Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WTF do I pay pet insurance for?!

81 replies

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 20:12

Looking at the FIFTH tooth extraction for Dcat. It's happening once a year now.

Years ago I naively didn't know that our insurance didn't cover teeth. Longtime cat owner since childhood never known dental issues in all those years. So, once the first issue happened Dcat insurance would not cover as it's seen as preexisting condition.

Honestly not sure we can afford it this time. I'm at a loss, they're saying it'll be over £2k, we only just paid £700 and that's on top of £££ monthly insurance which does sweet FA.

Even when Dcat had a leg issue a few years ago, the vet couldn't fucking figure out the issue to treat it (Dcat slowly improved but still not 100%). So although nothing was treated, initial care was covered by insurance and now ANYTHING potentially leg related is "preexisting".

Honestly don't know what I have to achieve by this thread other than to vent.

OP posts:
Tilllly · 23/02/2024 21:41

Hmmm I've got 6 weeks free with kennel club for puppy, was thinking of staying with them

Cats are with animal friends and they've been v good

ZellyFitzgerald · 23/02/2024 21:39

Pet insurance is always worth it as long as you pick the right company and the right policy.

A lifetime policy will never exclude conditions as pre-existing as long as the condition didn't start before the policy was taken out.

My dog is with Petplan, I would never use any other company. They have paid out £18,000 in 3 years for multiple issues.

Not all pet insurance companies and policies are equal. Choose carefully and read the small print.

  • NB I used to be a veterinary nurse and was also a pet insurance claims assessor.
BigDogEnergy · 23/02/2024 21:35

Insurance is only as good as the policy you buy. You need to read and understand the terms and conditions that you are agreeing to.

I've never known a policy to cover routine preventative dental work. Most will however cover anything caused by an accident (e.g. teeth damaged when hit by a car) or disease (e.g teeth needing to come out because of a tumour in the mouth).

Cheaper policies will often only cover a condition for 12 months and then you can no longer claim.

No policy will cover anything pre existing or relating to that body part. E.g. dog has diarrhoea in January, take out insurance in February all gastrointestinal conditions will be excluded. I've been out of the industry for a few years, but the only company I've ever known to consider removing an exclusion, is petplan. They will say OK, dog had diarrhoea in January, if they go 2 years with no repeat, we'll remove that exclusion. The time period will vary depending on what the exclusion is.

I've dealt with 100s of people contesting rejected insurance claims over the years and every single one was due to them not understanding (or just not reading) the terms and conditions of the policy they purchased.

Createausername1970 · 23/02/2024 21:32

Hoglet70 · 23/02/2024 20:53

The only decent policy is a lifetime policy that you do not change and you never therefore get conditions that aren't covered. We pay out a lot of money every month but everything is covered and always will be for the life of the animal. Unfortunately until people get fleeced by a crap policy (usually a cheap one) they continue to get seduced by the cheaper policies that ultimately wont pay out.

Hope you manage to sort DCat out @Savemykitchen

Yes, we have a lifetime policy. But the downside is you can't move to another provider because then anything that has been claimed for is pre-existing. We have a dog with IBD, had two claims for that so far and likely to have more in the future.

Tilllly · 23/02/2024 21:29

@Savemykitchen

Tell them no

We had this with our eldest cat but wouldn't go ahead as she wasn't in pain and was eating fine
2 years later, we agreed to it and all they ended up doing was cleaning them

I think it's a rip off, insurance doesn't cover cats teeth and it's quick money for vets

VanWeezer · 23/02/2024 21:27

That sounds a lot for one tooth

My cat had 10 teeth out and it cost £700. The next year more needed to come out. She only had 2 good teeth left so we decided to take those ones out. One as it would be another x-ray, anaesthetic etc. But another part of it was cost. The type of issue she had would eventually get to the good teeth.

The two operations came to just over £2k.

I would probably see other vets for a quote. Also ask if it's likely to happen again.

Tilllly · 23/02/2024 21:25

Containerhome · 23/02/2024 20:49

Oh gosh. I have had to use my insuramce for my kitten 3 times since we had her and the vet couldn't work out what was wrong. I worked it out myself and she just needed wormer. So now my premiums are going to sky rocket.... my insurers have paid about £600. Is that a lot?

I don't think pet insurance is allowed to increase premiums due to claims
Can't think where I read that

Riverlee · 23/02/2024 21:23

Our nineteen month old dog has had five hundred pounds worth of treatment, which we managed to claim back.

A friends eight year dog had eight thousand pounds worth of treatment due to a kidney infection.

A friends cat got attacked and has had four thousand pounds worth of treatment, scans, operation, x-rays etc.

So I guess saving £80-100 a month would probably be sensible. But you don’t know what’s around the corner.

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 21:20

Another recommendation for Petplan. I have an accident-prone young spaniel and in the first 3 years of her life they must have paid out more than 5 times what we've paid. Well worth it. Premiums also don't increase with claims, just age. I think it probably reaches a point where the premiums are so high it's better to put the money in a savings account, but not for youngsters.

Futb0l · 23/02/2024 21:18

I don't pay it. We just have savings and will use them as necessary. We briefly had it and noticed the vets add one everything and everything (often things thar arent necessary or worth it) when they think an insurers covering it... then your premium rockets so you pay really.

Tel12 · 23/02/2024 21:16

One reason to have insurance is public liability. We are now paying £75 a month for our elderly dog. Only had one claim which shot the price up.

Belovedbagle · 23/02/2024 21:15

Even though you're not insured for this, you'll still probably use the insurance for another issue.

When we got our kitten I almost didn't insure him.. just a kitten right? Luckily dh did- the following week he was diagnosed with Wet FIP and they coughed up 12k for it.

timeooooout · 23/02/2024 21:15

I pay about 6 quid a month for each of our rescue bunnies pet insurance.

One of them was off his food one day so I took him to the vet who didn't clock what was actually wrong.

Then he deteriorated in the evening (had a stroke) and I had to take him to the emergency vet. So that's 300 quid just to walk in the door.

Had all kinds of round the clock care then had to be PTS as had another stroke he couldn't recover from.

Total vet bill was around 1k and all I had to pay was 50 quid excess.

Had a big review of all our finances recently and decided to keep the pet insurance for the other rabbits precisely because of what happened to him.

Zanatdy · 23/02/2024 21:12

I get some people putting money aside instead but if I’d have done that I’d have paid 6k between weeks 12-16 and no diagnosis, later diagnosed with glaucoma - ongoing tests and later surgery to come, well over 10k in total I’d have paid so far. So I guess if you’ve got money to pay for these things don’t take insurance. Sure there are exemptions but like OP said they are listed. It’s still well worth taking insurance in my own experience

TheHennaHairedHarridan · 23/02/2024 21:12

Yeah we had similar, had been paying through the nose for monthly premiums, then insurance wouldn't pay out. Now we just have a fund for future vet bills.

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 21:09

Missingmyusername · 23/02/2024 20:49

How the hell is it costing that much?!

It includes radiographs and extraction as Dcat has bad inflammation that hasn't improved after recent extraction. The last 3 tooth extraction cost around £700

OP posts:
lovemycbf · 23/02/2024 21:08

I only had positive experience with pet insurance
Had it her entire life with pet plan and had the lifetime cover ,it wasn't the cheapest but they paid every single claim including a lifelong condition

2dogsandabudgie · 23/02/2024 21:06

£2,000 for tooth extraction? My dog had 3 teeth removed under GA and that was £240. Try another vet.

HouseIsOnFire · 23/02/2024 21:02

Hoglet70 · 23/02/2024 20:53

The only decent policy is a lifetime policy that you do not change and you never therefore get conditions that aren't covered. We pay out a lot of money every month but everything is covered and always will be for the life of the animal. Unfortunately until people get fleeced by a crap policy (usually a cheap one) they continue to get seduced by the cheaper policies that ultimately wont pay out.

Hope you manage to sort DCat out @Savemykitchen

Can't agree with this enough, find a firm you trust and stick with them for a life time policy.
I'm with petplan who paid out for a 5k emergency surgery and the plan for my 2 cats only went up a couple of quid - its £37 for both together a month.
I also think a lot of the policies being pushed now as cheap monthly premiums really aren't fit for purpose.
Saying that, the prices you're quoting are ridiculous - do you have a second vet you could get another opinion on?

AllTheWatersTurnedToClouds · 23/02/2024 20:59

We've never bothered, have 3 cats and it def wouldn't have been worth it so far - very few vet visits, even for the 18 yr old one.

When we got her as a young'un we asked the vet if he recommended insurance. He said if you have $5000 (we're not in UK) to spare you don't need to bother. Any higher fee than that and your cat will be dead anyway. Bit blunt, but got his point across.

Tel12 · 23/02/2024 20:57

You need to get another quote, that sounds excessive. Our vet charged £600 for 10 teeth removed from our dog.

catofglory · 23/02/2024 20:55

Our cat had 8 teeth removed a few months ago and it was just over £500 (and I’m in the South East so fairly expensive area) so I can’t understand how your vet is reaching those figures.

Hoglet70 · 23/02/2024 20:53

The only decent policy is a lifetime policy that you do not change and you never therefore get conditions that aren't covered. We pay out a lot of money every month but everything is covered and always will be for the life of the animal. Unfortunately until people get fleeced by a crap policy (usually a cheap one) they continue to get seduced by the cheaper policies that ultimately wont pay out.

Hope you manage to sort DCat out @Savemykitchen

BakedTattie · 23/02/2024 20:51

That’s surely not right?
Our greyhound needed 10 teeth removed, she was in vets for 2 nights and we were £500 in total.

Containerhome · 23/02/2024 20:49

Oh gosh. I have had to use my insuramce for my kitten 3 times since we had her and the vet couldn't work out what was wrong. I worked it out myself and she just needed wormer. So now my premiums are going to sky rocket.... my insurers have paid about £600. Is that a lot?

Swipe left for the next trending thread