Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys dominating the playground

211 replies

Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 12:02

I’ve noticed at DD’s school the enclosed, paved playground is quite dominated by boys playing their (rough!) games in the middle. Meanwhile the girls mill around the edges, seemingly a bit nervous to even cross it, let alone join in. I’ve noticed the boys also seem to feel more ‘entitled’ to play equipment as well as the playground space and will be quite rough and jostle past if a girl tries to play on it.

Do you think playgrounds should be halved, not to segregate by sex (and both sexes should be encouraged to join in any game they want) but to save some space for children who want to play less physical/rough games?

Feel free to tell me I’m being precious! (I have a son as well, not smug girl mum complaining about boys, but he’s only 1!).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
girlwhowearsglasses · 23/02/2024 15:12

Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 12:02

I’ve noticed at DD’s school the enclosed, paved playground is quite dominated by boys playing their (rough!) games in the middle. Meanwhile the girls mill around the edges, seemingly a bit nervous to even cross it, let alone join in. I’ve noticed the boys also seem to feel more ‘entitled’ to play equipment as well as the playground space and will be quite rough and jostle past if a girl tries to play on it.

Do you think playgrounds should be halved, not to segregate by sex (and both sexes should be encouraged to join in any game they want) but to save some space for children who want to play less physical/rough games?

Feel free to tell me I’m being precious! (I have a son as well, not smug girl mum complaining about boys, but he’s only 1!).

You’re not being precious- welcome to playground life. I really think schools need to up their game on ensuring everyone gets a chance to play. And I say that as a parent of 2 boys.

I really like the charity ‘make space for girls’ - they’ve done loads of research into this and have lots of advice for schools and leisure services. It’s all about design.

wiltonian · 23/02/2024 15:12

Completely agree with @Snarffaluffagus that OPAL are the people to speak to here. They are brilliant at helping schools create playgrounds where everyone is active, not just the boys. As they say, there are fourteen different kinds of play, why does school space prioritise just one, locomotive play?

I saw the most depressing but evocative graphic on this a few weeks ago - from a group who'd been studying use of space in a primary school in Spain.

As the tweet says - girls are literally marginalised.

https://x.com/MakeSpaceforGi1/status/1753033693021544784?s=20

But why this matters is that by the end of primary school, girls learn this as a life lesson - space isn't theirs. So they stay at home in their bedrooms.

Boys dominating the playground
GrumpyPanda · 23/02/2024 15:10

ichundich · 23/02/2024 12:29

The thing is though that most boys need the opportunity to play physical games between lessons; they tend to have a lot more excess energy than girls. I'm a parent reader, and some of the boys are so fidgety! Whereas a lot of girls prefer chatting, climbing, cartwheels etc., which require less space. And boys are being demonised; they get told off for just being alive it seems, just because they have a lesser tendency to sit still and draw nicely for hours.

Q.E.D.

twoshedsjackson · 23/02/2024 15:05

Some time ago, I taught in a school which reorganised its playground because of this issue; it had been ongoing for some time, but crystallised when one teacher reported to a Staff Meeting that when she had been on playground duty, one of the boys had called her over to assist him in clearing some of the more assertive girls out of the way of the customary football match which occupied the whole of one playground (one behind the building, one in front). In his eyes, this was the natural way of things, and she, as a mere female, albeit adult, was there to assist in the proper running of the status quo.
Solutions included providing more possibilities for other activities, making it clearer that some areas were for quieter activities, and encouraging the lunchtime assistants to initiate other pastimes, as well as providing seated areas; at that time, the LA actually funded training courses for running playtime supervision.
Of course, training, staffing and equipment all have budgetary implications, which may well be an issue.

outdooryone · 23/02/2024 15:03

As others are linking too, look at Make Space for Girls, but also the national school grounds charity called learning through landscape - https://ltl.org.uk/ as they can help with all sorts of advice, ideas and some training for the school staff.

Outdoor Learning and Play Charity | Learning through Landscapes

Learning through Landscapes is the leading UK charity dedicated to outdoor learning and play for children across the world.

https://ltl.org.uk

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 23/02/2024 15:02

MarnieMarnie · 23/02/2024 12:11

It's another reason that I think all schools should be single sex. Girls have much much better outcomes in all girls schools. This insidious expectation that they need to relinquish any shared space or area to boys is part of the reason girls to less well in co-ed schools.

Edited

Good God no!

I went to a single sex school for a while. The girls did not see boys as peers, colleagues or friends. Just as potential partners.

Shudders.

Hardbackwriter · 23/02/2024 14:46

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 23/02/2024 13:36

Oooh please no. How do we expect men and women to co-exist post school if they don’t learn to co-exist during school. I went to a single sex school and it did nothing at all to prepare you for a world where the other sex exists.

I went to a girls' school and we all seem to co-exist just fine with men as adults!

I think this is a fair thing to bring up with the school- it might also be worth discussing with the PTA? Ours quite often puts money into playground equipment and it might be that some thought could go into purchases that could change the use of the space a bit.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 23/02/2024 14:40

Many countries have lower divorce rates and arranged marriage - it’s not always that comparable as you say, other cultural factors are at play.

In my all-male school, the main part of the playground was also dominated by ball games and the more physical boys. Quieter boys were around the edges or like me spent playtimes in the DT rooms or library. I got all my homework done during breaks so my evenings were free.

milveycrohn · 23/02/2024 14:39

When I was at school, many many years ago the playgroung was divided into 2.
The boys (age 7-11) had one side as their playground.
The other side of the playground was divided into mixed infants (5-7 years), and girls (7-11).
Theoretically, it would seem that the boys had more space, but the school did not sit squarely within the plot, and I would not necessarily say that was the case. It was definitey the case that the boys tended to play more physical games, whereas the girls played more skipping, etc kind of games (a rope between several girls kind of thing).
I will say it was a large playground, but as the school has expanded, I have noted that first additional huts were placed in the playground, which later became proper extensions.
However, I note that these days school playgrounds (such as where my DGC attend) have far more things to do, whereas when my DC were at school (and myself), it was just a playground.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/02/2024 14:38

DarkAcademia · 23/02/2024 14:33

That might be your personal experience, but many countries, including my own, have single sex education as the norm, outperform the (normally mixed) U.K. for education (although to be fair that is a systemic problem deeper than mixed/single sex schools), and still have normal coexistence between the sexes when we all go to university/work.

What country are you from, out of interest?

DarkAcademia · 23/02/2024 14:33

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 23/02/2024 13:36

Oooh please no. How do we expect men and women to co-exist post school if they don’t learn to co-exist during school. I went to a single sex school and it did nothing at all to prepare you for a world where the other sex exists.

That might be your personal experience, but many countries, including my own, have single sex education as the norm, outperform the (normally mixed) U.K. for education (although to be fair that is a systemic problem deeper than mixed/single sex schools), and still have normal coexistence between the sexes when we all go to university/work.

DarkAcademia · 23/02/2024 14:23

MarnieMarnie · 23/02/2024 12:11

It's another reason that I think all schools should be single sex. Girls have much much better outcomes in all girls schools. This insidious expectation that they need to relinquish any shared space or area to boys is part of the reason girls to less well in co-ed schools.

Edited

100%. Both my girls enjoy sport and PE immeasurably more since moving from mixed sex primary to single sex secondary for this reason. I had constant complaints from them that the boys simply refused to ever pass to the girls (even ones who were bigger than them!), and the contract PE staff were utterly useless, and did nothing about the girls gradually drawing back.

Now both enjoy netball, football and hockey and play away games, and happily join the sports clubs at school, so it was nothing to do with them being less sporty, and everything to do with playing mixed sex sports without adequately trained or competent sports teachers. I have no idea how this is managed or segregated in mixed secondaries (presumably they are split up?) but the socialising damage has already been done for many girls (and boys).

This gender role “training” absolutely carries over into the classroom. (And equally disadvantages boys who would like to do well in art, drama and music - all subjects that boys do very well in at single sex schools, but less well in at mixed sex schools).

You can hammer away at the school, @Namechangeforthiss but unless you take a very active role in how playground supervision and PE are trained for and managed (and teachers have a thankless and stressful enough time if it as it is, so don’t expect to be welcomed with open arms), nothing will change.

SusieSussex · 23/02/2024 14:20

You're not in any way unreasonable to think that girls shouldn't be jostled out the way if they attempt to use the play equipment or hemmed in at the edges of the playground. Definitely worth mentioning.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/02/2024 14:19

AbsentCause · 23/02/2024 13:00

Is football causing the issue? I found this a really interesting read on footballing boys dominating space in primary school playgrounds - it’s ethnographic research done in two London primary schools.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/248975381_'Why_can't_girls_play_football'_Gender_dynamics_and_the_playground

Thanks for posting that - it is really interesting. I would say it is thankfully outdated now, certainly in terms of how primary school playgrounds in London are managed, and I certainly have no difficulty imagining the girls in my son's school bringing in awards won on the weekend and getting them announced at assembly. I suppose things gradually improve!

2mummies1baby · 23/02/2024 14:13

OP, how and when have you seen this happening?

JSMill · 23/02/2024 14:13

That sounds pretty much like the situation we had in the school I work in. The boys were dominating the playground with football and the girls milled around the edges. We divided the playground in half, one for ball games and the other for skipping, hoops etc. We also provided opportunities for quiet play like board games and drawing in our gazebo. It is a constant battle to stop certain 'strong' characters taking over. I would say something to the school but it's disappointing they haven't noticed themselves.

MarnieMarnie · 23/02/2024 14:05

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 23/02/2024 13:36

Oooh please no. How do we expect men and women to co-exist post school if they don’t learn to co-exist during school. I went to a single sex school and it did nothing at all to prepare you for a world where the other sex exists.

And yet I went to a series of co-eds and struggled since with all relationships due to bullying and dd went to a girls school and has very healthy relationships with both sexes, because she is confident in herself and her abilities, having never been pushed aside due to boys dominating. Your experience doesn't supercede the overwhelming evidence that girls have better outcomes when they attend girls schools.

RosaSkyes · 23/02/2024 13:46

At my school we actually noticed this a few years ago in regards to football, and we introduced a rota system for different areas of the playground - a calm space, a trim trail and the bottom playground.

definitely worth mentioning, I don’t think you’ll be seen as precious at all, I think sometimes it just takes somebody flagging it to change the status quo slightly

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/02/2024 13:45

Schools around here have rules to ensure the playground isn't dominated by any group. At my son's school football is in the MUGA and different years get different days to use it. Other ball games (mostly hockey, mostly boys) must be played in a certain area, and the rest of the space is for other games, and has the climbing wall, climbing frames etc, which the girls tend to colonise.

If the playground at your daughter's school really is a free for all, I think it is totally reasonable to ask the head to think about managing it better.

Macramepotholder · 23/02/2024 13:43

Both boys and girls need space to run around and be physical. Boys don't 'have more energy' than girls; girls are socialized from an early age into quieter play, including through clothing.

I was going to suggest OPAL and Make Space for Girls- one thing which can work well with limited space is to only allow ball games a couple of days a week (or have a proper lunchtime football club on the field if there is one) and the rest of the time have the space set up for other types of play.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 23/02/2024 13:36

MarnieMarnie · 23/02/2024 12:11

It's another reason that I think all schools should be single sex. Girls have much much better outcomes in all girls schools. This insidious expectation that they need to relinquish any shared space or area to boys is part of the reason girls to less well in co-ed schools.

Edited

Oooh please no. How do we expect men and women to co-exist post school if they don’t learn to co-exist during school. I went to a single sex school and it did nothing at all to prepare you for a world where the other sex exists.

Itwasfinetillitwasnt · 23/02/2024 13:14

I have 3 teens. 1 ds and 1dd struggled with the playground because of the rougher play. One wasn't bothered either way so yes majority of mine would have probably preferred a quieter area.

PrueRamsay · 23/02/2024 13:07

@Namechangeforthiss how/when do you see this happening? Assuming you must work at the school if you’re in the playground at break times?

Definitely speak to your HT if you think it’s a problem.

abeeabeeisafterme · 23/02/2024 13:04

It's a reasonable observation and depending on your relationship with the school, it would be worth speaking to them. Our playground has zones for ball games, quiet games, no running, climbing areas etc. Now obviously not all playgrounds are big enough for this, so an alternative is to have day. Ball games on Mon/Wed/Fri. Or at morning play but not lunchtime. If the boisterous behaviour still permeates the playground atmosphere- it's intimidating and staff should be used to model co-operative and peaceful play.