Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Poverty trap? What to do

239 replies

Duckingfun · 23/02/2024 14:24

I’m on benefits due to having a disabled child who currently isn’t in school.
I want to work, when he’s at a suitable school I will be looking for work. However my rent has now increased in my council house to just under £1k there is no way I can afford it if I work. The better off website says I will be something like £90 a month better off, I want to work but I don’t want to work 40+ hours a week for £90 and then I’d be worse off after travel/childcare etc
Whats the answer? I can’t move and it just feels so unfair that the council raise the rent to the top limit of what they can.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 15:41

Literally the only other thing I could have got wrong is your council tax at estimating band B.

Except the housing element is also wrong because the full rent of £950 would be paid since OP is in a council property.

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 15:37

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:33

And whilst I don't have an identical child, I have a disabled child. I help numerous people a week with disabled DC. This is not my first rodeo at these figures. I will have seen people in very similar situations to OP. Not identical but certainly not incomparable. With the equivalent of a £51,900 salary entitlement, and suggesting this isn't enough, exactly how much do you think OP should be given?

It’s interesting seeing your made up story of my mildly disabled children and 50k+ a year.
However that is not the case at all. It would be nice if you stopped making up scenarios in your head.
I CANNOT currently work. Doesn’t matter what you say, it’s impossible. I am trying to go back to work in the future when ds is in a suitable school. I CAN afford to live BUT if I work and lose benefits I wouldn’t be able to afford the rent in the house that I was given (again I didn’t choose this area) unless my wage was majorly topped up by uc. what you are saying is pointless and irrelevant to my situation.

OP posts:
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 15:37

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:35

Also, she doesn't receive DLA for the younger child, who she says attends nursery and expects to attend school. This is not a disabled child for DLA/benefits purposes.

The child is still disabled as per the Equality Act whether they are in receipt of DLA or not. I did not say OP received DLA for DC2. In fact, you can clearly see I acknowledge she doesn’t because there isn’t a second disabled or severely disabled child element on the UC workings I posted.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:36

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 15:34

That is over a grand more than I get

OP, go through it line by line. Most of the figures are set amounts per month over which their can be no discrepancy.

Which line(s) make up the £1000 difference?

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:35

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 15:30

no work required

except caring 24/7 for a disabled child while also having another disabled child. It may not be paid for employment but it is still significant.

Unpaid carers save the state a fortune.

Also, she doesn't receive DLA for the younger child, who she says attends nursery and expects to attend school. This is not a disabled child for DLA/benefits purposes.

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 15:34

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:30

UC calc, with zero childcare costs. Rent at £950, with LHA of £800.

Literally the only other thing I could have got wrong is your council tax at estimating band B. This won't make any notable difference if I've got it wrong though.

I hope you work out what the discrepancy is, as there may be something you're not claiming or something not calculated correctly, and we can help out this right, or at least understand why your claim is so much lower.

That is over a grand more than I get

OP posts:
WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:33

TigerRag · 24/02/2024 15:28

"And it's looking at this £536 a week with no rent or mortgage that OP needs to ask, "why can't I afford to live?""

Because having a disabled child especially one who isn't at school is expensive?

And whilst I don't have an identical child, I have a disabled child. I help numerous people a week with disabled DC. This is not my first rodeo at these figures. I will have seen people in very similar situations to OP. Not identical but certainly not incomparable. With the equivalent of a £51,900 salary entitlement, and suggesting this isn't enough, exactly how much do you think OP should be given?

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 15:30

no work required

except caring 24/7 for a disabled child while also having another disabled child. It may not be paid for employment but it is still significant.

Unpaid carers save the state a fortune.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:30

UC calc, with zero childcare costs. Rent at £950, with LHA of £800.

Literally the only other thing I could have got wrong is your council tax at estimating band B. This won't make any notable difference if I've got it wrong though.

I hope you work out what the discrepancy is, as there may be something you're not claiming or something not calculated correctly, and we can help out this right, or at least understand why your claim is so much lower.

Poverty trap? What to do
Poverty trap? What to do
Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 15:30

Also I never said I can’t afford to live 🙈

OP posts:
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 15:29

@Duckingfun also, because DS can’t attend school but is eligible for FSMs, are you receiving FSM provision for him? If not, Contact has model letters you can use to request FSM provision.

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 15:29

which she hasn't earned anything to cover

your benefit bashing attitude when I work 24/7 caring for my disabled children makes me want to spend the rest of my life claiming benefits. It is not supportive, it is not kind and it is not helpful.

OP posts:
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 15:28

If you have a problem with Scope’s figure take it up with them. The figures they state are after disability benefits such as DLA. Anyone who disputes the figures is clearly ignorant to the costs many disabled households incur even if they themselves don’t have those costs.

TigerRag · 24/02/2024 15:28

"And it's looking at this £536 a week with no rent or mortgage that OP needs to ask, "why can't I afford to live?""

Because having a disabled child especially one who isn't at school is expensive?

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:23

So just to clarify, you want to ignore the £557 DLA she gets for having a disabled child whilst deducting an average amount given by a charity because she has a disabled child...

Or we could look at the actuals. Using your £2768, and the £557, she gets £3325. (Actually £100 more than the calculator suggests, but let's use the highest amount of rent too at £1000). So once you deduct the £1000 rent which she hasn't earned anything to cover, she has £2325 a month after housing costs. £536 a week to live on.

I think a lot of people, including those with disabled children would like £536 a week to live on, no work required. That £536 grosses up to £27900 a year. That's the equivalent of a salary of £34500. With no rent or mortgage.

To make it more comparable, you add back the rent, most people pay rent or a mortgage. £3325 take home. That's an equivalent salary of £51,900 a year. Do you think most people would be able to cope on £51,900 with £1000 a month rent to pay. I think most people would be delighted at that. Especially if they didn't actually have to work to receive that net amount in their bank. Many parents of disabled children have to work.

And it's looking at this £536 a week with no rent or mortgage that OP needs to ask, "why can't I afford to live?"

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 15:10

Your UC award may be lower if you have anything like paying back an advance or previous overpayment being deducted.

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 15:05

I wish it was that much. Dd gets free nursery hours. I will look at my uc

OP posts:
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 14:58

So OP’s total monthly income minus DLA which is for disability related expenses would be £2768.97 with £1k rent. If you minus rent that leaves £1768.97. If you then take off extra £1,122 Scope say is required on average by disabled households for the same standard of living as non-disabled households that leaves £646.97 for all other expenses (except some or all of council tax). Hardly rolling in it like some people think.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 14:52

So, now I've updated an est £950 rent (of which you get circa £800 paid) and DS correct DLA award, the figure jumps to £3220.

The only way we can be miles apart is through the nursery amount? Seriously OP, check your UC award, something isn't adding up.

Poverty trap? What to do
Poverty trap? What to do
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 14:49

OP, your UC claim should be as below. I have assumed you are over 25 and used £1k rent. You say it is slightly below that, just insert the actually amount. The housing element would be the full rent since council property unless there is a bedroom tax reduction to be made.

Standard allowance. £368.74
First child. £315
2nd child. £269.58
Severely disabled child element. £456.89
Carer element. £185.86
Housing element £1000
Total = £2596.07

Carer’s allowance is deducted £ for £. Currently that equates to £332.58 per month. Total UC minus this deduction = £2263.49 but then you get the equivalent deduction via CA albeit 4 weekly rather than monthly.

Child benefit - £39.90 per week - £172.90 per month

You will then be eligible for council tax support/reduction and a single person discount. This may be the full council tax amount or it may leave some to pay. It depends on area.

Single claimants on UC who are carers can’t claim childcare costs via UC. Households where one works and the other is a carer can, but a single carer can’t.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 14:47

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 14:41

Ds gets hrc and lrm and I don’t get anywhere near that much? I’ve done the entitled to calculation and it says I’d be better off working but not by much.

Ok, so line by line, check that calc I've done against your UC calc, and see where the differences lie. Because I've underestimated your DLA, so actually that should be an even higher figure.

The things I have guessed are rent at £1000, which should be under LHA and more like £950? And DD nursery I've put in at £500pcm. Is that far wrong?

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 14:41

Ds gets hrc and lrm and I don’t get anywhere near that much? I’ve done the entitled to calculation and it says I’d be better off working but not by much.

OP posts:
WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 14:40

Oh, is she not on LHA, sorry as you kept banging on about non LHA I didn't go back and check if that was her case. In which case, her award would be a little less.

But still looking forward to OP explaining how she's managing to claim full UC for her, two DC, double child benefit, best part of £1000 rent, carer's allowance, DLA, 85% of childcare costs, council tax reduction and all this to come absolutely nowhere near £3k a month. It should be £2,600 lowest estimate. And she's got two children that she should be receiving CMS for? I guess that's another story though.

Springpug · 24/02/2024 14:40

Op ,have you looked at a house swap
I'm sure there are websites where people who want to move ,swap housing association houses .. literally a straight swap.
It's just a thought
Apologies if you have already rules it out
I also think you should think about applying for DLA for your youngest
You can't claim carers allowance for two children,but you can claim DLA for two
I'd no idea Norfolk was so expensive,
Could you downsize,could you drop down a bedroom,take a house with a dinning room and use that as a bedroom,just thinking,like if your desperate to stay in same area

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 14:35

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 13:43

and with my 19hrs I'd take home over £4kp/mth of income and benefits as a single mother now. I think that worked out to virtually the same take home as someone on £70k a year.

oh how I wish I lived in your made up world 🙈

Are you saying that your UC for you and 2 children, DLA for one child, Housing paid, Council tax paid, Child benefit, Carer's Allowance, 85% childcare reimbursement is significantly less than £3k a month?

If yes, respectfully what the actual fuck are you doing?? It's not a made up world. At all. Why aren't you receiving it? Take the below figures (which should there or thereabouts be your figures) Add my £1000 income (and the fact I have a third child) would take me to just over £4k on that calculation. Not to mention any CMS I'd get on top of that.

Calculations attached. Childcare/nursery guessed at £500pcm. DLA guessed at zero mobility and mid rate care. Rent at £1000. Norfolk area.

So why are you not getting what the calculation says you should?

Poverty trap? What to do
Poverty trap? What to do
Swipe left for the next trending thread