Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spending downsizing cash

362 replies

CueilleLeJour · 23/02/2024 11:27

I'm really not sure if I'm being unreasonable here.

Mum is 87 and downsized a few years after we lost my dad. She bought a nice little flat and had £150K from the sale.

Growing up, we never had much money and dad kept a close hand on the purse strings. Mum was left with a comfortable but not huge pension, and some moderate savings which she has spent over the last few years.

Since downsizing, she has basically had access to more free money than she's ever had in her life. In the last year, she's spent nearly half the £150k. Mostly on the flat - new kitchen, bathroom, carpets, furniture, professional decorating etc - but also an expensive holiday. It's clearly been an amazing feeling for her to have all the money she could dream of and spend it without my dad's disapproving eye peering over her shoulder. Part of me thinks it's great and she should just enjoy it while she can.

But part of me is really alarmed at her getting through half the proceeds in a year, and I worry about possible future care needs. My BIL's mum is 90 and has been in a care home for 3 years and it's just burning cash. They wouldn't let her in without proving she had 2 years of costs up front - which I think was about 140K.

My mum is just convinced she won't ever need a care home, and I know she's better off than many people who have nothing put by. It's also really none of my business, it's her money to do what she wants with. It's not dementia or anything, just someone who has never really had to make financial decisions having a whale of a time splashing the cash.

But am I right to have a little anxiety about it all?

YABU You only live once, she's right to spend it while she can
YANBU It's a bit reckless to spend half your downsizing profits in the first year

OP posts:
Flowerfairie · 26/02/2024 00:20

New kitchen, bathroom, carpets, furniture, professional decorating etc. It soon adds up. She wouldn’t have got much change from £40-50k for the kitchen and bathroom alone

in a massive house perhaps but not a flat and I live in London and have had both done.

ClairDeLaLune · 26/02/2024 00:20

toomuchfaff · 23/02/2024 12:21

Personally I'd be telling her to transfer ownership of the flat into a trust so that it doesn't get taken with care fees (that may or may not be needed).

Not everyone goes in a home, why are you telling her to not enjoy her life just in case she needs to go in a home. Having been a nurse for many years, many elder people just drop dead; stroke, heart attack etc. or they succumb after a short illness brought on by something like a car crash (broken ribs), a fall or a broken hip.

Think about what you'll feel guilt over when she is gone, will you wish you'd told her to cut back so she could afford care fees (that weren't needed)? or will you regret telling her to not spend? not supporting her and encouraging her to gain some happiness in her later years and do XY & Z when she wanted too and had the ability too? Even if that xyz is decorating her place or doing the garden or going on holiday... whatever gives her joy, even if you don't agree with her choices.

Let her enjoy spending the cash she has that she didn't get chance to spend in her previous 87 yrs of life. Or is the real story that she's spending your inheritance?

Personally I'd be telling her to transfer ownership of the flat into a trust so that it doesn't get taken with care fees (that may or may not be needed).

DO NOT DO THIS. This is unbelievably bad advice. It’s deliberate deprivation of assets. The money can still be claimed to pay for care, and your mum would lose the amount spent on the trust to a lawyer who would have to be extremely dodgy to agree to do this. Why tf would you advise anyone to do this, you are clearly clueless.

OP, as long as your mum’s flat is valued at least enough to fund 2 or 3 years’ care, whatever is required in your area, then she can spend all her money without losing out from a care perspective.

carelesser · 26/02/2024 00:14

Mostly on the flat - new kitchen, bathroom, carpets, furniture, professional decorating etc

Is the flat future proofed for her? I.e. is it ground floor, does the building have a lift, is the bathroom a wet room with special non slip lino?

If not, I agree she’s wasted an opportunity with the cash.

I think the subtext under a lot of the posts berating you OP is that ultimately a lot of these posters see you as back up care for your mother.

I think you need to be clear to your mum that she can’t move in with you and you can’t be her full time carer so she needs to consider that when managing her finances.

Fother · 25/02/2024 23:49

Sunandsea26 · 25/02/2024 14:41

Hmmm my best friend is going through an awful time atm with care for her dad so i would share your anxiety. She has basically been told that the nhs won’t cover his care, and once the families savings are rinsed, it’s on them. So it may fall onto you. I never had a clue this could happen but it really can!

This is not correct.

Harry12345 · 25/02/2024 23:24

Sunandsea26 · 25/02/2024 14:41

Hmmm my best friend is going through an awful time atm with care for her dad so i would share your anxiety. She has basically been told that the nhs won’t cover his care, and once the families savings are rinsed, it’s on them. So it may fall onto you. I never had a clue this could happen but it really can!

Family’s aren’t responsible financially for their parents care needs

Frangipanyoul8r · 25/02/2024 23:02

Care homes aren’t inevitable. Sadly mine and my DH’s elderly relatives all died quite quickly with support from relatives and hospice care while they stayed at home.

Let your mum spend her money and have fun.

Catza · 25/02/2024 22:42

Btwmum23 · 25/02/2024 21:26

Good care home cost average £4K a month, that is £720k in 15 years. Consider the pension (let’s say £1.5k a month) this is £450. Consider the sale of the house after taxes, depending where you live you might not even need any top up meaning you can spend any savings you want. Again we are talking about people who are relatively well off (good pension and one property) but not very rich at all. Totally attenable by many.

‘Totally attainable for many” makes an assumption that I am a single person household with paid off mortgage and that I go from being employed FT straight to the care home at the age of 68 which will allow me to spend my pension directly on care home fees.
Where is my partner supposed to go? How am I supposed to save £720 if I spend my salary paying off the mortgage and have to live on my pension between the ages of 68 and 80. Where is that £270k supposed to come from?

RosesAndHellebores · 25/02/2024 22:31

Let her enjoy herself. My 87 year old mother is waiting for urgent, life saving surgery. Without it she's got 9 months tops. I'm glad she's spent the last 25 years enjoying herself and cruising! She could drop dead at any time at present.

Let your mother enjoy herself.

Viviennemary · 25/02/2024 22:28

What do you mean 'more free money? She has spent a lot in a year but it doesn't sound as if the money has been squandered but spent sensibly on a holiday and refurbishing her home.

GinForBreakfast · 25/02/2024 22:09

Plan for the worst, hope for the best. I am right in the middle of an elderly relative having to make really tough decisions on finances and care and it's really hard on her. She wants to be in her own home with 24 hour care but realistically she needs to sell her house to afford care. It's a very difficult conversation and it would have been better to have had it 10 years ago.

Your mum is entitled to do what she wants with her money but you can help her understand the consequences of her decisions before it becomes a crisis situation. I would recommend setting up a LPOA ASAP (bitter experience). At older ages things can change in an instant.

FinallyFeb · 25/02/2024 21:56

Slightly concerned that you'll be left looking after her...wow do you realise how awful you make that sound.

The OP doesn’t sound awful, not everyone can be safely looked after by a relative, things aren’t as simple as that.

Singlemumto4k · 25/02/2024 21:53

CueilleLeJour · 23/02/2024 12:35

I'm not telling her anything! It's just been slightly alarming to watch.

Transfer the ownership of the flat so it isn't used for care home fees - so manipulate her finances to let the state pick up the bill? I'm not at all interested in protecting any inheritance, I'm just concerned about her possible future welfare. And maybe slightly concerned we will end up looking after her or paying for her care, but I don't think that's my main worry.

Slightly concerned that you'll be left looking after her...wow do you realise how awful you make that sound. I would have given anything to be able to take care of my mum but had that chance cruelly taken away from me by my own sister. My mum was 60 when she passed away after being dumped in a care home by my sister which I wasn't even aware of till I got a phone call 3 days after being put in there saying she had died
Let her enjoy the time she has left

Drearydiedre · 25/02/2024 21:47

She has the flat to cover care costs. As long as her pension is covering day to day living incase the savings are depleted.

You should bear in mind that not everyone will require care and out of those who do it is more often than not for just a few months.

I think there is no reason to intervene if she is in a good mental state and not being taken advantage of by trades people etc.

It is a real positive that she seems to be enjoying this time. Many 87 year olds would not have the motivation to improve their home to such an extent!

BIossomtoes · 25/02/2024 21:39

Flowerfairie · 25/02/2024 20:22

£75k on decorating and one holiday is a hell of an amount. She’s not being ripped off is she? I had a whole floor added to my house for less than that.

New kitchen, bathroom, carpets, furniture, professional decorating etc. It soon adds up. She wouldn’t have got much change from £40-50k for the kitchen and bathroom alone.

Soontobe60 · 25/02/2024 21:33

CueilleLeJour · 23/02/2024 12:35

I'm not telling her anything! It's just been slightly alarming to watch.

Transfer the ownership of the flat so it isn't used for care home fees - so manipulate her finances to let the state pick up the bill? I'm not at all interested in protecting any inheritance, I'm just concerned about her possible future welfare. And maybe slightly concerned we will end up looking after her or paying for her care, but I don't think that's my main worry.

Well done you! Too many people think the opposite!
Dont panic, you will not be expected to pay for her care. If she had to go into care tomorrow, she should have enough savings left to pay for at least a year from what you say. Then depending on the value of her flat, she’ll have longer. Her flat could be rented out until her savings have gone - that would make more sense as it should increase in value (plus generate some income from renting it out).

Btwmum23 · 25/02/2024 21:26

Catza · 25/02/2024 20:08

Care homes cost more than I earn in a year. I highly doubt it is realistic for most people to save approximately a million quid by the age of 80, especially after retirement. Good plan, but completely unattainable

Good care home cost average £4K a month, that is £720k in 15 years. Consider the pension (let’s say £1.5k a month) this is £450. Consider the sale of the house after taxes, depending where you live you might not even need any top up meaning you can spend any savings you want. Again we are talking about people who are relatively well off (good pension and one property) but not very rich at all. Totally attenable by many.

UKAus · 25/02/2024 20:40

YABU. She is 87, always had someone control her choices, especially the generation she is from. Let her spend it all if she wishes. She has downsized and made her home comfortable. She isn't down the casino. She has all her faculties. Leave her to have as much enjoyment as she can. A Lot of people don't bother making their homes nicer or more comfortable at her age and just wait for decline. What you have described sounds Marvellous. Good on her. An expensive holiday, wish I reach 87 and do exactly as she has done. When I started reading your post I was worried she had bailed out younger relatives or something else. But she hasn't. Spent it on her home and a holiday! Great! And in the future you can look back on this time and know your mum really enjoyed a comfortable time at home and on holiday. She still has half left. Now if she started re doing the whole flat again, then I would be concerned.

Iwasafool · 25/02/2024 20:38

CueilleLeJour · 23/02/2024 12:35

I'm not telling her anything! It's just been slightly alarming to watch.

Transfer the ownership of the flat so it isn't used for care home fees - so manipulate her finances to let the state pick up the bill? I'm not at all interested in protecting any inheritance, I'm just concerned about her possible future welfare. And maybe slightly concerned we will end up looking after her or paying for her care, but I don't think that's my main worry.

I have POA for a 90 year old relative. Yes care homes are expensive but it isn't all gloom and doom. My relative has been in the home, not a cheap one it is more than £4k a month. She has her state pension, her works pension which is small, half of her late husbands works pension and she gets extra because of his SERPs add to that attendance allowance which you can claim if you are paying your own fees. To top that up we have an IFA who looks after the money from the sale of her house. He has calculated she would have to live to 120 for the money to run out. She didn't own a mansion, a 3 bed house in a midlands city.

Flowerfairie · 25/02/2024 20:22

£75k on decorating and one holiday is a hell of an amount. She’s not being ripped off is she? I had a whole floor added to my house for less than that.

Catza · 25/02/2024 20:08

Btwmum23 · 25/02/2024 19:44

Check the monthly cost of a good care home. From when you are 80 keep 15 years of savings to cover it. Any year you are not there you can spend the yearly sum. Till there you need to save. So no stop spending anymore but be careful. This is if you want to be taken care in a good care home or do not weight on your kids. Otherwise you can just keep on splashing on holidays new cars new clothes and new furniture. of course if you have that money to start with, but we are talking about spending in “fun” or savings so we assume the person has money

Care homes cost more than I earn in a year. I highly doubt it is realistic for most people to save approximately a million quid by the age of 80, especially after retirement. Good plan, but completely unattainable

VickyEadieofThigh · 25/02/2024 19:49

Hayliebells · 25/02/2024 19:43

Thanks @VickyEadieofThigh. It sounds like the OP's mum isn't even in the ball park of being guilty of depravation of assets, so what are all the posters warning about this going on about?

Because a few have given "advice" that is poor - and I always work on the 'what you say on here is read by a wide variety of people' principle!

Yogatoga1 · 25/02/2024 19:46

Hayliebells · 25/02/2024 19:16

Are people not allowed to enjoy their money after a certain age incase they need care? At what age does depravation of assets become a consideration? My mother in her late 70s is thoroughly enjoying herself. She's going on more (expensive) holidays than she ever has before, her logic being that she's in good health so she's going to do it whilst she still can. Surely everyone who spend any money over and above basic living costs is guilty of depravation of assets should they need care, at any age. What's the criteria that LAs use?

It’s not age related.

basically you cannot give away money to intentionally avoid care costs.

so a fit, healthy 70 year old living independently with no expectation of needing future care, can give away or spend what they want and there is no deprivation of assets.

a 70 year old who is increasingly frail, sells her home and moves in with her daughter as she is struggling to cope alone, giving her daughter the proceeds of the house sale. At this point is is reasonable to think that this lady will need care to some extent, whether that’s in home care or nursing home. That is deprivation of assets and the LA will come after the house sale funds to pay for her care.

it also applies if she deliberately spends it, say she pays for an extension on her daughters home.

Btwmum23 · 25/02/2024 19:44

BobnLen · 23/02/2024 12:49

So is there a certain age when you should stop spending any money, not go on holiday, do up your house or buy a car because you should save it for care.

Just so I know...

Check the monthly cost of a good care home. From when you are 80 keep 15 years of savings to cover it. Any year you are not there you can spend the yearly sum. Till there you need to save. So no stop spending anymore but be careful. This is if you want to be taken care in a good care home or do not weight on your kids. Otherwise you can just keep on splashing on holidays new cars new clothes and new furniture. of course if you have that money to start with, but we are talking about spending in “fun” or savings so we assume the person has money

CueilleLeJour · 25/02/2024 19:44

Thanks everybody for your thoughts - even those who've said it's none of my business and I'm only concerned about my inheritance!

Just for the record, my dad wasn't abusive, they just didn't have much money and he was very careful with what they had. They had a happy retirement together with a lot of travel, she wasn't living in a flat with peeling wallpaper and she gets out and about all the time. She's amazing and I am very happy that she's happy.

There is no question of me trying to stop her spending her own money. If she could know how long she has left and time her money to last her remaining years, that would be fantastic.

But that's not how old age works, is it? I suspect most of us would prefer to go without warning while we are still active and healthy, but we don't actually get the choice. And a significant number of us (more like 25% than 99% though!) will need long term care.

I've seen with my in laws how not having to worry about money made dealing with dementia very slightly easier. They could buy in as much respite care as they needed and choose an expensive care home without having to think twice. It was still harrowing, but money gave them choices that someone without money would not have.

I think the quite traumatic and drawn out deaths of my father and FIL, which took a huge toll on all of us, have left me very anxious about how we are going to cope when the mums, who both live on their own, need more support than we currently need to give.

However, it's been really helpful to be robustly told to stop worrying.

I'm not going to tell her to stop, it may not end up being a problem, and if it is we will muddle through it somehow.

Thanks everyone.

OP posts:
Hayliebells · 25/02/2024 19:43

Thanks @VickyEadieofThigh. It sounds like the OP's mum isn't even in the ball park of being guilty of depravation of assets, so what are all the posters warning about this going on about?