Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My brother has hidden my nephews rugby playing...

685 replies

touchrugby · 24/02/2024 09:48

Asking for my brother - I think he’s in a mess and I need to tell him what to expect and how unreasonable he was. Interested to hear from other divorced parents and sports teachers/ school administrators. I’ve tried to give as much context as possible.

My brother got divorced 4 years ago. They have (had?) an amicable coparent relationship- there was no cheating or unkindness in either side. My brother just became obsessed with giving his family a good life and he worked a lot of hours. When he wasn’t working he was a very engaged parent- my nephew is hugely sporty and they were always off doing sports- swimming, tennis, football, cross country etc. Ex SIL was a SAHP but eventually got frustrated (with justification) at never seeing her husband so went back to work and divorced him. They share 50/50 custody with my brother as the higher earner paying all DNs expenses.

My brother really wanted nephew to go to this very nice private school. To facilitate this he pays all the fees. It’s a great academic school so ex SIL was pretty happy-except for the sport. They’re a big rugby school and she was adamant that DN not play rugby due to injury risks. There was a big argument about it, with my brother and DN really wanting rugby, and her adamant that he wouldn’t play.

The school offers non contact rugby and eventually they agreed DN would do that. DN is in year 9 now and it’s recently come out that he switched to full contact rugby in the 3rd week of year 7 and SIL didn’t know. It’s come out because he’s recently been made captain of the A team and a few mums congratulated her.

It seems he hated the non contact team. He’s very gifted with sport and apparently it was a team of lads who just wanted to run around for a few hours and throw a ball. The school put little effort into it and there were no matches. He asked to switch to “proper” rugby and the school said they needed a parent to approve it- and my brother did.

His argument is that his son wanted it, the school did email SIL as well, and it’s been 2.5 years.
Her argument is that he knew her stance, he also knows she’s a bit disorganised and rarely reads emails especially ones about sport which she know my brother manages (she has over 10,000 unread emails on her phone!) and that my brother conspired to hide it.

She has a very valid point about the conspiring. She has a new partner. He works Saturdays so my brother used to have DN every Friday night so they could see each other, and he’d then take him to Sat morning matches before dropping him at SILs Sat evening. Brother and DN have both, in 2.5 years, managed not to say anything to her about his rugby which is obviously duplicitous, especially considering how good he is. Brother just managed all the kit and the washing and the games and it apparently never came up in conversation.

Shes utterly furious and is going to the school Monday to tell them to remove him from rugby. Brother planning on going to the school to tell them to keep him in rugby. DN is apparently going to refuse to return to his mums house unless she agrees to the rugby and is determined to continue.

I’ve maintained a good friendship with SIL. In many ways I’m closer her than my brother as I see her more (he’s still a workaholic in his non parenting time so he’s hard to get hold of!) I heard about the odd match but nothing specific, I assumed it was non contact and frankly don’t know anything about rugby anyway. She’s very unhappy with our family as obviously our parents knew as well. My dad watches half the matches!

Does anyone know what the school might do? My brother and nephew are digging their heels in and saying he’ll live full time at my brothers and my brother will therefore get full parental responsibility. I think this is rubbish and not legal. I am worried that a nice coparenting relationship is ruined and that SIL might lose my nephew. He loves his mum but he’s obsessed with sport and apparently A team captain at a school like his is a BIG deal. He’s already playing some 2nd eleven matches as well which is also apparently important. I don’t know how to feel about what my brother did. He has absolutely supported what DN wanted. My nephew is so happy playing rugby and so good at it and still uninjured, and it’s the game played by 90% of the school. She knew sending him there that if he didn’t play rugby he’d be a bit isolated but she will not have it.

Frankly I think there’s fault on both sides, but on balance how much more unreasonable was my brother and what the hell might happen next?

OP posts:
FrustatedAgain · 24/02/2024 13:50

Your SIL created this situation. She didn’t want her son to play rugby, despite the fact her teenage son really wanted to. He’s playing a sport not taking drugs. She should have supported him especially as this is something he is gifted in.
she needs to move on and support her son or she will lose him. She’s putting herself first in all of this.

MaggieBroonofGlebeSt · 24/02/2024 13:50

touchrugby · 24/02/2024 10:12

Honestly no. She's a lovely person and a good mum (just a bit scatty!) she's not sporty and was happy for it to be their thing. About the time he was about to start year 7 there was a lot of press about American footballers suing because of brain injuries they received. She ended up down a rabbit hole and there are a lot of people who are saying that rugby will be next. She then just said a flat "no, no, never" and assumed it was happening.

American football is totally and utterly different to rugby in terms of risk. I wouldn't let DS play AF. It's been proven to be extremely dangerous for their bodies.
I have no worries about him playing rugby. I know kids who've broken bones falling out of trees, playing football, hitting their heads on radiators doing stupid jumps - that's life; boys are prone to doing these things.
Without sport he'd be miserable. The MH aspect matters too.
And before anyone jumps on me, I work for an MND organisation. The evidence of causality from rugby is still not there - people just think it is.

JCLV · 24/02/2024 13:49

IgglePiggledidntdothat · 24/02/2024 10:14

My father was an international rugby player and has dementia. He’s late stage now and I can’t tell you how horrible it is. But I can tell you is def because his head was smashed to bits on the rugby pitch. So whilst my son has both my father’s physique and looks like it the sport would be a natural fit I can’t even watch or talk about rugby, let alone conceive my child doing it.

So it kind of depends on whether or not she has seen first hand the issue of injury and is trying to relay that to people who don’t understand the problems it can causes and are therefore being blase about it. This is where I would be. Or if maybe she’s catastrophising about as it’s something she’s seen can happen but doesn’t always happen at which point the fixation is a bit less understandable.

But for those of us that live it no, I totally get that strength of feeling.

Lots of people get dementia. My mum had it and never played rugby. My dad did play rugby and never had it. You just cannot know.

LookItsMeAgain · 24/02/2024 13:47

touchrugby · 24/02/2024 10:28

This is good advice. My brother says DN wears a scrum cap and has never been injured. The school have a "concussion protocol" which he said he'd share with her but I'm not sure that will help. I mean... why do they need a protocol if concussion isn't a thing?

It's probably been already said but the concussion protocol is something that the RFU has handed down to clubs and schools so that they know what is expected of them should anyone complain about a head injury or be on the receiving end of a bad knock as they are playing.
It's to prevent someone returning to play if they have a concussion and what schoolboy will know what a concussion feels like? They just wont so their coaches and managers have the tools to stop them returning to play too soon, or even at all.

QueenOfTheLabyrinth · 24/02/2024 13:47

touchrugby · 24/02/2024 13:20

From what I can gather rugby isn't an extra curricular. Games is mandatory. The parents evenings are for academic subjects. There are so many coaches for each year group, sport and level that the sports dept expects parents to message/ email/ chat to them before, during or after matches etc. there's a ton of opportunities for parents to understand how their child is doing at sport and the school doesn't actively facilitate it.
DB is practically best mates with DNs coach. He certainly sees him more than his actual friends!

Sorry OP but this is bollocks & your SIL is spinning you a yarn.

Even if what you say is true about parents evening, you have said Games is mandatory therefore it will be listed on his progress reports so obviously she hasn’t been reading those either.

mitogoshi · 24/02/2024 13:45

The fact he's now 14, the courts would simply ask the nephew what he wants.

Far better she just admits she didn't read her emails.

Fwiw my own dd did this to me, the I'm only playing touch rugby to I'm playing full rugby!

Barrenfieldoffucks · 24/02/2024 13:44

bloodyBorat · 24/02/2024 11:20

Your SIL is going to have to accept the rugby. It was very wrong of your brother (and to a lesser extent your father) to deceive her and encourage your nephew to keep her in the dark, that's really appalling behaviour. I happen to agree with her position, but she's been presented with a fait accompli now. It's far too late to withdraw her son without causing terrible damage to the relationship and, anyway, he's soon going to be at an age where he can fully make his own decisions and I'm sure he'll just go back to it.

Your brother's focus needs to be on mitigating the damage to the relationship between your nephew and SIL. He needs to make it clear to your nephew (and your dad!) that lying to her was completely wrong and he's made a very bad misjudgment- he's sent the message that mum's wishes can just be completely ignored if all the blokes just keep schtum. He also needs to knock any idea of her losing custody on the head- yes, your nephew can choose, but he should be sending a strong message to nephew that mum is an equally important parent and he doesn't support the severing of their relationship.

I expect SIL will eventually come round given she's in an absolutely impossible position (and she should have checked her emails!) Your brother should be avoiding making this situation any more combative by talking about full custody!

This, in spades. This is dad's responsibility to sort out, ideally without severing his son's relationship with his mother, who has been backed into a corner by their deception.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 13:43

However this child's mother has not consented to this child playing contact rugby. She has assessed the risks, decided that she considers them too great and said no.

But she also ignored all communication from the school for two years - she doesn't know that there hasn't been multiple e-mails home about it in that time.

For lots of schools, they don't need two lots of parental consent - if dad said it's okay then they'll consider that sufficient.

dapsnotplimsolls · 24/02/2024 13:38

All 3 of them have behaved badly. I agree with PPs that she should engage with the school and find out what they're doing to ensure the safety of the pupils as much as possible.

CloudPop · 24/02/2024 13:36

Woodyandbuzz1 · 24/02/2024 13:28

You nephew will never forgive his mum if she's stops him.

Agreed. If ever there was going to be something that makes him dig his heels in, it's going to be his mum "insisting" he walks away from A team captaincy together with all the humiliation that will bring him at school.

Winter2020 · 24/02/2024 13:36

Singleandproud · 24/02/2024 13:13

@Winter2020 he was in his 20s, not in youth rugby and he and the other player went in for the tackle wrong.
Similar incidents have happened I football. It was a tragic accident but if everyone stopped playing sport after every tragic accident then we wouldn't have any horse riders, cheerleaders, skiers, watersport, board sport athletes etc. its terrible but it happens. Same as driving a car, you do t stop driving just because someone else has a crash.

I assume most children taking part in a dangerous sport have parental permision and if they were paralysed their parents would care for them - pulling together where two parents are on the scene.

I grew up riding horses and then had a horse of my own - I'm sure if I were paralysed my parents would manage as best they could.

However this child's mother has not consented to this child playing contact rugby. She has assessed the risks, decided that she considers them too great and said no.

The ex has gone against her wishes and I hope he would be willing to leave his job and be a full time carer for the rest of his life if it goes horribly wrong. Not that doing that would give his mother her healthy son back or their son his life back.

RhubarbGingerJam · 24/02/2024 13:36

By hiding this, your brother has (purposely?) driven a wedge between your DN and his mother and involved his son in deceiving his loving mum. That’s not good - and it won’t be looked on kindly by any court, if it came to that. It’s not about the rugby so much as the deceit and what could be framed as an attempt to alienate your DN from his mum.

I have sympathy with this view but the school e-mailed her and she just didn't bother reading - so it dents the argument it was kept from her.

Also he played matches - and she was with boyfriend on Saturday so didn't notice - doesn't take much to spin that to didn't notice due to lies to didn't care enough to ask.

I get why she's annoyed upset and angry but I think she 2.5 years too late and needs to focus on maintaining a good relationship with son.

Also think OP needs to steer as clear as possible - and at 14 were he wants to live is I believe taken into consideration by courts.

senua · 24/02/2024 13:35

I haven't read the full thread.
There seems to be a lot of talk about whether the father or the mother is right, who gets the final say. It's all about the parents and there is little talk of the DN.

If he is captain of the A team then this is about more than rugby; his teammates are his best friends. Does his mother really want to cut him adrift from his band of brothers at a crux time in his teenage life? He will never forgive her.

Braksonsboss · 24/02/2024 13:34

SIL is being ridiculous and could well lose her son over this. She needs to listen to him and work through it. This should have been sorted 3 years ago though.

Passthepickle · 24/02/2024 13:34

One side needs to apologise and the other needs to be more flexible. I am very concerned about the head injuries issue rather than the general twatting you get on pitch but one of mine loved the sport and played at a good level. At the point where he could have joined the next level teams he opted for another sport which I am happy about but I can still see the enormous benefits that those playing enjoy. I don’t think you can chose for others how the balance that fun/risk life profile. Part of her relationship with all of her children will be supporting them while they do things she might not chose for them.

travelallthetime · 24/02/2024 13:33

Im with your brother. Its not like is a banned sport, it is widely played in most schools and we are not living in the 1970's where you were encouraged to brush off a knock to the head, times have moved on.
What your DB should have done is have a discussion with her 2.5 years ago along the lines of, "our son wants to play rugby and I fully support him. These are the measures in place these days and if he wants to play I will sign the forms so he can".
But he didnt do that. He needs to apologise for lying but thats all. He needs to keep supporting your DN in his rugby, against the wishes of mum, who, despite your protests, preferred to spend Saturdays with her new partner and seemingly buried her head in the sand about rugby. I cannot believe such an involved parent as you say she is did not know this is what he was doing.

TheMadGardener · 24/02/2024 13:32

Your brother was wrong to encourage his son to keep rugby a secret and to lie by omission to his mum. I grew up in a family where we were made to be complicit in secret-keeping and it took me years to realise that wasn't normal.

However, SIL is very much in the wrong for not reading emails. If school kept her informed for 2 years and she just didn't read any emails then she can't complain. Did none of nephew's school reports have glowing comments about his sporting prowess? Did no staff member or other parent ever say anything to her about it for 2 years, or did she just switch off when someone mentioned sport? Seems there is fault on both sides.

She is unreasonable if she expects nephew to give up his team, and he is old enough to choose to live with dad full-time if he wants, but seems like irreparable damage has probably been done to the co-parenting relationship.

LaurieFairyCake · 24/02/2024 13:30

Kid is old enough to choose for himself about the rugby

I imagine the school will say it's up to him

Allywill · 24/02/2024 13:30

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 24/02/2024 11:53

She will have to take him to court on a specific issue order

Family court is not there to sort out every parenting decision that can’t be agreed upon. Plus no court would say a child is to be stopped from playing a legal organised sport.

Woodyandbuzz1 · 24/02/2024 13:28

You nephew will never forgive his mum if she's stops him.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 13:27

timeooooout · 24/02/2024 13:14

I had a really interesting interview on the radio recently about an academic paper that explores how allowing children to play contact rugby flies in the face of all safeguarding legislation.

The interviewee was saying that you don't need to have a specific bang to the head to get a head injury from rugby, the tackling and throwing to the ground etc sends the brain rattling around the skull and can cause brain injury without any impact to the head.

I found it very interesting becuse it's true that putting children at frequent risk of sustaining a brain injury would be considered a safeguarding concern in any other context.

Long term effects of the brain being thrown around like that are things like early onset dementia.

Having listened to that interview I can completely understand SIL point of view.

The thing is, however dangerous rugby may or may not be, the SIL in this scenario chose to spend 2.5 years paying absolutely no attention to that part of her child's life. She ignored the e-mails, didn't attend a single match and never even spoke to his coaches even though she knew he had signed up for touch rugby in year 7 (because she agreed to it).

If you're that fearful about a certain sport wouldn't you show as much interest in it as possible for your child's sake, instead of sticking your head in the sand?

L1ttledrummergirl · 24/02/2024 13:27

Your sil is being very unreasonable (and so are you for referring to a deception).

Your sil was informed by the school on many occasions that dn is playing rugby, that she chose not to engage is on her.

She needs to back off with her attitude or push her son away, if she prevents dn playing rugby at school, there are plenty of clubs out there.

ReadingLight · 24/02/2024 13:26

ChildrenOfTheQuorn · 24/02/2024 12:38

I'll go against the grain and say I'm Team SIL on this one. Your DN made a decision at 11(!) and your DB facilitated a young boy lying and deceiving his mother for 2 years. Rightly or wrongfully she had a line in the sand, a boundary, and a group of boys/men conspired against her because they thought they knew better. It's actually quite shocking.

Agreed, and I have a child at a rugby school.

OP, just steer clear. Your family’s involvement has been the reverse of helpful so far. This is not your battle.

touchrugby · 24/02/2024 13:26

Heathers4evs · 24/02/2024 13:17

Are there other kids in the family? Is it just the potential rugby star your brother is offering to move into his home?

And what's his plan for fitting his kid/kids into his workaholic lifestyle? Has he a better, rugby friendly step mother lined up.to move in and do the heavy lifting?

Only child for both. DB heavily invested in DN. DB has had no significant relationships since his divorce - we're pretty certain he just works and parents DN. He's still genuinely baffled by the divorce- in his field it's common for husbands to work stupid hours and for wives to put up with it for the ability to be a SAHP in a nice house with good schools and holidays and cleaners and skiing.... lots of friends and colleagues do time consuming hobbies like long distance cycling or iron man or sailing or golf- he did none of that and threw his considerable energy into becoming a good father. My SIL wanted more.

OP posts:
Esse1234 · 24/02/2024 13:26

My DS is much younger than the OP's DN and has recently switched at school from touch to contact rugby and I didn't realise until I turned up to watch a match as there wasn't any communication about the change and DS didn't think to mention it, i'm not particularly happy about the risk of injury, I wouldn't mind if they banned rugby in schools but I do trust the PE teachers and the guidelines, thankfully DS has quite a keen sense of self preservation on the pitch 🤔still I'd rather it was optional at senior school.