Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WTF do I pay pet insurance for?!

81 replies

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 20:12

Looking at the FIFTH tooth extraction for Dcat. It's happening once a year now.

Years ago I naively didn't know that our insurance didn't cover teeth. Longtime cat owner since childhood never known dental issues in all those years. So, once the first issue happened Dcat insurance would not cover as it's seen as preexisting condition.

Honestly not sure we can afford it this time. I'm at a loss, they're saying it'll be over £2k, we only just paid £700 and that's on top of £££ monthly insurance which does sweet FA.

Even when Dcat had a leg issue a few years ago, the vet couldn't fucking figure out the issue to treat it (Dcat slowly improved but still not 100%). So although nothing was treated, initial care was covered by insurance and now ANYTHING potentially leg related is "preexisting".

Honestly don't know what I have to achieve by this thread other than to vent.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hoglet70 · 24/02/2024 09:02

Containerhome · 23/02/2024 21:44

This thread got me thinking. I'm with animal friends lifetime superior plus. It covers dental up to 3k. I just randomly chose them. But it says no specific exclusions. I got lucky with my random pick. I pay just over £17 a month

My Tesco lifetime policy also covers dental. My old dog had teeth removed twice on her policy.

Bridgertonned · 24/02/2024 08:35

Savemykitchen · 24/02/2024 07:58

We were told this so DCat only had wet food for 6 or so years, constant teeth troubles and now the latest vets recommended dry and said the wet food caused his issues. So I'm not sure which is correct

We've also been told that the wet food is junk food and the kibble is better - the wet food sticks to the teeth, the kibble doesn't.

Though a big part is definitely genetics. We've got two cats, one eats anything in sight, including trash and human food if he can find it. I One eats only when he's hungry and only cat food. The first cats teeth have always been fine, the second has had signs of gum disease since he was a few years old. Both get the same food at home.

Savemykitchen · 24/02/2024 07:58

Haffiana · 23/02/2024 23:35

If you want your cat to have good teeth then never, ever give them dry food. Stick to wet food only. Not the garbage called 'dental food', not any dry food. And in fact - you can ask your vet for the actual evidence that dry kibble whether marketed as dental food or not, is beneficial to cats teeth and if they are honest (most are, btw) they will tell you that Royal Canin pay them to sell and display their products.

It is like expecting you to have good teeth by chewing on ritz crackers. What can help clean a cat's teeth is a raw chicken wing, but if you can't face that, just get them off the cat biscuits.

We were told this so DCat only had wet food for 6 or so years, constant teeth troubles and now the latest vets recommended dry and said the wet food caused his issues. So I'm not sure which is correct

OP posts:
PawsisShady · 24/02/2024 01:52

Mine is with Tesco and teeth are covered providing he has a yearly check up

Glasgowlass93 · 24/02/2024 01:46

My cat needed two teeth out recently. In total it was £700 odds. Luckily about £500 paid out from insurance. We hace never claimed before so who knows whats next years premium will look like.

GrannyRose15 · 24/02/2024 01:40

I pay pet insurance not just to cover vets bills but so that I am covered if my dog causes an accident. Personal injury claims can run into thousands so I don’t want to be caught out. Ps he’s a very good dog and not very likely to hurt anyone but accidents do happen.

SingingSands · 24/02/2024 01:34

My cat had ALL her teeth removed in 2020 or 2021 and it was about £300!

I never have insurance either, just a separate account I save into every month. The most I've had to pay out is £1k when she was hit by a car and needed x-rays, surgery and an overnight stay.

Treehuggingmutherfunkin · 24/02/2024 01:21

We pay insurance for nothing tbh. My car was stolen which I owned for 1 month. I paid 10,500 for the car and was returned 8,200 from insurance.

gillefc82 · 24/02/2024 01:04

Sympathies OP. I took my almost 1 year old rescue puppy into the vet last week for his 6 month health check and mentioned he occasionally seems to be stiff on his back legs when getting up/shifting position after sleeping and will sometimes whimper as if in pain.

Vet advised to wait for him to finish maturing before worrying about doing any tests, but agreed to give me a quote for some X-rays just in case we decided we want to investigate now.

Safe to say, at £1,600, we’ll be waiting until he’s older and hoping it resolves itself during the rest of him growing.

That is £200 less than I paid 2 years ago when another of my dogs was hospitalised to be treated for acute kidney failure and he sadly passed.

I continue to insure all 3 of mine but given there is no direct payment of claims, just reimbursement, you still have to find the money in the first place!

IloveAslan · 24/02/2024 00:47

WTF!!! One of my cats had four teeth extracted a few years ago and it cost $500 (so 250 pound). I can't imagine that it has gone up by that much. I would be looking around for another vet OP. Admittedly it was many years ago, but I only paid half of that quote for one of my cats to have complicated surgery at a specialist clinic.

I cancelled my pet insurance after a wrangle with the company several years ago, and now just pay as I go. It's only in the past few years that my cats have needed vet treatment (I had 5 cats) as they got older and even then only a vist or two each. It was only the oldest cat who was insured, and he didn't cost much after I cancelled the policy. I don't think I would get it again.

dothehokeycokey · 24/02/2024 00:47

My greyhound had to have 20
Teeth removed plus scale and polish on what was left and my bill was just under £1000 not covered on insurance

Catpuss66 · 24/02/2024 00:45

Get 2nd opinion different vets

MediumDwarf · 23/02/2024 23:48

Callipygion · 23/02/2024 23:16

My vet does a vacs for life scheme. You pay something like £60 or £80 for the first vaccination/s & an ID microchip, then the annual boosters and a check up are free. Might be worth asking if your vets run something similar?

They do have this, but as he’s an old boy who is already neutered and chipped, for the price it’s more than just paying for the annual vaccinations.

Thank you for the suggestion though x

Haffiana · 23/02/2024 23:35

If you want your cat to have good teeth then never, ever give them dry food. Stick to wet food only. Not the garbage called 'dental food', not any dry food. And in fact - you can ask your vet for the actual evidence that dry kibble whether marketed as dental food or not, is beneficial to cats teeth and if they are honest (most are, btw) they will tell you that Royal Canin pay them to sell and display their products.

It is like expecting you to have good teeth by chewing on ritz crackers. What can help clean a cat's teeth is a raw chicken wing, but if you can't face that, just get them off the cat biscuits.

NauseousNancy · 23/02/2024 23:20

I’m with petplan which covers dental care. My cat had two teeth taken out at a specialist cat dentist and it was about 2k. They were healthy teeth which apparently made them more difficult to remove. Insurance paid out no bother, only condition is that they have their teeth checked once a year.

My other cat has had about 2k worth of X-rays, sedations & blood tests due to a neurological issue. Again no issues claiming.

I pay about £25 per cat per month. They’ve all been insured since kittens and on the lifetime plan.

Toddlerteaplease · 23/02/2024 23:19

My two late cats ran up bills of £25k. All covered by insurance. My current girl has just cost £977 to have 6 teeth out.

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 23:17

Nightblindness · 23/02/2024 23:12

I've always half suspected that pet insurance is not worth it. A few years ago one of my cats had a health issue and cost us £3000 in the space of a couple of weeks (uninsured). It was a really hair raising time as, whilst we had the money, inevitably there would have come a time when we couldn't afford to go on. Since then, I have been regularly saving into a vet fund, roughly what the premiums would be for 2 cats. I haven't had to dip into it yet. It is a long term experiment, but I still believe putting money aside like this might end up being the better option to paying premiums.

Oh and try Royal Canin dental food. So far, I have kept 5 cats from needing dental treatment. Even cats who the vet has said should have dental treatment have ended up not needing it after a few months on Royal Canin.

He's on premium dental food as recommended by the vets.

OP posts:
Callipygion · 23/02/2024 23:16

MediumDwarf · 23/02/2024 23:00

That cost is madness! Go to another vet and find out their costs.

We have also given up on pet insurance. Our cat is feisty, and has had to be patched up a number of times after battles he has started. It was never covered, neither are annual vaccinations or check ups. As PP said we now also stash the previously monthly premium into a saving account as our own insurance policy.

My vet does a vacs for life scheme. You pay something like £60 or £80 for the first vaccination/s & an ID microchip, then the annual boosters and a check up are free. Might be worth asking if your vets run something similar?

BouncingJAS · 23/02/2024 23:15

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 21:09

It includes radiographs and extraction as Dcat has bad inflammation that hasn't improved after recent extraction. The last 3 tooth extraction cost around £700

Our cat had FCGS (he was a rescue and was FCV positive which then led to stomatitis) and required a full mouth extraction.

Cost was £3,000

The thing about tooth extractions is that you need dental x-rays along with anaesthesia to really do it properly. This requires a visit to a specialist dental clinic and surgeon. There are very few of these in the UK.

If your regular Vet does it, they do not use dental x-rays. They generally do not have the specialised equipment, so they just take the teeth out under anaesthesia. While this is cheaper, it is possible that a small part of the tooth is left behind, which can them cause problems with infection and inflammation. This is where the specialist dental surgeon checks the procedure has been done correctly with the dental x-rays. The regular vet does not do this check.

Korkie · 23/02/2024 23:14

My dog developed an eye ulcer, which the insurance paid up for. The insurer then wrote and said that future policies would exclude eye problems, so they lost my custom.
I have insurance, but I go through the policy small print with a fine tooth comb before taking the insurance policy on.
It's surprising what they don't insure once you get reading the small print thoroughly.

Notthatcatagain · 23/02/2024 23:14

I have one cat insured because he has epilepsy, so far they have paid all his bills bar the excess. They told me to only put a claim in once a year so only one lot of excess but if he gets sick, the bills are big so worth having. For the rest of the gang (dog, 2 more cats and 3 chickens) I have a fund, bank £100 per month, been doing it for 2 years, have paid for all their shots, big bill for the elderly cats teeth and one poorly chicken PTS. Still got about £1200 float

Nightblindness · 23/02/2024 23:12

I've always half suspected that pet insurance is not worth it. A few years ago one of my cats had a health issue and cost us £3000 in the space of a couple of weeks (uninsured). It was a really hair raising time as, whilst we had the money, inevitably there would have come a time when we couldn't afford to go on. Since then, I have been regularly saving into a vet fund, roughly what the premiums would be for 2 cats. I haven't had to dip into it yet. It is a long term experiment, but I still believe putting money aside like this might end up being the better option to paying premiums.

Oh and try Royal Canin dental food. So far, I have kept 5 cats from needing dental treatment. Even cats who the vet has said should have dental treatment have ended up not needing it after a few months on Royal Canin.

SouIs · 23/02/2024 23:10

We have definitely gotten our monies worth from pet insurance.

Our dog had to have hip replacements - £10,000 each! Luckily we were insured. At the referral clinic we met a young couple with a juvenile labrador. They cancelled their insurance and within weeks their dog was diagnosed with severe hip dysplasia and needed both hips replacing. Like most people, they couldn’t afford the cost so had maxed out their credit cards and taken out loans from the bank as well as friends and family.

We also had a rabbit who broke her leg and another dog with cruciate ligament disease which all cost about £12,000.

So I definitely feel it was worth it!

Definitelynotem · 23/02/2024 23:09

We had a good experience with John Lewis, my cat was ill very suddenly and unfortunately passed away within a couple of hours for unknown reasons. They paid out quickly and were so kind on the phone. Very much worth the £12 a month I’d been paying to get over £2k back in vet fees at what was already a traumatic time.

Callipygion · 23/02/2024 23:08

None of the companies I’ve ever had pet insurance with (and there’s been a few over the years) have covered teeth, apart from if they are damaged due to an accident or illness.

My cat has been in twice for tooth extractions, a couple of years ago, and I think it was around £1,000 in total I had to pay.

Apparently, so my vet says, cats can suffer from teeth being reabsorbed at the root, which is very painful, and it can’t be seen except on an X-ray. So the charge covers those, anaesthetics, and surgery (my vet charges per tooth and not just a procedure.) I have a suspicion she has something going on again now with her teeth, so I’m expecting another big bill again in the next week or so. :(