Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my mother is punishing me?

118 replies

Ohdearme1 · 24/02/2024 04:43

I’ve just had my 40th birthday, and my mother is someone who has always celebrated birthdays. When it’s hers, she likes a fuss. When it’s a significant birthday she expects all the stops to be pulled out; we’ve done huge parties, weekends away, fancy meals, tickets to concerts. To mark the occasion. In response, she’s usually very generous with her own present giving.
So when my 40th arrived and I received a plant in the mail, along with a card, I found myself a little shocked and upset. She took my brother out for the day for his, and bought him tickets to euro Disney for his family. When my DH had his last year, she bought him a generous gift voucher.
She also didn’t message me or call me on my birthday, but she oddly sent me a text the day before saying “happy birthday for tomorrow”.
My only conclusion is that she is punishing me. We had a falling out a few weeks ago after she sent inappropriate text messages to my teenage son accusing him of upsetting her and not giving him enough attention at a sporting event she went to watch him at. DS was so upset because as far as he was concerned, the event had gone well and she’d been fine with him. The language she used on him was totally unacceptable and I spoke to her about it, clearly highlighting which language wasn’t ok, bad enough on an adult let alone a child. She’s been frosty with me ever since, but I’ve just been giving her time to settle down. I didn’t think for a minute that it would drag on. But I feel now like I’m being punished for challenging her over her inappropriate behaviour. AIBU?

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 04/03/2024 08:17

Thank her... it's the plant you've always wanted.
Imperfect things happen.

Get over it and don't let it fester.
Show your son how to get over it too; focus on the good things and have a laugh.

Calliopespa · 04/03/2024 08:14

Yirk · 04/03/2024 07:47

Considering narcissism affects only 1 to 5% of the population, there seems to be an awful lot of narcissistic mothers on this thread!

… and on MN generally.

Calliopespa · 04/03/2024 08:00

ClairDeLaLune · 24/02/2024 07:43

This is perfect. You could add “You really shouldn’t have!”

That tips it firmly into sarcastic territory though.

Im afraid I’m a bit of a believer in “ say it” or “ get over it.” All these heavily encrypted messages normally make the person delivering look a bit uptight and odd - if they even get noticed.

I’d either just thank her ( politely not profusely) and ignore; or raise it with her straight if it’s bothering you.

I used to think all these “snide comment” games were clever when I was younger, but I’m realising straight bat when it’s needed saves a lot of wasted emotional energy.

Yirk · 04/03/2024 07:47

Considering narcissism affects only 1 to 5% of the population, there seems to be an awful lot of narcissistic mothers on this thread!

rowanoak · 04/03/2024 07:17

Your mom sounds like a narcissist. Mine is the same and I cut her off at exactly your age-40! That was over 2.5 years ago and it was the best decision I (finally) ever made. My life is so much better without her in it. Happy birthday! Give yourself the gift of loving yourself the way your mother never did/could and sadly never will /can.

Rottweilermummy · 04/03/2024 07:05

I feel as much for your son as I do for you, to have a nasty text sent to you by your grandmother is terrible and your Mum certainly crossed the line and you had to pull her up on her shocking behaviour. It's one thing as an adult dealing with a parent like that but now she's treated your son the same, did you tell your brother what she did as I'm sure he would probably be disgusted with her too maybe him saying something would make her see how wrong she was 🤔
The suggestion that you gushingly say how lovely the plant was and how you've been really spoiled I think is the best way to deal with her and definitely distance yourself as you'll never win and I can see her dragging this on for a while. Happy 40th, I do hope you have a wonderful day and you are spoiled by people that do care 🙏❤🎉

Nikki8762 · 04/03/2024 06:36

Galeforcewindatmywindow · 24/02/2024 11:24

Pick up on her theme going forward op. And send her a fucking cactus for her next birthday. In fact for Mother's Day if that is sooner..

Love this!!!

Ohdearme1 · 02/03/2024 16:07

Thank you all for all your advice and support. It’s been incredibly eye opening. I hadn’t dug deep into the way my mother operates, I’ve just always known that I feel uncomfortable in her presence and never really thought deeply about why. With your suggestions, I’ve started reading into narcissism and so much of it rings true. I feel a bit like my mind has blown 🙈.
I’m also starting to think I’m maybe not such a bad daughter after all (very much the feeling I’m often left with after interacting with her). DH has never liked her, but wasn’t able to fully pin down exactly why. But I’ve mentioned things you guys have said and his eyes have lit up. Learning for us both!
For now I’ve decided to leave it. I don’t know if I want to keep pushing back on the gift, or just let her do what she wants. Now I can see more clearly what’s going on, I don’t need to “win” that battle. Lots of reflection, processing and deeper reading is on the agenda for me. Thank you all for showing me the way, and reassuring me that it wasn’t in my head!

OP posts:
doneandone · 02/03/2024 12:04

Ohdearme1 · 01/03/2024 12:59

Second update… I text her back saying that was kind of her to want to, but not to worry as she’d already given me a gift and the birthday was now over, and there’s no need. That I was quite happy with that. She’s replied instantly saying she’s not taking no for an answer and the only reason she didn’t get me a more special gift for the day is because she didn’t know what I’d like because I’m hard to buy for 🤔. I just don’t get it. If it was me, I would have written this in their bday card. Or I would have had a conversation before the birthday to work out what to get them.

Ah so now it's your fault because you're hard to buy for. Agree with pp and so would go for "Whatever you like, mum".

Mary46 · 02/03/2024 10:03

Happy Birthday op. Mine is really tight nothing for my 50th. It did sting I wont lie. Ive decided zero fuss going forw. Then she wonders why no one takes her away. Its really hurtful. I do feel it when i hear how others are with their families.

Bringthejury1 · 02/03/2024 09:54

Onl · 02/03/2024 08:49

I'm not sure about some of the suggested replies in this thread. I'd be tempted to be more straightforward. I'm not sure that 'clever' retorts work with people like the OPs Mum. She isn't going to suddenly stop being some unpleasant because of a snippy text from the OP.
If the OP was upset with the gift and was wondering if it was because her Mum was punishing her I'd have asked the Mum that more directly.

Whilst ordinarily I would agree with this, when it comes down to dealing with someone such as ops mother, it would more then likely turn into her mother feigning upset that OP has mentioned it and would likely turn it all on OP (much like she has done a bit already saying she's hard to buy for...). I wouldn't go with passive-aggressive texts, but I would certainly tell her not to bother with anything else. She's doing it to try and make herself feel better for behaving so terribly - that isn't OPs responsibility, and her mother needs to sit with those uncomfortable feelings whether she likes it or not.

Onl · 02/03/2024 08:49

I'm not sure about some of the suggested replies in this thread. I'd be tempted to be more straightforward. I'm not sure that 'clever' retorts work with people like the OPs Mum. She isn't going to suddenly stop being some unpleasant because of a snippy text from the OP.
If the OP was upset with the gift and was wondering if it was because her Mum was punishing her I'd have asked the Mum that more directly.

Thefamilystallone · 02/03/2024 08:04

@Ohdearme1 classic narc behaviour I’m afraid. She didn’t get the reaction she was expecting from her snub on your birthday. Now the narrative isn’t “look how ungrateful she is complaining about my thoughtful present” but she fears other will see what you see. Narcissists need other people to see them has wonderful , benevolent people. They generally surround themselves with easily manipulated people who worship them/need them. You are neither. She needs to control you, hence the created drama. The offer isn’t a genuine need to gift you something you want, it is a way of trying to make you feel bad. “You are so hard to buy for” is a classic line.

My advice would be to not let her see how much she has hurt you, else she will repeat this behaviour again at a later date on another occasion special to you. My guess would be Disney would have strings such as she is coming with you…

I think you’ve done the right thing so far in refusing a ‘better’ gift. Let her wallow now for a bit. And absolutely pull back on participation in her own showy birthday activities. She has set the standard now and she absolutely knows it. Narcissists need large public shows of affection. Do not give them to her. I suspect your support for your DS is the kicker here. Many narcissists didn’t have someone standing up for them when they were children, so it could be envy of you breaking the abuse cycle that is at play here.

Keep going OP, you are stronger than you think.

HRHElizabeth · 01/03/2024 21:55

Someone up thread mentioned the Stately Homes thread - I highly recommend it.

My mother stopped celebrating Xmas and birthdays when I was 2. She instead made her wedding anniversary the family ‘present day’.
However my DM was not good at getting presents. She would get really stressed, would never know what to buy, couldn’t be bothered wrapping anything. Added to that, from 10 onwards my parents DID NOT get on, and the anniversary was a day for moods, sulking, taking to her room, and pledging a divorce by this time next year. Somethings we’d get a full blown row too.

FrenchBoule · 01/03/2024 21:11

OP, sadly the person like your mother never backs down, admits their fault or apologises. Never.

How dared you stand up for your child, of course you’ve earned your punishment in her eyes which meant no „big” present for your significant birthday.

Your mother knows/knew exactly what she’s doing. I wouldn’t rise to her bait of half arsed „apology” in the means of giving you a „speshul” birthday gift because she „didn’t know what to get you”.

Any loving parent doesn’t forget their children’s birthday. Never. If she didn’t know what to get you she could have asked you before the birthday,not after a week when she got over her perceived hurt.
Not acknowledging your actual birthday (especially as it was the big one)on the day with a message is literally „F… you, I don’t care about you”.

Whatever her motives are they are not good.Manipulative to the boot.Won’t take „no” for an answer? That’s because everything has to be HER way.

The offering came so you wouldn’t be able to say that she never got you anything for your significant birthday. The fact it came a week after your birthday? Well,she never knew what to get you.

Whichever way you want to turn OP, it will always be your fault and never hers. You are supposed to sweep things under the carpet and never challenge your mother about her behaviour,whether it’s swearing at your children or treating you like shit on your birthday.

Sorry,it sucks having self- absorbed relatives.

Belated Happy Birthday 🙂💐

MrsCarson · 01/03/2024 19:20

I think she's realised that if anyone finds out it makes her look bad for only sending a plant and a card when she got your Db so much. Stops you or anyone else saying she plays favourites.

Mumofteenandtween · 01/03/2024 19:07

Ohdearme1 · 01/03/2024 18:45

I don’t think she’s offering a trip to Disney. She said a special gift like my brother, but I don’t think she means the actual same thing…

Well that’s the other option then….

”Ok - if you insist then that would be lovely. Jack and Sarah have always said how much they would love to go to Euro Disney. We’ll have to discuss dates in more detail but I think that early July works well for us all.”

Only to be said if you actually want to go to Euro Disney though!

Ohdearme1 · 01/03/2024 18:45

StrawberryEater · 01/03/2024 15:46

You can be bloody minded about it, or pragmatic. She has not behaved well and I agree with others that she was disappointed that you didn’t have a strop and she can’t use that to behave badly. But frankly, if she is willing to buy your family tickets to Euro Disney as she did for your brother, I’d probably say that I’d like the same and take them. The damage is done, why forego a family trip if it won’t actually get you any further with her anyway?

I don’t think she’s offering a trip to Disney. She said a special gift like my brother, but I don’t think she means the actual same thing…

OP posts:
Ohdearme1 · 01/03/2024 18:43

PassingStranger · 01/03/2024 16:46

Do you ever speak on the phone? Might be better than texting.
All this texting seems a cop out. You can never tell peoples tone either. X

Yes that’s fair enough and does make a difference. I talk on the phone to my Dad, and it’s so much easier. The reason I don’t talk to her on the phone is that she’s very hard of hearing, so she hates it if people try to call her. Gets very stressed out because she can’t hear, so we text instead because of this. It’s quite a challenge to make sure she’s hearing properly in person, so phones are a no go.

OP posts:
ALongHardWinter · 01/03/2024 18:39

Happy birthday OP! Sorry you're having a bad time. Sounds to me like she just wants a reaction from you. Don't give her the satisfaction. Thank her profusely and say what a lovely day you're having. If it's any consolation,I can remember my late DM doing something similar to me years ago. She was lovely in so many ways,but for some reason,on my 40th birthday,she bought me a bale of towels. When it had been my older brother's 40th,a couple of years earlier,she'd given him the money to buy a new (second hand) car. That was 5 grand. I got a bale of towels costing 20 quid. My DD was like 'WTAF?!'.

TheBayLady · 01/03/2024 17:47

She is your mum and i am sure love her but i wouldn't like her at all. Please step away from her. She has been beyond awful to you and your Son. Let her sit and stew and then come and apologise to you. Never forget what she has done, don't let her too close.

3beesinmybonnet · 01/03/2024 17:31

@Ohdearme1
She wants you back where you belong - dangling on the end of her string wondering what your proper present will be and when you're going to get it, if ever.

Don't fall for it.

BMW6 · 01/03/2024 17:07

I'd just reply "Whatever"........

PassingStranger · 01/03/2024 16:46

Ohdearme1 · 01/03/2024 10:49

Just a small update… it’s been a week since my bday. Last communication was thanking her for the plant. Today I get a text saying she’d like to get me a proper 40th gift one day, like she did for my brother. I’m not really sure what to make of it, and how I’m meant to respond. I’m also unsure why this wasn’t written in my card, or in the text she sent me before my bday. Why now? What’s the motivation? Was a weeks punishment enough in her eyes? Is she wanting me to reach out to her to get a bigger gift? I’m obviously not doing that. I feel so confused and uncomfortable by the whole thing.

Do you ever speak on the phone? Might be better than texting.
All this texting seems a cop out. You can never tell peoples tone either. X

Caroparo52 · 01/03/2024 16:39

SharedAccountWithMySister · 24/02/2024 06:59

I would be ever so gushing in response by text… “thank you ever so much for my plant. I have been absolutely spoilt on my 40th by those I that I love”.

It would ruin her plan of getting a reaction from you, and she may over analyse it and think she didn’t spoil you, who did.

This could also imply that you don't love dm as her present was crappy. Only she will know this version of interpretation