Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Visits after having a baby

237 replies

KlaudH · 23/02/2024 10:28

Hi all! I’m new here, but I read some threads on Mumsnet over the last number of months. I just want some advice as I’m 34 weeks pregnant tomorrow with my first baby and I’m thinking about visitors post birth. I said it to my husband probably around 2 months ago that I’d like 5-7 days with no visitors after birth. I could tell he didn’t really understand it, but he agreed. I also said it to my mum in law at my baby shower earlier this month that we would like a few days after the birth just for the three of us. She looked a little taken aback, but agreed.
This week, however, I heard that my MIL was really upset that she might not be able to see her grandson for around a week after he’s born and asked my husband if she can see him the day after he’s born or even the second or third day for half an hour as she wants to see the baby soon after he’s born, because newborns change a lot in the first few days and when she gave birth to her children her mum saw her babies nearly straightaway. My husband would be willing for her and his dad and brother to come as soon as possible after birth, but I don’t feel comfortable with that. I will be having a home birth and I’ve never given birth before so I don’t know what it’s going to be like and how I’m going to be feeling afterwards. I don’t want to have any visits looming over me right after I give birth (also, it’s going to be in my home). I would like to have a few days to bond with my baby and husband and recover a bit after birth without feeling a need to be physically or emotionally ready/presentable to have guests, (and I don’t know if they would actually stay for half an hour)…
I think it’s worth mentioning as well that I spoke to my mum about this and although she would love to see the baby as soon as possible she respects that I don’t want visitors for a few days. I actually ended up reducing the time to 3 days, but I hope to keep it that way. My husband is going to talk to his mum and hopefully she will be fine with the 3 days as I don’t want our relationship to be strained (I have been getting along well with her so far) as I can tell she’s annoyed with me.. She knows it’s me who wants the few days and not my husband.. I can already see that when the baby’s arrival is close the mother’s comfort and preferences go out the window.. Thank you for reading, sorry it’s so long! AIBU?

OP posts:
WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 21:27

Zanatdy · 23/02/2024 21:03

Always make me think how the DP’s in this situation feel. No doubt forced to go along with it. It’s horrible how MIL’s are viewed on MN. Mine was far from perfect and many would be horrified if I shared some of that less than perfect on here but she deserved to meet her grandchildren and I’d have never said my parents not yours.

My husband could care less about anyone else’s feelings or health but mine and the babies. I thought this was standard for grown men who have supported their partner during pregnancy but I guess it’s common to feel appeasing your mother is the number one priority whilst your partner goes through pregnancy, childbirth and postpartum.

TheFairyCaravan · 23/02/2024 21:25

Zanatdy · 23/02/2024 21:03

Always make me think how the DP’s in this situation feel. No doubt forced to go along with it. It’s horrible how MIL’s are viewed on MN. Mine was far from perfect and many would be horrified if I shared some of that less than perfect on here but she deserved to meet her grandchildren and I’d have never said my parents not yours.

When I read some of these threads, it always makes me so incredibly grateful for my DDIL. All through her pregnancy she included us, she, or DS2 has sent photos and videos of DGS every day since he was born and we FaceTime multiple times a week. She had a wonderful relationship with both her sets of grandparents and wants DGS to have the same.

Houseplanter · 23/02/2024 21:24

So @WannabeMum22 you're going to have your baby right next to you 24/7, with no one else helping, giving you a break. No chance for dad to nip downstairs and introduce baby to his parents, the new grandparents. No need for you to take a shower, have a minute to yourself

Totally, utterly self centred unreasonable and selfish. Are you so precious all the time?! Good luck when you expect grandparents to drop everything and provide free childcare.

FlyingHighFlyingLow · 23/02/2024 21:23

What's with the MIL bashing? Mine didn't see me as a grandchild incubator, we had a great relationship before I got pregnant, and when she arrived post birth first thing she did when she saw the baby was give me a huge hug with tears in her eyes and tell me how beautiful he was and how amazing I was. Before going to her own son that was holding said baby 😂 she certainly didn't push me out of the way. She also double checked I was ok with her coming, asked if we needed anything, bought food and flowers and chocolates for me. She was there for all three of us and is an awesome lady. She also asked if she could hold him (of course she could!) And went to wash her hands without even being asked. Her holding him and her face is a treasured memory.

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 21:22

Houseplanter · 23/02/2024 21:02

@WannabeMum22 you seem to be struggling with the idea that a son's child mean as much to a grandparent as a daughter child. To see your son become a parent and want to meet their newborn is no different to seeing your daughter be a mother.

My sons children mean the world to me

No I’m not struggling with anything. In fact very soon I’m going to have a son of my own - I’m 100% sure my love for my son and whatever children he may decide to have will not be contingent on me seeing them as soon as they are born. I don’t meet my nieces until they were 6 weeks old for a host of reasons and yet they both tell their parents we’re the closest people to them and we have an extremely tight bond. I’ll have no problem prioritising my son and his partners feelings in the postpartum period because that’s what is necessary. Happy to support in whatever capacity even if that means supporting from a distance whilst they bond and recover. That’s part of being a healthy adult in a functional family unit where you care about people beyond what they supply to you.

Mazuslongtoenail · 23/02/2024 21:21

Having a baby to look after 24 hours is a slog, it’s tiring and boring a lot of the time. People coming to visit adds joy and magic to it and makes it so special.

Reading all the posts about bit allowing grandparents to visit for a while make me a little sad. My parents and in laws have such a lovely relationship with their GC, they need to bond too.

I also don’t understand why you wouldn’t think yes I’ll take the opportunity to have a hot drink / shower / do anything that you’ve been wanting to for the last 48 hours.

MyInduction · 23/02/2024 21:20

movedtothecountry · 23/02/2024 20:56

So selfish. Also I bet you want your in laws to babysit now!

I was unwell after giving birth and I was in hospital for days. I have permanent damage from giving birth. If wanting my parents there makes me selfish then so be it. In laws don't live nearby.

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 21:18

Grammarmum · 23/02/2024 21:02

@WannabeMum22 ,why are you using such emotive language? Since when did anyone push a new mother out of the way and grab their baby ?

That’s exact what you describe when you suggest OP’s DH should leave her upstairs and take the baby she’s just given birth to, to his mother. Because of course it’s his mothers feelings that need to take priority here and not his wife, the mother of his child whose recovering from childbirth.

Galeforcewindatmywindow · 23/02/2024 21:16

When my dil had dgc her dm was with her the whole labour.. Didn't bother me as that was dil's choice. A week later it was Mother's Day and ds's birthday and they visited me at my home. Was amazing. We already had a great relationship.. Maybe different if mil is kept at arm's length before you have dc...

marathon123 · 23/02/2024 21:16

Millie890 · 23/02/2024 19:42

This is not a thread about birth. Expectant Mums don't need unasked for, negative opinions about their birth choice, keep it to yourself!

What are you on about ? I was adding to my comment that you can plan ahead as much as you like but nobody knows what will happen , in my case a much wanted home birth ended up in a weeks hospital stay after intervention, not just once but twice…… so mothers in laws getting upset about a theoretical plan of visiting is a bit pointless!

Tillycx · 23/02/2024 21:15

Zanatdy · 23/02/2024 21:03

Always make me think how the DP’s in this situation feel. No doubt forced to go along with it. It’s horrible how MIL’s are viewed on MN. Mine was far from perfect and many would be horrified if I shared some of that less than perfect on here but she deserved to meet her grandchildren and I’d have never said my parents not yours.

Yes is sad, DILS who plan some crazy scheme to shut everyone out and then expect everyone to be interested in them and their child when they click their fingers. The poor DP in these situations

ItsVeryHyacinthBucket · 23/02/2024 21:14

I’m not surprised that the vote on this has turned out 50/50.

First. Your baby, your rules. You can’t get the time back with them. Also you just don’t know how you’re going to feel yet, so play it by ear and remember to prioritise rest and your bond etc.

However, it does in reality make a difference to certain people around you if you refuse to let people meet your baby for a long time (weeks) after the birth. The baby then isn’t a newborn any more and that special stage is gone.

I recently started a thread because I was finding it hard my DBro and his wife weren’t allowing visitors. I still haven’t met my niece nearly 2 weeks after. I met their other child, my nephew, in the hospital right after he was born and it was really beautiful. To be honest, I’m pretty sad about it all this time. I won’t hold it against them but I feel like I’ve missed out on that beauty, awe and joyful moment with her and them. They wanted it all to themselves, that’s up to them and I don’t judge them for it - but I do feel sad.

pinkunicorns54 · 23/02/2024 21:09

I would see how you feel. All my hormones were crazy and I just wanted to show off this gorgeous new bundle I had created as soon as I could!

But that was DC2, DC1 we went into lockdown the day they were born... so that might have impacted that!

Ruffpuff · 23/02/2024 21:08

@KlaudH I felt this way after reading through Mumsnet while pregnant.

In the end we had family come to visit at the hospital and I was really glad they did. I was so happy and hormonal, I really wanted to ‘show off’ my new baby and I was glad to see familiar faces after a difficult birth.

Don’t assume you won’t want to see anyone because of Mumsnet.

Broodywuz · 23/02/2024 21:08

I think it's absolutely up to you and I really do understand the wanting some time just the 3 of you but i personally think mums (yours and DH's) don't really count as visitors. I couldn't wait for my mum to meet my babies and both my mum and mil were a godsend in the days after birth, nipping to the shop to pick up things, they brought food and helped out while I sat on the sofa breastfeeding. I guess it depends on your relationship with your mum and mil but don't shut them out. When you have your baby and imagine him/her having their own babies, you would want to be involved too, I don't think your mil is being mean or intentionally upsetting you

Millie890 · 23/02/2024 21:07

Zanatdy · 23/02/2024 21:03

Always make me think how the DP’s in this situation feel. No doubt forced to go along with it. It’s horrible how MIL’s are viewed on MN. Mine was far from perfect and many would be horrified if I shared some of that less than perfect on here but she deserved to meet her grandchildren and I’d have never said my parents not yours.

The Mum's the one giving birth and she's the one recovering so it's absolutely her choice who does and does not come into her space. Shouldn't be up for discussion!

Tillycx · 23/02/2024 21:07

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 20:57

why would you be devestated to wait seven days? what exactly would you be sad about other than a hit to your ego? can you explain logically the reason why you would be devestated?

Perhaps if someone has a very distant relationship with their DD they wouldn’t see this as an issue?? I felt awfully sorry for my DIL and her mother when they couldn’t see each other after the birth of her first child in lockdown as that’s the normal relationship most mother’s and daughter’s have. Even as an adult if my DD was sick in hospital I would want to be with her asap and she would no doubt want me there too, same with my mum if it were me. Can understand you don’t necessarily want mother coming to stay and being there all the time as you want alone time with baby plus time with just you and your husband and your new baby, however rejecting even a short visit from your own mother (if you normally get on well) seems quite sad and sad for DH too that he’s not allowed to include his parents

Zanatdy · 23/02/2024 21:03

movedtothecountry · 23/02/2024 20:56

So selfish. Also I bet you want your in laws to babysit now!

Always make me think how the DP’s in this situation feel. No doubt forced to go along with it. It’s horrible how MIL’s are viewed on MN. Mine was far from perfect and many would be horrified if I shared some of that less than perfect on here but she deserved to meet her grandchildren and I’d have never said my parents not yours.

Houseplanter · 23/02/2024 21:02

@WannabeMum22 you seem to be struggling with the idea that a son's child mean as much to a grandparent as a daughter child. To see your son become a parent and want to meet their newborn is no different to seeing your daughter be a mother.

My sons children mean the world to me

Grammarmum · 23/02/2024 21:02

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 20:59

that's exactly why people don't want their MIL's round. who wants someone who just wants to push them out of the way and grab their brand new baby whilst they are trying to recover from giving birth? certainly not me.

@WannabeMum22 ,why are you using such emotive language? Since when did anyone push a new mother out of the way and grab their baby ?

Tillycx · 23/02/2024 20:59

Zanatdy · 23/02/2024 20:48

I understand the disappointment. I personally found it easier to have DP’s parents round as soon as child was born, they came anyway to give us a lift home and then it was over with for another week to two whilst I was still feeling upbeat after the birth. With DD they brought BIL and SIL (who actually didn’t allow people to even hold their first born for a few weeks). I gave birth at 5 and they were all there for 7 and we had to order takeaway pizza and they stuck around until 10. But then I had time to get bf established etc and they’d had their first visit. My family had to wait a bit as they live 250 miles away. I would want to strike a balance with grandparents and allow a quick half hour visit on day of birth or day after but your choice. I think people often think mothers get too precious over it and it does cause upset. But do what’s right for you. But let your DP have a say too

Agree with this, a half hour visit by GP the day after the birth (or evening if an early morning birth) quite normal and appropriate. A visit within 2 hours of giving birth by other family who then stay for hours is totally unreasonable and would say absolutely do not accept this. I do wonder if wise advice to have some reasonable boundaries has been misunderstood and totally blown out of proportion by OP

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 20:59

Neverpostagain · 23/02/2024 20:38

I doubt very much mil wants to see you. She wants to see the baby. Why can't she do that? Your DH can facilitate it and you can stay upstairs or vice versa.

that's exactly why people don't want their MIL's round. who wants someone who just wants to push them out of the way and grab their brand new baby whilst they are trying to recover from giving birth? certainly not me.

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 20:57

Tillycx · 23/02/2024 20:27

Can’t agree more, I do feel sorry for the dh as this attitude would rather set the tone if this had been my DIL. It’s one thing holding off extended family and friends for a couple of weeks and not agreeing to prolonged visits, people coming to stay etc for several weeks but this is your closest family. I’d be devastated if my daughter told me I couldn’t see her or baby for a week after she’d just given birth (she’s already told me she would like me there for the birth if she has children) I had my mum with me, having been through it I can’t imagine having wanted her to stay away. It is up to the OP but as long as doesn’t go complaining about everyone not fawning enough over her and baby later on, is quite sad

why would you be devestated to wait seven days? what exactly would you be sad about other than a hit to your ego? can you explain logically the reason why you would be devestated?

Olika · 23/02/2024 20:57

Personally I didn't want any visitors during the first week as I was recovering and getting my head around of everything, and anyway HV was over every few days. I didn't also care if someone was upset about it.
Do whatever you fe is best for you and the baby. Just make sure your DH in on the same page.

movedtothecountry · 23/02/2024 20:56

MyInduction · 23/02/2024 20:30

I wanted to see my parents soon after my dd's birth as I'd been through a lot and birth and recovery was not easy. I said no to in laws and Mil kicked up a fuss. In laws visited when baby was a week old.

So selfish. Also I bet you want your in laws to babysit now!