Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys dominating the playground

211 replies

Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 12:02

I’ve noticed at DD’s school the enclosed, paved playground is quite dominated by boys playing their (rough!) games in the middle. Meanwhile the girls mill around the edges, seemingly a bit nervous to even cross it, let alone join in. I’ve noticed the boys also seem to feel more ‘entitled’ to play equipment as well as the playground space and will be quite rough and jostle past if a girl tries to play on it.

Do you think playgrounds should be halved, not to segregate by sex (and both sexes should be encouraged to join in any game they want) but to save some space for children who want to play less physical/rough games?

Feel free to tell me I’m being precious! (I have a son as well, not smug girl mum complaining about boys, but he’s only 1!).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Vittoriosa · 23/02/2024 22:32

What a load of nonsense. As a mum of 2 boys and a female myself I think this is coming across as extremely precious. All girls are not precious little wallflowers and all boys are not violent tyrants. If there is a specific issue that affects your child raise that with the school.

BogRollBOGOF · 23/02/2024 19:49

I remember it being raised in one of my first PGCE lectures 20+ years ago.

At DS's primary school there is half the playground for football, half for general play and an additional adventure zone and the zones rotate around different year groups.
Football can be an issue. DS likes it, but he often reports temporary bans when games get too gung-ho, normally involving certain regular names. Being small year groups, it doesn't take many being taken out of the equation to make playing it unviable.

My memory of junior school was two sports courts- being half the playground being dominated by boys playing football, and being 30 years ago, it was only boys. Girls would play in the other half including games like skipping and elastics. Some of the quieter boys would play games like Top Trumps.

I think zoning and breaking spaces up to meet a variety of play needs is the more practical approach.

Longma · 23/02/2024 19:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

ehb102 · 23/02/2024 19:17

We have the same issue at our village primary school. It's been a year now. The Football Association have "Let Girls Play" on 8th March. School supports this. So then I go in and one day a week I do football for KS2 girls on the field at lunch. I'm a parent volunteer so I'm already checked. I am also a football coach and we have lots of keen girl footballers - we even have a girl footballer on our village sign. But the thing that doesn't happen is that girls don't play football outside of coached sessions. On enquiry it is because the boys dominate not only the space and the provided balls but also how the game is played. The girls don't want to play with them or play in that way (very keen, very focussed on winning, lots more body contact). It's actually a problem, the boys are overly violent so football is now banned at lunchtimes. But before that I provided four balls marked for Year 3 girls, Year 4 girls etc. There was uproar! Boys, particularly year 5 boys, were incensed that there was something football that was not specifically for them. Lots of PSHE was needed. And it didn't totally stick.

So yes. Op. It is a problem. Physical differences are starting to emerge between boys and girls at 8, as well as social. The odd girl who likes to play on the mainly boys team doesn't change that. Our SLT is on it, it is a work in progress. Adult supervision and PSHE and behaviour coaching are all part of it.

TempsPerdu · 23/02/2024 19:11

There are sex based differences - it would be weird if there weren't - but they're much smaller than socialisation makes them

Yes - I’m absolutely on board with the idea that boys and girls are different in some ways, but I’ve been shocked by the level of investment of many parents in ensuring their boys fulfil all the tired masculine stereotypes and their girls all the feminine ones.

DD6 has recently declared herself a ‘tomboy’ simply because her range of interests spans science, Pokémon, football (and toilet humour!) as well as more typically ‘girly’ stuff. Her school classmates all seem to have much more binary interests - football parties for all the boys; mermaid/unicorn/princess ones for all the girls - and we’ve just had to turn down an invite for a full on spa/princess pamper party for one of her schoolmates because, at barely 6, DD isn’t keen on the idea of sitting around for 3 hours doing nails, hair and make up!

nutbrownhare15 · 23/02/2024 18:55

My daughter's school has stopped football (pretty much all boys) being played at break times to allow for other activities which I support

FloofyBird · 23/02/2024 18:50

Errr no. They shouldn't be playing roughly and lunchtime staff should be ensuring everyone gets a fair turn on equipment.

thecatsthecats · 23/02/2024 18:29

Spinet · 23/02/2024 15:31

Totally agree, but the amount of 'they're just different aren't they' among parents of boys/ girls drives me nuts.

There are sex based differences - it would be weird if there weren't - but they're much smaller than socialisation makes them.

We are, after all, overevolved monkeys, and monkeys don't make their girl babies sit and play quietly without spoiling their fur.

My primary school has a great environment for this to be fair. I think the key to success was small mixed year group classes - you were much more likely to find someone compatible on merit than just being another Y5 girl etc.

londonmummy1966 · 23/02/2024 17:32

@MaggieBroonofGlebeSt - I agree that it is great that there are other sports like gymnastics but then you have reports of girls not being allowed to turn cartwheels in playgrounds as they show their knickers - and a lot of gymnastics isn't really playground suitable. The issue that was identified was that girls didn't have room to run around and play sports in playgrounds as the boys took over almost all the space to play football and then excluded the girls from joining in or more subtly excluded them by never passing to them etc.

If I recall correctly the thinking was that if games like football didn't take place in the playground then other activities like running etc which are more equal in prepubescent children might be more prevalent (in games of catch etc) and might make children of both sexes think beyond the "box" of running around in the playground = football by default.

TBH nothing really came of that particular discussion as the group eventually went for the "this girl can" campaign instead.

Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 17:28

Alittlecappuccino · 23/02/2024 15:49

You can't change the nature of kids or the differences between the sexes.

So let boys occupy 90% of playground space..?

OP posts:
Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 17:25

MaggieBroonofGlebeSt · 23/02/2024 17:06

Don't agree. Anti boy bias on here is ridiculous. DS loves his football; I'm happy he has something he enjoys. DD has her hobbies she loves as well.
If you think the women's team is 'brilliant' then why not encourage men and boys to play football too?

Do they need any encouragement?

OP posts:
LakeTiticaca · 23/02/2024 17:23

I was at primary school mid/late 60s. Playground had 2 halves, the boys half and the girls half. It worked. We liked it. The boys did their stuff and left us girls alone to do our stuff

StaunchMomma · 23/02/2024 17:20

I don't think playgrounds should be halved but it does sound like the school aren't doing an awfully good job of 'policing' playtime.

If it is exactly as you described it, staff on duty aren't doing their job sufficiently.

I think I'd bring it up, potentially with a senior member of staff, as it's not a classroom issue, and enquire as to how they monitor this. If they haven't thought about it, it may spark them to. It's not something that would go down well with Ofsted - if a couple of female pupils were to say they feel unsafe at playtime (when questioned as a part of an inspection) that could lead to an unsatisfactory rating.

TempsPerdu · 23/02/2024 17:18

Yes, this has been an issue in most of the primaries I’ve worked in, and I’m currently seeing the beginnings of it with my own daughter in Year 1 (who actually wants to play football with the boys but is either being left out entirely or made to be the goalie).

Some of the schools I’ve worked in have tried to implement things like girls-only football days, or segregated areas of the playground but in practice lack of space often makes it difficult. We’re also struggling a bit with a prevailing ‘boys will be boys’ attitude among some of the staff at DD’s school, which, as a governor there, I’m trying to push back against. But it’s a bit of an uphill struggle - I can completely see where the issues around girls’ lack of participation in sport/physical activity stem from. And tbh it isn’t just the school - parenting in general seems a lot more gendered among DD’s peers than I remember when I started out in teaching 15 years ago.

Spinet · 23/02/2024 17:11

MaggieBroonofGlebeSt · 23/02/2024 17:06

Don't agree. Anti boy bias on here is ridiculous. DS loves his football; I'm happy he has something he enjoys. DD has her hobbies she loves as well.
If you think the women's team is 'brilliant' then why not encourage men and boys to play football too?

It's not an anti-boy bias at all. Boys are lovely. Football encourages a culture in which boys and men are not lovely unless you like hooliganism, violence, and using rivalry in the place of expressing emotions.

I'm not interested in football at all by the way, but I'd rather go to a women's match than men's and that's not because of the quality of the football but because the crowd is less likely to be violent. Squashing boys into that culture is just as damaging as denying girls space to exist.

MaggieBroonofGlebeSt · 23/02/2024 17:06

Spinet · 23/02/2024 16:58

It's not just a game they enjoy though is it. It's a culture which has traditionally been, to be honest, the route of much toxic masculinity. That's changing a bit now I think, mostly thanks to our brilliant women's teams, but I don't think it's essential that boys are allowed to play football at all.

Don't agree. Anti boy bias on here is ridiculous. DS loves his football; I'm happy he has something he enjoys. DD has her hobbies she loves as well.
If you think the women's team is 'brilliant' then why not encourage men and boys to play football too?

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 23/02/2024 17:00

This is interesting, because I was only reading an article about shared spaces a little while ago.

It was about sports spaces outside of schools - but it basically said that it was noted that sports areas are not used by girls past the age of about 5 or so, because they have to compete even to get in. I think it was Sweden (?) did lots of research and made lots of simple improvements like placing a second entrance to the playground and splitting out the ball games to a separate area.

Have a google and see if you can find what the hell I'm talking about it might help bolster your conversations!

Spinet · 23/02/2024 16:58

MaggieBroonofGlebeSt · 23/02/2024 16:45

Do you not think the growth in interest in gymnastics is more of a favour? Nearly all my DD's friends do gymnastics; same with older sisters. I don't remember anyone doing it when I was at school; now it seems nearly all of them do! There seems to be a wider availability of dance classes now as well.

I also don't think that boys should necessarily have to not play a game they enjoy, just to include girls. Imagine if it was suggested the other way round?

It's not just a game they enjoy though is it. It's a culture which has traditionally been, to be honest, the route of much toxic masculinity. That's changing a bit now I think, mostly thanks to our brilliant women's teams, but I don't think it's essential that boys are allowed to play football at all.

Imamastermind · 23/02/2024 16:50

Listen to this podcast. Talks about exactly that!

podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/visible-women-with-caroline-criado-perez/id1627229311?i=1000567285700

MalvernValentine · 23/02/2024 16:45

MaggieBroonofGlebeSt · 23/02/2024 16:39

'cliques' - a group of friends. Imagine if adults were told they couldn't ever have a solid friendship group, and had to socialise with people they don't particularly like.
My DD was deliberately split from her nursery best friend going into primary - they do it to all the friendships at our school. I can't understand the school's policy on this at all.
It was pointless anyway as three years later they're still great friends, despite the teachers all saying they would immediately forget each other.

I can't say I agree or disagree to be honest. Mainly as my child seems happy with it despite having some friends in the class environment. I imagine it would be more of an issue as children get older and less so at Ks1, but it's different for all kids I guess. I'm glad it's not had a long lasting impact on your child and their friend group!

MaggieBroonofGlebeSt · 23/02/2024 16:45

londonmummy1966 · 23/02/2024 16:39

I sat on a Sport England group looking at the decline in girls interest in sport about 20 years ago and playground football was flagged as a potential issue even then ( I also suggested that PE teachers might be a bit of an issue but that was shouted down......)

When I was at school no balls were allowed in the playground at all and games were much more inclusive - quite a bit of catch but the girls at that stage were often as fast as the boys. I also don't recall there ever being much of an issue finding space to play. I do wonder whether cutting back on playground football might well make the boys more creative/inclusive about how they play

Do you not think the growth in interest in gymnastics is more of a favour? Nearly all my DD's friends do gymnastics; same with older sisters. I don't remember anyone doing it when I was at school; now it seems nearly all of them do! There seems to be a wider availability of dance classes now as well.

I also don't think that boys should necessarily have to not play a game they enjoy, just to include girls. Imagine if it was suggested the other way round?

ladykale · 23/02/2024 16:40

My own experience at primary school thinking back was the same

MaggieBroonofGlebeSt · 23/02/2024 16:39

MalvernValentine · 23/02/2024 16:07

My child's school segregates the play areas by groups. I think there's about 5/6 groups mixed across each KS year, then they rotate around the spaces each week.

Then when all 5/6 rotations are done, they reallocate the groups and mix them up and start again.

This is to prevent cliques and help behaviour management and support social mixing.

'cliques' - a group of friends. Imagine if adults were told they couldn't ever have a solid friendship group, and had to socialise with people they don't particularly like.
My DD was deliberately split from her nursery best friend going into primary - they do it to all the friendships at our school. I can't understand the school's policy on this at all.
It was pointless anyway as three years later they're still great friends, despite the teachers all saying they would immediately forget each other.

londonmummy1966 · 23/02/2024 16:39

I sat on a Sport England group looking at the decline in girls interest in sport about 20 years ago and playground football was flagged as a potential issue even then ( I also suggested that PE teachers might be a bit of an issue but that was shouted down......)

When I was at school no balls were allowed in the playground at all and games were much more inclusive - quite a bit of catch but the girls at that stage were often as fast as the boys. I also don't recall there ever being much of an issue finding space to play. I do wonder whether cutting back on playground football might well make the boys more creative/inclusive about how they play

Marblessolveeverything · 23/02/2024 16:17

I don't think segregation is the answer! My two sons played with boys and girls until late primary, their friendships are mixed. Are the fme rough or active? Because active play is important for all children and assists development understanding of risk, flexibility and team work.
My experience of working in all girls school was toxic sly bullying and no encouragement to engage in sports etc. we live in a mixed society. The quoted research on girls has been questioned by researchers for a longtime.

I don't believe it is healthy, children need to be surrounded by as many people of different sex, interests, etc. Why would you keep them apart? Research shows the opposite is true and in Ireland new schools are mixed.