Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS might be dangerously obsessed with studying?

66 replies

pinotmore · 24/02/2024 11:20

I am getting a little worried about this and wonder if I should do something about it and if so, what?

He is in Y12 doing 3 essay-based subjects and got excellent results last year for his GCSEs. He's always been very academically able but also very driven, competitive and hardworking. He has decided he wants to apply to Oxbridge and, imo, is becoming over-invested in this. He goes to a decent but unremarkable comp which sends 1 or 2 students each year and he's being egged on by teachers saying things like, 'If anyone will get in you will,' and 'you're the best candidate we've had for years.' I know they mean well, but I wish this would stop.

He has decided he needs to do 40 hours additional study each week on top of his taught lessons, and is aiming for that, which I think is far too much. He stays at school until 5ish then walks home and is on the sofa with an app on his phone that times him, making notes/writing essays/reading pretty much all evening. He is in the room with me and does seem to be able to multi-task and talk to me quite a bit (he's always been chatty) and takes lots of mini-breaks to listen to a song or talk etc. I go to bed at 10ish and he goes up at about 11.30, often waking me up talking aloud to himself about one of his topics. I feel he's getting himself hyped up and not winding down before bed, but he does seem to sleep ok and is up at 7ish (including weekends) and seems fine in the mornings.

He has a large group of friends - no particular close friend - and sees them at school and socially on a Friday. So last night he was out with them 6-12 but then no further social plans for the weekend, which is typical for him. When on study leave/in the summer he socialised a lot, so I do think this is partly down to the time of year. He doesn't do online socialising but is very interactive with me and, when ds2 is around, with him. We were all up by 9ish and been chatting/listening to music, but now he's got the laptop out and will be on it for most of the day.

What has prompted me to post is that he plays cricket for our local team and has done since being about 6. It can be a source of frustration to him with not batting/bowling much, but he does love being part of the team and usually gets the 'captain's award' at the end of the season for his great attitude/commitment/team-playing etc. But it's long days, sometimes both days of the weekend, with him feeling, I know, a bit disappointed with how it goes a lot of the time. Before anyone says it, he's well aware that fielding is crucial and he does a great job at that. I'm a lp with a stressful full-time job and I know nothing about cricket, so I haven't been able to support him in this, which makes me feel guilty. He has just told me that he doesn't want to do it this year and doesn't intend to play at all. He says it's because he doesn't have time, and I admit it is a hugely time-consuming sport and would eat into his study time, but part of me thinks this would be a good thing. Then I think, would it, if he's not even completely enjoying the cricket?

He doesn't have other hobbies as such, though he has loads of interests and, as I've said, isn't shut in his room all the time, but is indoors on his laptop. I don't really know what I'm asking - obviously I can't make him do cricket and I also can't really control how much he studies, but does it sound like I should worry?I'd love to hear others' perspectives.

OP posts:
EverlastingStar · 24/02/2024 14:22

I don't why you would even want to interfere

Just let him do his thing

BlueGrey1 · 24/02/2024 14:11

My worry would be the lack of sport, getting into the habit of playing sport will help him deal with stress now and in later life…..does he play any sport now?

Would he get involved in park runs…..running could be very beneficial to him and may help him avoid burnout

YouOKHun · 24/02/2024 14:10

Dixiechickonhols · 24/02/2024 12:14

I’d be worried all eggs in one basket and may struggle if he doesn’t get Oxbridge offer. It really is partly luck to be the one in a sea of outstanding candidates. I’d spend time doing to other university open days and encourage him to aim high but not fixate on Oxbridge.

I agree with this and others saying the same. It’s good you’re encouraging him to look beyond Oxbridge as well.

A friend of mine who interviews at Oxford has said to me more than once that they know they say no to many candidates shortlisted for interview each year who would have done well and been very capable. This can be devastating for some who have focussed on Oxbridge, handed in good work, done well in the tests, got an interview and then waited for weeks only to be told no, especially as the other competitive universities may not have made offers at that point, so it can be very discombobulating. It’s important to develop some attractive alternatives.

ilovesushi · 24/02/2024 13:29

I'd be worried about burnout and being overly fixated on Oxbridge. He may get in but he may not. My DB got in and I didn't. I was absolutely gutted at the time. Make sure he visits other top unis. Find out which the best ones are in his subject area and get some visits in.

Winter2020 · 24/02/2024 13:25

Hi Op,
If your son opts out of cricket this year I wonder if he would consider doing something that is a much smaller commitment to take it's place. Is there a local Park Run? - That would blow the cobwebs off.

pinotmore · 24/02/2024 12:41

I am definitely trying to get him interested in other universities and we will do some open days of those he has said he'd like to go to. He does have a shortlist as he has done some research. I am very well aware that there are many other exceptional young people out there and I really don't want him to see himself as a failure if he doesn't get there.

OP posts:
whohoo · 24/02/2024 12:40

Have you spoken about what will happen if he doesn't get into Oxbridge? He's clearly going to get into a top university but he needs to be prepared for that not being Oxbridge and being ok with that.
He sounds amazing, though!

AIstolemylunch · 24/02/2024 12:38

This is the level he needs to be at for Oxbridge applications I think. The danger for me is, even then, it's still a numbers game so he might not get in and the disappointment can be crushing. Id focus on getting him enthusiastic about his second choice great university, taking him for visits etc so he can see that oxbridge isn't the be all and end all for clever people such as himself (it really isnt)

Octavia64 · 24/02/2024 12:33

I was like that as a teen.

I loved the subjects I was studying and always had my nose in a book.

I did extra a levels at evening classes because I just wanted to know more, and they helped me understand the world.

I really don't think you should be trying to stop him.

I went to Cambridge and studied economics and while the workload is high for people who are interested in what they are studying it's just such an opportunity to immerse yourself in a subject.

Through my life I've continued learning and I still do this with new subjects. I have a maths degree as well now which I did for fun and I'm now learning Arabic, also for fun.

Some people are like this.

I have very little interest in drinking, socialising, and most sports.

Thingamebobwotsit · 24/02/2024 12:30

Is he anxious or stressed with it? Or is he thriving and pushing?

There is a real positive element to being this focused and as others have said being relentlessly focused at A level isn't necessarily a bad thing for Yr 12 and 13. However I would be having a conversation with him about what will he do/feel if he doesn't get through and how will he ease off himself after the exams over the summer. It is really hard to go from 100mph on heavy work/stuff to nothing, so get him to focus on what happens over the school holidays, this summer and over the summer before he goes to university and plan for after that. And also tell him that university applications/interviews will be looking for students that manage to combine the academics with the outside stuff as well. It is competitive in Oxbridge but the students that stand out are the ones that have interesting stories to tell too.

The vast majority of successful people work really hard. But it does need a balance and he needs to look after himself.

Fair play to him though. I am properly impressed.

beyourcoffeepot · 24/02/2024 12:27

We send a number of students to Oxbridge and as a teacher yourself you're well aware of the 1 hour taught = 1 hour independent study (our Oxbridge do more, of course, but not 40 hours!) I would be worried, as a previous poster says, that he's placing too much emphasis on his Oxbridge application. He may not get a place: how will he feel? Have you raised your concerns with the school?

FabFebHalfTerm · 24/02/2024 12:26

He sounds fine.

hes at an age/stage where you can be intense about things. And have the energy/stamina to do it.

just support him. Maybe encourage him to take time each day for a walk/run, although he maybe getting exercise/fresh air on his daily commute.

museumum · 24/02/2024 12:23

He needs fresh air and exercise so I’d talk to him about how he’s going to get that consistently if he doesn’t play cricket this year. He needs to schedule in outdoor time for his own well-being.

Kdtym10 · 24/02/2024 12:23

Sounds like me at his age. It’s fantastic. Fwiw I was later diagnosed -ADHD - it’s not always disruptive it’s sometimes a super power. Hyperfocus “ lots of mini breaks, listening to music whilst he works (is it classical or heavy metal by any chance) like socialising but can’t do it too much because it’s draining!

My mum used to always try and get me to go out as and didn’t understand my studying, I still get wound up about it 30 years later. Support him - I 100% do!

Not read through the full threat but I’m guessing history, English and sociology/psychology/Philosophy?

rainyskylight · 24/02/2024 12:22

sounds fine to me, but then I also cared about the same things your son does, and then went on to Oxbridge..

1 hour independent for every hour taught is nothing when doing A Levels and on a reduced timetable (due to less subjects).

he absolutely should be reading around the subject, podcasts etc.

what you could do is try and get some variety in his week by occasionally finding an activity with him that complements his subject and provides a social 1-2-1 aspect. Eg museums, an historical film, etc.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/02/2024 12:16

I’d encourage practical life skills too - driving lessons, him cooking a night a week. A pt job at sixth form does them a world of good in terms of developing skills - managing time, speaking to people etc.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/02/2024 12:14

I’d be worried all eggs in one basket and may struggle if he doesn’t get Oxbridge offer. It really is partly luck to be the one in a sea of outstanding candidates. I’d spend time doing to other university open days and encourage him to aim high but not fixate on Oxbridge.

MatildaTheCat · 24/02/2024 12:13

In terms of sport is there another form of exercise he might substitute for the cricket? If not I’d be encouraging him to keep it up as it adds an element of life balance which is so important.

pinotmore · 24/02/2024 12:10

As for whether he's happy or stressed, I don't think he's stressed overall, but he is very intense and if he comes across a hurdle at all, like a question he doesn't quite get the wording of, or a piece of seemingly contradictory advice from a teacher, he can fly right off the handle. Doesn't happen that often, especially now he has dropped certain subjects, but it does happen and it does worry me as it's not a good response to a hurdle. I suppose it's ok if I'm there to intervene, but obviously that isn't always the case.

OP posts:
twingiraffes · 24/02/2024 12:09

Single-minded, determined, motivated and with a strong work ethic?

Leave well alone, he is great!!

mynameiscalypso · 24/02/2024 12:06

I'd probably want him to sleep a bit more but appreciate you can't really tell a 16/17 year old to do that. But I do recognise the interest in the subject. I wasn't necessarily that committed to spending hours over my homework but I loved to read around my subjects. I found it truly fascinating - I did English, Politics and a language - and I always wanted to read more. So I'd read other books by the set authors so I could understand and appreciate their work better. Or read books about political theory which weren't part of my A levels of course. It sounds like he has an okay balance, sleep aside though.

Cismyfatarse · 24/02/2024 12:05

I have two (now at University) like this. For them, studying is fun. It is relaxing and absorbing. I am a bit like this but more with books. I could easily read for 40+ hours a week on top of school (I am a teacher).

Our Oxbridge pupils (and top students) at school often love their subjects so much that they can't imagine not doing them.

Rosiiee · 24/02/2024 12:02

It sounds pretty normal I think? It’s what I did in my final year of school- as did every other girl in the boarding house. The only time we had a break was meal times and my roommates and I took an hour walk in the afternoons but it was a really intense year!

Ironoaks · 24/02/2024 12:00

"he's reading ahead or around etc"
This sounds like a worthwhile use of his time, especially if he is interested in the subject and enjoys it.

Ironoaks · 24/02/2024 11:57

"If he gets to Oxford or Cambridge he can then enjoy himself and embrace all the lovely social aspects that Uni life brings. A-Levels are the hard bit."

Not in DS's experience. First year was a significantly greater volume of workload than 4 A-levels, although perhaps that was subject-specific.

OP: it's good that your DS is self-motivated. For A-levels he should be doing approximately 1 hour of independent study for each hour spent in lessons. Is it possible that someone suggested 40 hours in total (including lesson time) and he misheard?

Swipe left for the next trending thread