Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys dominating the playground

211 replies

Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 12:02

I’ve noticed at DD’s school the enclosed, paved playground is quite dominated by boys playing their (rough!) games in the middle. Meanwhile the girls mill around the edges, seemingly a bit nervous to even cross it, let alone join in. I’ve noticed the boys also seem to feel more ‘entitled’ to play equipment as well as the playground space and will be quite rough and jostle past if a girl tries to play on it.

Do you think playgrounds should be halved, not to segregate by sex (and both sexes should be encouraged to join in any game they want) but to save some space for children who want to play less physical/rough games?

Feel free to tell me I’m being precious! (I have a son as well, not smug girl mum complaining about boys, but he’s only 1!).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Namechangeforthiss · 26/02/2024 14:37

This is your thread and your observation so you should be willing to back it up with reliable sources.

It’s getting very tedious now so this will be my last reply to you. Plenty of information has been shared on here regarding boys dominating communal play space, how girls feel about this, and how things could be improved so the spaces are shared better. You’ve sidestepped all of this, and instead just keep ranting on and on about… what? How girls prefer not to run about and instead mill about chit chatting, then it turned into ‘well it’s a parenting failure if they don’t rough and tumble with the boys’, and now it’s demanding evidence for some obscure part of the discussion when plenty of information has already been provided.

You seem irrationally irritated by something (me, I think) and just keep repeating the same nonsense over and over, while refusing to acknowledge the study that has been posted on here (probably the only relevant one) and the experiences of people who work in schools.

OP posts:
Alittlecappuccino · 26/02/2024 14:24

Namechangeforthiss · 26/02/2024 11:31

Where is the research to show they don’t? Do you even have a daughter? Everything you’re saying about girls is very 1950s and not at all representative of my DD or the little girls I know.

That isn't how it works, academics don't focus on providing evidence to prove something that isn't, they focus on finding evidence to prove something that is.
This is your thread and your observation so you should be willing to back it up with reliable sources.
Struggling to see where I've said anything remotely 1950s? I'd say my mention of the importance in parents raising confident girls who don't allow themselves to be ushered into a corner (if they don't want to be there) is completely opposite to 1950s attitudes.
I have 2 of each. My girls were 'tomboys' who played for the local and school football teams until around 15yo when their interest organically changed to the more typical girly stuff.

VoiceOfCommonSense · 26/02/2024 14:15

Namechangeforthiss · 23/02/2024 12:02

I’ve noticed at DD’s school the enclosed, paved playground is quite dominated by boys playing their (rough!) games in the middle. Meanwhile the girls mill around the edges, seemingly a bit nervous to even cross it, let alone join in. I’ve noticed the boys also seem to feel more ‘entitled’ to play equipment as well as the playground space and will be quite rough and jostle past if a girl tries to play on it.

Do you think playgrounds should be halved, not to segregate by sex (and both sexes should be encouraged to join in any game they want) but to save some space for children who want to play less physical/rough games?

Feel free to tell me I’m being precious! (I have a son as well, not smug girl mum complaining about boys, but he’s only 1!).

Just getting them ready for what they can expect in life when they leave school it sounds like 🤷‍♂️

Mercedes519 · 26/02/2024 12:25

Alittlecappuccino · 26/02/2024 10:12

As expected. But where is the evidence to suggest those girls are sitting by the sides when they don't want to? That diagram supports that boys and girls naturally segregate themselves at this age and that males engage in games that take up more space. It's interesting to see that some of the girls do go out into the middle and play amongst the boys yet boys seem to avoid the girl dominated area altogether.

But given what we know about female socialisation and the patriarchy in general don’t you think we ought to at least entertain the notion that the ‘choices’ they are making are not the ones they could or should be making?

Half the time we make choices that we think are free will but are a product of our society. It’s only when they are pointed out (like here) that we realise that maybe it shouldn’t be that way. And most importantly perhaps (like the OP has) we should do something about it?

Namechangeforthiss · 26/02/2024 11:42

And LOL at parenting failure. Same could be said in reverse, no? Although I wouldn’t say that because I’m not silly enough to think this is an issue of parenting failure. Unless every parent at the school in the study have magically failed together.

OP posts:
Namechangeforthiss · 26/02/2024 11:31

Alittlecappuccino · 26/02/2024 09:44

Girls that want to run around do run around regardless of the boys, they often get involved with the boys games! If people are raising daughters that can't stick up for themselves then that is a parenting failure.
Where are the actual figures on what percentage of girls who would like to run around but don't because they have accepted boys space allegedly rules?

Where is the research to show they don’t? Do you even have a daughter? Everything you’re saying about girls is very 1950s and not at all representative of my DD or the little girls I know.

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 26/02/2024 11:18

Playgrounds are definitely (and obviously) sexist. It gives me the rage how early my dds learned that boys get to take up the most space.

SleepingStandingUp · 26/02/2024 10:15

ichundich · 24/02/2024 10:06

So when those children who haven't been able to let off steam because football is banned then disrupt your DD's lesson, you won't complain? And why do you keep making this into a boys vs. girls issue? Some girls play football and some boys prefer drawing or pretend play.

Why can boys only let off steam kicking a football around a large space,? Why can't they run around a large space without the football or kick the football in a smaller space? Our school has a couple of goals one end so they can play with the footballs without requiring a match sized space dedicated to them every single playtime

Alittlecappuccino · 26/02/2024 10:12

Mercedes519 · 26/02/2024 09:52

Research here which shows sex-based data on playground usage. Blue is boys and red is girls

As expected. But where is the evidence to suggest those girls are sitting by the sides when they don't want to? That diagram supports that boys and girls naturally segregate themselves at this age and that males engage in games that take up more space. It's interesting to see that some of the girls do go out into the middle and play amongst the boys yet boys seem to avoid the girl dominated area altogether.

SleepingStandingUp · 26/02/2024 09:56

MarnieMarnie · 23/02/2024 12:11

It's another reason that I think all schools should be single sex. Girls have much much better outcomes in all girls schools. This insidious expectation that they need to relinquish any shared space or area to boys is part of the reason girls to less well in co-ed schools.

Edited

So compulsory single sex education until what, 18? Uni? Then single sex work places because I'm sure women do better in female dominated workspaces too. Perhaps we can just find a big pen to put all the males in, rather than tackling the why.

Mercedes519 · 26/02/2024 09:52

Research here which shows sex-based data on playground usage. Blue is boys and red is girls

Boys dominating the playground
Alittlecappuccino · 26/02/2024 09:44

Namechangeforthiss · 26/02/2024 09:31

I've stated that kids who like to run around should be able to do so, it doesn't matter what sex they are. You're argument is a very confused one. One moment you are saying girls are left to the side lines and in the next breath stating they like the more physical play too. So what is your point?

My argument is very simple so I think your ‘misunderstanding’ is phony. Either that or you have comprehension issues. Girls want to run around but generally don’t want to play games that are quite as rough and physical as the boys games are. They should have space to play tag, statues, throwing games and all the rest of it. They shouldn’t be left milling around the outside to ‘chat and colour’ because they’ve just resignedly accepted that the boys are more entitled to the space for their own games.

You’d do well to read the studies here which back this up rather than ranting nonsense and dodging anybody who has experience of this or posts some evidenced research.

Girls that want to run around do run around regardless of the boys, they often get involved with the boys games! If people are raising daughters that can't stick up for themselves then that is a parenting failure.
Where are the actual figures on what percentage of girls who would like to run around but don't because they have accepted boys space allegedly rules?

Namechangeforthiss · 26/02/2024 09:31

I've stated that kids who like to run around should be able to do so, it doesn't matter what sex they are. You're argument is a very confused one. One moment you are saying girls are left to the side lines and in the next breath stating they like the more physical play too. So what is your point?

My argument is very simple so I think your ‘misunderstanding’ is phony. Either that or you have comprehension issues. Girls want to run around but generally don’t want to play games that are quite as rough and physical as the boys games are. They should have space to play tag, statues, throwing games and all the rest of it. They shouldn’t be left milling around the outside to ‘chat and colour’ because they’ve just resignedly accepted that the boys are more entitled to the space for their own games.

You’d do well to read the studies here which back this up rather than ranting nonsense and dodging anybody who has experience of this or posts some evidenced research.

OP posts:
Alittlecappuccino · 26/02/2024 09:20

Namechangeforthiss · 24/02/2024 09:51

The relevance is you seem to be pushing the best interests of boys very very very strongly while denying girls have any needs at all beyond ‘sitting at the side and colouring’. I assumed you either have no experience of raising girls or spend very little time around them. In my experience they love running about, climbing, scooting, throwing games and all the rest of it. This ‘awww they just want to chit chat at the side, let boyz be boyz’ is a nonsense in my experience.

You can assume all you like but you would be wrong. I never said anything about boys interests being promoted over girls. I've stated that kids who like to run around should be able to do so, it doesn't matter what sex they are. You're argument is a very confused one. One moment you are saying girls are left to the side lines and in the next breath stating they like the more physical play too. So what is your point?

Active kids use up more space for their activities, that is the nature of active activities. Why would a less active child be bothered about the uneven playground spilt if they're happy doing their own thing in a smaller area away from the hustle and bustle. You're more bothered about this than the kids involved.

tiredandtiredandtiredandtired · 26/02/2024 08:05

I’m a teacher and most playgrounds where I’ve worked have dedicated quiet spaces for children to read, colour, do crafts and other more physical areas. Both are used by both sexes.

theprincessthepea · 24/02/2024 13:04

MissMarplesNiece · 24/02/2024 09:54

boys usually played football - although they were alright when the girls joined (I remembered being a goal keeper a few times haha).
Thats interesting, @theprincessthepea In the research paper, referenced earlier in the thread, the authors describe how when girls were permitted to join in with the boys' football, they take up defensive positions like goal keeper, rather than being allowed to participate in the prestige roles of attacking & scoring goals.

Even when on the surface it looks like girls can participate in the boys game, there is still lack of equality.

@MissMarplesNiece that’s super interesting. And there is me thinking I was being included haha! I also noticed the boys were much gentler when the girls played, almost assuming they had a responsibility to be nice. Or it would be the classic boys v girls. However in Secondary school there was no chance of getting in. Watching my DD in secondary school now it’s sad that she has gone from being sporty in the playground (in primary) to just walking around with friends (in secondary). Whilst boys continue to play sports during break if they want to.

sashagabadon · 24/02/2024 11:12

I remember from my 70’s childhood one child would start a chant “ who wants to play….. bulldog!” or whatever and then children who wanted to play would link arms and join in the chant until there was a critical line of kids all marching a round chanting who wants to play etc.
problem was it used to take all break to get to that critical mass number 😂
70’s children were actually very equal opportunities!
then british bull dog was banned and football took over.
girls used to spend break with a paid of tights with a tennis ball in the end standing against the wall and wacking it about. We all had great skills with our tights and ball.
or playing slapping game until that got banned too

Goblinmodeactivated · 24/02/2024 10:09

Sorry have only read OP posts not full thread, looks like some links may have been posted already!

RufustheFactualReindeer · 24/02/2024 10:09

There are other games than just football

we didn’t allow football on the playground but all of the children managed to play games which involved running round

Goblinmodeactivated · 24/02/2024 10:08

There’s actually evidence to support what you’re saying, that in general girls end up using open spaces less because they feel that they are dominated by boys. Was reading about this a while back. Here’s an example.

https://www.makespaceforgirls.co.uk/resources/make-space-for-us

Definitely follow it up!

Make Space for Us

Research by Women in Sport on the barriers girls face to enjoying parks.

https://www.makespaceforgirls.co.uk/resources/make-space-for-us

ichundich · 24/02/2024 10:06

Namechangeforthiss · 24/02/2024 09:22

@saraclara for goodness sake my OP specifically says I don’t want sex segregation. How many more times must I say this?!

If football can’t be played in a smaller area then it shouldn’t be played at all. If the girls came up with a game tomorrow which took up equal amount of space, and said therefore the boys would just have to squeeze in around the edges, do you think the boys and their parents would just shrug and say fair enough? Of course they wouldn’t. That’s why this is, at its heart, sexist - the same consideration would never be applied in reverse.

So when those children who haven't been able to let off steam because football is banned then disrupt your DD's lesson, you won't complain? And why do you keep making this into a boys vs. girls issue? Some girls play football and some boys prefer drawing or pretend play.

OutOfTheHouse · 24/02/2024 09:55

Alittlecappuccino · 24/02/2024 09:48

Anecdotal.

And the research posted up thread?

MissMarplesNiece · 24/02/2024 09:54

boys usually played football - although they were alright when the girls joined (I remembered being a goal keeper a few times haha).
Thats interesting, @theprincessthepea In the research paper, referenced earlier in the thread, the authors describe how when girls were permitted to join in with the boys' football, they take up defensive positions like goal keeper, rather than being allowed to participate in the prestige roles of attacking & scoring goals.

Even when on the surface it looks like girls can participate in the boys game, there is still lack of equality.

LordSnot · 24/02/2024 09:52

Alittlecappuccino · 24/02/2024 09:48

Anecdotal.

So are your nonsense posts.

saraclara · 24/02/2024 09:51

for goodness sake my OP specifically says I don’t want sex segregation. How many more times must I say this?! for goodness sake my OP specifically says I don’t want sex segregation. How many more times must I say this?!

You might be the OP @Namechangeforthiss but you are not the only person posting on this thread. This has become a general discussion and I didn't aim my post at you specifically.

Many people on here have said that playground should be split by sex dvd I was simply saying that I don't agree with that view.