Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest they ban this child from the SEN session

111 replies

Heartofglass83 · 24/02/2024 16:06

DD3 attends a weekly SEN gymnastics session which she loves. It’s got a big inflatable assault course / slide which is obviously really popular. The average age of the kids is probably about 5/6. Occasionally there’s an older child but they would normally have two parents walking round holding their hands etc.

the last few weeks there’s been a boy probably about 12 or 13 with quite visable learning difficulties who is very excitable and climbs to the top of the slide and stops children from going down the slide the supervisor has a few times had to ask his parent/carer to get him down as he jumps about so much the whole inflatable knocks all the other kids down. The parent / carer sits away on their phone the whole time.

DD went into the assault course and I normally follow her down and as she climbs up the ladder I walk back down to the bottom of the slide. As I was walking the boy ran up the slide and sat at the top. DD said “excuse me please” and he grabbed her by the pigtails and yanked them really hard before dragging her by the hair to throw her down the slide. I bellowed at the adults who were with him (who were all slouched away on their phones) and one jumped up the slide to get him off her.
DD has spent the last few hours really shocked and upset. I’m really angry because this is one of her favourite spaces where she can be herself.

i want to flag this to management - am I being unreasonable to say they need to give a warning and then ban this child from attending the session? I don’t blame the child in anyway, I blame the complete lack of supervision and care from the adults in charge of him. He is too big, and too excitable to be playing with small children without an adult constantly being with him. I dread to think of what could have happened as he is already quite a big lad.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Heartofglass83 · 01/03/2024 08:06

Springcat · 01/03/2024 07:44

I've two with sen ,there's always adults at these sessions ,who are so exhausted from caring for their child they just need to switch off.
Maybe the session needs another member of staff on duty and maybe different sessions for different ages ..
But most sen sessions ,are at times the company don't get much business ,so they are unlikely to have two different sen sessions as they will loose money.
I always got round this by sticking to my DC like glue

One of the reasons we love SEN sessions so much is that it does give parents the chance to do that - to have a chat with another adult or sit down and know their child can’t escape etc but they are still watched even if it’s from afar and there’s no judgement when there’s the occasional upset - we all get it. I think the issue here is that the child was too big, too hyper and not being remotely watched and is obviously known to have issues with no boundaries with touching. And it’s not a parent getting a much needed break - it was a carer being paid to look after him. It’s made for a little perfect storm.

OP posts:
Springcat · 01/03/2024 07:44

I've two with sen ,there's always adults at these sessions ,who are so exhausted from caring for their child they just need to switch off.
Maybe the session needs another member of staff on duty and maybe different sessions for different ages ..
But most sen sessions ,are at times the company don't get much business ,so they are unlikely to have two different sen sessions as they will loose money.
I always got round this by sticking to my DC like glue

Jifmicroliquid · 01/03/2024 07:00

NoOrdinaryMorning · 24/02/2024 22:46

I have a child with SEN and attitudes like yours that INFURIATE me. Just because a child has SEN, does not mean they do not need to be disciplined and redirected! Like any other child, if they're doing something unacceptable then something should be done. The SEN means that the 'something' is just different to what would be done if the child were neurotypical.

It's this "but, but he's got SEN so he can do whatever he likes" attitude which causes this sort of thing and causes such widespread misunderstanding of SEN for the rest of us. Far too many people associate SEN with bad behaviour & exclude kids like my DC. This kind of approach is precisely why!

Edited

You have just restored my faith in parenting.

I am sick to the back teeth of SEN parents using their child’s diagnosis as an excuse for lazy parenting. It does make me judge the parents of these children, which I know is wrong, but when SEN is used time and time again as an excuse it becomes infuriating. I can’t even begin to imagine how it makes you feel, as the parent of an SEN child who is trying their best to raise a decent and compassionate human being.

ICrunchCrispsNotNumbers · 01/03/2024 06:19

Heartofglass83 · 28/02/2024 15:54

I spoke to the manager of the gym this morning who said she was taking the incident with the utmost seriousness to ensure safeguarding for all children. They are sending out a mass communication tomorrow to remind all parents and carers that children must remain supervised at all times, as well as adding a tick box during ticket booking to say you agree to the T&C of supervising children. She has said the manager on site will be given extra training and support to ensure she has the confidence and backing of management to approach parents/carers whose children are not being supervised and that if the behaviour did not change, they will be asked to leave.

I am happy with this - I feel more confident as well to approach the carer again if the child is being too boisterous/physical and blocking the children again.

Edited

@Heartofglass83 I've just read your update- that's fantastic news! Well done to the manager for treating the matter with the seriousness it deserves. I hope your daughter is feeling better now ❤️

ICrunchCrispsNotNumbers · 01/03/2024 06:06

@Baileyscream and you sound like you're blaming the OP's daughter. Whether she did or said something wrong or not, that's absolutely no excuse for what he did.

ICrunchCrispsNotNumbers · 01/03/2024 06:04

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 23:06

@GinForBreakfast no it isn't exactly the same but the principle is. A person with a disability cannot be excluded because they do something in relation to their disability which makes others uncomfortable. Try to see it from the point of view of the venue. They cannot say his needs are too much for an inclusive sen session without being discriminatory. At what point do they decide someone is too disabled for the session? How would they word that without getting themselves into trouble?

While there is no need to question the OP's account here, it cannot just be taken as gospel, it's only one side of the story. What the boy did was a form of communication it could have been that he thought he was helping the girl and didn't understand his actions, it could have been that something she said or did aggrevated him.

It's an sen session and not every child has the right type of sen, behaviour is going to vary with each child. If this child did get banned another child could go that throws things or another that has tourettes. I'd imagine many children attending sen sessions at soft play like to bounce or crash.

@Baileyscream 'He thought he was helping the girl.'

What's wrong with you?

That's not help. That's assault. He grabbed her by the hair. It's not his fault, but it's still asssult and if he can't behave appropriately then he shouldn't attend.

ICrunchCrispsNotNumbers · 01/03/2024 05:49

And just because someone has SEN, it doesn't mean that every SEN thing will be definitely right for them.

ICrunchCrispsNotNumbers · 01/03/2024 05:48

@Heartofglass83 I agree with @Sirzy- I don't think asking for the boy in this case to be banned is BU at all. I don't think this session sounds the right environment for him. At the end of the day he has really hurt and upset your daughter, so he might to the same to others. I would definitely have a word with management and inform them of your concerns.

Tatonka · 01/03/2024 01:37

YANBU. Escalate.

456pickupsticks · 01/03/2024 01:21

Absolutely not unreasonable to make management aware of what's happened, and let them know how you feel and what you've seen.
It is unreasonable to tell them they need to give a warning or ban a child - they just need facts and can decide what's appropriate.

You're well within your rights to say things like 'I'd like to see...' or 'We won't feel safe returning until...' or to suggest 'perhaps a separate session for anyone over 10 would be helpful' but you can't say 'you need to ban this child' as its not your decision.

You could suggest an email to all parents or carers saying something like 'children must be directly supervised whilst using the equipment, as a guide, adults should be activity moving through the venue with their child and not sat on the sidelines watching.'
If you've been going a while, it might be that the owners could tell you when is particularly quiet for you to attend a different session, at least so you know your daughter can get comfortable with the venue again and definitely wouldn't see the boy.

Ulysees · 28/02/2024 17:01

@Heartofglass83 that's excellent. I bet you're relieved. I hope dd isn't nervous about going?

Isthisexpected · 28/02/2024 16:50

Good for you. If it happens again though I'd take further action and report the carers and the incident to the police.

Heartofglass83 · 28/02/2024 15:54

I spoke to the manager of the gym this morning who said she was taking the incident with the utmost seriousness to ensure safeguarding for all children. They are sending out a mass communication tomorrow to remind all parents and carers that children must remain supervised at all times, as well as adding a tick box during ticket booking to say you agree to the T&C of supervising children. She has said the manager on site will be given extra training and support to ensure she has the confidence and backing of management to approach parents/carers whose children are not being supervised and that if the behaviour did not change, they will be asked to leave.

I am happy with this - I feel more confident as well to approach the carer again if the child is being too boisterous/physical and blocking the children again.

OP posts:
Baileyscream · 26/02/2024 18:08

NoOrdinaryMorning · 24/02/2024 22:46

I have a child with SEN and attitudes like yours that INFURIATE me. Just because a child has SEN, does not mean they do not need to be disciplined and redirected! Like any other child, if they're doing something unacceptable then something should be done. The SEN means that the 'something' is just different to what would be done if the child were neurotypical.

It's this "but, but he's got SEN so he can do whatever he likes" attitude which causes this sort of thing and causes such widespread misunderstanding of SEN for the rest of us. Far too many people associate SEN with bad behaviour & exclude kids like my DC. This kind of approach is precisely why!

Edited

Where have I said that?

I have referenced your comment in the quote above about using discipline and redirection and made a comment something along the lines of 'I wish the sen could be disciplined out of my child' or similar. It's a common response when people make this sort of remark.

Londonrach1 · 26/02/2024 16:27

The management needs to go sessions...one for younger ones one for older ones... maybe a height limit rather than age limit ..

NoOrdinaryMorning · 26/02/2024 16:22

@Baileyscream I never once said 'All Sen can be countered using discipline?!?!?!' You've just made that up!

Jobsharenightmare · 25/02/2024 10:46

I used to be a support worker for a young man with SEN who due to his additional needs had committed various assaults and had no insight so was on a community treatment order with a forensic LD service managing his care. The first step towards this was documenting his assaults with the police as a teen when his parents could not stop him from physically harming others.

Baileyscream · 25/02/2024 10:11

@GinForBreakfast when have I said he doesn't need supervising? I have repeatedly said he should be supervised. What I have done is try to the OP other views rather than just an echo chamber of 'ban him' and make her aware of what could be said in return.

I have said some people cannot be taught via discipline and distraction and that some people may never understand or their understanding of the situation maybe different because of their needs.

MariaVT65 · 25/02/2024 10:08

I would consider this incident more extreme than ‘hair pulling’

GinForBreakfast · 25/02/2024 09:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Baileyscream · 25/02/2024 09:45

@Sirzy the largest theatre at the Lowry has boxes which they can allocate to just your party. There is enough room at the back of them to move about a little as they have a coat area. There is also a door which leads right out into the corridor. You could try these if there is something in particular your son wants to see.

@ZebraPensAreLife no idea what they'd say. I'd guess they'd offer a refund or tickets to another show if it was a standard show. If a standard show i dont think it would happen often in that many shows wouldnt have a person making involuntary noise, so i think it'd be difficult to say 'i can't cope with that one person' type of thing. If it was a relaxed show some noise is expected as its usually part of the description of the shows remit. Eg extra lighting, movement and noise.

Sirzy · 25/02/2024 09:14

ZebraPensAreLife · 25/02/2024 09:10

I wonder if they realise this policy excludes anyone who can’t cope with involuntary noises due to their own disabilities? It would be interesting to know how they handle conflicting needs.

I think that’s the issue across the board. It is impossible to cater for all needs because of the wide variety of needs.

we went to a relaxed show at the Lowry a few years ago and the way they did it was fantastic - but DS couldn’t cope with the noise of others. He can’t access the “normal” performances because of his need to move and not be in crowds.

its an impossible balancing act really and places can only do their best.

ZebraPensAreLife · 25/02/2024 09:10

Baileyscream · 24/02/2024 20:01

I wonder if they realise this policy excludes anyone who can’t cope with involuntary noises due to their own disabilities? It would be interesting to know how they handle conflicting needs.

Baileyscream · 25/02/2024 09:09

@Squirrelsonthescaffolding Mattew Selby committed a horrific crime but there is a world of difference between this and a boy at a play centre. He was locked away because of what he did as anybody would be. People without autism commit these crimes too.

Autism isn't an excuse for bad behaviour however some people have very severe autism and do not know or understand their actions. They should be supervised.

It's also worth noting that the OP said the child has learning needs and is excitable, which you can have without having autism. Not everyone with ld has autism. Maybe you should consider if your jump to autism and linking to tje Matthew Selby case is your own bias coming through?

Longma · 25/02/2024 09:06

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Swipe left for the next trending thread