Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Visits after having a baby

237 replies

KlaudH · 23/02/2024 10:28

Hi all! I’m new here, but I read some threads on Mumsnet over the last number of months. I just want some advice as I’m 34 weeks pregnant tomorrow with my first baby and I’m thinking about visitors post birth. I said it to my husband probably around 2 months ago that I’d like 5-7 days with no visitors after birth. I could tell he didn’t really understand it, but he agreed. I also said it to my mum in law at my baby shower earlier this month that we would like a few days after the birth just for the three of us. She looked a little taken aback, but agreed.
This week, however, I heard that my MIL was really upset that she might not be able to see her grandson for around a week after he’s born and asked my husband if she can see him the day after he’s born or even the second or third day for half an hour as she wants to see the baby soon after he’s born, because newborns change a lot in the first few days and when she gave birth to her children her mum saw her babies nearly straightaway. My husband would be willing for her and his dad and brother to come as soon as possible after birth, but I don’t feel comfortable with that. I will be having a home birth and I’ve never given birth before so I don’t know what it’s going to be like and how I’m going to be feeling afterwards. I don’t want to have any visits looming over me right after I give birth (also, it’s going to be in my home). I would like to have a few days to bond with my baby and husband and recover a bit after birth without feeling a need to be physically or emotionally ready/presentable to have guests, (and I don’t know if they would actually stay for half an hour)…
I think it’s worth mentioning as well that I spoke to my mum about this and although she would love to see the baby as soon as possible she respects that I don’t want visitors for a few days. I actually ended up reducing the time to 3 days, but I hope to keep it that way. My husband is going to talk to his mum and hopefully she will be fine with the 3 days as I don’t want our relationship to be strained (I have been getting along well with her so far) as I can tell she’s annoyed with me.. She knows it’s me who wants the few days and not my husband.. I can already see that when the baby’s arrival is close the mother’s comfort and preferences go out the window.. Thank you for reading, sorry it’s so long! AIBU?

OP posts:
Tillycx · 23/02/2024 22:19

muggart · 23/02/2024 22:10

I can already see that when the baby’s arrival is close the mother’s comfort and preferences go out the window

You sound like you're being a little precious if I'm honest.

When the baby comes you may have legitimate reason to keep everyone at arms length, but you also might be desperate for help or to show off the baby. Realistically you have no idea how you'll feel so I don't know why you've decided to make this a 'thing'.

You've told your in laws that no matter what happens all you know for sure is that you sure as hell don't want them there! No wonder they are upset. Your pre-emptive rejection is more hurtful than you seem to grasp. You could have just played it by ear and DH could then fob them off with messages like "my wife not feeling up to it after a rough birth but can't wait for you to come in a couple of days".

FWIW, I was a low risk pregnancy with no pain relief and a full term baby but we still ended up in NICU for 3 nights. I got no sleep in the postnatal ward due to being separated from my baby and by the end I was so exhausted I was hallucinating. I didn't think I would need anyone but I really, really, really did. You'll be doing yourself a favour if you keep your options open and are kind to your family in the run up to the birth.

Absolutely this, and not no it’s not usually the reality that the mother’s comfort and preferences go out of the window, just as most of us didn’t feel the need to be such Prima donna’s, most of us who have actually had babies were quite touched by the interest, care and consideration shown by so many people towards us and our precious baby’s. Yes kindly set boundaries with people who might not have thought how tiring a long visit can be (probably completely unintentionally) and by all means ask if can postpone a visit if you’ve had a rough night etc, most people will be more than understanding

MissMarwood · 23/02/2024 22:17

Make it two weeks. With Nr 1 we allowed being steamrolled by visitors, which was just super exhausting. "Helping" meant holding the baby, whilst I fetched and carried. I remember screaming inside when some wellmeaning visitor stuck his finger in my newborns mouth to "calm her". I healed badly, got an infection... it was misery until I put my foot down (too late) that unannounced daily visits were having to stop.
We had learned the lesson with Nr 2. We emailed the fact that a child had been born fit and well, and then promptly went off grid, muted the doorbell and silenced all phones. For 2 weeks we had what I remember with utter bliss as our babymoon, just the four of us, cuddling, sleeping, getting to know each other. No infection, superfast healing, content calm children.... just do it. You earned it. MIL will have her time.

(There was grumbling after, but two figs were not given)

WandaWonder · 23/02/2024 22:17

It is not something I planned I just had visitors after the birth when it happened

I don't see a need to have a visitor timetable i am not a princess

muggart · 23/02/2024 22:10

I can already see that when the baby’s arrival is close the mother’s comfort and preferences go out the window

You sound like you're being a little precious if I'm honest.

When the baby comes you may have legitimate reason to keep everyone at arms length, but you also might be desperate for help or to show off the baby. Realistically you have no idea how you'll feel so I don't know why you've decided to make this a 'thing'.

You've told your in laws that no matter what happens all you know for sure is that you sure as hell don't want them there! No wonder they are upset. Your pre-emptive rejection is more hurtful than you seem to grasp. You could have just played it by ear and DH could then fob them off with messages like "my wife not feeling up to it after a rough birth but can't wait for you to come in a couple of days".

FWIW, I was a low risk pregnancy with no pain relief and a full term baby but we still ended up in NICU for 3 nights. I got no sleep in the postnatal ward due to being separated from my baby and by the end I was so exhausted I was hallucinating. I didn't think I would need anyone but I really, really, really did. You'll be doing yourself a favour if you keep your options open and are kind to your family in the run up to the birth.

Cakeandcookies · 23/02/2024 22:07

Giving birth is a magical but stressful time. As others have said there will be lots of checks in those first 10 days/more if you end up in hospital staying in. Be mindful, that you may end up transferring to hospital and have a contingency plan written into your birth plan (explain beforehand your wishes to hubby) as things can go out the window in labour.
Especially if you have to have any stitches or interventions/section (hopefully not!) You will want to get to grips with everything including breastfeeding if you choose to and meeting your new little person.
My advice don't overthink it, set boundaries, yes people can visit but keep it short (get hubby on this). Good luck with the birth 💐

JussathoB · 23/02/2024 22:07

I don’t think anyone is suggesting new parents of a newborn should be hosting five course meals.
Many grandparents and in laws just wish to meet their grandchild, hug their daughter and/or son the new mum or dad etc and see that everyone is ok.
it needn’t take long, and shouldn’t put pressure on the new parents recovering from the birth.
Hopefully they might then visit again a couple/few weeks later at the new parents convenience and after they had had some recovery and bonding time with their new baby.

DidYouSeeTheKey · 23/02/2024 22:04

I loved having visitors both times, they kept me sane. See how you feel, I wouldn’t put any rules in yet but just say you may not be up for visitors straight away which is totally fair. If however after baby is born you don’t want to see anyone for a month then that’s totally fine.

dawnie4416 · 23/02/2024 21:59

I think most people here sound so unreasonable.

No one is entitled to see that baby until you are ready. That's up to you. Could be three days, three weeks or three months.

I had my parents and brother and sister visit in the hospital the day after my baby was born for 10 minutes and didn't want any longer. I then visited them 6 days later for an hour.

My in laws live quite far away and had booked trains and a hotel for when I was due to be induced. Baby came early so they had no choice but to wait to come down. They came when she was about 2 weeks old. Stayed in a hotel but came over every day for a few hours or we'd go for a little walk with coffee.

Having those first few days really helped. Especially as we were in hospital 24 hours, then the health visitor came at 3, 5 and 10 days. Plus I had additional appointments as baby had a tongue tie so needed support from the feeding team. Between that and no sleep and everything being brand new I didn't want people in my house - there was too much going on!

Plus if people were honest MIL and parents aren't missing out on anything. Baby doesn't care whether they come or not. Baby just wants to be close to you and to feed and sleep. Doesn't want strange smells and people who aren't their mummy/daddy. If they've got some pictures it's basically the same thing.

Don't be peer-pressured by the holier than thou Mums-netters who think they gave birth and hosted a 5 course meal 5 minutes later so everyone should. It's out of touch with reality.

Chanhedforthis · 23/02/2024 21:59

It's completely your decision op.

FWIW i gave birth 6 days ago, I've had MIL and DM to visit which has been nice but not the rest of the family yet. Ive had baby blues and issues with my stitches so I am definitely not ready for more visitors just yet.

See how you go op.

JussathoB · 23/02/2024 21:55

I agree with @Lorelaigilmore88 although I must admit I am a recent first time grandmother rather than a first time mum.
Back in the day when I had my babies, we all thought it was helpful to have our mums and dads ( if we had them) and parents in law visiting when baby arrived.
The grandparents and aunts/uncles naturally want to come and admire the baby and celebrate the arrival of the new family member. Please try to remember this. Of course it’s important that new parents and baby do not get too tired and have chance to bond. But close family visits, within reason, should help with this rather than hinder it!!

Pottedpalm · 23/02/2024 21:54

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 21:42

I’m perfectly calm. Just absolutely sick of ridiculous mumsnetters who are unhappy in their lives and so decide to spend their Friday night piling on a pregnant woman because she’s asked for 5-7 days before having visitors after birth.

This is AIBU and many posters think the OP is BU. Why ask if she is unwilling to hear the answer? There is a parenting section available.

judgedreadful · 23/02/2024 21:51

I do think you're being unreasonable for immediate family not to visit for a week. You may feel completely fine and up for visitors within a day or two of being home. I know I was in all three of mine. Play it by ear.

Tillycx · 23/02/2024 21:47

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 23/02/2024 21:41

Maybe you enjoyed the hospital visits but chances are they were awful exhausting and intrusive for the postpartum woman so I'm not
Surprised they leaned from experience and put boundaries in place this time w

Myself and friends all very much appreciated people who came to visit us in hospital and short visits by friends in the days afterwards (always without their children and asked what time best suited me) Only prolonged visits or those where anything expected of us were annoying

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 21:42

EmilyTjP · 23/02/2024 21:32

@WannabeMum22 you need to calm down!

I’m perfectly calm. Just absolutely sick of ridiculous mumsnetters who are unhappy in their lives and so decide to spend their Friday night piling on a pregnant woman because she’s asked for 5-7 days before having visitors after birth.

Grammarmum · 23/02/2024 21:41

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 21:18

That’s exact what you describe when you suggest OP’s DH should leave her upstairs and take the baby she’s just given birth to, to his mother. Because of course it’s his mothers feelings that need to take priority here and not his wife, the mother of his child whose recovering from childbirth.

@WannabeMum22 …you are now in such a tizz that you have got me confused with a different poster …I did not suggest leaving anyone upstairs!!! Read back and relax .
I took exception to your use of pushing and grabbing mothers and babies !

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 23/02/2024 21:41

ItsVeryHyacinthBucket · 23/02/2024 21:14

I’m not surprised that the vote on this has turned out 50/50.

First. Your baby, your rules. You can’t get the time back with them. Also you just don’t know how you’re going to feel yet, so play it by ear and remember to prioritise rest and your bond etc.

However, it does in reality make a difference to certain people around you if you refuse to let people meet your baby for a long time (weeks) after the birth. The baby then isn’t a newborn any more and that special stage is gone.

I recently started a thread because I was finding it hard my DBro and his wife weren’t allowing visitors. I still haven’t met my niece nearly 2 weeks after. I met their other child, my nephew, in the hospital right after he was born and it was really beautiful. To be honest, I’m pretty sad about it all this time. I won’t hold it against them but I feel like I’ve missed out on that beauty, awe and joyful moment with her and them. They wanted it all to themselves, that’s up to them and I don’t judge them for it - but I do feel sad.

Maybe you enjoyed the hospital visits but chances are they were awful exhausting and intrusive for the postpartum woman so I'm not
Surprised they leaned from experience and put boundaries in place this time w

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 21:40

Houseplanter · 23/02/2024 21:30

@WannabeMum22 was t your OH so delighted with his newborn he was desperate to show them off to his parents? Or was he keeping his mouth shut for the sake of peace?

Poor fella.

The baby isn’t born yet - but no showing him off to his parents isn’t top of his list he’s terrified about my health and that’s all he cares about.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 23/02/2024 21:40

FlyingHighFlyingLow · 23/02/2024 21:23

What's with the MIL bashing? Mine didn't see me as a grandchild incubator, we had a great relationship before I got pregnant, and when she arrived post birth first thing she did when she saw the baby was give me a huge hug with tears in her eyes and tell me how beautiful he was and how amazing I was. Before going to her own son that was holding said baby 😂 she certainly didn't push me out of the way. She also double checked I was ok with her coming, asked if we needed anything, bought food and flowers and chocolates for me. She was there for all three of us and is an awesome lady. She also asked if she could hold him (of course she could!) And went to wash her hands without even being asked. Her holding him and her face is a treasured memory.

You probably felt comfortable having her around as she'd always been so lovely and respectful to you before the baby was there and she doesn't seem entitled she seems caring and kind

mitogoshi · 23/02/2024 21:38

I can't imagine not wanting people on day one, I had my mum with me! First visitors 2 hours later. I also went shopping on the way home, not everyone wants to hide away

angsanana · 23/02/2024 21:38

Your baby your rules. However, you need to stop making a big deal out of this. I genuinely hope your home birth goes beautifully and as planned, but often they don't.
You may find yourself in hospital with an emergency c section. You may need to stay in for a few days and you may find it so dull you'll be glad of company.
Just say you'll see how you feel.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 23/02/2024 21:37

As a mum of a boy I would never want to make my future grandchild's mother feel uncomfortable - I would offer to drop food off and take laundry away but would not expect an invite into the house unless they're ready she might be crying with her boobs out and her hair unwashed. The early days they often go back into hospital for jaundice etc too it's not a time to 'host' it's a time to be helped only.

BUT before the baby comes I would have been looking after her all through pregnancy doing whatever I could to help her relax and be well nourished and ensuring my son did the same for his child's mother, so I hope I would have built up enough trust that she would want me around when the baby arrives

Houseplanter · 23/02/2024 21:37

@WannabeMum22 as a paternal grandparent I am hardly 'public'. I am as much a grandparent as any other.

I thank my lucky stars by lovely DIL agrees

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 21:33

Houseplanter · 23/02/2024 21:24

So @WannabeMum22 you're going to have your baby right next to you 24/7, with no one else helping, giving you a break. No chance for dad to nip downstairs and introduce baby to his parents, the new grandparents. No need for you to take a shower, have a minute to yourself

Totally, utterly self centred unreasonable and selfish. Are you so precious all the time?! Good luck when you expect grandparents to drop everything and provide free childcare.

I’m West African LOL I’m absolutely going to have help from day one. My husband and my family respect my boundaries and their help and support is unconditional. I won’t have people in my home passing my baby around and eating biscuits I’ll be off with my baby whilst they take care of everything for me. Some of us come from cultures where childbirth and postpartum (even pregnancy) is respected as a private time for women and their healing and bonding with the baby is prioritised. I’m so disgusted at this toxic entitled western attitudes where people think it’s normal to treat a pregnant woman and new babies like public property because of their relation to the parents.

My mother and I are extremely close and she’ll be my second birthing partner and be staying with me for months to assist. But that’s my choice not her right because she’s my mother. I understand other people even if they are as close to their mothers as I am will not want that. I’m happy to be unreasonable, to be selfish (because it’s me/OP being selfish not the person insisting they can’t wait a few days to visit) because my postpartum period is about me. And again I’m West African we don’t even leave our house for 40 days post birth and we definitely don’t hold babysitting as some sort of reward for enough baby time. But what do I know I’m just a precious selfish baby machine :D.

EmilyTjP · 23/02/2024 21:32

@WannabeMum22 you need to calm down!

Houseplanter · 23/02/2024 21:30

@WannabeMum22 was t your OH so delighted with his newborn he was desperate to show them off to his parents? Or was he keeping his mouth shut for the sake of peace?

Poor fella.