Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WTF do I pay pet insurance for?!

81 replies

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 20:12

Looking at the FIFTH tooth extraction for Dcat. It's happening once a year now.

Years ago I naively didn't know that our insurance didn't cover teeth. Longtime cat owner since childhood never known dental issues in all those years. So, once the first issue happened Dcat insurance would not cover as it's seen as preexisting condition.

Honestly not sure we can afford it this time. I'm at a loss, they're saying it'll be over £2k, we only just paid £700 and that's on top of £££ monthly insurance which does sweet FA.

Even when Dcat had a leg issue a few years ago, the vet couldn't fucking figure out the issue to treat it (Dcat slowly improved but still not 100%). So although nothing was treated, initial care was covered by insurance and now ANYTHING potentially leg related is "preexisting".

Honestly don't know what I have to achieve by this thread other than to vent.

OP posts:
WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 23/02/2024 23:07

Reading this is certainly making me think about changing our insurance to someone like pet plan, at Christmas both dogs were at the Emergency vets thanks to a Christmas present that had no warning but contained mince pies, dark chocolate - you name it it was in there (gift giver knew we had dogs 😡).
The overall bill was around the £5k mark, despite a £160 excess the insurance refused to pay out for so many different things we ended up with a bill of £1k

In terms of teeth, we had a cat have three teeth out last year and that was about £800, it included things like bloods prior to check liver/kidney to minimise risk of antisthetic, fluids whilst under, pain relief for after and all post op checks none of which we'd want to scrimp on for an older cat

HollyKnight · 23/02/2024 23:06

I'd say cheap insurance is a con. Those are really limited and not worth it for ongoing conditions. It's much better to get a policy that doesn't come with so many limits and exclusions. Of course you might not ever need to claim on it (lucky you!), but if you do get hit with a massive bill or an ongoing condition it's so worth it.

buswankerz · 23/02/2024 23:05

Chicheguevara · 23/02/2024 20:34

Had a very negative experience with pet insurance so now I have the ‘vet fund’, which is a bank account where I paid in the ‘premium’ each month that I would have paid the insurance company for my really healthy dogs. As long as a bill isn’t over £10k, we are fine. This has accrued over years though.

My bad experience was my old Jack Russell sliced her paw open, on some glass, while hooning about in deep snow, quite a lot of years ago. She was operated on - it was a heck of a cut, deep and very long - and the insurance company paid out. The following year, my premium skyrocketed and they said anything cut or leg related was pre-existing. I contacted them and pointed out that cut paws on glass are hardly hereditary or a ‘condition’, it was a freak accident. They were not budging. Hence the ‘vet fund’.

I have saved a fortune, over the years. Just my take on it and I do appreciate that I have been lucky with nothing dire occurring.

Was this animal friends by any chance because they did that to me even though I had a lifetime policy. They'll do anything to avoid paying out.

I have a separate account for my vet fund.

Babypuppyshark · 23/02/2024 23:03

That does sound expensive.

Pet insurance can be a pain though. I just tried to claim £750 back for emergency treatment. I got £200 because that’s what the emergency fee was capped at 🙄

Ironic really because for non life threatening treatment during usual vet hours they’d have paid the full amount.

Nellieinthebarn · 23/02/2024 23:02

I think all insurance is a bloody con, it only really works as a business model if they manage to weasel out of paying. My dog has anything skin related, digestive related or allergy related as pre-existing. And the premiums are ridiculous. Oh, and anything bilateral, so if one hip goes, they only pay for that one, not the other one a few years later. Whats the point?

MediumDwarf · 23/02/2024 23:00

That cost is madness! Go to another vet and find out their costs.

We have also given up on pet insurance. Our cat is feisty, and has had to be patched up a number of times after battles he has started. It was never covered, neither are annual vaccinations or check ups. As PP said we now also stash the previously monthly premium into a saving account as our own insurance policy.

HollyKnight · 23/02/2024 22:53

Petplan covered for life here. It's expensive, but I've never had them not pay out. Broken legs, tumours, tail amputations, epilepsy, dental, water therapy, biologics etc. Covered for up to £7k per year per pet.

If your cat isn't too old now you should look into getting a lifetime policy rather than a one-off yearly one.

Jowak1 · 23/02/2024 22:53

My cat had to have 3 teeth out last week and it cost £300. The nurses warned me that my insurance may not pay out as they are funny about teeth 🦷 and a lot say it's wear and tear. I am with Pet plan and was happily surprised that they paid the lot ! Very quickly too within 48 hrs the money was in the bank!

Wexone · 23/02/2024 22:46

Sister works in insurance and told me a few years ago that pet insurance is the most profitable insurance out of all insurances you can get. so I have never bothered plus most pet insurance I checked stop after 8 years of age so as mine are all old I do two things. I pay a monthly plan with vets si get reduced consultation prescriptions etc. also as going there years they allow monthly pay off on larger bills. also save a bit each month. if know a large bill coming I sell stuff myself towards it - did this for specific hernia operation for one of my dogs. touch wood worked so far
for yours though would defo get a second opinion sounds a bit mich

WiddlinDiddlin · 23/02/2024 22:46

Dog owners can get public liability insurance to cover all their dogs if they are members of the Dogs Trust, which is £25 a year.

Oldest DDog is not insured, two youngest have pet plan lifetime policies which they've absolutely had their moneys worth out of over the years.

We have a credit card with nothing on it and I think a 10k limit, and when these two get old enough that the insurance is no longer worth it (couple more years) we'll move to sticking the premiums in a bank account with the credit card as a back up should we need it before the bank account has a decent amount in it.

hilariousnamehere · 23/02/2024 22:41

My two are with petplan covered for life and it includes dental if I get an annual dental checkup by the vet. Which I do. They're 10.5 and we've had one dental op, various emergency stuff and some ongoing gastro issues and petplan have paid up for everything. So I think my £70 a month is well spent - and it was £26 a month when they were kittens, now just under £70 for them both which I think is reasonable premium rises considering my claim history. It's peace of mind if something big happens, but I think if I didn't have the cover I do I'd just be saving monthly into a fund specifically for them and also making sure I had a credit card with a high limit!

Nonbio46 · 23/02/2024 22:40

Tel12 · 23/02/2024 21:16

One reason to have insurance is public liability. We are now paying £75 a month for our elderly dog. Only had one claim which shot the price up.

This is why we have insurance too. Although we have claimed some vets fees over the years ( my dog is 12).

BigDogEnergy · 23/02/2024 22:34

I've been out of the loop for a few years and things may have changed, but when I was working in practice dealing with insurance claims, Animal Friends were the worst for well buried exclusions in their Ts & Cs.

Pippa246 · 23/02/2024 22:23

*rescuing not reducing

Pippa246 · 23/02/2024 22:22

Yeah it’s a rip off. My cat “needed” a tooth out and it ended up £945 for anaesthetic etc (but they trimmed claws whilst under woopy do). Pet insurance of £12 a month didn’t cover dental so I had to pay it myself.

mine were rescue cats and I was thinking of reducing a dog but not now. Owning a pet is now way beyond the costs of a lot of people.

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 22:18

laclochette · 23/02/2024 22:15

I had to pay £900 for a full teeth clean under anesthetic for DCat including one removal. Didn't realise my insurance didn't cover it either. FML.

Switched insurers to one who covers dental. They cover all preexisting conditions as long as they don't first reoccur within 24 months, which thankfully nothing did. Under the original insurer, in the first 2 months of having DCat I had a £2k bill which they did cover, so I've been lucky so far. But always have a sense of impending doom around vet bills. They are insane.

Who is your new provider please?

OP posts:
laclochette · 23/02/2024 22:15

I had to pay £900 for a full teeth clean under anesthetic for DCat including one removal. Didn't realise my insurance didn't cover it either. FML.

Switched insurers to one who covers dental. They cover all preexisting conditions as long as they don't first reoccur within 24 months, which thankfully nothing did. Under the original insurer, in the first 2 months of having DCat I had a £2k bill which they did cover, so I've been lucky so far. But always have a sense of impending doom around vet bills. They are insane.

Missingmyusername · 23/02/2024 22:08

I’d be tempted to just take the tooth out, but I expect it’s more complicated than that. What would grate is knowing they’ll go in, charge £2k and likely have no idea. I’d seek a second opinion.

I’ve had questionable experiences like the vet wanting to do an mri, but admitting it might not show anything. So £1k and anaesthetic (and possible death) ended up being £75 problem solved. 🙄I have lost my faith.

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 21:57

I'm with Animal Friends, I thought it was a good level of cover, and it actually is but just not for teeth, which don't seem to be covered by many policies.

I don't think I should have bothered tbh, as I only believe in a certain level of care for animals. I understand and respect why other people do, but personally I don't think an animal's life needs to be prolonged or sustained by long term medical intervention or drugs with all their side effects.

If DCat were to get cancer or something similar then I would only want to keep him comfortable for as long as felt manageable for him. It must be such a scary and horrible process for an animal. I hate to think of DCat being put under anaesthetic as many times as he has been. Must be petrifying for him.

OP posts:
Weeteeny · 23/02/2024 21:56

I'm (my cat is) with petplan and have claimed over 11k in total for a variety of things over a 3 year period. Luckily no further cause for claim in the past 6 years though the policy cost has gradually increased from £9 a month to £32 a month.
Maximum claim per year is 8k

Broken leg in two places
Poisoning
And various tummy problems probably due to the previous poisoning

Not sure if he is covered for teeth though I am going to check!

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 21:48

Tilllly · 23/02/2024 21:29

@Savemykitchen

Tell them no

We had this with our eldest cat but wouldn't go ahead as she wasn't in pain and was eating fine
2 years later, we agreed to it and all they ended up doing was cleaning them

I think it's a rip off, insurance doesn't cover cats teeth and it's quick money for vets

Also had similar experience, the time before last. Took a bunch of teeth out, said there needed to be more extractions and then when they looked six months later couldn't find the issue. The most recent extractions have been a totally different area.

OP posts:
BrokenWing · 23/02/2024 21:47

we lost our 10 year old Labrador last year, but had a petplan lifetime policy since he was a pup. We claimed over twice the amount we paid out in premiums during his life.

the premiums went up steadily every year with his age, not related to claims, but for us it was financially worth it and worth it for the peace of mind we would be able to get him the right treatment when he needed it.

Iwrotethelyricstoaxlf · 23/02/2024 21:46

Ddog is insured with Petplan on a lifetime policy. Current cost £80/month.

Her meds are £600/month and she’s recently had a few nights in doggy hospital and that was £4k.

We definitely get our moneys worth out of the insurance.

Teeth aren’t covered though, but she has regular scans where she’s sedated so if any teeth need doing they get done then as the sedation is the most expensive bit.

Bridgertonned · 23/02/2024 21:44

We've always had pet insurance (and has been worth it) but often even the expensive lifetime policies have exclusions about dental treatment. I agree the prices quoted seem excessive though!

Containerhome · 23/02/2024 21:44

This thread got me thinking. I'm with animal friends lifetime superior plus. It covers dental up to 3k. I just randomly chose them. But it says no specific exclusions. I got lucky with my random pick. I pay just over £17 a month

Swipe left for the next trending thread