Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this put you off a man-never moved out

190 replies

Urghhhcba · 23/02/2024 11:36

A friend of mine is interested in a 31 year old, but she's found out he's never lived away from home apart from going to uni halls.
Like never been in a serious relationship/lived with a woman or even just moved into a place on his own. Like he's saving but she's just really put off him now.

OP posts:
iwafs · 25/02/2024 13:12

I wouldn't write him off just for that. It seems quite sensible and he's close to his family, which is a green flag. I mean, if you get on well with your parents and can live with them - ie have family meals together etc instead of moving out and being lonely, eating along, massive cost implications - why would you move out? Just to please society or judgey people?

KK05 · 25/02/2024 13:09

Depends on the circumstances and the individual.

Slight difference but I moved back with my parents a few time. Had lived away from home and country for a few years then came back. Stayed with them when I was at uni and then moved out again. I moved back in temporarily but ended up being (3 years) when a relationship broke down. Then moved out again to live with DH.

My parents have a bigger house so I did sort of have my own space. Separate sitting room and bedroom/ bathroom but shared the kitchen. I was fully independent and paid some rent. It allowed me to save for a place of my own.

DH was also living at home when we met (29) again he had been away for work etc but not properly moved out. It was awkward but it did allow us to save a decent deposit each and then to merge for a decent first home.

I guess it depends on lots of factors and the individual.

Bigearringsbigsmile · 25/02/2024 13:06

PingvsPong · 25/02/2024 12:42

Living at home gives them more disposable incoming allowing them to go travelling and all sorts. not just 'save for a deposit'. Also, if you live in a place like London in no way are you restricted!

Rents are so high, things are so expensive, so many young people do very little apart from working to pay for the shabby little room they're renting. Then spend the rest of their time after work in said shabby little room.

I don't know how old you are but... my colleagues in their 50's spent their twenties bumming around, had great adventures, came back , got a 'good job' and almost immediately bought property. In the days of 100% mortgages. Those don't exist anymore and unless you get handed a deposit you need to save up thousands.

@breadandroses1992 exactly. People just don't get it.

The important thing here is timeline to moving out. If someone's got 50K in the bank and is still living at home then obviously independence isn't important to them.

Edited

Erm....no! The ' younger generation ' have such a fucked view of how easy people in their 50s had it!

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 13:03

In fact, I think comparative poverty was freeing. There was no parental safety blanket to retreat to. We knew we were on our own at 18.

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 13:01

I’m 51, @PingvsPong, from an extremely poor background, have been supporting my own parents and helping my younger siblings from pretty much the moment I left home, and I can assure you there was no culture of ‘bumming around’ among the people I knew, or my university cohort, with the knowledge of an eventual ‘good job” waiting. My country was in a deep recession, with high unemployment, so few jobs of any kind, ‘good’ or otherwise, waiting. No 100% mortgages, no parental deposits. But I refused to barter the freest time in my life for ‘savings’.

Catandsquirrel · 25/02/2024 12:57

Wouldn't be my preference as I value independence very highly. More highly in fact than affluence.

However, sorry if this has been said but I've only skimmed replies- there could be a cultural factor. What culture is he from? Some backgrounds traditionally stay at home until marriage unless moving for uni/ work. It can affect dating openly and being welcome in his home so I'd ask about that if it's the case and you're not from the same background. Several of my friends are in this position in their 30s. Great people, perfectly self sufficient and hardworking, not particularly timid, but it comes with its challenges when dating outside the same/similar cultures.

tryingtobenormalish · 25/02/2024 12:45

Its not just men that still live at home women do to.
Some have just cant afford to move out some have to go back home for other reasons.
My friend is 32 and she still lives at home ftw does her bit in the home her parents are lovely.
I dont get why women look down on a man living at home but noting said about a woman doing it.
If it makes him a mummys boy or parents pet does it make a woman a daddys girl or is she the parents pet.

Americano75 · 25/02/2024 12:43

No, not at all or I wouldn't have my lovely husband. Luckily I could see past his home circumstances (hadn't been able to move out as he'd helped his parents buy a new house after their business went bust) and judge him as a person.

PingvsPong · 25/02/2024 12:42

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 12:01

It’s bizarre to me that anyone other than the most timid types would even contemplate returning home from an independent life at university, and restrict themselves to considering jobs that would allow them to live with their parents at a time in their lives when they won’t generally have children, commitments or things tying them to a specific place, but are very free.

The world is your oyster, but, no, you’re going to go and live in your childhood bedroom so you can ‘save for a deposit’.

Which is obviously your choice, but wouldn’t work for me. If I were single and in my 30s, it would be a clear signal we had very different attitudes to life.

Living at home gives them more disposable incoming allowing them to go travelling and all sorts. not just 'save for a deposit'. Also, if you live in a place like London in no way are you restricted!

Rents are so high, things are so expensive, so many young people do very little apart from working to pay for the shabby little room they're renting. Then spend the rest of their time after work in said shabby little room.

I don't know how old you are but... my colleagues in their 50's spent their twenties bumming around, had great adventures, came back , got a 'good job' and almost immediately bought property. In the days of 100% mortgages. Those don't exist anymore and unless you get handed a deposit you need to save up thousands.

@breadandroses1992 exactly. People just don't get it.

The important thing here is timeline to moving out. If someone's got 50K in the bank and is still living at home then obviously independence isn't important to them.

breadandroses1992 · 25/02/2024 12:29

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 12:01

It’s bizarre to me that anyone other than the most timid types would even contemplate returning home from an independent life at university, and restrict themselves to considering jobs that would allow them to live with their parents at a time in their lives when they won’t generally have children, commitments or things tying them to a specific place, but are very free.

The world is your oyster, but, no, you’re going to go and live in your childhood bedroom so you can ‘save for a deposit’.

Which is obviously your choice, but wouldn’t work for me. If I were single and in my 30s, it would be a clear signal we had very different attitudes to life.

I lived with my mother in law who has a house in London. It's what enables us to stay in London when others have been priced out. I am from another country though and have lived out since I was 19. Honestly though I probably wouldn't have agreed to marry my dh straight after university if I didn't know he had a parental home in London which enabled us to build our careers.

If he didn't have a parental home, we would be really poor on a combined income of £120k! We are OK now cos of the headstart he had. My dh being a 4th generation Londoner is equivalent to someone with a gift of £40k from parents i think. If I wanted to marry someone who is financially better off than me, I would have had to marry someone who either earned £100k at 25 or had generous parents who gave out £40-70k. I would have felt far more beholden to his parents in the latter. Guys with parental homes in London are far more common I think, also how cna I expect someone to earn 100k when I don't even earn £100k.

But cos I married my dh I can live really well in London on a meagre household income of £120k and be happy.

My DH's sister moved abroad probably cos she thought her world is her oyster. She is now moving to America to live with her mother in law at 31 with a baby. She needs the mother in law to sponsor her visa as they don't have enough assets between her and her husband otherwise. It would be the same if she moved back to London or perhaps even if she moved to Manchester. Cos reality catches up eventually. Our generation has far less options when 51% of first time buyers need help. It's hard perhaps for people who bought even a few years ago to understand.

When we bought in 2019, we bought with combined income of £75k. Today you need nearly £100k combined household income to buy in London and that is assuming you have 10% deposit. We had 15% deposit. It's gone up for all other regions, average home needs around £60-70k combined. If you are 35 and there are babies in the picture your affordability goes way down. So actually the time to save is in your 20s before you get priced out.. And bearing in mind, prices are falling but rents are rising faster than wages and also interest rates.

Shayisgreat · 25/02/2024 12:06

Shayisgreat · 25/02/2024 12:05

I was with someone who had never moved out by 33 and it was a massive turn off. He had no interest in moving out either and was planning to buy a house with someone when he got serious enough to get married. I mean, he had been engaged previously and had still not moved out.

It suggested to me that he would not be able to run a house himself and may not even be able to do basic things like budget for bills and groceries and plan out meals for the week. I interpreted it as wishing to remain dependent on others and I had no desire to obtain a manchild.

It was a very brief relationship - ended after 3 months of dating.

Shayisgreat · 25/02/2024 12:05

I was with someone who had never moved out by 33 and it was a massive turn off. He had no interest in moving out either and was planning to buy a house with someone when he got serious enough to get married. I mean, he had been engaged previously and had still not moved out.

It suggested to me that he would not be able to run a house himself and may not even be able to do basic things like budget for bills and groceries and plan out meals for the week. I interpreted it as wishing to remain dependent on others and I had no desire to obtain a manchild.

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 12:01

breadandroses1992 · 25/02/2024 11:36

That's what I find weird, wouldn't you rather move back after university, save and then move out again.. Why waste money renting when your eventual intention is to buy? Unless you are the kind where you are sure that your income will progress that rent would be less than 10% of income and you can invest the difference!

It’s bizarre to me that anyone other than the most timid types would even contemplate returning home from an independent life at university, and restrict themselves to considering jobs that would allow them to live with their parents at a time in their lives when they won’t generally have children, commitments or things tying them to a specific place, but are very free.

The world is your oyster, but, no, you’re going to go and live in your childhood bedroom so you can ‘save for a deposit’.

Which is obviously your choice, but wouldn’t work for me. If I were single and in my 30s, it would be a clear signal we had very different attitudes to life.

EveryOtherNameTaken · 25/02/2024 11:58

Wouldn't bother me as he has lived out of home for uni.

Someone who had literally never lived outside would be different.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 25/02/2024 11:46

I find it a bit childish when adults refer to themselves or other adults living with parents as "living at home" or "still living at home" as if their own "home" isn't or couldn't be a proper home. As if they are just playing at being adults in their pretend home.

I realise for some it's just something people say without thinking, but I am surprised how many people well into adulthood (and presumably most of them parents themselves given that this is "Mumsnet") have a persistent subconscious belief that only a parents' home is "home".

When I bought my first flat I didn't "leave home", I left my parents' home for my own new home.

Blanketpolicy · 25/02/2024 11:44

In isolation not moving out would not be an issue.

Having to be home for dinner, mummy doing his washing, or other man child behaviours would be concerns.

Clearly being an independent, competent adult but living at parental home is ok.

Spirou · 25/02/2024 11:42

Urghhhcba · 25/02/2024 11:19

I don't think that someone moving back in for a defined period of time to save is any issue whatsoever. I guess it's someone who's never had the curiosity to even try it for a year or so, even just with a friend or something. Uni halls at 18 is different.

Yes, totally agree with that. For me it’s a mindset problem. It would bother me that they’d never wanted to. I value independence and want a partner who feels the same. I want someone who has experienced standing on their own two feet so that when I inevitably take on some of the load they have some appreciation for the work involved (and vice versa of course).

breadandroses1992 · 25/02/2024 11:36

Urghhhcba · 25/02/2024 11:19

I don't think that someone moving back in for a defined period of time to save is any issue whatsoever. I guess it's someone who's never had the curiosity to even try it for a year or so, even just with a friend or something. Uni halls at 18 is different.

That's what I find weird, wouldn't you rather move back after university, save and then move out again.. Why waste money renting when your eventual intention is to buy? Unless you are the kind where you are sure that your income will progress that rent would be less than 10% of income and you can invest the difference!

Urghhhcba · 25/02/2024 11:19

I don't think that someone moving back in for a defined period of time to save is any issue whatsoever. I guess it's someone who's never had the curiosity to even try it for a year or so, even just with a friend or something. Uni halls at 18 is different.

OP posts:
semicole · 25/02/2024 11:19

It would not put me off exactly but would make me somewhat cautious. I'd want to find out what his living situation is like.

Is he living with his parents but working and financially contributing to make up for what he costs to house eg paying for increased bills? Is he sensible with money and saving to get his own place? Is he able to cook for himself, clean, do his own washing?

Does his relationship with his parents (particularly his mother to be honest) seem healthy? Does he care for her and treat her kindly but have healthy boundaries and maintain independence? How much influence does she have on his decisions about his private life like partners, where he lives etc? Is there some weird enmeshment where he acts more like her husband than her son?

If I liked someone I would not stop dating them over this but I would be mindful of it and be slow to move forward until I could figure out what's going on there.

My main concerns would be a potential future very difficult MIL and a partner who was unable to draw boundaries with her or a man who has been looked after his whole life and would expect me to take on the role of a mother.

So I am perhaps being judgemental but not judgemental of anyone who has always lived at home. More wary of what that might be a sign of. If my concerns prove unfounded then it wouldn't be an issue at all.

ChihuahuasREvil · 25/02/2024 11:15

No, wouldn’t go out with someone who lived with their parent/s. I did my acting like a teenager/being quiet/creeping around parents’ houses in my teenage years.

also, I’m not straight, but who needs a bloke who is used to being looked after by his mummy? We all know he will be. Most blokes won’t look after themselves even if they have to and will try and find a woman to do it for them instead, so the chances of finding that unicorn man who lives at home but is completely independent of mummy is, well, impossible, because such a man does not exist.

JMSA · 25/02/2024 11:05

It would put me off.

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 11:00

Manthide · 25/02/2024 10:56

A lot of university students think they are slumming it if they don't have an en suite and a dishwasher. Big difference from when I was at university where we had to walk to the nearest laundrette and there was normally only one bathroom for 5 or 6 people.

In fairness, around here they are paying quite insane sums for accommodation., and half of the places we lived in when we were students would probably be condemned as unsafe now. I lived somewhere once that was so cold I used to wear a jumper in the bath, rolled up out of way of the water…😀

Manthide · 25/02/2024 10:56

Garlickit · 23/02/2024 16:35

Most people don't want to have to live in a flatshare with near strangers

I've seen this comment more often lately, in relation to 20-30 year olds. Why not? What's changed? Flat sharing used to be part of life, a social resource and a learning experience.

A lot of university students think they are slumming it if they don't have an en suite and a dishwasher. Big difference from when I was at university where we had to walk to the nearest laundrette and there was normally only one bathroom for 5 or 6 people.

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 10:54

Hereforaglance · 25/02/2024 10:48

Ur a snob then n refusing to get to no someone because of their living situation that man got a lucky escape in my book lol

Snort. When you’re contemplating a relationship, where do you draw the line a regards the ‘living situation’ you regard as so minor — sofa surfing? Sleeping on park benches? Completely irrelevant, obviously.

Swipe left for the next trending thread