Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Poverty trap? What to do

239 replies

Duckingfun · 23/02/2024 14:24

I’m on benefits due to having a disabled child who currently isn’t in school.
I want to work, when he’s at a suitable school I will be looking for work. However my rent has now increased in my council house to just under £1k there is no way I can afford it if I work. The better off website says I will be something like £90 a month better off, I want to work but I don’t want to work 40+ hours a week for £90 and then I’d be worse off after travel/childcare etc
Whats the answer? I can’t move and it just feels so unfair that the council raise the rent to the top limit of what they can.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 13:47

No, it’s not essentially the same thing. One means only the LHA is the housing element. The other means the full rent is the housing element. The difference may be a drop in the ocean for you, but for many it isn’t.

Scope’s latest disability price tag research shows households with a least 1 disabled person on average need an additional £975 per month for the same standard of living as non-disabled households. This is on top of disability benefits such as DLA. Scope state if the figure was updated to account for inflation during 22/23 that would rise to £1,122. Presumably even higher now, especially for a family with 2 disabled DC.

OP you should apply for DLA for DD.

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 13:43

and with my 19hrs I'd take home over £4kp/mth of income and benefits as a single mother now. I think that worked out to virtually the same take home as someone on £70k a year.

oh how I wish I lived in your made up world 🙈

OP posts:
Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 13:42

ds had a statement of special needs and then ehcp and I’ve never known of a ss having a child without an ehcp.

I dont claim dla for dd because she’s currently in nursery and I don’t feel we need it at this point. I’m not willing to disclose their diagnosis but they both have different scans/MRIs/xrays/hospital stays along with different medication and equipment etc

I won’t be renting private as I like that I have the security here, there’s not going to be a landlord wanting to sell/move back in etc and the house is suitable for dc. Where we used to live we were an hour away from the closest hospital so it’s not a case of just choosing the best house and moving in, that’s not going to happen.

In my opinion Norfolk is one of the most expensive places to live, I’ve lived all over and other than London and potentially Cornwall I would say it’s up there for expense.

OP posts:
WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 13:39

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 13:27

As I posted, in a council property the LHA does not apply. But the housing element will be subject to the earnings deduction just like every other UC element.

Having multiple disabled DC can be extremely expensive. It is brilliant you don’t find this and think OP should be managing better, but for many with multiple disabled DC money is extremely tight.

It's essentially the same thing. Very little difference in rent covered/payable.

OP has many housing options in Norfolk. Many.

I'm going to do a brief calc to see what OP is most likely receiving. Because, whilst I know first hand there are some extra costs inherently with a disabled child, (just DLA for my DS is over £400 p/mth so not insignificant and that's without child benefit, carers allowance and the child element of UC) some people are bad at money management.

I did a calc the other day, as I knew what I received previously as a single mother on tax credits etc, and with my 19hrs I'd take home over £4kp/mth of income and benefits as a single mother now. I think that worked out to virtually the same take home as someone on £70k a year. I think it should be looked in to if I then said I couldn't afford to live. That's a lot of money to account for each month.

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 13:27

As I posted, in a council property the LHA does not apply. But the housing element will be subject to the earnings deduction just like every other UC element.

Having multiple disabled DC can be extremely expensive. It is brilliant you don’t find this and think OP should be managing better, but for many with multiple disabled DC money is extremely tight.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 13:21

Ok, right you are....

Anyway @Duckingfun if you really want to start making the right changes, there is a lot of support available. Your assumptions about what you will receive vs lose via a part time job, are not correct. You will be significantly better off as long as you keep your assessable amount under £602 per month. This will depend what your nursery fees are as there's a calculation to follow. If you want to PM me your monthly fees, I will tell you what you can earn and not lose your CA.

The priority for you is getting DS into the right provision. Nothing else can happen until this child is not at home with you all day every day. You need to keep on at the LA. On and on. They have not given you an adequate solution.

Housing wise, there are many places in Norfolk to choose from. The swap method is not really a thing, people sit on that for years and the odd one gets lucky, so honestly, stop wasting your time. Norfolk is one of the cheapest places to live. Rent under £1k is very easy to find. The council can help with deposits and moving costs.

As a side note, you need to look at why, with full UC for you and two DC, circa £800 free rent, DLA for one child (two? do you get it for DD as well?) Carer's allowance, 85% of your childcare costs paid plus double child benefit....you can't afford potentially £200 a month rent top up?

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 13:10

I haven’t had to do anything. SS without an EHCP these days is extremely rare (flying pig rare) and just doesn’t happen unless in situations which don’t apply to OP. Even with an EHCP many have to appeal.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 13:08

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 13:06

Clearly not.

Well considering you've already had to relinquish that a situation you declared couldn't exist, does in fact exist...

Rocket1982 · 24/02/2024 13:08

Your're thinking about this wrong. The amount you earn isn't the difference between the amount you earn and what you could be getting on benefits! It's just the amount you earn. You will be off (some of the) benefits and building a career which you can progress in. If I work and earn an hourly rate of say £12, I don't think of it as £4 because I would be getting the equivalent of £8 on benefits... It's £12. If you can reduce benefits and support yourself financially you should be proud of your efforts, not thinking it's not worth it.

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 13:06

Clearly not.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 13:06

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 12:22

I didn’t say more than one property couldn’t be adapted, but it isn’t as simple to move between adapted properties. Some people wait years for a suitable property. Some LAs claw back adaptation costs if people move with a set timeframe (1/2/5/10/20 years). Some LAs don’t allow households in an adapted property to swap.

And sometimes the suitable properties are more expensive than your typical 3rd floor 3 bed flat or your 2 up/2 down.

You can’t possibly become an expert in the SEN system within 7 months.

Edited

No I'm very knowledgeable in the SEN system through having a disabled child within that system for the last 15yrs. Specifically in Norfolk.

Tatumm · 24/02/2024 13:05

@Duckingfun
Your initial mission should be to buy yourself some time in order to explore your options thoroughly. I agree with others who have said that it would be worth exploring training options and looking to the longer term.

Find some advice on benefits to see how much of the rent increase would be covered. Some advice agencies, such as your local Citizens Advice should also be able to advise if you have grounds to challenge the rent increase. Although successful challenges are most often for tenants of clueless private landlords https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/housing/renting-privately/during-your-tenancy/challenging-a-rent-increase/

Also check your local council’s website for other locally tailored help:
https://www.norfolk.gov.uk/what-we-do-and-how-we-work/campaigns/help-with-living-costs

If you prefer, you could contact Carers UK, or your local Carers support agency.
https://carersmatternorfolk.org.uk/
Carers charities have an advice line and they signpost to other services if it’s something they don’t have expertise in. It is worth signing up with them as a carer if you aren’t already. They are there to support you, and it sounds as though you’ve been battling to get help for your child. 💐

Finally, please check this grant finder https://grants-search.turn2us.org.uk/

Challenging a rent increase

Find out if you can challenge your section 13 rent increase for free at a tribunal and check what evidence you need to send with your application.

https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/housing/renting-privately/during-your-tenancy/challenging-a-rent-increase/

OriginalUsername2 · 24/02/2024 13:05

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 12:59

I work 19hrs a week. I get £1000 a month. They deduct your nursery fees from your wage (to a certain limit) to come to the assessable amount of earnings for CA. You certainly wouldn't be working for £2.80 an hour.

The fact you haven't looked into this properly, or that you live directly where I know a lot of what you're claiming to be virtually impossible, is actually very possible because my work deals with this sort of thing week in, week out, does not make me "awful."

You could talk with a little more empathy, jeez.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 13:04

So hospital wise, you've got N&N around Norwich. You've got QE around Kings Lynn. You've got JP nearer the coast. My personal recommendation would be to head closer to the Suffolk border and fall under WSH.

Correct me if I'm wrong but I'm guessing DS is more ADHD/ASD type needs than something like dialysis. WSH is excellent.

That would lean towards Brandon or Thetford for housing. Both dirt cheap. Well covered by your UC. Houses available in both areas.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 12:59

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 12:28

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn I think you’re in the wrong job as you’re quite awful to be honest.

It doesn’t matter what I say, you will call it an excuse and I really wish I lived in your fairytale world where I could just move and have my children in school and not too far from a hospital.

I have been on the swap sites for a couple of years with no luck, I can’t afford to move, not only rent and deposit but moving fees never mind all the stress that would come with that and the stress on my children. I have been fighting with schools for many years for my son so no I’m not just complaining and doing nothing.

Ultimately I don’t think anyone (in a private house or housing association) should be priced out of their home and when universal credits covers the rent it’s makes it extremely difficult to be financially better off. Even if I would be £500 better off working, that’s the equivalent of working for £2.80 an hour before tax and national insurance. That’s nowhere near minimum wage.

I work 19hrs a week. I get £1000 a month. They deduct your nursery fees from your wage (to a certain limit) to come to the assessable amount of earnings for CA. You certainly wouldn't be working for £2.80 an hour.

The fact you haven't looked into this properly, or that you live directly where I know a lot of what you're claiming to be virtually impossible, is actually very possible because my work deals with this sort of thing week in, week out, does not make me "awful."

OriginalUsername2 · 24/02/2024 12:58

You can earn £379 a month but yeah you would lose some money in working costs and paying a percentage of your childcare. That would still leave you with at least a couple hundred extra.

Self-employment from home is an option too if you have any ideas. When you’re on UC and have caring responsibilities there is no minimum income floor so you could earn sporadically and not mess up your benefits claims.

Think longer term than the next few years. If you start a job or small business now, when they go to school your income will rise again because you won’t be paying that childcare and you’ll be better off all around (although, wraparound and holidays have to be considered.. so it depends on if you can wangle that with other mums, grandparents, time off, etc.)

Realistically, this all only works if you physically and mentally have the energy for work after all the care you provide.

LondonQueen · 24/02/2024 12:56

You'd be better off getting a qualification for a better paid job, bookkeeping is quite easy to pick up and jobs start about 25k (up north, it will be higher further down south).

Boomer55 · 24/02/2024 12:52

tryingtogetinshape · 23/02/2024 22:56

Wow your rent is an outrage i live in a 2 bed HA flat for 400 a month.

It must depend on area/HA. I’m paying £900 for a two bed flat. London/Kent borders😳

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 12:48

The LHA doesn’t apply to those in council properties. For those in council properties on UC, the full rent amount is the housing element except if there is a bedroom tax deduction. Unlikely in this case. Although obviously the total award would be reduced by any earnings deduction if OP had one.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 12:41

nappyvalley2024 · 24/02/2024 12:32

It depends where it is, if inner London where market rents are £3k then 1k is very reasonable.

It's in Norfolk. Where I help people in this exact position. It's virtually unheard of to be this high.

The most OP should be looking at is £850 for 3 bed which her UC will cover (without knowing her exact position, she's most likely entitled to a 3 bed) which means she gets (for example under Breckland, a Norfolk council district) £800 paid for her. £50 rent a month, with (min £2.5k UC/DLA/CA) isn't exactly a bad deal. Even if that rent was £1000, let's not forget OP gets £800 of that for free.

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 12:37

No you don't need an EHCP for SS.

In practice, these days, yes, you do. Unless you are self funding, which clearly isn’t an option for the OP. It is extremely rare for LAs to fund an SS placement without an EHCP these days with the exception of sometimes new arrivals to England and EYFS assessment places. Your cousin is very unique in England atm.

An if OP was ‘in effect’ homeschooling online schooling wouldn’t be being provided by the LA.

nappyvalley2024 · 24/02/2024 12:32

rubyredknowsitall · 23/02/2024 15:45

Just under £1k a month for a council house? That's outrageous.

It depends where it is, if inner London where market rents are £3k then 1k is very reasonable.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 12:32

@Duckingfun is your house structurally adapted for a disabled person?

Scarletttulips · 24/02/2024 12:32

It’s been like this for years - you can’t do right for doing wrong.

DFriend is in the same boat - can’t move due to adaptations and needing room for medical equipment, doesn’t have family support, never had a holiday, if it’s not one kid needing assistance it’s another, she ferries them round to appointment after appointment let alone emergency appointments - she’s exhausted: the thought of working 40 plus hours son too is ridiculous.
Then the benefits are less that 16 hours she won’t get one over 16 hours she won’t get the other one and is literally worse off.

Now if special schools were kept open these children would get placements - bit the huge campaign to get all children into mainstream is back firing.

Only now there’s no buildings and no socialist staff.

Wvwryone I know with a disabled youngster is on the breadline and exhausted. Funny how the men don’t stick around.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 12:31

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 12:13

it's your posts that are clueless.

Far from it. Supporting parents of DC with SEN is also my job.

She is in effect homeschooling

EOTAS and s19 provision is not EHE.

She hasn't mentioned an EHCP. Maybe DS has one.

OP mentioned a new SS being consulted. If you knew anything about SS and consultations you would know OP would need an EHCP for SSs to be consulted. So, OP’s DC clearly has an EHCP.

It's unlikely his medical needs are extremely complex due to the fact he has been in school previously.

There are many DC with complex medical needs attending schools in England.

That's why I said "in effect* homeschooling. But then you knew that, didn't you.

No you don't need an EHCP for SS. I know this without doubt as my cousin's child is in this exact situation. In Suffolk. It's far more likely OP's DS does have one, I'll give you that, but not definitely. That tells me enough...