activity cannot happen safely, that comes above right of access. It's really the centre's problem to sort out the adjustments, either through separate sessions or through making it an absolute condition of entry that parents/carers must supervise, and any incidents due to lack of supervision mean removal.

momonpurpose · 25/02/2024 02:35

NoOrdinaryMorning · 24/02/2024 22:46

I have a child with SEN and attitudes like yours that INFURIATE me. Just because a child has SEN, does not mean they do not need to be disciplined and redirected! Like any other child, if they're doing something unacceptable then something should be done. The SEN means that the 'something' is just different to what would be done if the child were neurotypical.

It's this "but, but he's got SEN so he can do whatever he likes" attitude which causes this sort of thing and causes such widespread misunderstanding of SEN for the rest of us. Far too many people associate SEN with bad behaviour & exclude kids like my DC. This kind of approach is precisely why!

Edited

I could not agree with you more @NoOrdinaryMorning . It is such a disservice to all persons with SEN children or adults.

Caffeineislife · 24/02/2024 23:20

Just seen your update about him been brought by a carer. Do they wear lanyards or a uniform which could identify the care agency? If so I would be tempted to also notify the care agency that the carers bringing the boy to the session are not supervising him adequately. Its the sort of thing management of these agencies are quite hot on. The boys parents will be paying the care agency to keep their son safe on an outing, if the carer is just sat on their phone and not actually supervising and keeping the boy safe, they are not doing their job.

I imagine if you bring this up with management of the centre, a good centre manager will probably also phone the care agency the boy is coming with to explain to the carers the boy is coming with needs supervision.

Safe isn't just him not physically hurt, it's also safe from accusations or him hurting another.

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 23:18

NoOrdinaryMorning · 24/02/2024 22:46

I have a child with SEN and attitudes like yours that INFURIATE me. Just because a child has SEN, does not mean they do not need to be disciplined and redirected! Like any other child, if they're doing something unacceptable then something should be done. The SEN means that the 'something' is just different to what would be done if the child were neurotypical.

It's this "but, but he's got SEN so he can do whatever he likes" attitude which causes this sort of thing and causes such widespread misunderstanding of SEN for the rest of us. Far too many people associate SEN with bad behaviour & exclude kids like my DC. This kind of approach is precisely why!

Edited

At no point did I say he could do whatever he wanted?! Be infuriated, you may find some sen parents get pretty ticked off with parents like you who think that all sen can be countered using discipline and redirection. Some children are a little bit more complex than that. If only my ds's needs could have been disciplined out of him.... you're doing a fair bit of misreprenting yourself.

Blaming other parents on the Internet for your child being excluded? I can't possibly think of another reason why they would be.

P3anutbutt3r · 24/02/2024 23:16
  • might NOT be aware.
P3anutbutt3r · 24/02/2024 23:15

I haven't read the full thread so I apologise but rather than straight ask for the child to be warned / banned - I'd speak to management & suggest a younger & older sessions to be held rather than completely mixed ages & I would also ask them to change their 'rules' that children HAVE to be supervised at all times / a phone ban to stop people from just disregarding their child. Then if that doesn't work go to the warning & ban.

I know this behaviour isn't acceptable but a child with SEN also might be fully aware of their actions & it's sad they would be punished by being banned because of neglectful carers / parents. Their actions should be targeted first.

I hope your daughter is ok OP.

buswankerz · 24/02/2024 23:11

This needed being flagged up.

You did the right thing. He needs constant supervision, not a parent sitting on their phone.

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 23:06

@GinForBreakfast no it isn't exactly the same but the principle is. A person with a disability cannot be excluded because they do something in relation to their disability which makes others uncomfortable. Try to see it from the point of view of the venue. They cannot say his needs are too much for an inclusive sen session without being discriminatory. At what point do they decide someone is too disabled for the session? How would they word that without getting themselves into trouble?

While there is no need to question the OP's account here, it cannot just be taken as gospel, it's only one side of the story. What the boy did was a form of communication it could have been that he thought he was helping the girl and didn't understand his actions, it could have been that something she said or did aggrevated him.

It's an sen session and not every child has the right type of sen, behaviour is going to vary with each child. If this child did get banned another child could go that throws things or another that has tourettes. I'd imagine many children attending sen sessions at soft play like to bounce or crash.

SomethingDifferentt · 24/02/2024 22:58

If he can’t be suitably supervised then as hard as it is for him he shouldn’t be at the sessions

This.