Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my mother is punishing me?

118 replies

Ohdearme1 · 24/02/2024 04:43

I’ve just had my 40th birthday, and my mother is someone who has always celebrated birthdays. When it’s hers, she likes a fuss. When it’s a significant birthday she expects all the stops to be pulled out; we’ve done huge parties, weekends away, fancy meals, tickets to concerts. To mark the occasion. In response, she’s usually very generous with her own present giving.
So when my 40th arrived and I received a plant in the mail, along with a card, I found myself a little shocked and upset. She took my brother out for the day for his, and bought him tickets to euro Disney for his family. When my DH had his last year, she bought him a generous gift voucher.
She also didn’t message me or call me on my birthday, but she oddly sent me a text the day before saying “happy birthday for tomorrow”.
My only conclusion is that she is punishing me. We had a falling out a few weeks ago after she sent inappropriate text messages to my teenage son accusing him of upsetting her and not giving him enough attention at a sporting event she went to watch him at. DS was so upset because as far as he was concerned, the event had gone well and she’d been fine with him. The language she used on him was totally unacceptable and I spoke to her about it, clearly highlighting which language wasn’t ok, bad enough on an adult let alone a child. She’s been frosty with me ever since, but I’ve just been giving her time to settle down. I didn’t think for a minute that it would drag on. But I feel now like I’m being punished for challenging her over her inappropriate behaviour. AIBU?

OP posts:
Bringthejury1 · 01/03/2024 16:17

Ohdearme1 · 01/03/2024 12:59

Second update… I text her back saying that was kind of her to want to, but not to worry as she’d already given me a gift and the birthday was now over, and there’s no need. That I was quite happy with that. She’s replied instantly saying she’s not taking no for an answer and the only reason she didn’t get me a more special gift for the day is because she didn’t know what I’d like because I’m hard to buy for 🤔. I just don’t get it. If it was me, I would have written this in their bday card. Or I would have had a conversation before the birthday to work out what to get them.

You do get it - she's punishing you and now she wants to rake back the control through manipulative excuses about you being "hard" to buy for. A normal person would do exactly as you have said - talk about it before or write it in a card.

Just keep on with the "no thanks mum, appreciate the offer but my birthday is now over". Rinse and repeat.

LetsBePositive10 · 01/03/2024 16:01

My mum is like this, but she would secretly punish me whilst being as nice as pie to my face. Others would know and talk behind my back whilst I had no idea. I’d find out weeks or months later what had happened and it was awful. I’m now cut off after she had a hissy fit whilst drunk over something I was trying to help her with. It’s almost 4 years since she has been in touch and I still don’t know how a parent can ever do that to a child. I hope you had a happy birthday regardless.

VictoriaPink · 01/03/2024 15:53

learieonthewildmoor · 01/03/2024 15:30

“Whatever you like, mum” on repeat now.

Yes, this.

She snubbed your birthday to punish you and now she wants to reel you back in.

Honestly, I would put a lot of distance in here. And no more super-duper efforts for her birthday, either - she has set the precedent that a card and a plant (and no message on the day) is fine.

FannyGotobed · 01/03/2024 15:50

Both my parents show narcissistic traits and one of the big things they like to do is brag to other family and friends about how generous they are. Maybe she's realised that she can't show off to others at the moment so wants to do something bigger now. Maybe a relative has asked how your 40th went and that's why she's now desperate to have something to say - she obviously can't admit she only sent a plant!!

Also, as a PP said, she is still saying it's all your own fault you didn't get a decent present!

StrawberryEater · 01/03/2024 15:46

You can be bloody minded about it, or pragmatic. She has not behaved well and I agree with others that she was disappointed that you didn’t have a strop and she can’t use that to behave badly. But frankly, if she is willing to buy your family tickets to Euro Disney as she did for your brother, I’d probably say that I’d like the same and take them. The damage is done, why forego a family trip if it won’t actually get you any further with her anyway?

BigButtons · 01/03/2024 15:36

She is making it your fault that you didn’t get a proper present.
my late MN used to use presents/ money as weapons.
For my 50th she said she would pay for my cousin and I to go abroad for a few days. Cousin and I found it almost impossible to settle on a date. When I did say we had found something( a good while later) she told me I hadn’t been quick enough and she had since spent all the money set aside on jewellery for herself.
She was forever writing me out of her will if she got cross with me.
She would regularly take presents back and sell them if she didn’t think you were being effusive enough.

learieonthewildmoor · 01/03/2024 15:30

“Whatever you like, mum” on repeat now.

Hughs · 01/03/2024 15:19

"Thanks mum but I have everything I need and had a lovely birthday, thoroughly spoilt with some gorgeous presents. There's really no need, don't give it another thought x"

twingiraffes · 01/03/2024 14:17

Ohdearme1 · 01/03/2024 12:59

Second update… I text her back saying that was kind of her to want to, but not to worry as she’d already given me a gift and the birthday was now over, and there’s no need. That I was quite happy with that. She’s replied instantly saying she’s not taking no for an answer and the only reason she didn’t get me a more special gift for the day is because she didn’t know what I’d like because I’m hard to buy for 🤔. I just don’t get it. If it was me, I would have written this in their bday card. Or I would have had a conversation before the birthday to work out what to get them.

Oh so now she making it out to be your fault she didn't buy you a special gift.

Talk about manipulative.

Makegoodchoices · 01/03/2024 14:08

She was expecting a massive strop from you - which she would use to justify her original treatment. She didn’t get it and now realises that she may lose influence over you if you back away from the relationship. It sounds exhausting and you have my sympathy.

Galeforcewindatmywindow · 01/03/2024 14:06

Do Oxfam still have goats?

MiniCooperLover · 01/03/2024 14:03

She's annoyed you didn't call her out or fall for her trick and you were gracious about the lack of a decent present so she wants to make a fuss now to make herself look better

Ready4ActionRyderSir · 01/03/2024 13:53

Ohdearme1 · 01/03/2024 12:59

Second update… I text her back saying that was kind of her to want to, but not to worry as she’d already given me a gift and the birthday was now over, and there’s no need. That I was quite happy with that. She’s replied instantly saying she’s not taking no for an answer and the only reason she didn’t get me a more special gift for the day is because she didn’t know what I’d like because I’m hard to buy for 🤔. I just don’t get it. If it was me, I would have written this in their bday card. Or I would have had a conversation before the birthday to work out what to get them.

It’s either guilt…

shes saying it to assuage her guilt (and possibly, it’ll never happen)

or

she is a mumsnet user….

Carrydaily25 · 01/03/2024 13:39

My mum got my brother and his family a holiday for his big birthday. I’m a few years younger. She never bothered with me and then claimed the next year she didn’t realise it was my milestone birthday previously. She did. I paid for her to come on a big holiday with my husband and kids for it. Still nothing. It hurts but what can you do.

Barney16 · 01/03/2024 13:12

My mother does similar. A couple of years ago she didn't contact me at all on my birthday so I rang. She wouldn't speak to me. My dad said oh your mother won't come to the phone. My crime? I hadn't gone "home" for my birthday. I was 54. I have three adult children and live with my partner in what I quite reasonably I think consider my home. She posted on FB, my daughter refused the come home for her birthday, first time she hasn't been at home for her birthday for 54 years. ( She isn't my FB friend, someone I know saw it and told me). Given her obvious complete lunacy, I just ignored her.

babybunny123 · 01/03/2024 13:05

She is back tracking, she did not think you would be so thankful for the gift she sent you. Bet she feels guilty now.

Ohdearme1 · 01/03/2024 12:59

Second update… I text her back saying that was kind of her to want to, but not to worry as she’d already given me a gift and the birthday was now over, and there’s no need. That I was quite happy with that. She’s replied instantly saying she’s not taking no for an answer and the only reason she didn’t get me a more special gift for the day is because she didn’t know what I’d like because I’m hard to buy for 🤔. I just don’t get it. If it was me, I would have written this in their bday card. Or I would have had a conversation before the birthday to work out what to get them.

OP posts:
RaraRachael · 01/03/2024 11:52

It wasn't til my mother died that I realised she was a narcissist. All my life I'd been the preferred one - more academic than my sister, had views that mirrored mother's etc
Then I committed the ultimate sin - I left an unhappy marriage where I did absolutely everything and wasn't appreciated. This brought such shame on her that she left my sister (whom she'd criticised virtually her whole life) half of everything and the other half was split between me, my 2 kids and XH.

The more I read since she's gone I realise she was a controlling horrible narcissist and I'm sorry OP that yours sounds like the same.

Wode · 01/03/2024 11:48

I think she is trying to get her power back, it was a power move to give you that plant, she wanted you angry so you would confront her and when she didn't get that she sees is as losing a battle with you. So now she is trying to get you wondering what gift she could get. If she truly wanted to get a big gift like your brother she would have actually done it for your birthday, not a week late.

I wouldn't give her the satisfaction, I would just say thank you for the offer but no need, I got lovely gifts from family and my birthday is over now. Then move onto when you are next seeing her or something trivial to put at the end to show you have moved on.

Luckily I had a lovely Mum and MIL but my sister's MIL works the way your Mum does, feigns surprise at people being hurt by her behaviour. She is awful.

Maybeicanhelpyou · 01/03/2024 11:37

She’s realised. she’s trying to buy you back.
it depends how you feel about that. My mil does this. I take the gifts, as payment for all the crap I have to take!! That’s the way I see it, I completely emotionally detach as does my DH.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 01/03/2024 11:30

permanently · 01/03/2024 11:01

Gosh, so difficult. It's definitely an opportunity/turning point in your relationship for change and for you to take control. Maybe text later on/tomorrow Thanks for getting in touch. Yes that would be nice. Speak soon x and then keep repeating the idea that you'll be in contact when it suits you? A good solid week of keeping her at arms length might get her to reflect on her behaviour...

I think this is a good suggestion, its either this or you accept her 'apolagy' and nothing changes.

Galeforcewindatmywindow · 01/03/2024 11:28

She wants you to be sooo grateful for The Big Gift... So don't accept one.. Then you owe her nothing..
Not a moment of your thoughts either..

TrumpetOfTheMatriarchy · 01/03/2024 11:20

'no need Mum, the plant was the perfect gift from you. Hope you are keeping well' and leave it at that. She's squirming now and wants some control back over you.

Janpoppy · 01/03/2024 11:14

You are on the right track with your thinking; Her behaviour is all about her - it says nothing about you and who you are as a person. The reason it may be confusing is that you would not behave the way she has, so trying to understand her motivation is difficult - it is simply not the way you think.

Read up on narcissism and covert passive aggressive narcissism. There's a good book by Debbie Mirza.

Healthyhappymama · 01/03/2024 11:05

Sounds like she's being very petty, probably not intentionally punishing you as such , but she is probably offended and feels she has done no wrong , therefore won't be willing to be as generous!