Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this put you off a man-never moved out

190 replies

Urghhhcba · 23/02/2024 11:36

A friend of mine is interested in a 31 year old, but she's found out he's never lived away from home apart from going to uni halls.
Like never been in a serious relationship/lived with a woman or even just moved into a place on his own. Like he's saving but she's just really put off him now.

OP posts:
Hereforaglance · 25/02/2024 10:48

Ur a snob then n refusing to get to no someone because of their living situation that man got a lucky escape in my book lol

Sparklfairy · 25/02/2024 10:48

Deathbyfluffy · 25/02/2024 10:45

All these men? My friendship group are mostly in their 30s, and several of them live at home but have significant savings.

There’s only one that fritters away cash like it’s going out of fashion; the rest are very good with money.

I'm just saying my experience, OLD for 10 years on and off. I have to point out though, said OLD hasn't been that successful so perhaps I attract a type! Wink

Remeniss · 25/02/2024 10:48

Run for the hills.
yes the cost of living is tough, could be saving etc etc yadda yadda, but really it’s actually one of two scenarios.
1- he’s tighter than a gnats arsehole and if he hasn’t managed to save a house deposit in the ten years since uni he ain’t never leaving home.
2- he can’t cut the umbilical cord, and from personal experience, he will either expect you to take the place of his mother and be his love in maid OR he will expect you to defer to his mother at all times and undermine you completely at every turn.

hes a man child.

Deathbyfluffy · 25/02/2024 10:45

Sparklfairy · 23/02/2024 11:59

Yes it would put me off. I live in the SE so people in their 30s living at home isn't unusual. However all these men say they live with parents 'to save' yet miraculously, have little savings...

All these men? My friendship group are mostly in their 30s, and several of them live at home but have significant savings.

There’s only one that fritters away cash like it’s going out of fashion; the rest are very good with money.

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 10:43

Hereforaglance · 25/02/2024 10:28

Everyone has to live somewhere only a snob or a gold digger would be put off by this it personality that counts not where a person lives ffs

Personality is the reason I wouldn’t be interested. The kind of personality that would contemplate living with parents till the age of 31 would be deeply unappealing to me.

IgnoranceNotOk · 25/02/2024 10:41

This would have put me off 10-15 years ago but now I think the house/rent prices and the cost of living is so high that if they’re saving instead it makes sense.

Manthide · 25/02/2024 10:38

awflote · 23/02/2024 14:29

It would put me off. Living independently is such an important life skill - DH was living in flat shares when I met him, so no need to be able to afford a place to yourself.

My DS is in that position - he's autistic and would struggle to live independently (functionally and financially). I'm sure he could make a good partner but he is less independent than many women would want.

My ds is also ND, living atm in a house share but I can imagine him coming back home after university. He would also make a lovely partner, is good with finances and loves fixing things around our house. It wouldn't make sense him paying rent when he could help me out with household expenses and save towards his own home. He does like living with other people but he's very house proud which doesn't always go down well with the other students.

Hereforaglance · 25/02/2024 10:28

Everyone has to live somewhere only a snob or a gold digger would be put off by this it personality that counts not where a person lives ffs

Beezknees · 25/02/2024 09:37

It wouldn't put me off. Why make life harder than it needs to be? If his parents are happy with the situation then it saves everyone money. I've lived on my own since I was 18 and there's nothing great about struggling to pay the rent and bills as a single person. Wish I'd had the opportunity to live with parents!

Zanatdy · 25/02/2024 09:36

No as it’s expensive to move out these days and why would you and pay out for rent when you can live with family and save.

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 09:32

prescribingmum · 25/02/2024 09:24

It is extremely shallow to dismiss all those who have chosen to remain in the family home as ‘prolonging adolescence’. As has been pointed out many times, it is about financial choice especially if living in a high cost area.

DH’s parents purchased a new family home when in his 20s which was extended and modernised before moving in. He contributed both towards the cost and also towards the practicalities in the build project. He also cared for his elderly grandparents who lived with them for a period of time in this home. He was living there independently when we were dating - contributing both towards the upkeep of the house as well as usual daily costs.

You are simply excluding a whole group of people with no background or context. As I said originally, their gain!

There’s nothing at all shallow about excluding a group of people whose choices mean they would not work for me as potential partners. And yes, I do see those choices as artificially prolonging adolescence, regardless of whether they contribute to household running costs. They’ve made a limiting choice which would rule them out for me. It’s no one’s loss or gain.

prescribingmum · 25/02/2024 09:24

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 08:35

It’s not remotely shallow, and culture of origin is irrelevant to me. I simply wouldn’t contemplate a relationship in which the other person had missed out on, for whatever reason, the crucial step in independent selfhood that is living independently. I wouldn’t want a relationship with someone who thought ‘saving for a deposit’ legitimated prolonging adolescence into his 30s.

It is extremely shallow to dismiss all those who have chosen to remain in the family home as ‘prolonging adolescence’. As has been pointed out many times, it is about financial choice especially if living in a high cost area.

DH’s parents purchased a new family home when in his 20s which was extended and modernised before moving in. He contributed both towards the cost and also towards the practicalities in the build project. He also cared for his elderly grandparents who lived with them for a period of time in this home. He was living there independently when we were dating - contributing both towards the upkeep of the house as well as usual daily costs.

You are simply excluding a whole group of people with no background or context. As I said originally, their gain!

NameNew · 25/02/2024 09:21

I probably wouldn't date a man still living at home. I live in a relatively cheap part of the country and bought my own home in my early twenties, my life is here so I would be looking to date a relatively local man therefore he would also be living in a relatively cheap part of the country, so living at home in his 30s to save for a deposit would be unacceptable to me.

To the PP who said about her son in the RAF, that wouldn't put me off that his official address is yours, he's obviously moved out to join the RAF.

ChristmasFluff · 25/02/2024 09:19

It would put me off because I have always wanted an partner who values and prioritises their independence, as I do. If someone is willing to give up their independence long term, even for financial reasons, they aren't for me.

youmustrememberthis · 25/02/2024 09:12

@ReadingLight see for me, I don't think that's a necessary stage if the person living at home contributes properly, pays their own way and has their own plans for their future. I've prioritised being able to save (whilst absolutely contributing weekly and to home improvements) and therefore be financially better off than have the experience you're talking of, in my opinion it's a lot about the background you come from, how psychologically willing you are to live financially precariously and having a blanket judgemental approach completely fails to consider it. It's not about prolonging adolescence it's about financial choices especially if you're properly paying your way whilst at home. Everyone's entitled to their own views but I personally think it's incredibly naive and judgmental to suggest your way makes someone an adult and anything else is just childishness.

Sususudio · 25/02/2024 08:37

I am from an Asian background too. All my friends and family who married men who never moved out have simply had to move in with them to live with inlaws, brothers, sisters etc etc. My idea of hell.

I married an Asian, who left home at 18 to live in a grotty hostel and does not want to return, ever.

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 08:35

youmustrememberthis · 25/02/2024 08:27

I think this is really good point and agree a lot.

It’s not remotely shallow, and culture of origin is irrelevant to me. I simply wouldn’t contemplate a relationship in which the other person had missed out on, for whatever reason, the crucial step in independent selfhood that is living independently. I wouldn’t want a relationship with someone who thought ‘saving for a deposit’ legitimated prolonging adolescence into his 30s.

youmustrememberthis · 25/02/2024 08:27

prescribingmum · 24/02/2024 09:46

Coming from an Asian background where it is taken for granted that parents have space for their children until they are married, I can’t believe how many would discount a potential partner for something so shallow without knowing the context. As well as it being cultural, it is also to allow the individual to save for their own place. From our social circle, almost everyone would have saved and purchased a property of their own by their 30s but property prices are going up much faster than salaries so it is not as easy as 10-15 years back.

If you are in SE, your parents are close by with space and a good relationship, why spend upwards of £1000 per month for a house share when can put it towards a deposit? Admittedly everyone does not have this luxury and there are some who live at home because they are lazy but it seems ludicrous that those who do are prematurely judged - their gain from avoiding a relationship with someone so judgmental!

I think this is really good point and agree a lot.

Bookkeepermum · 25/02/2024 08:15

When I met my fiancé, he lived at home with his mum. He was 38! It was a 6 bedroom farm but still, never lived on his own. His longest relationship was 6 months!
He moved in with me and now we have a 5 year old and 1 year old.
I never understood how he had hardly any relationships (he looks a lot like Bradley Cooper) He's a lovely man.

Kwasi · 25/02/2024 08:03

Riverlee · 23/02/2024 11:55

My dh was 27 and still living at home, and had never lived away (didn’t go to uni).

However, he was independent and planning for the future.

How independent is the dp? Does he cook, clean, have independent hobbies etc, or does he rely on (and expect his mother) to do everything? Does he run everything by his parents, or does can he make his own decisions? Ie, is the parent/sibling relationship enmeshed?

These are the questions I would be asking.

If he’s never picked a pair of dirty socks up off the floor, she needs to run to the hills. If he does his own food shopping and share of the housework, she should be fine.

LizHoney · 24/02/2024 20:05

Not a dealbreaker but certainly a question mark.

breadandroses1992 · 24/02/2024 17:46

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 24/02/2024 15:07

But there are still plenty of people who don't live with parents? They aren't all millionaires.

Tbh my dh wouldn't be rent burdened even if he rented on his own. His nett income is £4000 a month (gross income £75k per annum with 10% employer contribution to pension) and a room in London rents for £1000 (our mortgage for a 2 bed flat also £1020 due to rise to £1250 in August).

I would say to be a comfortably off renter wherever you are in the UK, you need to earn 40-80k in most places at least to rent a room and be caught in an unsustainable rental trap cycle (assuming no huge pay increases) . Perhaps in the cheapest cities you could get away with £35k. But in most place you are likely to be a higher rate taxpayer to not spend more than 30% on housing. Higher rate taxpayers are not millionaires but expecting a partner to be a higher rate taxpayer rules out probably at least 75% of all 30 year old men and I am being generous and taking into account men earn more than women (though they don't tend to at that age)

breadandroses1992 · 24/02/2024 16:42

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 24/02/2024 15:07

But there are still plenty of people who don't live with parents? They aren't all millionaires.

I don't live with parents and we spend 10% of gross income /17% of nett on our mortgage in London. Was just lucky to buy in 2019. Definitely not a millionaire lol. Am 31.but increasingly renting today mean you are very likely to be cash poor after all rent and bills and unlikely to be financially stable without help from parents or some future income increases.

In cheaper areas,, just a gift of 10-20k added to savings could mean you pay a mortgage instead of rent and the average mortgagor tends to pay about 20% of gross income compared to average renter. But a lot of that is dependent on luck. Unless you have a high income whether you own or rent can be dependent on luck and not whether you are a millionaire

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 24/02/2024 15:07

breadandroses1992 · 24/02/2024 15:04

Renters in London, South East and South West England spend a higher proportion of their take-home pay on rent than in other regions. In London 86% pay over 30% of their salary on rent, followed by 83% in the South West and 82% in the South East.
Northern Ireland is the least rent burdened region of the UK, with 67% of respondents paying over 30% of their take home pay on rent.

No longer just a London thing. Even in the cheapest region, two thirds are rent burdened.

But there are still plenty of people who don't live with parents? They aren't all millionaires.

breadandroses1992 · 24/02/2024 15:04

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 24/02/2024 13:28

Well yes, but we don't all live in London. Many of these 'men who live with parents' are in Doncaster or Newcastle or Sterling too.

Renters in London, South East and South West England spend a higher proportion of their take-home pay on rent than in other regions. In London 86% pay over 30% of their salary on rent, followed by 83% in the South West and 82% in the South East.
Northern Ireland is the least rent burdened region of the UK, with 67% of respondents paying over 30% of their take home pay on rent.

No longer just a London thing. Even in the cheapest region, two thirds are rent burdened.

Would this put you off a man-never moved out