Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this put you off a man-never moved out

190 replies

Urghhhcba · 23/02/2024 11:36

A friend of mine is interested in a 31 year old, but she's found out he's never lived away from home apart from going to uni halls.
Like never been in a serious relationship/lived with a woman or even just moved into a place on his own. Like he's saving but she's just really put off him now.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Allshallbewell2021 · 25/02/2024 21:50

Sorry Pingversuspong, I was very unclear; I meant to imply the opposite - that because rents are high etc therefore more people will live at home. Pressed post too quickly.

The economic environment is massively different when I moved out in the 90s.

EricaJohns · 25/02/2024 21:34

I know times are different now, but I'd still be a bit weirded out by a man that's still living at home at 25 tbh.

There's saving and there's mooching.

PingvsPong · 25/02/2024 21:30

CowCuddler · 25/02/2024 19:56

For this reason exactly it would put me off.

I have children and so won't have my place as the default address. A past partner had his own flat then had to move back in with his mum for various reasons. Killed the relationship as we had nowhere to go after a few drinks.

Also, I'd worry that he'd very quickly be at hers all the time, cocklodger before you know it.

Maybe it's perspective but I wouldn't be put off by a 'childhood bedroom'. Unless it genuinely looked like, well, a child's bedroom.
Same with parents as well, unless they were cold/unwelcoming/judging whatsoever. My exes who lived at home well their parents just left us to it.

I suppose it's also because in London, where a lot of my dating was, a shared house was more of a problem. No kitchen space, rules on overnight guests, drama etc I found people living at home much easier. Of course owning their own place, or sharing a flat with one other person would be ideal but not everyone has that.

@Allshallbewell2021 sadly those conditions don't describe most desirable areas in the UK, in 2023.
Although, I'd raise an eyebrow at someone earning a good salary, living in a cheap place but choosing not to move out. Think teacher or nurse in a more deprived area whose salaries would be higher than average as based on the national payscale.

But then again. Maybe they want to save to move out of said deprived area as quickly as possible. Idk.

No matter what I think we're all entitled to be out off by whatever we want. And be as choosy as possible. So what I think is immaterial.

Allshallbewell2021 · 25/02/2024 20:22

I think it's very common in other countries, it used to be the case Italy. It's also a great use of resources and a companionable way to live.

Where there are low rents, decent pay and job security, why not move out?

CowCuddler · 25/02/2024 19:56

JonVoightBaddyWhoGrowls · 23/02/2024 12:05

I think also, in my 20s, one of the reasons I didn't like it was how do you conduct a relationship in that scenario? So date 2, you've had a few drinks, things are getting heated and what? You go back to his childhood bedroom? Doesn't exactly make me feel sexy and adult. And then what, meet his mum the next morning over coffee? OR, from date 2, your place becomes the default place because its easier so you're almost immediately into that zone of being the host, and the one doing all the prep work etc etc etc.

No, sorry, not for me.

For this reason exactly it would put me off.

I have children and so won't have my place as the default address. A past partner had his own flat then had to move back in with his mum for various reasons. Killed the relationship as we had nowhere to go after a few drinks.

Also, I'd worry that he'd very quickly be at hers all the time, cocklodger before you know it.

Chouquettes · 25/02/2024 17:15

Manthide · 25/02/2024 13:13

My brother has weeks to live and he's meant to be going home this week (he's been in hospital since Christmas). Dh said no he's not going home he's going to his parents' home! Well he can't go back to his own home as he needs a lot if care and he considers it going home! In fact he might have to go straight into a hospice which is really sad as I know he really wants to go home. He went in as a day case!

I’m so sorry to read this.

gannett · 25/02/2024 16:10

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 12:01

It’s bizarre to me that anyone other than the most timid types would even contemplate returning home from an independent life at university, and restrict themselves to considering jobs that would allow them to live with their parents at a time in their lives when they won’t generally have children, commitments or things tying them to a specific place, but are very free.

The world is your oyster, but, no, you’re going to go and live in your childhood bedroom so you can ‘save for a deposit’.

Which is obviously your choice, but wouldn’t work for me. If I were single and in my 30s, it would be a clear signal we had very different attitudes to life.

But not everyone is you and has your life experience.

I did exactly the same as you - when I left home for university I knew I'd never be back. I had a toxic family to escape, I hated where I'd grown up and I knew I had to be in London for the career I wanted.

If I'd had good parents with a big house in London? I would have absolutely loved to take advantage of that luck. Why on earth wouldn't I? Everyone I know who had parents in London lived with them well into their 20s and none of them were harmed by it, quite the opposite.

gannett · 25/02/2024 16:05

I don't think someone never having moved out tells you anything because there could be any number of reasons for it. I think it'd be fairly stupid to judge anyone for this without knowing the reasons (as many posters have done on this thread) and that would be more of a red flag, tbh.

Some reasons might be legitimately off-putting (the worst case scenario loafer who can't do anything independently), others are fine (caring responsibilities, saving up with a specific goal to move out). Plus the rental market these days fucks people over even more than it did when I was renting. When I was in my 20s one of my best friends (female) lived with her mum and she didn't move out until she met her now-husband. It wasn't what she wanted ideally but it made no sense to throw money down the drain of London rented houseshares when she could live at home and save up. Didn't mean she wasn't independent or hadn't grown up.

Most people I know who are living with their parents into their 30s are female and all of them (male and female) are perfectly well-adjusted. Doesn't mean the opposite can't happen but it does mean it's incredibly idiotic to assume the worst.

Longma · 25/02/2024 15:49

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Chouquettes · 25/02/2024 15:24

Would she rather him be living in a little bedsit with little disposable income? Or sharing a flat which is sort of what he’s doing anyway with his parents?

Maddy70 · 25/02/2024 15:16

Why?

Longma · 25/02/2024 15:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

StaunchMomma · 25/02/2024 14:56

Would depend on the person & circumstances, for me.

If they'd never moved out because they were generally immature, weren't working & wanted to be looked after by Mummy then it would put me off.

If they're a lovely person, not awfully confident or working in a male dominated workplace, hence no relationship and has been saving for a house deposit those 8 years post uni then absolutely not.

Sometimes women put way too much stock in some ridiculous 'dating rules' that mean they miss out on a genuinely good bloke.

Groovy48592747 · 25/02/2024 14:49

Absolutely it would put me off. 30's and still living at parents? The lack of independence is not exactly inspiring.

Sounds like a loser.

Cheshiresun · 25/02/2024 14:47

I've got a cousin like that. In his 30's and has never left home. Would put me off, yes, if they're anything like him!

PingvsPong · 25/02/2024 14:26

breadandroses1992 · 25/02/2024 13:26

I am aware it wasn't totally easy for the older people, my mother in law bought a flat and moved in with all her things in garbage bags. We bought flats in the same area of London though at the same age (i was 27 and dh was 29). She was a secretary and her husband was a legal executive, flat was 3 times income. We borrowed 4.7 times income and dh was an analyst at an investment bank (and I was in same industry) and we stayed at home for 3 years to save up. Our mortgage is now 2.3 times our household income but we are in early 30s and have moved job several times to scale up income..

Sorry for my generation, you need to inherit or do something Big I. E. Live really frugally which is easier with no rent, get a really good job or career earning at least 6 figures, marry well or work in public sector which allows you to live in the dwindling number of cheaper areas (which probably wouldn't be cheap in 5 years time relative to stagnant wages in public sector as everyone would get the same idea). You need favourable circumstances either by design or by your own decisions. That is the difference.

Most people don't have all options on the table so they need to make the best of what they can do. Or they will face the consequences in their 40s.

Edited

Yep. @Bigearringsbigsmile have a look at wage to house price ratio stats.
Also I'm only saying what my colleagues, other people in their 50's said. if you think they're wrong then maybe you should take it up with your peers.

PingvsPong · 25/02/2024 14:25

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 13:01

I’m 51, @PingvsPong, from an extremely poor background, have been supporting my own parents and helping my younger siblings from pretty much the moment I left home, and I can assure you there was no culture of ‘bumming around’ among the people I knew, or my university cohort, with the knowledge of an eventual ‘good job” waiting. My country was in a deep recession, with high unemployment, so few jobs of any kind, ‘good’ or otherwise, waiting. No 100% mortgages, no parental deposits. But I refused to barter the freest time in my life for ‘savings’.

Bearing in mind that freedom means no restrictions. You supporting your family doesn't sound particularly free to me. I don't know what you did with the 'freest time of your life' but you presumably had to either earn well or restrict your spending to do the above. You may not have had children, but you certainly seem to have had erm responsibilities.

What I find odd is that you equate 'not staying at home' to freedom. If you explicitly want a world traveller, frequent mover, that's fine. But to say that someone staying at home 'restricts themselves' makes no sense. Someone could live away from home but stay in the same town and work the same job all their lives.

What PP was saying is that if you have the choice between renting and staying at home. In the same place. The latter makes more financial sense. They are not saying that you should restrict yourself to living at home and never moving anywhere else. As @breadandroses1992 put it her DH was already from London, with a wealth of opportunity. If he was going to stay there anyway. Why should he pay rent? What benefit would it have brought him?

Also, those living at home can be free (if their parents are chill). Spending on whatever they like, travelling whenever they want. They could move out, if they want to so there's no restriction here really. DH parents had a big enough house for people to stay over, GF's, roll in at 2 a.m. no issue. He left to work elsewhere but if he'd stayed home he'd have lost nothing, but gained £££.

I'm sure there are some who want to live at home and base their life choices around it, a lot of them probably have SEN but IME those who live at home - they'd have rented in the same place anyway. People are not giving up, say London life for a rural backwater just to save.

SusieSussex · 25/02/2024 13:34

If anyone has seen the lovely Victoria Wood film "That Day we Sang." The character Jimmy lived with his mother til his 50s but you wouldn't turn him down would you? He was lovely.

SusieSussex · 25/02/2024 13:30

No I don't think so, even though I moved out young myself. I'd think it was positive he had good enough family relationships to do this. (I didn't) If the mum was on her own I'd think it was helpful to her to have company so he was kind. He may have saved more towards a house rather than spending it on rent.

SerenChocolateMuncher · 25/02/2024 13:27

Manthide · 25/02/2024 13:13

My brother has weeks to live and he's meant to be going home this week (he's been in hospital since Christmas). Dh said no he's not going home he's going to his parents' home! Well he can't go back to his own home as he needs a lot if care and he considers it going home! In fact he might have to go straight into a hospice which is really sad as I know he really wants to go home. He went in as a day case!

How terribly sad for your family. Wherever your brother goes for his end of life care, I hope he is able to spend time and receive comfort from the people he loves. ❤️

NatMoz · 25/02/2024 13:26

Think it depends on circumstances.

My brother lives at home rent free so has been able to by a house which is now mortgage free.

However he has chosen not to live in this house he has purchased as it would mean having to pay bills, wash his own clothes and feed himself whilst also having to deal with any plumbing/DIY/boiler issues that may arise so for him, it is a no brainer to stay at home rather than having to do jobs when arriving home from work.

He is single.

breadandroses1992 · 25/02/2024 13:26

Bigearringsbigsmile · 25/02/2024 13:06

Erm....no! The ' younger generation ' have such a fucked view of how easy people in their 50s had it!

I am aware it wasn't totally easy for the older people, my mother in law bought a flat and moved in with all her things in garbage bags. We bought flats in the same area of London though at the same age (i was 27 and dh was 29). She was a secretary and her husband was a legal executive, flat was 3 times income. We borrowed 4.7 times income and dh was an analyst at an investment bank (and I was in same industry) and we stayed at home for 3 years to save up. Our mortgage is now 2.3 times our household income but we are in early 30s and have moved job several times to scale up income..

Sorry for my generation, you need to inherit or do something Big I. E. Live really frugally which is easier with no rent, get a really good job or career earning at least 6 figures, marry well or work in public sector which allows you to live in the dwindling number of cheaper areas (which probably wouldn't be cheap in 5 years time relative to stagnant wages in public sector as everyone would get the same idea). You need favourable circumstances either by design or by your own decisions. That is the difference.

Most people don't have all options on the table so they need to make the best of what they can do. Or they will face the consequences in their 40s.

Manthide · 25/02/2024 13:19

ReadingLight · 25/02/2024 11:00

In fairness, around here they are paying quite insane sums for accommodation., and half of the places we lived in when we were students would probably be condemned as unsafe now. I lived somewhere once that was so cold I used to wear a jumper in the bath, rolled up out of way of the water…😀

I set fire to my jumper (I was wearing it) because I was so cold I was practically sitting in the gas fire - which some relative of the ll has put in (probably not a qualified gas fitter).

Wolfpa · 25/02/2024 13:15

It depends why he never moved out, if it was because they were not capable that would put me off. If it was because there was no need I would be fine with it.

Manthide · 25/02/2024 13:13

SerenChocolateMuncher · 25/02/2024 11:46

I find it a bit childish when adults refer to themselves or other adults living with parents as "living at home" or "still living at home" as if their own "home" isn't or couldn't be a proper home. As if they are just playing at being adults in their pretend home.

I realise for some it's just something people say without thinking, but I am surprised how many people well into adulthood (and presumably most of them parents themselves given that this is "Mumsnet") have a persistent subconscious belief that only a parents' home is "home".

When I bought my first flat I didn't "leave home", I left my parents' home for my own new home.

Edited

My brother has weeks to live and he's meant to be going home this week (he's been in hospital since Christmas). Dh said no he's not going home he's going to his parents' home! Well he can't go back to his own home as he needs a lot if care and he considers it going home! In fact he might have to go straight into a hospice which is really sad as I know he really wants to go home. He went in as a day case!

Swipe left for the next trending thread