Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Poverty trap? What to do

239 replies

Duckingfun · 23/02/2024 14:24

I’m on benefits due to having a disabled child who currently isn’t in school.
I want to work, when he’s at a suitable school I will be looking for work. However my rent has now increased in my council house to just under £1k there is no way I can afford it if I work. The better off website says I will be something like £90 a month better off, I want to work but I don’t want to work 40+ hours a week for £90 and then I’d be worse off after travel/childcare etc
Whats the answer? I can’t move and it just feels so unfair that the council raise the rent to the top limit of what they can.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 16:41

squashedalmondcroissant · 24/02/2024 16:36

Apologies I haven't had time to read the whole thread just yet but just going from my personal experience I'd be very wary of being totally reliant on benefits in the long term.

Obviously you are a bit stuck right now, which I completely understand, I know just how impossible it can be to get and keep employment when you are also the full time carer for disabled children. As soon as you are able to though I would do whatever you can to get back into work, even part time to keep your foot in the door, because one day your disabled children will be disabled adults and then (as far as I'm aware) any extra UC payments for this element will stop.

What you really don't want is to suddenly find a drop of several hundred ££ in your benefits entitlement and a 10 year gap in your CV which will make getting a job that much harder when you really need it.

This was exactly the position I found myself in!

The child element and severely disabled child element would cease when DC are no longer qualifying children or young people but when adults OP’s DC can apply for UC themselves if necessary or an appointee on their behalf can.

squashedalmondcroissant · 24/02/2024 16:36

Apologies I haven't had time to read the whole thread just yet but just going from my personal experience I'd be very wary of being totally reliant on benefits in the long term.

Obviously you are a bit stuck right now, which I completely understand, I know just how impossible it can be to get and keep employment when you are also the full time carer for disabled children. As soon as you are able to though I would do whatever you can to get back into work, even part time to keep your foot in the door, because one day your disabled children will be disabled adults and then (as far as I'm aware) any extra UC payments for this element will stop.

What you really don't want is to suddenly find a drop of several hundred ££ in your benefits entitlement and a 10 year gap in your CV which will make getting a job that much harder when you really need it.

This was exactly the position I found myself in!

Tahinii · 24/02/2024 16:35

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn why don’t you the OP of your charity so she can seek support? Appreciate you don’t want to publicise it on here.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 16:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 16:15

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 16:10

Did you miss the bit where I'm the mother of a disabled child. And also that child's carer. In the exact same location as OP. Oh, and work for a charity that helps people like OP, and those in general poverty, with food, fuel, children, housing, benefits, specifically in the Norfolk area.

Just because I'm calling OP out on things she's claiming she can't do (which I know can be done, having done those things multiple times a month with other people) she doesn't like it.

  1. your child isn’t with you 24/7
  2. your calculations are 30k off
  3. not many people can just move somewhere else
  4. your ‘help’ is in trying to bring someone down who is worried about going to work and being able to afford a high rent
there has been helpful posters, you’re not one of them
OP posts:
Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 16:12

BouncingJAS · 24/02/2024 16:09

I have paid more in UK tax in the last 10 years than all of you combined.

And thats me being generous.

Than all of us combined 😂😂 I hope if you ever have a disabled child you’ll continue to work full time (with the child by your side - no excuses!) and not claim anything.

OP posts:
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 16:12

It is amazing someone who supports parents with disabled DC doesn’t know the UC childcare element isn’t available to single carers. Or that the LHA doesn’t apply to council tenants. Or that there are many medically complex DC in schools. Or that many carers can’t work and it isn’t a choice for many. Or a SS without an EHCP is extremely rare in the current climate, it just doesn’t happen in OP’s situation. Or that EOTAS and s19 provision are not in effect homeschooling. Or that there are thousands of DC out of school across the country, including in Norfolk - on the 2nd Aug 2023 a FOI showed there were, at that time, 349 DC in Norfolk with EHCPs without a school placement, some of those will have EOTAS but by no means the majority or even half.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 16:10

OriginalUsername2 · 24/02/2024 15:59

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn You’re being unreasonable. The thread had decent advice until you joined and started pecking.

Those on their high horses clearly have no mental ability to imagine the work that goes into being a carer for a disabled child and how exhausting everyday existence will be for her.

Did you miss the bit where I'm the mother of a disabled child. And also that child's carer. In the exact same location as OP. Oh, and work for a charity that helps people like OP, and those in general poverty, with food, fuel, children, housing, benefits, specifically in the Norfolk area.

Just because I'm calling OP out on things she's claiming she can't do (which I know can be done, having done those things multiple times a month with other people) she doesn't like it.

Tahinii · 24/02/2024 16:10

BouncingJAS · 24/02/2024 16:09

I have paid more in UK tax in the last 10 years than all of you combined.

And thats me being generous.

Please prove it.

Sincerely,
the King of England

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 16:10

In future if you want advice on SEN matters, the SN boards are friendly with posters who understand.

BouncingJAS · 24/02/2024 16:09

Tahinii · 24/02/2024 16:08

@BouncingJAS for how many years have you been a U.K. tax payer?

I have paid more in UK tax in the last 10 years than all of you combined.

And thats me being generous.

Tahinii · 24/02/2024 16:08

@BouncingJAS for how many years have you been a U.K. tax payer?

TigerRag · 24/02/2024 16:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The OP is saving the state thousands a year by giving up paid employment and being a carer

Tahinii · 24/02/2024 16:07

I cannot imagine working in the field with individuals who have vulnerabilities, acting like the big “I am” online with all my experience with such a lack of basic compassion and empathy.

@Duckingfun I have worked in the field for a lot longer and I do appreciate the difficulties you face. I do not think you sound like you don’t want to work, I think you are beginning to look and worrying. You’ve had some excellent advice so I won’t repeated it. I would strongly encourage you to get a proper benefits check from Citizens Advice. Those online calculators are not always accurate. Your local area will have a carers organisation, so please contact them. They will have specific targeted support to assist carers into education and employment.
You are a strong, capable woman who has survived domestic violence and you’re single handedly raising 2 children with additional needs. I’m sure you have plenty to offer the workforce so I hope you can find a way to balance it all.

BouncingJAS · 24/02/2024 16:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 16:05

To the posters with empathy and understanding thank you, I will look into training so that I can hopefully go into employment with better earning potential. I think this is definitely going the way of snotty people complaining about the welfare system unfortunately but thank you for the advice.

OP posts:
Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 16:01

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:46

OP I'm not sure why you are so determined to insist a benefits calculator, with little wiggle room for error, is "made up."

The benefits you are entitled too, given the figures above, equate to a £51,900 salary. Again, that is fact. Not a fancy story. It's maths.

I literally work, housing people with Norfolk CC, and again, you are insistent you can not move. You live in Norfolk. Factually you can. There are many hospitals in Norfolk offering excellent provisions and so many cheap areas. Claiming you'd be too far from a hospital is quite odd because you can't be far from anything ok Norfolk really, it's not huge, you can drive from furthest point to furthest point in under 1.5hrs, so when you factor in the many hospitals within that total distance, you should always be within 20 mins or so of one. Dereham, anywhere in the Fens, Brandon (technically Suffolk) Thetford, Swaffham, Kings Lynn. In fact, unless you're trying to live in Holy/North Norfolk coast, or central Norwich, there aren't many places that aren't cheap because essentially Norfolk is the buttcrack of nowhere. Beautiful, but definitely cheap, and even in Norwich there are estates which you can live on well under your rental limit. You just don't want too.

Ok, I’ll tell UC that some rando on the internet says I should be getting more than twice as much as I do. I’m sure they’ll listen.
I don’t drive and would move tomorrow if I could.

@Iloveblink182 they will cover it, I’m more worried about when I do work how I would pay it.

@BouncingJAS carer for 2 disabled children wants to go to work but is worried because of rent cost. Obviously that translates into I don’t want to work. Even though I don’t have to and have said I want to but carry on, maybe you and @WillYouPutYourCoatOn can live together in your benefit bashing fantasy land.

OP posts:
BouncingJAS · 24/02/2024 16:01

OriginalUsername2 · 24/02/2024 15:59

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn You’re being unreasonable. The thread had decent advice until you joined and started pecking.

Those on their high horses clearly have no mental ability to imagine the work that goes into being a carer for a disabled child and how exhausting everyday existence will be for her.

None of that is relevant.

The "woe is me" stories on here are completely out of control.

What is relevant is her financial situation. Leave the martyr stories at the door.

OriginalUsername2 · 24/02/2024 15:59

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn You’re being unreasonable. The thread had decent advice until you joined and started pecking.

Those on their high horses clearly have no mental ability to imagine the work that goes into being a carer for a disabled child and how exhausting everyday existence will be for her.

feellikeanalien · 24/02/2024 15:59

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:46

OP I'm not sure why you are so determined to insist a benefits calculator, with little wiggle room for error, is "made up."

The benefits you are entitled too, given the figures above, equate to a £51,900 salary. Again, that is fact. Not a fancy story. It's maths.

I literally work, housing people with Norfolk CC, and again, you are insistent you can not move. You live in Norfolk. Factually you can. There are many hospitals in Norfolk offering excellent provisions and so many cheap areas. Claiming you'd be too far from a hospital is quite odd because you can't be far from anything ok Norfolk really, it's not huge, you can drive from furthest point to furthest point in under 1.5hrs, so when you factor in the many hospitals within that total distance, you should always be within 20 mins or so of one. Dereham, anywhere in the Fens, Brandon (technically Suffolk) Thetford, Swaffham, Kings Lynn. In fact, unless you're trying to live in Holy/North Norfolk coast, or central Norwich, there aren't many places that aren't cheap because essentially Norfolk is the buttcrack of nowhere. Beautiful, but definitely cheap, and even in Norwich there are estates which you can live on well under your rental limit. You just don't want too.

Perhaps the OP would prefer to have security of tenure rather than being at the mercy of the private rental market where she and her children could be evicted at any time. She would also need to find a landlord who would be prepared to accept a single mother on benefits. Rarer than hens teeth these days.

Overtheatlantic · 24/02/2024 15:59

I don’t have anything to add, just that I wish you all the best in sorting this out. 💐

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 15:55

She wants to be subsudised so that she lives in comfort.

And yet disabled households are more likely to live in poverty.

Iloveblink182 · 24/02/2024 15:54

Surely your UC is going to adjust to rental increase though? I thought council were only allowed to charge what the maximum LHA is? Once you report the change the rent component on your UC will be upped unless you have been placed in a property that is bigger than your bedroom allowance?

BouncingJAS · 24/02/2024 15:51

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:46

OP I'm not sure why you are so determined to insist a benefits calculator, with little wiggle room for error, is "made up."

The benefits you are entitled too, given the figures above, equate to a £51,900 salary. Again, that is fact. Not a fancy story. It's maths.

I literally work, housing people with Norfolk CC, and again, you are insistent you can not move. You live in Norfolk. Factually you can. There are many hospitals in Norfolk offering excellent provisions and so many cheap areas. Claiming you'd be too far from a hospital is quite odd because you can't be far from anything ok Norfolk really, it's not huge, you can drive from furthest point to furthest point in under 1.5hrs, so when you factor in the many hospitals within that total distance, you should always be within 20 mins or so of one. Dereham, anywhere in the Fens, Brandon (technically Suffolk) Thetford, Swaffham, Kings Lynn. In fact, unless you're trying to live in Holy/North Norfolk coast, or central Norwich, there aren't many places that aren't cheap because essentially Norfolk is the buttcrack of nowhere. Beautiful, but definitely cheap, and even in Norwich there are estates which you can live on well under your rental limit. You just don't want too.

I have read the whole thread and you are wasting your time.

She doesn't want to work. She wants to be subsudised so that she lives in comfort.

Thats what it comes back to every time.

Your points in this thread have been spot on. She is not looking for solutions.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:46

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 15:37

It’s interesting seeing your made up story of my mildly disabled children and 50k+ a year.
However that is not the case at all. It would be nice if you stopped making up scenarios in your head.
I CANNOT currently work. Doesn’t matter what you say, it’s impossible. I am trying to go back to work in the future when ds is in a suitable school. I CAN afford to live BUT if I work and lose benefits I wouldn’t be able to afford the rent in the house that I was given (again I didn’t choose this area) unless my wage was majorly topped up by uc. what you are saying is pointless and irrelevant to my situation.

OP I'm not sure why you are so determined to insist a benefits calculator, with little wiggle room for error, is "made up."

The benefits you are entitled too, given the figures above, equate to a £51,900 salary. Again, that is fact. Not a fancy story. It's maths.

I literally work, housing people with Norfolk CC, and again, you are insistent you can not move. You live in Norfolk. Factually you can. There are many hospitals in Norfolk offering excellent provisions and so many cheap areas. Claiming you'd be too far from a hospital is quite odd because you can't be far from anything ok Norfolk really, it's not huge, you can drive from furthest point to furthest point in under 1.5hrs, so when you factor in the many hospitals within that total distance, you should always be within 20 mins or so of one. Dereham, anywhere in the Fens, Brandon (technically Suffolk) Thetford, Swaffham, Kings Lynn. In fact, unless you're trying to live in Holy/North Norfolk coast, or central Norwich, there aren't many places that aren't cheap because essentially Norfolk is the buttcrack of nowhere. Beautiful, but definitely cheap, and even in Norwich there are estates which you can live on well under your rental limit. You just don't want too.