Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this put you off a man-never moved out

190 replies

Urghhhcba · 23/02/2024 11:36

A friend of mine is interested in a 31 year old, but she's found out he's never lived away from home apart from going to uni halls.
Like never been in a serious relationship/lived with a woman or even just moved into a place on his own. Like he's saving but she's just really put off him now.

OP posts:
Daffyaboutdaffs · 23/02/2024 17:26

Not really. Things are different now. My son is still with us. He is 29. He has a lovely gf 29 . They have both stayed at home to save and hopefully will move out together soon

HadEnufff · 23/02/2024 17:23

breadandroses1992 · 23/02/2024 17:17

Really. Where i live a room rents for £1k, but a studio rents for £1200 to £1300 so there is still a difference.

Yes, but my point is a few years ago it would have cost £1k - or less - to rent a studio flat.

And that rent has risen faster than wages.

HadEnufff · 23/02/2024 17:21

OpieMo · 23/02/2024 15:10

Disagree. It's off-putting for men and women. Where's their sense of drive? Of wanting independence? Of craving wanting to forge their own way in the world? If someone can't afford a house share, then they're obviously not paying their way at home. And if someone's finances are so poor they can't afford to support themselves they should be focusing on that before dating seriously.

Do you have any idea how much it costs to live in a house share now? Its not 1995 any more!

The idea that in order to have a relationship they first have to pay 50% of their take home pay to a landlord is bonkers.

And you must be an idiot to think that paying a share of bills to parents costs the same as a room in a rented house would.

People who live at home typically have more "drive" to better themselves longterm in life than those who move out and are constantly in their overdraft, saving nothing each month.

breadandroses1992 · 23/02/2024 17:17

HadEnufff · 23/02/2024 17:13

Flat shares aren't cheap any more. It's not like it used to be where you'd get a decent room for a few hundred quid a month.

They now cost just as much (or more) than it used to cost to rent your own place.

There's very little value in it now.

Really. Where i live a room rents for £1k, but a studio rents for £1200 to £1300 so there is still a difference.

HadEnufff · 23/02/2024 17:13

Garlickit · 23/02/2024 16:35

Most people don't want to have to live in a flatshare with near strangers

I've seen this comment more often lately, in relation to 20-30 year olds. Why not? What's changed? Flat sharing used to be part of life, a social resource and a learning experience.

Flat shares aren't cheap any more. It's not like it used to be where you'd get a decent room for a few hundred quid a month.

They now cost just as much (or more) than it used to cost to rent your own place.

There's very little value in it now.

bringbacksideburns · 23/02/2024 17:04

My husband was at home until 30. He got on brilliantly with his mum and dad. His sisters had married and moved out very young so he did up their room as his own space too. There was still plenty of privacy. He had done some travelling but never wanted to move in with anyone.

I on the other hand left for uni at 18 and stayed away as I couldn’t get on with my mother. I’d lived in flats and bedsits and moved south for a while. His family were so lovely they became mine. We’ve been married 30 plus years. Yes some can’t wait to move out but I think more than ever, with the cost of living, if people get on with their parents then they will do this more and more.

What about women in their late twenties living at home? No different!

What would put me off would be many other things, fathering several children and not looking after them, addictions, prison record, inability to string a sentence together without swearing, constantly gaming or on phone like a child, a string of unhappy relationships etc

breadandroses1992 · 23/02/2024 17:04

OpieMo · 23/02/2024 15:10

Disagree. It's off-putting for men and women. Where's their sense of drive? Of wanting independence? Of craving wanting to forge their own way in the world? If someone can't afford a house share, then they're obviously not paying their way at home. And if someone's finances are so poor they can't afford to support themselves they should be focusing on that before dating seriously.

We lived at home for 3 years because when we moved out we wanted it to be forever and into our own place with a fixed term mortgage to buy us 5 years of time.. Not needing to boomerang back cos landlord evicted us and we couldn't find a new place!

Would rather take snarky remarks circa 2016 to 2019 when we were in our 20s rather than have to move back in our 30s. MY BIL and SIL moved out straight after university but is now moving back to live with her MIL, together with a baby! They are 31 and 35 respectively.

I don't think my pride could take that! At least when I was in my 20s I was a new immigrant and my dh was still trying to find his feet in his new job so that was at least easier to explain. To be fair once we were settled in jobs, we started trying to buy our flat straight away but it did take a year. How am I supposed to explain living at home in my 30s with a baby?

breadandroses1992 · 23/02/2024 16:57

Naunet · 23/02/2024 16:39

Weird isn’t it? Adult children staying at home longer doesn’t all come down to cost of living, it’s also a rise in their standards compared to previous generations. They want to be able to buy right away, something previous generations didn’t really do, we accepted we’d have to work our way up the chain and valued our independence more I think.

We lived at home and saved for 3 years but still bought our flat in our late 20s (27 and 29). Was because dh had a gap year and was sick while at university (so had the chance to repeat the masters year). Plus started school late due to childhood epilepsy. So ultimately he was 26 when he started working properly in London other than the earlier internships... We married when he was 24 and I was 22

I felt like we were getting too old and if we didn't buy quickly we may be ultimately priced out esp if I got pregnant and had to pay childcare instead of deposit.

We do have some fertility problems and didn't conceive but I am grateful in a way we had 5 good years of overpaying the mortgage instead of rent. It was only possible to buy as quickly as we did by living at home. Also I am 31 now so still have a few years ahead of me to conceive and have paid back a good chunk of the mortgage during our Dinky years. I think if you are lucky enough to find your partner in your 20s it's better to live at home and save for a good 2-3 years and that will help you in future regardless of your plans.

breadandroses1992 · 23/02/2024 16:48

Dh only moved out at 29 (rented when doing his masters) and that was cos we lived together with his mum for 3 years after marriage and managed to save 60k. Without me, I guess he could have taken until his early 30s to buy a flat in London.

If he is saving, how much savings has he managed to accrue and what is his job etc. My SIL's boyfriend claims he moved out at 18 but he has never had a job in his life despite being 34. He has just been a student all this time and using student loans and probably parental money to get ahead. I am sorry but I think my dh is a better catch (also 34 this year and in middle management in a bank and bought a property at 29 in London). Even without me, I think based on his salary today he could have bought alone provided he worked in banking. Might be harder if he went into the civil service.

Justifiedcheese · 23/02/2024 16:41

HelloDarlingWhatAreYouDoingHere · 23/02/2024 12:01

If he's a mummy's boy who has been kept like a Labrador then would be very off putting. I can imagine him being into painting those little statues and going to battle re-enactments.

However, if he is a competent adult who has stayed at home piling his weight and saving money then that's great.

ODFOD. DS1 has lived independently since 21 and still loves wargaming and LARP. Bloody sight more interesting and creative than football or golf.

Naunet · 23/02/2024 16:39

Garlickit · 23/02/2024 16:35

Most people don't want to have to live in a flatshare with near strangers

I've seen this comment more often lately, in relation to 20-30 year olds. Why not? What's changed? Flat sharing used to be part of life, a social resource and a learning experience.

Weird isn’t it? Adult children staying at home longer doesn’t all come down to cost of living, it’s also a rise in their standards compared to previous generations. They want to be able to buy right away, something previous generations didn’t really do, we accepted we’d have to work our way up the chain and valued our independence more I think.

Garlickit · 23/02/2024 16:35

Most people don't want to have to live in a flatshare with near strangers

I've seen this comment more often lately, in relation to 20-30 year olds. Why not? What's changed? Flat sharing used to be part of life, a social resource and a learning experience.

Skyecat · 23/02/2024 16:27

As others have said, depends on the circumstances - how independent etc.

Would it be more palatable if he had his own property brought with a deposit from the bank of mum and dad? That seems to be more acceptable in society.

Saltandpeppero · 23/02/2024 16:26

And if someone's finances are so poor they can't afford to support themselves they should be focusing on that before dating seriously.

True, some people’s priorities seem a bit mixed up. i was once talking to a 41 year old man who lived between his brothers family house and his mums house where he still had a bedroom. He had also been made redundant last year and was doing odd jobs for his brothers business. It wasn’t clear how long he had been living with family but he didn’t seem to have any plans to move out.

I have to say that did put me off as in his situation he clearly was living with his family because he couldn’t afford not too. Massive difference between 31 and 41 though. So I think age matters as well as their overall circumstances.

He had recently just got himself 3 dogs and I couldn’t help thinking that money could have been spent on a deposit to rent his own place. And he didn’t seem to be focused in finding proper employment, just was all about the gym and walking his dogs.

It’s up to him how he spends his time & money but I didn’t feel he was in a good position to date in terms of his employment and living situation. He wanted to move off the app and talk on WhatsApp which I said no to , and he asked if he said something wrong . It was a bit awkward but I was just put off by the whole thing so had to unmatch.

ClockworkDisaster · 23/02/2024 16:22

It all depends, doesn’t it? Sure in an ideal world they would have their own place. Sadly we don’t live in an ideal world.

I met my partner last year. He was early 30s and living at ‘home’ still. Except he had bought the house (ex council) and has his own business. He acts as carer for his mum as she has mobility issues. But he is grown up enough to be able to the household chores.

We obviously spend our time together at my place, but I don’t mind that. I’d rather be at mine anyway.

Naunet · 23/02/2024 16:21

C1N1C · 23/02/2024 16:07

My comment was actually made sarcastically. I honestly don't know any women who would be 'discriminated' against for living at home though. I highly doubt men would be on DN saying their girlfriend still lives at home, with men demonising her because she has to (in effect) 'grow up', and that it's a red flag like some of the comments above.

It's like how men staying at home while their wife works are seen the same way; these are cocklodgers.

And? Do women’s preferences have to match men’s for some reason? Women tend to be less focused on looks than men, we’re all different and there’s nothing wrong with that.

ReadingLight · 23/02/2024 16:18

Pootle23 · 23/02/2024 14:45

But we only have what OP has said. Maybe e travels a lot. There are loads of reasons why he might still live at home. He could be a carer or anything.

Personally if I liked him, I would get to know him.

Him living at home means nothing.

I assume she would have said so if there was a reason like being a carer — she said he’s ‘saving’. ‘Getting on the property ladder’ is not sufficient reason for me for prolonging adolescence well into adulthood by living longterm with your parents. I don’t think it’s good for most people.

Saltandpeppero · 23/02/2024 16:14

FinallyFeb · 23/02/2024 15:51

It would put me off, if they didn’t go you university they’d have had approximately 13 years to either save up a deposit to rent or buy and get their act together. In my mind 28 is the cut off age.

OP said they lived in uni halls so I assume they did go to uni.

user1497787065 · 23/02/2024 16:10

My DS is 32 and still at home. The only way to buy a house with a single income is with a large deposit. Hopefully by the end of this year he will purchase a house with a 50% deposit.

Would that put you off too? Is that not just showing financial competence?

C1N1C · 23/02/2024 16:07

Naunet · 23/02/2024 15:46

How deeply sexist of you.

My comment was actually made sarcastically. I honestly don't know any women who would be 'discriminated' against for living at home though. I highly doubt men would be on DN saying their girlfriend still lives at home, with men demonising her because she has to (in effect) 'grow up', and that it's a red flag like some of the comments above.

It's like how men staying at home while their wife works are seen the same way; these are cocklodgers.

SKG231 · 23/02/2024 16:06

I think it depends on the whole picture. If he has mummy cooking all his meals and wiping his bum then yes it’s a big no no but if he’s actually saving and has a good job and seems to have his shit together it’s more understandable.

lazyarse123 · 23/02/2024 16:06

FinallyFeb · 23/02/2024 15:51

It would put me off, if they didn’t go you university they’d have had approximately 13 years to either save up a deposit to rent or buy and get their act together. In my mind 28 is the cut off age.

Does that not depend on their job and how they progress?

lazyarse123 · 23/02/2024 16:03

I really hope not. I have a 31 yr old at home, he has had a few relationships but he is actually next week seeing a mortgage advisor as he has now saved enough for a deposit, fees and hopefully most of his furniture. But hey ho feel free to judge the fantastic work ethic that he has.

Hufflemuff · 23/02/2024 16:01

Yeah it probably would put me off. Not even moving out with your mates in a shared house or something is a bit odd.

Does he not have a circle of friends?

Sususudio · 23/02/2024 16:00

Ulysees · 23/02/2024 15:59

And you said it'd put you off

Yes, it does put me off. I don't believe in multi-generational living. I was being facetious.