Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Poverty trap? What to do

239 replies

Duckingfun · 23/02/2024 14:24

I’m on benefits due to having a disabled child who currently isn’t in school.
I want to work, when he’s at a suitable school I will be looking for work. However my rent has now increased in my council house to just under £1k there is no way I can afford it if I work. The better off website says I will be something like £90 a month better off, I want to work but I don’t want to work 40+ hours a week for £90 and then I’d be worse off after travel/childcare etc
Whats the answer? I can’t move and it just feels so unfair that the council raise the rent to the top limit of what they can.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 17:51

PringPring · 24/02/2024 17:48

You think I should call the DWP up and tell them they're calculating wrong?! So same as the op. Yes. I'm sure we'll get right on that. First thing Monday morning.

Excuse me UC worker, some random on the internet is insistent I should be raking in cash and I'm not. I insist you recalculate immediately! 🙄

I can't speak for op but in my area we have a carers support service who offer to go through your benefits and check it's all okay, which I have done.

You're clearly very set on how parents of disabled children are living. Raking in money, and being lazy not trying hard enough to get our kids to special school. 🙄🙄🙄

Good luck to the families you work with.

Could you imagine actually getting £50k+ a year!

OP posts:
Lwrenn · 24/02/2024 17:49

@BouncingJAS more than us on this thread or the entirety of mumsnet?

PringPring · 24/02/2024 17:48

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 17:40

I haven't quoted anything. It's the government benefits calculator. Why don't you tell them there wrong.

You think I should call the DWP up and tell them they're calculating wrong?! So same as the op. Yes. I'm sure we'll get right on that. First thing Monday morning.

Excuse me UC worker, some random on the internet is insistent I should be raking in cash and I'm not. I insist you recalculate immediately! 🙄

I can't speak for op but in my area we have a carers support service who offer to go through your benefits and check it's all okay, which I have done.

You're clearly very set on how parents of disabled children are living. Raking in money, and being lazy not trying hard enough to get our kids to special school. 🙄🙄🙄

Good luck to the families you work with.

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 17:46

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 17:43

Again, I didn’t have to retract anything. In the current climate it is rare (unicorn rare) to get a SS placement without an EHCP in the OP’s situation. It just doesn’t happen. Even with an EHCP many have to appeal.

Edited

Don’t worry, I think everyone with a child in ss knows you need an ehcp.

@PringPring thank you, I’m definitely going to look at any training I can do. My only qualifications is in childcare and sen but I need a break from that kind of work 🙈

OP posts:
SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 17:43

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 17:42

You're amazed at a lot for someone who works in SEN declared a child "clearly" had to have an EHCP for SS... And then had to retract that...

Again, I didn’t have to retract anything. In the current climate it is rare (unicorn rare) to get a SS placement without an EHCP in the OP’s situation. It just doesn’t happen. Even with an EHCP many have to appeal.

PringPring · 24/02/2024 17:43

OP I think retraining if you can is probably the best plan of action. That's what I'm going to do. I also have an older and you get child, on my own, eldest has sen. When eldest is big I'm hoping he may be a wee bit more independent and I can work at least part time out of the home. Fingers crossed.

I hope your consultations with the new school go well. My son missed a chunk of secondary school while there was no suitable place for him and it was a huge strain for us all. The battle to find a suitable place for him took a real toll on me (my finances, relationship, physical and mental health etc). I don't think people realise how hard it can be to find a suitable placement for a child with complex sen.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 17:42

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 17:40

I also do this day in, day out across the country and have done for years. I can categorically tell you it doesn’t work like that for many. If it did there wouldn’t be as many SENDIST cases as there is and there wouldn’t be such a demand for PAP letters and JR proceedings. As I posted, there is a rapidly growing number of children for whom there is no suitable school.

Nowhere have I said OP is an “unhelpable” case. Absolutely nowhere. I have posted many suggestions of ways forward. None of them include the disdain and judgement your posts do.

For her child (who has already attended school) to be unplaceable would be more unlikely. The only times we see this become an issue is when one (or even two/three) placements are found and the parent will still be insisting that it's not good enough for their child, whilst declaring the council is doing nothing to school their child.

This shows such a lack of knowledge and understanding. Most DC with EOTAS (i.e. they meet the legal threshold for it to be inappropriate for the provision to be made in a school) have previously attended a school. Many parents disagree with the LA about what SEP is reasonably required and what placement (or otherwise) is suitable and are forced to appeal where more than 98% of them are proven correct.

I am amazed someone who is providing financial advice has a limited grasp of UC housing and childcare elements.

You're amazed at a lot for someone who works in SEN declared a child "clearly" had to have an EHCP for SS... And then had to retract that...

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 17:41

TigerRag · 24/02/2024 17:36

For many it's a contribution and doesn't come close to the extra costs of being disabled

This. Those that don’t understand clearly don’t have a disabled child/ren with significant additional costs.

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 17:40

I also do this day in, day out across the country and have done for years. I can categorically tell you it doesn’t work like that for many. If it did there wouldn’t be as many SENDIST cases as there is and there wouldn’t be such a demand for PAP letters and JR proceedings. As I posted, there is a rapidly growing number of children for whom there is no suitable school.

Nowhere have I said OP is an “unhelpable” case. Absolutely nowhere. I have posted many suggestions of ways forward. None of them include the disdain and judgement your posts do.

For her child (who has already attended school) to be unplaceable would be more unlikely. The only times we see this become an issue is when one (or even two/three) placements are found and the parent will still be insisting that it's not good enough for their child, whilst declaring the council is doing nothing to school their child.

This shows such a lack of knowledge and understanding. Most DC with EOTAS (i.e. they meet the legal threshold for it to be inappropriate for the provision to be made in a school) have previously attended a school. Many parents disagree with the LA about what SEP is reasonably required and what placement (or otherwise) is suitable and are forced to appeal where more than 98% of them are proven correct.

I am amazed someone who is providing financial advice has a limited grasp of UC housing and childcare elements.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 17:40

PringPring · 24/02/2024 17:39

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn bloody hell! Wind your neck in. 🙄 I'm not sure why you're gunning for OP so much but it's completely unnecessary.

She doesn't have to give you a breakdown of her finances. As someone with a very similar family situation to the op I could only dream of being on the income figures you have quoted here.

Telling her to just keep on at the LA to get her eldest into school is embarrassing. You've no idea of the ins and outs of the situation.

I'm cringing reading your posts. Cringing.

I haven't quoted anything. It's the government benefits calculator. Why don't you tell them there wrong.

PringPring · 24/02/2024 17:39

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn bloody hell! Wind your neck in. 🙄 I'm not sure why you're gunning for OP so much but it's completely unnecessary.

She doesn't have to give you a breakdown of her finances. As someone with a very similar family situation to the op I could only dream of being on the income figures you have quoted here.

Telling her to just keep on at the LA to get her eldest into school is embarrassing. You've no idea of the ins and outs of the situation.

I'm cringing reading your posts. Cringing.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 17:39

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 17:36

You just live in your own little world don’t you. Because I’ve not been on my knees in gratitude for your frankly useless advice I must be a certain type of person? Urgh do us all a favour and stop posting please.

Um, because you're ignoring basic legal entitlements and maths. Or not giving the full story. Two of us have done the calcs on the information you've given. A third from DWP told you that your claim to be only £90 better off was wrong as well.

Zero to do with gratitude.

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 17:38

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 17:17

If you bothered to read the OP’s posts you will see she posted “There’s a new school recently opened, very tiny and unique and seems perfect for ds so we’re consulting with them along with around 10 others. We were refused a place at every mainstream/special/private school in 3 counties”

Consulting has a specific legal meaning in EHCP terms (it isn’t just the parent calling/emailing or even visiting) and consultations are via the LA.

It's not impossible.

For some, it is. There is a rapidly growing number for whom there is no suitable school and who require bespoke EOTAS packages (which may not look like anything anyone else has in the LA because they are bespoke) which often takes an appeal, which OP can’t do yet, especially for a good package. Brilliant for the example you gave. Doesn’t and can’t work like that for many.

Edited

Thank you, I’ve been fighting for a school place (any school place!) for years. Some people are just unpleasant and like to patronise and belittle others.
I’m going to take on board the actual decent advice.
I can’t believe a thread about my wanting to work but worrying about the high rent has turned into this absolute farce 😂

OP posts:
TigerRag · 24/02/2024 17:36

Babyroobs · 24/02/2024 17:35

Good point about the DLA - it absolutely is for the additional cost of a disability. Not sure how scope come up with these figures.
It's a large amount to be getting.

For many it's a contribution and doesn't come close to the extra costs of being disabled

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 17:36

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 17:31

Brilliant for the example you gave. Doesn’t and can’t work like that for many.

Except it also does and can work like that for many. Because that's what my colleague does. (I'm more finance/volunteers, she's more housing/children but we overlap a lot). And we di this specifically in Norfolk. With many parents. Why are you so determined for OP to be such an "unhelpable" case? It's equally likely she's no different to many of the parents we see. For her child (who has already attended school) to be unplaceable would be more unlikely. The only times we see this become an issue is when one (or even two/three) placements are found and the parent will still be insisting that it's not good enough for their child, whilst declaring the council is doing nothing to school their child. Now, given what I've read, that I can believe.

You just live in your own little world don’t you. Because I’ve not been on my knees in gratitude for your frankly useless advice I must be a certain type of person? Urgh do us all a favour and stop posting please.

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 24/02/2024 17:35

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 15:23

So just to clarify, you want to ignore the £557 DLA she gets for having a disabled child whilst deducting an average amount given by a charity because she has a disabled child...

Or we could look at the actuals. Using your £2768, and the £557, she gets £3325. (Actually £100 more than the calculator suggests, but let's use the highest amount of rent too at £1000). So once you deduct the £1000 rent which she hasn't earned anything to cover, she has £2325 a month after housing costs. £536 a week to live on.

I think a lot of people, including those with disabled children would like £536 a week to live on, no work required. That £536 grosses up to £27900 a year. That's the equivalent of a salary of £34500. With no rent or mortgage.

To make it more comparable, you add back the rent, most people pay rent or a mortgage. £3325 take home. That's an equivalent salary of £51,900 a year. Do you think most people would be able to cope on £51,900 with £1000 a month rent to pay. I think most people would be delighted at that. Especially if they didn't actually have to work to receive that net amount in their bank. Many parents of disabled children have to work.

And it's looking at this £536 a week with no rent or mortgage that OP needs to ask, "why can't I afford to live?"

Good point about the DLA - it absolutely is for the additional cost of a disability. Not sure how scope come up with these figures.
It's a large amount to be getting.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 17:31

Brilliant for the example you gave. Doesn’t and can’t work like that for many.

Except it also does and can work like that for many. Because that's what my colleague does. (I'm more finance/volunteers, she's more housing/children but we overlap a lot). And we di this specifically in Norfolk. With many parents. Why are you so determined for OP to be such an "unhelpable" case? It's equally likely she's no different to many of the parents we see. For her child (who has already attended school) to be unplaceable would be more unlikely. The only times we see this become an issue is when one (or even two/three) placements are found and the parent will still be insisting that it's not good enough for their child, whilst declaring the council is doing nothing to school their child. Now, given what I've read, that I can believe.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 17:18

Tahinii · 24/02/2024 17:02

I thought the charity offered more than just benefit advice. It could afford OP the opportunity to speak to someone empathetic and really improve her life.

I would never ever say “what’s the point?”. People change in their mindset. I’d want to offer the help. She’s in your area. It sounds a fantastic service. Even if there is a 0.1% chance, I would want to help someone.

We offer food support. Benefit support. Fuel support. Children related support. College courses. Volunteer opportunity. Housing assistance. Funding assistance. Meetings with both local and county councillors. SEN support. Mental health support.

We are all very good at what we do. We are a tiny team with an enormous outreach. We have a great deal of empathy, knowledge, and resources. However, is it not "lacking in empathy" to recognise someone who just wants to vent with no real intention of helping themselves. One of the key things is you quickly notice things just not adding up in their stories. And I would say a good 30% of people who come in to us, fit this criteria. The people who genuinely want to sort their finances/lives out, we can literally turn their lives around. However we have to get quickly attuned to those who are just looking to vent, but don't accept the effort they need to put into the solution. Because it's a waste of our time putting resources this way, when we have so many genuine people to help. It would be lovely to be a listening ear to everyone regardless. There are helplines people can call, when they just want to vent but take no action to change the problem.

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 17:17

If you bothered to read the OP’s posts you will see she posted “There’s a new school recently opened, very tiny and unique and seems perfect for ds so we’re consulting with them along with around 10 others. We were refused a place at every mainstream/special/private school in 3 counties”

Consulting has a specific legal meaning in EHCP terms (it isn’t just the parent calling/emailing or even visiting) and consultations are via the LA.

It's not impossible.

For some, it is. There is a rapidly growing number for whom there is no suitable school and who require bespoke EOTAS packages (which may not look like anything anyone else has in the LA because they are bespoke) which often takes an appeal, which OP can’t do yet, especially for a good package. Brilliant for the example you gave. Doesn’t and can’t work like that for many.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 17:08

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 16:52

Neither would yours be, just he wasn't like before, if you sorted out the school provision and kept on at the LA.

Neither JR and/or SENDIST solve the issue here and now. OP is working towards a school placement, another consultation has gone out.

She's in talks with a newly opening SS, yes? Was that via LA recommendation or consultant or just OP making phonecalls, did she say? I think I know which one that must be (well, one of two, but I'm leaning towards one in particular as she says he has been refused a school in the last 3 counties so I'm guessing extreme behavioural difficulties, might be wrong). If that is the case, there's a SS about two minutes from my work which is for children with these needs... but most parents refuse a place from the start because inherently the other children there are quite extreme.

One woman in particular I've helped was housed in Norfolk after fleeing previous county due to DV. She has 4DC. One extreme additional needs, EHCP, SS. She was initially in emergency accommodation and has been housed on a really nice local estate. She arrived in mid Nov. It took NCC 5 weeks to sort out his new SS placement. The best school for him is actually 20 miles away and he has a paid taxi taking him too and from there daily. It's not impossible. And yes, yes, every child is different, but OP's situation won't be so different to anything ever seen before. We cover 3000 people in the immediate area.

Tahinii · 24/02/2024 17:02

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 16:50

Whatever is the point.

I can only tell her what I (and others) have on this thread. It helps hundreds that come through our doors each year.

According to OP it's all fantasy.

I thought the charity offered more than just benefit advice. It could afford OP the opportunity to speak to someone empathetic and really improve her life.

I would never ever say “what’s the point?”. People change in their mindset. I’d want to offer the help. She’s in your area. It sounds a fantastic service. Even if there is a 0.1% chance, I would want to help someone.

SearchingForSolitude · 24/02/2024 16:52

Neither would yours be, just he wasn't like before, if you sorted out the school provision and kept on at the LA.

Neither JR and/or SENDIST solve the issue here and now. OP is working towards a school placement, another consultation has gone out.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 16:51

squashedalmondcroissant · 24/02/2024 16:36

Apologies I haven't had time to read the whole thread just yet but just going from my personal experience I'd be very wary of being totally reliant on benefits in the long term.

Obviously you are a bit stuck right now, which I completely understand, I know just how impossible it can be to get and keep employment when you are also the full time carer for disabled children. As soon as you are able to though I would do whatever you can to get back into work, even part time to keep your foot in the door, because one day your disabled children will be disabled adults and then (as far as I'm aware) any extra UC payments for this element will stop.

What you really don't want is to suddenly find a drop of several hundred ££ in your benefits entitlement and a 10 year gap in your CV which will make getting a job that much harder when you really need it.

This was exactly the position I found myself in!

I had thought about that, but I imagine as DS hits 16, will be when OP does a claim for DD, so she's got another 10yrs or so of the same.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 16:50

Tahinii · 24/02/2024 16:35

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn why don’t you the OP of your charity so she can seek support? Appreciate you don’t want to publicise it on here.

Whatever is the point.

I can only tell her what I (and others) have on this thread. It helps hundreds that come through our doors each year.

According to OP it's all fantasy.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 24/02/2024 16:47

Duckingfun · 24/02/2024 16:15

  1. your child isn’t with you 24/7
  2. your calculations are 30k off
  3. not many people can just move somewhere else
  4. your ‘help’ is in trying to bring someone down who is worried about going to work and being able to afford a high rent
there has been helpful posters, you’re not one of them

your child isn’t with you 24/7

Neither would yours be, just he wasn't like before, if you sorted out the school provision and kept on at the LA.

your calculations are 30k off

You are failing to provide the information to explain why the figures are £30k off. Because the situation you are putting forward, two of us have done the calcs and you are not providing the full story somewhere, because those are the results on the information you've given in this thread.

not many people can just move somewhere else

Loads can, and do. I see this weekly.

your ‘help’ is in trying to bring someone down who is worried about going to work and being able to afford a high rent

Pointing out that you are not correct because I happen to do the exact job that deals with these kind of situations in the exact location you live is not "bringing you down" and it's disingenuous to play that card. You aren't correct. It's simply that. Whether that be through genuinely believing certain things and never properly checking them, or otherwise. I've shown you specifically how easy it is to work around that. I've given you the name of the fund to apply to specifically in Norfolk who will sort your deposit and moving costs. You just do your weird "fantasy land" speech. You're literally being spoon fed the solution. All you have is non obstacles as a response.

Swipe left for the next trending thread