Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My brother has hidden my nephews rugby playing...

685 replies

touchrugby · 24/02/2024 09:48

Asking for my brother - I think he’s in a mess and I need to tell him what to expect and how unreasonable he was. Interested to hear from other divorced parents and sports teachers/ school administrators. I’ve tried to give as much context as possible.

My brother got divorced 4 years ago. They have (had?) an amicable coparent relationship- there was no cheating or unkindness in either side. My brother just became obsessed with giving his family a good life and he worked a lot of hours. When he wasn’t working he was a very engaged parent- my nephew is hugely sporty and they were always off doing sports- swimming, tennis, football, cross country etc. Ex SIL was a SAHP but eventually got frustrated (with justification) at never seeing her husband so went back to work and divorced him. They share 50/50 custody with my brother as the higher earner paying all DNs expenses.

My brother really wanted nephew to go to this very nice private school. To facilitate this he pays all the fees. It’s a great academic school so ex SIL was pretty happy-except for the sport. They’re a big rugby school and she was adamant that DN not play rugby due to injury risks. There was a big argument about it, with my brother and DN really wanting rugby, and her adamant that he wouldn’t play.

The school offers non contact rugby and eventually they agreed DN would do that. DN is in year 9 now and it’s recently come out that he switched to full contact rugby in the 3rd week of year 7 and SIL didn’t know. It’s come out because he’s recently been made captain of the A team and a few mums congratulated her.

It seems he hated the non contact team. He’s very gifted with sport and apparently it was a team of lads who just wanted to run around for a few hours and throw a ball. The school put little effort into it and there were no matches. He asked to switch to “proper” rugby and the school said they needed a parent to approve it- and my brother did.

His argument is that his son wanted it, the school did email SIL as well, and it’s been 2.5 years.
Her argument is that he knew her stance, he also knows she’s a bit disorganised and rarely reads emails especially ones about sport which she know my brother manages (she has over 10,000 unread emails on her phone!) and that my brother conspired to hide it.

She has a very valid point about the conspiring. She has a new partner. He works Saturdays so my brother used to have DN every Friday night so they could see each other, and he’d then take him to Sat morning matches before dropping him at SILs Sat evening. Brother and DN have both, in 2.5 years, managed not to say anything to her about his rugby which is obviously duplicitous, especially considering how good he is. Brother just managed all the kit and the washing and the games and it apparently never came up in conversation.

Shes utterly furious and is going to the school Monday to tell them to remove him from rugby. Brother planning on going to the school to tell them to keep him in rugby. DN is apparently going to refuse to return to his mums house unless she agrees to the rugby and is determined to continue.

I’ve maintained a good friendship with SIL. In many ways I’m closer her than my brother as I see her more (he’s still a workaholic in his non parenting time so he’s hard to get hold of!) I heard about the odd match but nothing specific, I assumed it was non contact and frankly don’t know anything about rugby anyway. She’s very unhappy with our family as obviously our parents knew as well. My dad watches half the matches!

Does anyone know what the school might do? My brother and nephew are digging their heels in and saying he’ll live full time at my brothers and my brother will therefore get full parental responsibility. I think this is rubbish and not legal. I am worried that a nice coparenting relationship is ruined and that SIL might lose my nephew. He loves his mum but he’s obsessed with sport and apparently A team captain at a school like his is a BIG deal. He’s already playing some 2nd eleven matches as well which is also apparently important. I don’t know how to feel about what my brother did. He has absolutely supported what DN wanted. My nephew is so happy playing rugby and so good at it and still uninjured, and it’s the game played by 90% of the school. She knew sending him there that if he didn’t play rugby he’d be a bit isolated but she will not have it.

Frankly I think there’s fault on both sides, but on balance how much more unreasonable was my brother and what the hell might happen next?

OP posts:
nolongersurprised · 25/02/2024 00:10

NotAgainWilson · 24/02/2024 23:04

There’s nothing stopping the mother to apply for a court order and while the issue get resolved the pattern of contact is very likely to remain the same.

No kid under 16 will be allowed to decide freely where to live if the parents are in disagreement and prepared to fight their corner.

I have seen c”a case when a parent wanted to change just one day on a 50/50 contact agreement and that only took a few months and over £50,000 in solicitors fees.

If the parents stubbornly decide not to compromise at all, it can be very costly in terms of time and money and emotionally damaging enough to destroy everyone involved.

What if the 14 year old child leaves the mother and refuses to go back? Are you saying that, in the UK, this boy would be picked up by the police and taken from his mum’s house to his dad’s house? Every time?

if a 14 year old is refusing to live with one parent and wants to live with the other, why would a court insist otherwise?

QueenOfTheLabyrinth · 25/02/2024 00:07

We had a school ski trip when I was in year 9, one of the girls died after hitting her head on a rock.

Your SIL has obviously done her research about Rugby so maybe suggest she do the same about skiing, especially when it comes to injuries in children because she’s being a complete hypocrite here just because it happens to align with her own interests.

brassbells · 24/02/2024 23:31

touchrugby · 24/02/2024 17:00

Interesting.... she's ok with skiing. Possibly because she herself enjoys it...

Ok this makes her the unreasonable one, for sure

If she was completely risk averse and just wrapped DN in cotton wool and just wanted him to play tiddle winks then I could understand her POV

But just because SHE likes skiing she thinks it is perfectly ok for him to ski BUT DB likes rugby and she thinks it is too dangerous for DN to play

What if DB didn't agree with his son skiing then what would she have said about that?

Her passion is skiing so she thinks ok for him to ski and DB passion is rugby so he thinks it is ok for him to do that too

Both 50/50 parenting

Please make sure he is only paying with boys the same age as him though, not the 6th formers in 2nd XV.

Also, not school fault as she should have read the emails from the school and objected 2 years ago

Garlicnaan · 24/02/2024 23:25

I'm team SIL. Your DB clearly took the lead in terms of DS's sport when they were together, so I don't think it's weird that continued once they'd split. Both parents don't have to be all over everything.

She made her stance on contact rugby crystal clear, and it was something she felt very strongly about. DB has been a poor coparent and a poor father by not discussing this with SIL and clearly telling DS to lie. For YEARS. That's outrageous. And way worse than missing some emails. He's betrayed her and let his son down.

On the flip side, SIL could be more open minded about trying to understand her DS's passion and skill. But the years of lying is only going to make it LESS likely for all parties to move to a consensus.

mathanxiety · 24/02/2024 23:12

@Goldbar

The school emailed her.

She had every chance to take part in any conversation she felt necessary about rugby.

Failure to open her emails is a big problem here. It's her problem though, not anyone else's.

mathanxiety · 24/02/2024 23:09

BreatheAndFocus · 24/02/2024 17:43

She no doubt assumed it was about the non-contact rugby she’d agreed to! Her ex misled her and engaged in deception even though it had previously been agreed their don would only do non contact rugby. How was she to know that agreement would be breached?

By opening the email and reading it, perhaps?

lto2019 · 24/02/2024 23:05

A friend of mine died following an epileptic seizure - his epilepsy was brought on by a head injury incurred during a school rugby match. I never wanted my son to play rugby for that and many other serious injuries which occur. However, it is not illegal, the same as riding a motorbike is not illegal and I wouldn't want him doing that either.
Unfortunately, I am not sure there is anything SIL can actually do if your brother allows it and he is one of the parents. I can see why she is livid and probably scared for her son. Your brother and nephew have both been duplicitous but I don't think she can do anything apart from appeal to them and the school and it sounds like the pair of them would not really be trustworthy anyway.
I can see why the nephew is upset but dad should not be facilitating him basically trying to force his mother to agree by threatening to move out.
It's a game played all over though so I suspect she is on a hiding to nothing.

NotAgainWilson · 24/02/2024 23:04

nolongersurprised · 24/02/2024 21:56

But - the son could just move out and live with his dad. Which sounds like it might happen. His mum can’t stop him. She can’t call the police because he’s living with a parent, unless there’s a prior court order. A court won’t find in her favour because his dad works hard if the boy makes it clear he wants to live with his dad.

There’s nothing stopping the mother to apply for a court order and while the issue get resolved the pattern of contact is very likely to remain the same.

No kid under 16 will be allowed to decide freely where to live if the parents are in disagreement and prepared to fight their corner.

I have seen c”a case when a parent wanted to change just one day on a 50/50 contact agreement and that only took a few months and over £50,000 in solicitors fees.

If the parents stubbornly decide not to compromise at all, it can be very costly in terms of time and money and emotionally damaging enough to destroy everyone involved.

mathanxiety · 24/02/2024 23:03

BlueMongoose · 24/02/2024 19:41

The type of injury is different. I for one would not ski because a) I'm not interested, and b) I wouldn't risk injury in it. But the sort of injuries you mention are not the ones most parents worry about when it comes to rugby. Basically broken bones is the most likely with skiing, but with rugby, you add broken neck and potential brain damage.

Skiing injuries are absolutely not confined to extremities.

Head injuries as well as spinal and neck injuries happen frequently. TBI is the leading cause of death in the winter sports population as a whole (various Alpine sports). Downhill skiers in particular tend to get concussions. Snow boarders get TBIs.

mathanxiety · 24/02/2024 22:55

NotAgainWilson · 24/02/2024 21:49

It doesn’t matter who is right or wrong, if they take this to court it can go on for months, cost £1000s and during that time the child won’t be allowed to play.

I doubt very much the school will allow the kid to play if the parents are not in agreement as if there is an accident they will be, rightly, blamed.

DN may be claiming that he will move to his dad’s and at that age, courts will certainly hear his views but that is not the same as saying that they will agree with him as mum is a good carer, the main carer and having divorced because your brother is a workaholic, the court will be concerned that he wouldn’t be able to have his child living with him without neglecting him and again a court case about this will take months or possibly years to be decided UNLESS at some point both parents get to an agreement or one runs out of money to keep financing a legal battle.

I think a court would look at all those years of never looking at emails or anything else she ever got from the school relating to rugby playing/ her own DS, and wonder if she was too 'scatty' to be put in charge of a hamster.

6pence · 24/02/2024 22:17

The main point now is their relationship going forward. Sil has no choice but to accept it if she wants life to resume back to normal with ds.

Db and dn need to do some serious grovelling though. And really accept the lying by omission is still very hurtful.

nolongersurprised · 24/02/2024 22:17

You’d hope she wouldn’t stop her child playing the sport he loves though.

if this is real - I agree with a pp. you’d have to not read any form of correspondence from the school or go to any P-T interview to be obvious that your child was playing playing sport to a high level. There’d be: mention of sport in reports, invitations to awards ceremonies where they got their colours or whatever, and of season ceremonies.

she is either next-level vacuous or it’s all a bit odd.

NamingConundrum · 24/02/2024 21:59

nolongersurprised · 24/02/2024 21:46

Was that for a 14 year old though? I have experience of warring parents in the Aus court system and at that age, the boy could pretty much decide who he wanted to live with

11/12 and yes, 14 year old can decide he wants to only live with dad but that doesn't remove her parental responsibility. A parent can sign birth certificate and never see the child again but PR means right to choose education etc so they could contact all schools in area if they wanted and say no permission for child to attend and the other parent wouldn't be able to send them without court order. Having PR can literally mean rights over medical and educational decisions etc for a child they have never even met.

nolongersurprised · 24/02/2024 21:56

NotAgainWilson · 24/02/2024 21:49

It doesn’t matter who is right or wrong, if they take this to court it can go on for months, cost £1000s and during that time the child won’t be allowed to play.

I doubt very much the school will allow the kid to play if the parents are not in agreement as if there is an accident they will be, rightly, blamed.

DN may be claiming that he will move to his dad’s and at that age, courts will certainly hear his views but that is not the same as saying that they will agree with him as mum is a good carer, the main carer and having divorced because your brother is a workaholic, the court will be concerned that he wouldn’t be able to have his child living with him without neglecting him and again a court case about this will take months or possibly years to be decided UNLESS at some point both parents get to an agreement or one runs out of money to keep financing a legal battle.

But - the son could just move out and live with his dad. Which sounds like it might happen. His mum can’t stop him. She can’t call the police because he’s living with a parent, unless there’s a prior court order. A court won’t find in her favour because his dad works hard if the boy makes it clear he wants to live with his dad.

KBBuniv · 24/02/2024 21:54

This is quite odd - i doubt very much that his talent/success wasn’t mentioned in his reports; i also very much doubt that there weren’t team photos in newsletters, school magazines etc esp as its a rugby focussed school; and you say SIL was involved in his social life - some of that was prob rugby team focused? What about training sessions pre and post school and in holidays? I find it really hard to believe she wouldn’t have known for 2.5 years unless she is ignoring every bit of school material, schedules etc!

Ottersmith · 24/02/2024 21:52

She should have sent him to a school that plays football if she didn't want him to play rugby. She had her head in the sand.

NotAgainWilson · 24/02/2024 21:49

It doesn’t matter who is right or wrong, if they take this to court it can go on for months, cost £1000s and during that time the child won’t be allowed to play.

I doubt very much the school will allow the kid to play if the parents are not in agreement as if there is an accident they will be, rightly, blamed.

DN may be claiming that he will move to his dad’s and at that age, courts will certainly hear his views but that is not the same as saying that they will agree with him as mum is a good carer, the main carer and having divorced because your brother is a workaholic, the court will be concerned that he wouldn’t be able to have his child living with him without neglecting him and again a court case about this will take months or possibly years to be decided UNLESS at some point both parents get to an agreement or one runs out of money to keep financing a legal battle.

nolongersurprised · 24/02/2024 21:46

NamingConundrum · 24/02/2024 21:35

Not if she makes enough of a fuss. She has PR. I've known someone who had to take their ex to court over permission for school trips so I imagine brother could get a court order to allow the rugby if it went that far.

Was that for a 14 year old though? I have experience of warring parents in the Aus court system and at that age, the boy could pretty much decide who he wanted to live with

senua · 24/02/2024 21:44

Apparently SIL is not interested in her DS's rugby but is very interested in his academics. Now - when he is about to choose GCSE options - is not the ideal time to fall out with him.

NamingConundrum · 24/02/2024 21:35

FlamingoQueen · 24/02/2024 21:22

School will probably roll their eyes, ask the child what he wants to do and put it down to another family that won’t talk to each other, but expect school to do their dirty work!

Not if she makes enough of a fuss. She has PR. I've known someone who had to take their ex to court over permission for school trips so I imagine brother could get a court order to allow the rugby if it went that far.

FlamingoQueen · 24/02/2024 21:22

School will probably roll their eyes, ask the child what he wants to do and put it down to another family that won’t talk to each other, but expect school to do their dirty work!

DodgeDoggie · 24/02/2024 21:17

she should have read her emails. It’s her fault she doesn’t know ..

he should not facilitate his son leaving the maternal home. That is childish cruel and reactionary behaviour.

time for the son to do some research online and provide facts to both parents. That way he is aware of the risks and knows what he’s got into. This may put your sil mind at peace … or not

SaffaIrish · 24/02/2024 21:15

Your DN is very likely to be Gillick competent. He can make his own decisions as long as he understands what the ramifications are. The school only needs permission from one parent about anything to do with school. If the other parent disagrees, they will need to take that up with the family courts. The school will not (and should not) get involved.

Gcsunnyside23 · 24/02/2024 21:15

As you have a good relationship with them both is there any way you can meditate a conversation between them? I do think you need your brother to concede he was an arsehole being deceptive but that he won't risk his sons relationship with her by allowing him to remove himself from her home. But your sil needs to concede she should have paid more attention all around, listened to her son and tried to compromise. But removing him now isn't an option as it's too far down the line. Your brother was completely wrong how he went about it but your sil is also completely wrong in that she flat refused him to play, takes zero interest in that part of her sons life and cherry picks what she thinks is safe e.g all sports gave risks, I'd even say skiing which she's fine with is just as risky

GnomeDePlume · 24/02/2024 21:08

whenemmafallsinlove · 24/02/2024 18:26

The fact that she's ok with with skiing speaks volumes. It's really all about her isn't it?

This struck me as well.

I wonder if the real issue for SIL is that her DS is passionate about the 'wrong' thing ie rugby rather than being passionate about the same things she is passionate about.