Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slimming World for sustained weight loss?

38 replies

SummerGardener · 24/02/2024 13:08

I am on a waiting list for an operation. It is likely to be months before I am operated on, and in the meantime my mobility is low.

I both need and want to lose weight beforehand.

AIBU to do Slimming World for sustained weight loss?

If not that, then what?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SomersetTart · 24/02/2024 20:51

Cosycover · 24/02/2024 20:44

I did it years ago and it worked. I didn't ever eat the processed crap they tried to sell though. 6 mullerlights a day etc. I ate Full fat Greek and it didn't do any harm.

They've actually given the mullerlights a syn value now to stop people troughing them down six at a time just because they were free.

Cosycover · 24/02/2024 20:44

I did it years ago and it worked. I didn't ever eat the processed crap they tried to sell though. 6 mullerlights a day etc. I ate Full fat Greek and it didn't do any harm.

Thementalloadisreal · 24/02/2024 20:41

SomersetTart · 24/02/2024 20:32

My experience of SW seems so different from the negative comments on here. I found there is so much positive talk about food at my group, about all the healthy and tasty foods you can eat freely and the amazing recipes in the books. We have food parties where everyone brings in their favourite dishes and the food was amazing.

I haven't 'inevitably' put the weight back on and feel that having gone through the SW programme I've learned so much about what to eat to keep myself at a healthy weight. I serve SW meals all the time in my house and guests often ask for the recipe so it's good, tasty stuff and not 'diet' food.

Obviously they're a business and there to make money, but fair play to them, it really works and it's changed my life. I guess what works for some doesn't work for others and the secret is to find what will help you and be in the right head space for it.

Most people do ‘inevitably’ put the weight back on. There have been studies.

ps. I’m pleased it works for you and that you enjoy the food. I’m not trying to take away peoples personal experiences.
Just sharing the facts that diets generally do more harm than good.

SomersetTart · 24/02/2024 20:32

My experience of SW seems so different from the negative comments on here. I found there is so much positive talk about food at my group, about all the healthy and tasty foods you can eat freely and the amazing recipes in the books. We have food parties where everyone brings in their favourite dishes and the food was amazing.

I haven't 'inevitably' put the weight back on and feel that having gone through the SW programme I've learned so much about what to eat to keep myself at a healthy weight. I serve SW meals all the time in my house and guests often ask for the recipe so it's good, tasty stuff and not 'diet' food.

Obviously they're a business and there to make money, but fair play to them, it really works and it's changed my life. I guess what works for some doesn't work for others and the secret is to find what will help you and be in the right head space for it.

Tagyoureit · 24/02/2024 19:54

I don't like sw due to the negative language around food, syns, its so crap. The whole banana issue, whole its syn free, mushed its synful.

Calorie counting would probably be better but whatever you do try, it's got to come from you, lead a horse to water and all that.
If you want it, you've got to do it and if do you have a crap day, write it off and carry on.

Thementalloadisreal · 24/02/2024 19:38

Dogdilemma2000 · 24/02/2024 18:14

@SomersetTart ”Slimming World's revenue is $921 Million”

It’s a money making machine. You get access for free at target, but it’s still a massively profitable business, and we shouldn’t pretend it isn’t. The owner is very rich. People wouldn’t buy into the system if it didn’t work though.

People buy into it because it works to a point. It’s a profitable business because people inevitably put weight back on and start paying them again.

whenemmafallsinlove · 24/02/2024 18:29

You don't have to eat their branded products. Dh likes the bars and finds them handy but otherwise they make very little from us Grin

Dogdilemma2000 · 24/02/2024 18:15
tabulahrasa · 24/02/2024 18:15

Rosestulips · 24/02/2024 17:49

correct me if I’m wrong but is the focus on low fat rather than low sugar?

No, it’s both

Dogdilemma2000 · 24/02/2024 18:14

@SomersetTart ”Slimming World's revenue is $921 Million”

It’s a money making machine. You get access for free at target, but it’s still a massively profitable business, and we shouldn’t pretend it isn’t. The owner is very rich. People wouldn’t buy into the system if it didn’t work though.

SomersetTart · 24/02/2024 17:59

I would suggest intermittent fasting and a healthy, Mediterranean type diet. Lots of vegetables, moderate amounts of lean protein, and small amounts of complex carbs, healthy fats/nuts and dairy/full fat Greek yoghurt.

With the exception of fasting what you describe is pretty much Slimming World. I ate olives, loads of veg, lean protein, rice, yoghurt, fruit galore, cheese, fish and the odd treat of chocolate and wine.

At the end of the day slimming world is a money making machine.

Once you get to target you can continue going for life without paying a penny.

Where it falls apart is the extra crap they try to peddle you that is all mega ultra processed food.

I lost my three stone without eating any of the ready meals or bars. I used the free recipes on the SW website to make home cooked meals. I never felt pressured to buy any of the meals, bars or recipe books....in fact, the books I have were all free when I signed up for blocks of classes.

NoFucksToGive · 24/02/2024 17:58

I agree with @Thementalloadisreal.

Have a look at TeamRH on TikTok, I really like him and he talks a lot of sense, especially about many of the diet clubs out there. For me, I needed a complete lifestyle change, I needed to understand calories and why I was gaining a few pounds here and there. Good luck, I hope you find an eating plan that suits you.

Thementalloadisreal · 24/02/2024 17:58

Also it will probably mess with your relationship with food. No diet with arbitrary rules is sustainable. You can have a banana but not if it’s mashed. You can eat as much pasta and muller light yogurts as you want?! Some food is sinful?! It basically nicely packaged disordered eating.

I would suggest looking into nutrition, macros, whole grains, good foods for staying full, more vegetables and whole food protein sources.

Don’t demonise any food as that will just make you crave it more. Move your body if you are able to exercise (apologies I missed what the operation is and if you’re fully mobile or not) , for joy and pleasure not as punishment.

Diet culture and quick fixes are unhealthy in the long run, unfortunately. If there was one diet or plan that worked for everyone there wouldn’t be any customers for slimming world etc.

PaminaMozart · 24/02/2024 17:49

@SummerGardener - to lose weight and KEEP it off requires a change of lifestyle, and I'm not sure SW is the best avenue for this.

I would suggest intermittent fasting and a healthy, Mediterranean type diet. Lots of vegetables, moderate amounts of lean protein, and small amounts of complex carbs, healthy fats/nuts and dairy/full fat Greek yoghurt.

Plus exercise. Try Lucy Wyndham Read - she is very calm and lovely, and her workouts are quite short and not too challenging. If you can also use some weights/dumbbells, so much the better. Look at Rebecca Louiseand Growingannanas to start with, but endeavour to get fit enough for Caroline Girvan.

Thementalloadisreal · 24/02/2024 17:49

You will lose weight with most diets - slimming world, weight watchers etc. But you are incredibly unlikely to keep it off. That’s their business model.

Rosestulips · 24/02/2024 17:49

correct me if I’m wrong but is the focus on low fat rather than low sugar?

Dogdilemma2000 · 24/02/2024 17:48

BobbyBiscuits · 24/02/2024 15:57

@NCForQuestions I get it, but potatoes have lots of carbs which are the same as sugar, so not great for diabetics for example.

I know you can't have endless chips. Haha. That would be too good to be true.

I guess it's the type of diet that suits people who like to feel full and eat quite large portions. It enables you to do that without the calories being too high. I just think the principles of it are simply low fat, calorie control under a slightly gimmicky name. My friend lost plenty weight on it, but it didn't last.

It's not the worst by any stretch. WW is even more gimmicky. Meal replacement diets are depressing and unhealthy and you never keep the weight off. Keto/ low carb can be quite good. As long as you want the opposite of unlimited potatoes, haha.

Potatoes are not the same as sugar. Sugar causes a very real insulin spike that potatoes do not for the majority of diabetics.

Dogdilemma2000 · 24/02/2024 17:46

Slimming world works as it’s just a different way of doing calorie restrictions.

Where it falls apart is the extra crap they try to peddle you that is all mega ultra processed food. There’s no nutritional value whatsoever in the bars they sell.

If you do it but avoid ultra high processed food you’ll do a lot better.

At the end of the day slimming world is a money making machine.

brunettemic · 24/02/2024 17:44

You can eat anything but not everything. Just have a balanced diet, leave some treats in there but have a good mix of everything you need, including carbs. Don’t ever treat anything as a “sin”, it’s ridiculous.

AnneLovesGilbert · 24/02/2024 17:43

I have 3 friends who did it together for a while. They all hit target then each ended up heavier than they started within a couple of years. The fear of olive oil always seemed strange.

SomersetTart · 24/02/2024 17:40

You're not encouraged to eat 'an unlimited amount' of anything on SW.

You're encouraged to eat until you are satisfied, not to stuff your face with spuds until you're bursting.

I lost 3 stones on it in six months last year and, using the information they gave me, I am keeping it off and feel much better about myself and healthier.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 24/02/2024 17:33

CherryBlossomPants · 24/02/2024 13:22

No, slimming world is awful diet cult that doesn’t even understand the basics of weight loss. There is no food in this world that should be classed as a ‘syn’ It’s about a healthy balance.

Calorie counting will be your best bet moving forward focusing on protein to keep you full and vegetables. Have a look at ‘The Fitness Chef’ on Facebook/Insta and you’ll see how much sense he talks. It’s all about calories in and calories out but please don’t follow slimming world.

The whole point of the 'syns' is about balance . Fill up on basic vegetables, protein and complex carbs and have a limited amount of treat food - literally as a treat - that's why you count it but don't need to count the healthier stuff as long as you are still losing weight .

Simply calorie counting can mean that someone could 1,000 cals a day on chocolate - so hardly teaching about healthy eating .

BobbyBiscuits · 24/02/2024 15:57

@NCForQuestions I get it, but potatoes have lots of carbs which are the same as sugar, so not great for diabetics for example.

I know you can't have endless chips. Haha. That would be too good to be true.

I guess it's the type of diet that suits people who like to feel full and eat quite large portions. It enables you to do that without the calories being too high. I just think the principles of it are simply low fat, calorie control under a slightly gimmicky name. My friend lost plenty weight on it, but it didn't last.

It's not the worst by any stretch. WW is even more gimmicky. Meal replacement diets are depressing and unhealthy and you never keep the weight off. Keto/ low carb can be quite good. As long as you want the opposite of unlimited potatoes, haha.

NCForQuestions · 24/02/2024 15:31

@BobbyBiscuits what's wrong with unlimited potato? Boiled, mashed, air fried or jacket potato is all good - there's no fat or sugar in those and it's pretty low calorie. Potatoes in and of themselves are not bad for you, and if you're eating the 1/3 rule, your plate should still be a balanced meal.

Roast or fried potatoes changes things and they are not unlimited, you have to account for the fat used to cook them and that's harder to do on SW.

BobbyBiscuits · 24/02/2024 15:02

Some of the principles of SW are pretty weird. Like you can eat an unlimited number of potatoes? The classes seem quite culty, a guess a lot like WW but without the points. I always think that these clubs are designed to keep you needing to go back, which to me means they don't help you keep the weight off that effectively.
The principles of a low fat calorie controlled diet are same as SW, without the gimmicks.
Can I ask how much you are hoping/ needing to lose?