Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys dominating the playground

211 replies

Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 12:02

I’ve noticed at DD’s school the enclosed, paved playground is quite dominated by boys playing their (rough!) games in the middle. Meanwhile the girls mill around the edges, seemingly a bit nervous to even cross it, let alone join in. I’ve noticed the boys also seem to feel more ‘entitled’ to play equipment as well as the playground space and will be quite rough and jostle past if a girl tries to play on it.

Do you think playgrounds should be halved, not to segregate by sex (and both sexes should be encouraged to join in any game they want) but to save some space for children who want to play less physical/rough games?

Feel free to tell me I’m being precious! (I have a son as well, not smug girl mum complaining about boys, but he’s only 1!).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
CheersToMe · 23/02/2024 16:11

Have a look at the OPAL project. My DC's old primary introduced a few years ago and the outcomes for staff and students have been transformative. Check out the videos.

outdoorplayandlearning.org.uk

MalvernValentine · 23/02/2024 16:07

My child's school segregates the play areas by groups. I think there's about 5/6 groups mixed across each KS year, then they rotate around the spaces each week.

Then when all 5/6 rotations are done, they reallocate the groups and mix them up and start again.

This is to prevent cliques and help behaviour management and support social mixing.

NinetyPercent · 23/02/2024 16:03

Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 15:40

The votes are pretty split so it seems I’m not being ridiculous. I think I’ll email the head, just outline what I’ve noticed, include the info included in this thread and ask them to give it some thought. We want our girls to grow up feeling sport and physical activity is a natural pastime for them, not just for the boys while they watch on from the sides. I’ll update if/when they respond. Thanks.

Good luck! Hope you've seen my two replies since your update.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/02/2024 16:02

wiltonian · 23/02/2024 15:13

Also @TheYearOfSmallThings it has not changed enough yet. I was talking to another mum whose daughter was giving up football because in the junior mixed teams the boys refused to pass to the girls...

Oh it's far from perfect, agreed. But at least the schools are trying!

NinetyPercent · 23/02/2024 15:59

@Namechangeforthiss

'Do you think playgrounds should be halved, not to segregate by sex (and both sexes should be encouraged to join in any game they want) but to save some space for children who want to play less physical/rough games?'

To answer your specific question - like other posters, the ideal is zones. Have four square in one bit, hopscotch in another, ball games other than four square in another, and then somewhere where games don't have to be organised. Or rotate days or times within a lunch break for different games. This is where OPAL can be really good, and having trained outside staff. I know not all schools can have it, but local football clubs often send in their young staff to initiate different games at lunchtime. Like this https://www.brentfordfccst.com/en/curriculum-coaching

Spendonsend · 23/02/2024 15:56

Theres quite a bit of research in this, and there are things that can be done with playground design to help bring girls into the space. One of the schools i worked at did a lot of work on this.

MaggieBroonofGlebeSt · 23/02/2024 15:54

Girls and boys often used to have separate playgrounds back in the day. That was got rid of as 'sexist', because realising they have slightly different needs wasn't allowed. My old primary school had a bit of wall left where the divide had been. Got rid of in the 60s or 70s I guess.
What I think is more of an issue is the older ones totally overrunning the littler ones. My children's school playground is quite overwhelming when I ever walk through it at breaktimes (occasional early pick up for doctors etc). The very little ones have a separate section, but from P3 onwards they're all in together.

NinetyPercent · 23/02/2024 15:52

@Namechangeforthiss Glad to see that Make Space for Girls and OPAL have both been mentioned - look them up and how they can help, and definitely say something to the school. My DS is older now (secondary schools and lack of space or time for exercise is a whole other thread!) but his primary school at one point banned footballs but the kids still played football with a tennis ball... More effective strategies are having certain days for certain sports or girls only football, and explaining why to all the pupils. It's worth also looking at their PE teaching generally, and what after school clubs are available and on which days - eg if football and ballet are always on the same afternoon, or coding and gymnastics, do those clubs end up being heavily girl or boy dominated? (and yes, I am stereotyping on purpose). Is there a girls' football team?

You're not being precious at all. I'm not sure why other posters are so bothered about how you've seen this or not - plenty of primary schools you can walk past and see how the kids are playing. Do speak to your DD to get her input as well. As my DS got older he didn't like me saying anything. You are observing gender stereotypes at play. I've always said there's many a PhD in the dominance of primary playgrounds by football...

Women in Sport is worth looking at too https://womeninsport.org/resource/sport-stereotypes-and-stolen-dreams/

Oh, and the other thing is the attitude of the playground supervisors / lunch ladies / dinner ladies (😜). Without meaning to, they may be enabling the boys to play football and the girls not to. Look up 'whole school approach' to challenging gender stereotypes as part of it is training ALL staff (ie non-teaching staff as much as teachers and TAs) and getting all pupils and families on board.

Sport, Stereotypes and Stolen Dreams: Why girls still feel they don’t belong in sport

Women in Sport knows that sport gives girls and women resilience, courage and self-belief. We also know that gender stereotypes hold girls and women back from sport, and in life. In this study we…

https://womeninsport.org/resource/sport-stereotypes-and-stolen-dreams/

PrincessHoneysuckle · 23/02/2024 15:51

I'm a midday supervisor at a primary and ime you'd never get the kids to stay separate into rough and quiet.
It's a nice idea but not a practical one at all.

Alittlecappuccino · 23/02/2024 15:49

You can't change the nature of kids or the differences between the sexes.

Caffeineislife · 23/02/2024 15:47

It would be really interesting to see if dominated playgrounds are more of an issue in schools that have expanded their class sizes and year groups but have not expanded their outside space? Children need space to run around and burn off some energy and be in the outdoors. It's something massively overlooked IMO when schools are expanded and open new classes in year groups. I also think the shortening of playtime has negatively affected children's play. We've lost the long 1hr+ lunchtimes, the 25 minute morning and afternoon break. Most schools seem to have a 15 minute morning break and a 50 minute lunch.

One school I worked at went from 2 form to 3 form in the course of a couple of years but we never got any more outside space, only a fancy new extension on the old building taking up the infant playground space. We had to start doing 3 staggered playtimes and lunchtimes as the single playground left just became too busy. We lost afternoon break as well.

What is interesting is that in summer months when the field was opened up so therefore more space the playground did always feel calmer.

Ponderingwindow · 23/02/2024 15:45

Your observations are not wrong. It happened at my DD’s school. It was especially bad for her because she is very small. she got knocked over and injured repeatedly even in the tamest areas and eventually just retreated from playing.

I remember it happening at my school growing up and we even had quite a large playground.

At my school the boys played so rough the school actually banned girls from entering areas like the field where they were playing football, even if the girls wanted to play. We were told that games like hopscotch were sufficient. There were simple solutions, like taking the zones on alternating breaks or days, but instead the boys just ruled.

Hardbackwriter · 23/02/2024 15:44

girlwhowearsglasses · 23/02/2024 15:24

Yes exactly - and boys need to learn a bit of humility, how to behave around girls, how not to objectify them, how to function in work and like when, you know, women need as much consideration as men

I wouldn't say that the evidence that co-ed schooling achieves this is exactly striking.

LoobyDop · 23/02/2024 15:43

I think limiting the number of days when football can be played is a reasonable compromise that also works for boys who are pushed out of the playground, but I imagine the howls of outrage from the football fathers will be heard in outer space.

Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 15:40

The votes are pretty split so it seems I’m not being ridiculous. I think I’ll email the head, just outline what I’ve noticed, include the info included in this thread and ask them to give it some thought. We want our girls to grow up feeling sport and physical activity is a natural pastime for them, not just for the boys while they watch on from the sides. I’ll update if/when they respond. Thanks.

OP posts:
Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 15:37

Slanketblanket · 23/02/2024 15:21

I complained to our school that boys were allowed to play football and there was no provision to allow girls to do any sport (netball, skipping) during playtime. I was told girls can play football too, which I responded to by saying, yes of course they can but the boys won't let them and not all want to because they've already been socialised by age 7 into gendered roles, so practically they won't and need other provision. I was told I was being sexist.

This is how I feel. All very well saying the girls can join in but can they REALLY? Will the boys treat them as equal or just ignore them and shout to each other? DD loves boisterous play but is short and slight for her age and quite clumsy, she’s nowhere near matching the boys speed or force during these games. She wants to join in, not be knocked flying then ignored.

OP posts:
Spinet · 23/02/2024 15:31

thecatsthecats · 23/02/2024 15:25

I have been heavily involved in developing early years programmes, and this sort of behaviour is massively driven by the home, even at the baby stage.

People encourage little girls, even babies, to be careful, and not to spoil their clothes that are useless for play. The trend is often intensified if the children have been cared for mostly by grandparents - lots of "sit nice and quietly" care.

A little anecdata to back up the actual trends - yesterday a meeting with my antenatal group. Stark differences already between the boy and girl mums in attitudes, as outlined above. The babies in question are four months old.

Totally agree, but the amount of 'they're just different aren't they' among parents of boys/ girls drives me nuts.

thecatsthecats · 23/02/2024 15:25

I have been heavily involved in developing early years programmes, and this sort of behaviour is massively driven by the home, even at the baby stage.

People encourage little girls, even babies, to be careful, and not to spoil their clothes that are useless for play. The trend is often intensified if the children have been cared for mostly by grandparents - lots of "sit nice and quietly" care.

A little anecdata to back up the actual trends - yesterday a meeting with my antenatal group. Stark differences already between the boy and girl mums in attitudes, as outlined above. The babies in question are four months old.

girlwhowearsglasses · 23/02/2024 15:24

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 23/02/2024 13:36

Oooh please no. How do we expect men and women to co-exist post school if they don’t learn to co-exist during school. I went to a single sex school and it did nothing at all to prepare you for a world where the other sex exists.

Yes exactly - and boys need to learn a bit of humility, how to behave around girls, how not to objectify them, how to function in work and like when, you know, women need as much consideration as men

Slanketblanket · 23/02/2024 15:21

I complained to our school that boys were allowed to play football and there was no provision to allow girls to do any sport (netball, skipping) during playtime. I was told girls can play football too, which I responded to by saying, yes of course they can but the boys won't let them and not all want to because they've already been socialised by age 7 into gendered roles, so practically they won't and need other provision. I was told I was being sexist.

Beamur · 23/02/2024 15:18

I was just coming on to post about make space for girls 😁
The physical design of play and public spaces is incredibly important if we want spaces that both boys and girls can use.

LivingRoomTiger · 23/02/2024 15:16

When I was a deputy head I ended up separating the playground with low wooden fences. Football/ ball games, area of grass under tress. Climbing frames, benched no running area. Tiny playground but worth it. It was frankly a horrendous uncrossable hell. I think all playgrounds need distrupting with furniture and fencing to prevent the take over. It’s not even all boys, though it is boy dominated. Some boys also need to read without being smacked in the head with a ball!

girlwhowearsglasses · 23/02/2024 15:14

ZoeyBartlett · 23/02/2024 12:26

There is a great group who looks at the issues around space for teenage girls - I'm sure the same applies for younger. www.makespaceforgirls.co.uk/

sorry pressed ‘post’ too many times 🙄

girlwhowearsglasses · 23/02/2024 15:14

ZoeyBartlett · 23/02/2024 12:26

There is a great group who looks at the issues around space for teenage girls - I'm sure the same applies for younger. www.makespaceforgirls.co.uk/

Brava @ZoeyBartlett

wiltonian · 23/02/2024 15:13

Also @TheYearOfSmallThings it has not changed enough yet. I was talking to another mum whose daughter was giving up football because in the junior mixed teams the boys refused to pass to the girls...

Swipe left for the next trending thread