Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My brother has hidden my nephews rugby playing...

685 replies

touchrugby · 24/02/2024 09:48

Asking for my brother - I think he’s in a mess and I need to tell him what to expect and how unreasonable he was. Interested to hear from other divorced parents and sports teachers/ school administrators. I’ve tried to give as much context as possible.

My brother got divorced 4 years ago. They have (had?) an amicable coparent relationship- there was no cheating or unkindness in either side. My brother just became obsessed with giving his family a good life and he worked a lot of hours. When he wasn’t working he was a very engaged parent- my nephew is hugely sporty and they were always off doing sports- swimming, tennis, football, cross country etc. Ex SIL was a SAHP but eventually got frustrated (with justification) at never seeing her husband so went back to work and divorced him. They share 50/50 custody with my brother as the higher earner paying all DNs expenses.

My brother really wanted nephew to go to this very nice private school. To facilitate this he pays all the fees. It’s a great academic school so ex SIL was pretty happy-except for the sport. They’re a big rugby school and she was adamant that DN not play rugby due to injury risks. There was a big argument about it, with my brother and DN really wanting rugby, and her adamant that he wouldn’t play.

The school offers non contact rugby and eventually they agreed DN would do that. DN is in year 9 now and it’s recently come out that he switched to full contact rugby in the 3rd week of year 7 and SIL didn’t know. It’s come out because he’s recently been made captain of the A team and a few mums congratulated her.

It seems he hated the non contact team. He’s very gifted with sport and apparently it was a team of lads who just wanted to run around for a few hours and throw a ball. The school put little effort into it and there were no matches. He asked to switch to “proper” rugby and the school said they needed a parent to approve it- and my brother did.

His argument is that his son wanted it, the school did email SIL as well, and it’s been 2.5 years.
Her argument is that he knew her stance, he also knows she’s a bit disorganised and rarely reads emails especially ones about sport which she know my brother manages (she has over 10,000 unread emails on her phone!) and that my brother conspired to hide it.

She has a very valid point about the conspiring. She has a new partner. He works Saturdays so my brother used to have DN every Friday night so they could see each other, and he’d then take him to Sat morning matches before dropping him at SILs Sat evening. Brother and DN have both, in 2.5 years, managed not to say anything to her about his rugby which is obviously duplicitous, especially considering how good he is. Brother just managed all the kit and the washing and the games and it apparently never came up in conversation.

Shes utterly furious and is going to the school Monday to tell them to remove him from rugby. Brother planning on going to the school to tell them to keep him in rugby. DN is apparently going to refuse to return to his mums house unless she agrees to the rugby and is determined to continue.

I’ve maintained a good friendship with SIL. In many ways I’m closer her than my brother as I see her more (he’s still a workaholic in his non parenting time so he’s hard to get hold of!) I heard about the odd match but nothing specific, I assumed it was non contact and frankly don’t know anything about rugby anyway. She’s very unhappy with our family as obviously our parents knew as well. My dad watches half the matches!

Does anyone know what the school might do? My brother and nephew are digging their heels in and saying he’ll live full time at my brothers and my brother will therefore get full parental responsibility. I think this is rubbish and not legal. I am worried that a nice coparenting relationship is ruined and that SIL might lose my nephew. He loves his mum but he’s obsessed with sport and apparently A team captain at a school like his is a BIG deal. He’s already playing some 2nd eleven matches as well which is also apparently important. I don’t know how to feel about what my brother did. He has absolutely supported what DN wanted. My nephew is so happy playing rugby and so good at it and still uninjured, and it’s the game played by 90% of the school. She knew sending him there that if he didn’t play rugby he’d be a bit isolated but she will not have it.

Frankly I think there’s fault on both sides, but on balance how much more unreasonable was my brother and what the hell might happen next?

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 24/02/2024 15:42

Shabby of the brother.

The lad is 14 almost certainly Gillick competent so can decide for himself. She risks losing him if she goes in hard on this. Can see why she’s upset though.

sheflieswithherownwings · 24/02/2024 15:41

While I don't agree with what your DB did, I am also struggling to understand why your DSIL feels she should have had the last word on this - it comes across as very controlling. I understand why she might be angry now, but at the same time, I also have some sympathy for them both hiding it from her. It's a sport that's played in so many schools now and enjoyed by thousands of people every day.. it seems crazy to me that she believes her feelings about the sport should trump her son's desire to play it. Why does she think her opinion should have trumped that of your DB or her DS? Surely in this situation, where the parents are completely at odds, (and it's over something that really only impacts on the child) the DS decides - he can listen to both points of view and then makes his own decision? Would she still feel the same about it if he ended up playing the sport for this country one day?

Pinkfrlls · 24/02/2024 15:39

I come from a rugby mad country. I also lived in a city with a spinal unit. As a teenager, a lot of young rugby players got spinal injuries and you'd hear the whir of helicopters taking them to the spinal unit. Eventually my school could not field a single rugby team - neither boys nor their parents wanted them to play. They did change the rules to make it safer but you're still one high tackle away from a neck or spinal unit. I would not have ever agreed to my own sons playing rugby and my husband is in total agreement. Your brother is an idiot.

Goldbar · 24/02/2024 15:38

FrippEnos · 24/02/2024 15:32

What a bastard your dad must be to support his daughter in doing something that she wanted to do.

My 6yo is a terrible eater in general, but would happily eat haribo or marshmallows from morning until night. DC has told me several times that one of their dreams is falling into a pit full of gummy bears and marshmallows.

Now we have a large paddling pool and we could afford to buy sufficient sweets to fill it. Are we "bastards" for refusing to facilitate DC's long-term ambition (this one's been going for over six months) because we think it would be harmful for them?

Sometimes as a parent you have to make the right choice not the popular choice. They may overlap, but not always.

Pl242 · 24/02/2024 15:34

This thread is fascinating given the split of views. And also some are focusing more on the rugby and some on the deception. Most people can see the perspective of both parties to a degree but siding instinctively with one side over the other.

We’ve been drawn a scenario by the OP which in some ways feels like a school debating challenge (not accusing you of lying OP!) because you can really create several, justified, points of view and perspectives here. Obviously none of us know these people and the OP’s perspective will also inform how they’ve set the issues out, but I suppose we all are influenced by our life experiences and prejudices here.

If I had to choose a side here (which is not the question and I’ve posted my thoughts on the wider points upthread) I’d be with the SIL. Mostly because I think the active deception is the worst part of all of this and also because I can’t stop thinking about the brother/dad being like the rugby version of Rupert from Ted Lasso… this of course reveals my own prejudices against stereotypical workaholic rugby boys who always think they know best.

Scirocco · 24/02/2024 15:32

@touchrugby rugby itself isn't the biggest problem they have - it's what the rugby represents and what this situation shows about family dynamics.

Essentially, your DB made a co-parenting decision, then unilaterally changed that decision without telling his co-parent, and then embarked on a two-year deception in relation to it, including getting his son involved in a sustained lie. Getting a child to maintain a lie to a parent like that is actually considered a form of parental alienation, damages their relationship, and risks feeding into an unhealthy pattern of behaviour in relationships longer-term.

Your DB has fucked up.

If I were him, I would apologise to SIL and to DN for putting him in this situation. I would tell DN that I'm not going to facilitate any form of non-contact with SIL as she hasn't done anything that warrants that. I would then withdraw DN from rugby myself at least temporarily, making it clear to DN that it was my decision and my responsibility, as it had been my error of judgement that led to him being there secretly. Then I'd suggest the family get some family therapy, to try to fix this mess. Part of that could also involve discussion of the pros and cons and importance of rugby to DN - as a family.

FrippEnos · 24/02/2024 15:32

ORLt · 24/02/2024 15:18

The mum is right. The injuries from rugby are not worth the idiocy of a few minutes' happiness. The father is just stupid or does not care about his son. Probably just stupid. In my child's school some male pupils were invalids by the time they were in S6. I personally was a competitive athlete with a clever mum (did not want to allow this) and a stupid dad (cheered me on). I destroyed my health in the process and by mid 20s it began to bother me to such an extent, that I understood mum was right. If only I listened to mum.

What a bastard your dad must be to support his daughter in doing something that she wanted to do.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 24/02/2024 15:30

touchrugby · 24/02/2024 10:24

But the parent with equal parental responsibility (my brother) said yes. The school had no clue about the deception.
Why does she choose and not DB and what do you do in a situation where no compromise is possible?

Maybe let the 12 year old student decide? Or at least discuss her concerns with the school rather than a blanket ban

user1471523071 · 24/02/2024 15:26

I think your SIL has to not think about who is right or wrong in this situation, but what future relationship she wants with her son. If she goes to the school about this she could damage that relationship irreplaceably. He son obviously has a talent and loves playing rugby, she has to think of him only.

My son does play rugby, yes, there are injuries but they really have a 'if in doubt sit it out' mentality and he absolutely adores it. There are injuries in all sports and unfortunately the worst one, which resulted in a fatality was from swimming on holiday in a pool. No one says not to learn to swim. Part of being a parent is about supporting your child.

HollyKnight · 24/02/2024 15:22

Teaching the boy to lie to get what he wants is a great lesson that will serve him well in life. That's some A+ parenting right there. Not at all a toxic trait for a man to have.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 15:20

Coyoacan · 24/02/2024 15:17

The mother contributed to that poor relationship by showing absolutely no interest in a sport her son loves. She couldn't even be bothered to attend a match because she was too busy visiting her bloody boyfriend!

I didn't have to co-parent, but if I had and my child's father was interested in taking them to boring sporting events, I would have said that it was lovely that they had an interest in common and no need for me to muscle in there.

But, in your opinion, the mother was wrong for trusting her child's father not to lie and not to teach her son to lie to her and doubly wrong for having a "bloody boyfriend".

IMO it has nothing to do with whether she trusts him or not, and everything to do with her choosing not to show an interest in something that her child clearly loves and enjoys.

Loads of parents go and stand on the sidelines every weekend even when they'd rather be just about anywhere else - because that's what you do for your kids.

I also didn't say she was wrong for having a boyfriend either, I said she was wrong for prioritising her new relationship over her child's love of rugby every single time there was a match on for two and a half years.

Moveoverdarlin · 24/02/2024 15:18

Sending a sporty boy to a good independent school and not letting him play rugby is a bit like taking your child to the beach and saying ‘don’t get in the sea’. It’s a given. The school will be on the side of the Dad and Son. They will have seen thousands of boys come and go through school, but very few (if any!), will have had life threatening injuries from rugby. I think SIL has been a bit naive and she needs to drop it for the sake of her relationship with her DS.

ORLt · 24/02/2024 15:18

The mum is right. The injuries from rugby are not worth the idiocy of a few minutes' happiness. The father is just stupid or does not care about his son. Probably just stupid. In my child's school some male pupils were invalids by the time they were in S6. I personally was a competitive athlete with a clever mum (did not want to allow this) and a stupid dad (cheered me on). I destroyed my health in the process and by mid 20s it began to bother me to such an extent, that I understood mum was right. If only I listened to mum.

Coyoacan · 24/02/2024 15:17

The mother contributed to that poor relationship by showing absolutely no interest in a sport her son loves. She couldn't even be bothered to attend a match because she was too busy visiting her bloody boyfriend!

I didn't have to co-parent, but if I had and my child's father was interested in taking them to boring sporting events, I would have said that it was lovely that they had an interest in common and no need for me to muscle in there.

But, in your opinion, the mother was wrong for trusting her child's father not to lie and not to teach her son to lie to her and doubly wrong for having a "bloody boyfriend".

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 24/02/2024 15:16

Squirrelsnut · 24/02/2024 15:11

OP has said her SIL is a great mum who deals with everything except the sport.

Sport is the issue, she buried her head in the sand, she is most likely a good mother however having ignored her sons interests as it does not interest her, she has also given her son the opportunity to not discuss any sporting topics that may have come up.

For me it reads like sports has become a mute topic when at his mothers.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 15:15

Squirrelsnut · 24/02/2024 15:11

OP has said her SIL is a great mum who deals with everything except the sport.

I simply don't think that's relevant, especially when OP says the dad knows nothing about music or instruments but still goes out of his way to attend his sons performances and concerts.

You can't willingly opt out of a huge chunk of your child's life and education and then complain about it nearly three years later.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 15:13

diddl · 24/02/2024 15:09

I do think though any point she might have had falls down if she has the information but didn't read it.

She must feel quite betrayed though-perhaps most especially by her son.

I won't condemn her for not going to matches if that has always worked for them-but of course that has also meant an opportunity missed.

The thing is, if a woman posted on here that her ex was "furious" because he'd just found out their 14yo played rugby after three years, she'd be told it was on him for not being interested in their child's activities.

If she then posted that the reason he never attended a match was because he was too busy with his new girlfriend, he would be absolutely slammed for being a shit, useless dad.

Squirrelsnut · 24/02/2024 15:11

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 14:59

My responses have nothing to do with the fact that it's rugby. It could have been any sport or activity - the fact is the mother deliberately chose to ignore a huge part of her child's life and education.

She ignored e-mails about it, never attended a single match (was too busy visiting her boyfriend), never read a school report about it and never spoke to her child's coaches. For two and a half years.

That's just as appalling (if not more so) than a dad encouraging his child to do a sport he loves.

OP has said her SIL is a great mum who deals with everything except the sport.

diddl · 24/02/2024 15:09

I do think though any point she might have had falls down if she has the information but didn't read it.

She must feel quite betrayed though-perhaps most especially by her son.

I won't condemn her for not going to matches if that has always worked for them-but of course that has also meant an opportunity missed.

KrisAkabusi · 24/02/2024 15:05

The mother had stated her lack of interest in sports and (foolishly, as she now knows) expected that her ex would supervise responsibly. Which he clearly didn't.

No. She expected her ex would supervise the way she wanted. That's not the same thing. Her opinion doesn't automatically override his.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 24/02/2024 15:04

Coyoacan · 24/02/2024 14:58

But when the child is with the father, she has no authority

You see, that is the attitude that brings about wars. Of course lots of people have to apply that maxim because they are co-parenting with unreasonable people but he was lucky enough to be co-parenting with a loving and thoughtful woman and he had zero consideration for the benefits that brought to him and his son.

Now he has damaged his son's relationship with his mother for the remainder of his teenage years at least.

Unfortunately it doesn’t take away the truthfulness of the statement , how many times to we see on MN that mothers and fathers disagreeing with each other on how to raise the children.

In an ideal world co-parenting would be harmonious however this isn’t an ideal world and the child in question is stuck in the middle as the mother is actively chosen to ignore that side of her son’s life.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 15:04

Coyoacan · 24/02/2024 14:58

But when the child is with the father, she has no authority

You see, that is the attitude that brings about wars. Of course lots of people have to apply that maxim because they are co-parenting with unreasonable people but he was lucky enough to be co-parenting with a loving and thoughtful woman and he had zero consideration for the benefits that brought to him and his son.

Now he has damaged his son's relationship with his mother for the remainder of his teenage years at least.

The mother contributed to that poor relationship by showing absolutely no interest in a sport her son loves. She couldn't even be bothered to attend a match because she was too busy visiting her bloody boyfriend!

Marblessolveeverything · 24/02/2024 15:03

@Livinghappy I am in Ireland there have been success outcomes in the family courts.

I very much doubt a school would want the attention. The relationship with the son is already severely fractured, for his physical protection yes I would fight because I could never live with myself if he ended up with life changing injuries.

I don't believe rugby should be played in school in its current format where neurosurgeons are saying clearly every knock has an impact and the stats on ex rugby players presenting with neurological conditions outstrip their peers.

Abeona · 24/02/2024 15:01

Everyone in the scenario is being unreasonable, including you OP for getting involved. You should have said 'Ooooh, this sounds like mess for you all' and then bowed out. If asked to pick a side you say 'Problem is, I can appreciate all sides so I can't pick one.'

Captaining rugby could be very advantageous for your nephew. Oxbridge and Russell group universities like to see sport on an application.

girlfriend44 · 24/02/2024 15:01

How awful trying to dictate your sons hobbies and something he is good at?
No wonder it's backfired on her.

I'm glad he pursued it and the boy has two parents not just her.
How would she have liked it if a parent had tried to stop her hobby when a child.
If she isn't careful she could lose her son too.