Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Visits after having a baby

237 replies

KlaudH · 23/02/2024 10:28

Hi all! I’m new here, but I read some threads on Mumsnet over the last number of months. I just want some advice as I’m 34 weeks pregnant tomorrow with my first baby and I’m thinking about visitors post birth. I said it to my husband probably around 2 months ago that I’d like 5-7 days with no visitors after birth. I could tell he didn’t really understand it, but he agreed. I also said it to my mum in law at my baby shower earlier this month that we would like a few days after the birth just for the three of us. She looked a little taken aback, but agreed.
This week, however, I heard that my MIL was really upset that she might not be able to see her grandson for around a week after he’s born and asked my husband if she can see him the day after he’s born or even the second or third day for half an hour as she wants to see the baby soon after he’s born, because newborns change a lot in the first few days and when she gave birth to her children her mum saw her babies nearly straightaway. My husband would be willing for her and his dad and brother to come as soon as possible after birth, but I don’t feel comfortable with that. I will be having a home birth and I’ve never given birth before so I don’t know what it’s going to be like and how I’m going to be feeling afterwards. I don’t want to have any visits looming over me right after I give birth (also, it’s going to be in my home). I would like to have a few days to bond with my baby and husband and recover a bit after birth without feeling a need to be physically or emotionally ready/presentable to have guests, (and I don’t know if they would actually stay for half an hour)…
I think it’s worth mentioning as well that I spoke to my mum about this and although she would love to see the baby as soon as possible she respects that I don’t want visitors for a few days. I actually ended up reducing the time to 3 days, but I hope to keep it that way. My husband is going to talk to his mum and hopefully she will be fine with the 3 days as I don’t want our relationship to be strained (I have been getting along well with her so far) as I can tell she’s annoyed with me.. She knows it’s me who wants the few days and not my husband.. I can already see that when the baby’s arrival is close the mother’s comfort and preferences go out the window.. Thank you for reading, sorry it’s so long! AIBU?

OP posts:
BuntyCollocks · 24/02/2024 13:44

You hope to have a homebirth.

Please don’t assume because you’re planning one it happens. Different for second babies onward, but first babies are notorious for transfer in. You might be glad of the support after birth as well. How about say you’re planning for a few days by yourself but you’ll see how you go? Honestly, I couldn’t have done without my MIL. She was an absolute treasure and still is.

dawnie4416 · 24/02/2024 13:21

jannier · 24/02/2024 12:51

I think it's sad in many ways
The idea that once you marry your family shrinks to the two of you and you no longer love or need your parents for the support they gave you ...until you need the childcare of course.
That parents and in-laws are seen as grandchild grabbers with no concern for the parents.
That giving birth is so traumatic we must resort to hiding away until our masks of being beautifully turned out and organized can be reinstated like some Victorian wife.
When did women's rights push us back into the old ways of staying hidden unless perfect or being so weak we would be unable to cope?
And how the hell are we going to be coping with second or third children if the first is so awful?
Many women are out and about with their seconds days after giving birth and not because they have no partner pulling their weight.

That giving birth is so traumatic we must resort to hiding away until our masks of being beautifully turned out and organized can be reinstated like some Victorian wife.

Maybe now we just recognise how traumatic birth can be. How much damage it can do to someone's body, and how it can be life and death. We recognise and respect women's right to have time to recover rather than act like she hasn't done something deeply difficult that she should just bounce back from.

When did women's rights push us back into the old ways of staying hidden unless perfect or being so weak we would be unable to cope?

It's not staying hidden unless perfect, but actually taking time for yourself and not putting everyone's else's wants before yours and your babies needs.

And how the hell are we going to be coping with second or third children if the first is so awful?
Many women are out and about with their seconds days after giving birth and not because they have no partner pulling their weight.

If they want to be out and about good for them. It shouldn't be expected of people. Your body has done something incredibly tiring. All your organs are moving back to where they were, your hormones are all over the place, you're just starting to produce milk. If you feel you need more time to adjust ESPECIALLY being a first time mum, take it.

It's not weak to recognise you need time and space to feel comfortable, and I think it's much braver to do what's best for you and your baby than bowing down to other family members beliefs of what's important. After the first few months most people aren't interested anyways and it's you and often your partner who needs to feel comfortable with the baby, feeding, routine. Not grandparents, aunts, uncles and friends.

Lavender14 · 24/02/2024 13:10

judgedreadful · 23/02/2024 21:51

I do think you're being unreasonable for immediate family not to visit for a week. You may feel completely fine and up for visitors within a day or two of being home. I know I was in all three of mine. Play it by ear.

Having visitors in the first week was the exact reason why we struggled so much with breastfeeding and my ds dropped lots of weight and then struggled to get up over birth weight again. We were told by the midwives no more visitors until feeding was better established.

I'm curious why you feel my inlaws needs to see my baby every day were more important than my baby's right to feed and be healthy?

Because the impact of lots of visitors (especially those who don't stick to the agreed visiting times or who just turn up) is that women recover slower and babies can struggle to thrive. It's completely individual and op shouldn't be pressured by anyone to have visitors before SHE decides she's ready.

jannier · 24/02/2024 12:51

I think it's sad in many ways
The idea that once you marry your family shrinks to the two of you and you no longer love or need your parents for the support they gave you ...until you need the childcare of course.
That parents and in-laws are seen as grandchild grabbers with no concern for the parents.
That giving birth is so traumatic we must resort to hiding away until our masks of being beautifully turned out and organized can be reinstated like some Victorian wife.
When did women's rights push us back into the old ways of staying hidden unless perfect or being so weak we would be unable to cope?
And how the hell are we going to be coping with second or third children if the first is so awful?
Many women are out and about with their seconds days after giving birth and not because they have no partner pulling their weight.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 24/02/2024 10:49

thecatsthecats · 24/02/2024 10:42

But if you work for social services, you're bound to see more parents who are struggling/neglectful, therefore see better bonds with grandparents.

True but possibly I was not clear, We've experience this as per my initial post here and they were not struggling, DiL felt they could manage and felt wrongly that it was no visitors inc immediate family. However, DiL is good now but then, younger and TBH a bit selfish, I knew if her parents were in the UK, she would have allowed them but our son would have insisted

TBH, when I was younger, I was selfish and looking back I've made many mistakes and I wish I had not - the mistake I refer to how I dealt with my, our parents - I was young as married at 19 and youngest child in the family and silly at times

Most grandparents are only too aware about the stress etc of having a baby and would not put a burnden/pressure on their children and or children in law but there to help and most new arrival families can do with help. However, it is OP'schocie and we are all different

thecatsthecats · 24/02/2024 10:42

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 24/02/2024 09:38

I've seen it with my own eyes when I worked for soc services and I thought WTF - I was young and niaivie at the time and now I get it

Its NOT "all about myself" I'm just sharing my views with my experiences that may help or not others here. Why are you so upset by my post?

But if you work for social services, you're bound to see more parents who are struggling/neglectful, therefore see better bonds with grandparents.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 24/02/2024 09:38

PansyOatZebra · 24/02/2024 03:10

Your post is all about you…

Also children love their grandparents more??? I think that’s just what you want to believe.

I've seen it with my own eyes when I worked for soc services and I thought WTF - I was young and niaivie at the time and now I get it

Its NOT "all about myself" I'm just sharing my views with my experiences that may help or not others here. Why are you so upset by my post?

WannabeMum22 · 24/02/2024 09:34

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 24/02/2024 08:33

Hmm I find women who expect their husband to only care about them and their DC to be total princesses tbh. I would find it really weird and off putting if my DH didn’t care about his mother and I don’t expect my DS to stop caring about me when he gets married, prioritise his wife and DC yes, but only care about them and no one else? No I would think him brainwashed. I think most mature adult men to have the capacity to love and care for more people than just his wife and child but to each their own.

I’m a proud princess it doesn’t bother or upset me to have people throw sexist labels at me because my husband prioritises me and puts his family that he chose to create with me first. If my husband is brainwashed because he doesn’t care if people are upset they have to wait to meet our baby until I feel ready to receive visitors then so be it.

Millie890 · 24/02/2024 09:13

Rosesanddaisies1 · 24/02/2024 09:05

“I will be having a home birth”. Off topic but you don’t know you will be having anything. It’s your first. Prepare for the worst. And do some research on ambulance waiting times in your area..

Edited

Who gets a kick of saying shit like this to someone who is about to have their first baby. Why scare people, God, people like you make me so angry! "Prepare for the worst"! Stupid mentioning ambulances. She might not even need an ambulance...many people get themselves to hospital nowadays. No wonder ambulances are so busy and people are absolutely terrified of Childbirth with people like you around. If this lady has planned a nice calm homebirth then she should be encouraged to do so, if it goes wrong then there will be a back up plan but just imagine if it did actually go to plan as many home births do and she has a lovely experience and gets to be in her own bed after. Just grow up!

Rosesanddaisies1 · 24/02/2024 09:05

“I will be having a home birth”. Off topic but you don’t know you will be having anything. It’s your first. Prepare for the worst. And do some research on ambulance waiting times in your area..

Rosesanddaisies1 · 24/02/2024 09:03

I think YABU to not allow a short visit from your MIL, or your own parents. It seems a bit OTT that you’re laying down the law at this stage. If you’re really struggling after the birth, at that point just say to wait a bit for visit.

thecatsthecats · 24/02/2024 09:00

movedtothecountry · 23/02/2024 20:56

So selfish. Also I bet you want your in laws to babysit now!

I don't get comments like this.

Most grandparents I know are gagging to babysit their grandchildren, they don't see it as some sort of big favour - it's something they really want.

My MIL babysits her great niece. My mum is still fuming that my aunt helped my sister bathe my nephew before she did on the evening before my wedding.

Only on MN do I see any sort of "do what I say or I won't babysit" type bullshit.

MyInduction · 24/02/2024 08:37

Millie890 · 24/02/2024 07:48

Gosh, just imagine having been through a traumatic birth and then bring told "people are coming round whether you like it or not, I'll take your baby off you even though they need you the most they will ever need to be constantly with their Mum and you just stay in bed eh". Ridiculous. Any man who has any respect for his partner should never put her through this because some impatient arseholes can't wait a week.

Exactly! I was bleeding heavily and in so much pain post partum. I didn't mind my parents seeing me in hospital because I'm comfortable around them. I was not ok hence being in hospital for several days. I didn't want my in laws seeing my blooded sheets and me crying in pain. However, many posters here think I'm selfish for not wanting to see in laws until I'd been at home for a few days! And to the poster who said baby should be taken from mum to see mil for a few hours - absolutely not!

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 24/02/2024 08:33

WannabeMum22 · 23/02/2024 21:27

My husband could care less about anyone else’s feelings or health but mine and the babies. I thought this was standard for grown men who have supported their partner during pregnancy but I guess it’s common to feel appeasing your mother is the number one priority whilst your partner goes through pregnancy, childbirth and postpartum.

Hmm I find women who expect their husband to only care about them and their DC to be total princesses tbh. I would find it really weird and off putting if my DH didn’t care about his mother and I don’t expect my DS to stop caring about me when he gets married, prioritise his wife and DC yes, but only care about them and no one else? No I would think him brainwashed. I think most mature adult men to have the capacity to love and care for more people than just his wife and child but to each their own.

Millie890 · 24/02/2024 07:48

Zanatdy · 24/02/2024 04:41

Well it’s a joint child and I’d imagine the grandparents just want to see the child so mum is welcome to stay in bed and get some rest whilst dad shows off his new baby to his own parents. Of course it’s up for discussion, I wouldn’t have said I’m not even discussing having your parents over to see their grandchildren and what I say goes. That’s not a partnership. For some women it’s a power thing towards a MIL and we all know a MIL is the enemy on here. Many times a woman will have her own mother in the delivery room and MIL is on the visit list a week later behind a load of their close friends. Let’s hope their own son’s wife’s don’t take the same approach one day

Gosh, just imagine having been through a traumatic birth and then bring told "people are coming round whether you like it or not, I'll take your baby off you even though they need you the most they will ever need to be constantly with their Mum and you just stay in bed eh". Ridiculous. Any man who has any respect for his partner should never put her through this because some impatient arseholes can't wait a week.

Zanatdy · 24/02/2024 04:41

Millie890 · 23/02/2024 21:07

The Mum's the one giving birth and she's the one recovering so it's absolutely her choice who does and does not come into her space. Shouldn't be up for discussion!

Well it’s a joint child and I’d imagine the grandparents just want to see the child so mum is welcome to stay in bed and get some rest whilst dad shows off his new baby to his own parents. Of course it’s up for discussion, I wouldn’t have said I’m not even discussing having your parents over to see their grandchildren and what I say goes. That’s not a partnership. For some women it’s a power thing towards a MIL and we all know a MIL is the enemy on here. Many times a woman will have her own mother in the delivery room and MIL is on the visit list a week later behind a load of their close friends. Let’s hope their own son’s wife’s don’t take the same approach one day

DrJump · 24/02/2024 04:26

Oh I wanted to show off my babies as soon as possible.

Hours after birth for all of them. I wanted my babies to be loved by everyone that could love them.

I breastfeed them all so I was never many minutes away from having them in my arms.

BasiliskStare · 24/02/2024 03:21

@Oreosareawful - I was the same - PILs drove to hospital whilst I was recovering from EMCS & visited same day as birth but they are gone now ( by which I mean died ) and I have just found some photographs of them on that day. The joy on their faces. The nurse offered to eject them but for a while it was fine . My mother stayed in our house and then popped over later in the day.

If I am absolutely honest - I think the whole idea of having no visitors for days or weeks ( & I mean mainly nice GPs ) is a little precious. (I know this is not a popular view and it is mine only - just my opinion ) Everyone must make their own choice. But we had parents in the hospital and then my DM for a day or two & she just helped out and then went home . After that DH & I were on our own.

Loads of further afield people dropping in at random I am more agreeable to that or indeed I would not like that. ( not that anyone needs my approbation )

PansyOatZebra · 24/02/2024 03:10

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 23/02/2024 14:05

Wait until you you have children and when they are grown up and have their fist DC etc, they say "dear mummy and daddy.... I know you are eager and excited to see your new GC and us.... but please do not bother for 10 days"""

One of our children, well more a case of his wife did not want people over for 1 or 2 weeks. We told our son, as above how would he feel in our shoes - he was aware of this but felt he was in an award position so he put it to his dear wife and told her "have no one but mum and dad will be coming and you can go to bed before they arrive and come downstairs when they are gone in hour or 2.
Guess what, she started crying when we went over the day they got home as the baby would not let her sleep and we helped them out with sleeping, looking after the baby -- a few months later our daughter-in-law actually said sorry for being immature - she was but a older and a lot wiser and we are proud to have her as a DiL

We are all different ad too often the newer generation of mothers feel they want to be alone for a week or 2. All sensible visitors will understand you are worn out, lack sleep, home may not be as tidy as it us and all are aware you may not have time to make a cup of tea etc - parents are not stupid

NB: The above is not aimed at you but more of a general observation but I do hope you dot hurt your parents feelings as grandchildren really love their grandparents as much and at times more than parents as of the grandparents have more time to offer as often left work and more time to offer re help etc

You choice and good lunch with your new baby and best wishes to all of you

Your post is all about you…

Also children love their grandparents more??? I think that’s just what you want to believe.

PansyOatZebra · 24/02/2024 03:03

I don’t think a week is too much at all. Babies don’t change that much in the first week and it’ll still have that new born cutesy feel to it at one week old.

It is also all about when you feel ready not anyone else. Childbirth takes a massive toll on your body and you need to feel ready.

PillowRest · 23/02/2024 23:12

Neverpostagain · 23/02/2024 20:38

I doubt very much mil wants to see you. She wants to see the baby. Why can't she do that? Your DH can facilitate it and you can stay upstairs or vice versa.

I really hope you don't have a DIL who is planning to have children or has already been having to deal with this...
Do you genuinely not see how vile that attitude is?

MsCactus · 23/02/2024 23:02

EmilyTjP · 23/02/2024 11:10

Babies have survived for centuries with being breathed on by people, I’m sure this one will be fine.

I mean, this isn't true, most babies/kids used to die before their fifth birthday.

My great granny was horrified that everyone would come over to see a newborn baby - in her day no one ever kissed a baby, or passed them round when so young, there was way too much risk of illness and death.

1983Louise · 23/02/2024 22:35

I held my granddaughter at 2 hours old, I was so excited and emotional it didn't cross my mind my daughter wouldn't want me there. It was a beautiful moment and a privilege, I'll never forget it.

TheAquaFawn · 23/02/2024 22:26

dawnie4416 · 23/02/2024 21:59

I think most people here sound so unreasonable.

No one is entitled to see that baby until you are ready. That's up to you. Could be three days, three weeks or three months.

I had my parents and brother and sister visit in the hospital the day after my baby was born for 10 minutes and didn't want any longer. I then visited them 6 days later for an hour.

My in laws live quite far away and had booked trains and a hotel for when I was due to be induced. Baby came early so they had no choice but to wait to come down. They came when she was about 2 weeks old. Stayed in a hotel but came over every day for a few hours or we'd go for a little walk with coffee.

Having those first few days really helped. Especially as we were in hospital 24 hours, then the health visitor came at 3, 5 and 10 days. Plus I had additional appointments as baby had a tongue tie so needed support from the feeding team. Between that and no sleep and everything being brand new I didn't want people in my house - there was too much going on!

Plus if people were honest MIL and parents aren't missing out on anything. Baby doesn't care whether they come or not. Baby just wants to be close to you and to feed and sleep. Doesn't want strange smells and people who aren't their mummy/daddy. If they've got some pictures it's basically the same thing.

Don't be peer-pressured by the holier than thou Mums-netters who think they gave birth and hosted a 5 course meal 5 minutes later so everyone should. It's out of touch with reality.

I agree with this. I'm pregnant, due any day now, and we've told family that it could be 2-3 weeks before visits but that we'll need to play it by ear. I'm also planning a home birth but who knows what will end up happening on the day (and when that day will be) and how I'll be afterwards mentally, physically, emotionally. It's also my first baby and everyone I've asked has recommended holding off immediate visitors so that you and your partner have time to adjust and bond with the baby.

My situation might be a bit different to most because both sides of the family live far away or abroad, it's not a matter of popping round for tea, any visits would mean they'd be here for at least a few days or a week. I know that would be too much for me. Also they're not the types to help out with chores or bring food etc, it would be more me entertaining them. I think as women we're expected to always be appeasing, but for me this time is so crucial to put my needs first, as well as that of my partner and the baby (who won't know/care that he met family immediately).

There's been mixed reactions from our family off the back of our request, some are understanding and some aren't, and that has felt hurtful as surely it's what supports us rather than what's right for them? But I would say stay strong in your decisions and lean into your instincts. You can always change your mind when the baby arrives, but at least take the pressure off by limiting the expectations of others.

ImRen · 23/02/2024 22:21

I think you are building it up to be a problem that doesn't exist. I'd not worry about it and plan to let them come when they want. Otherwise you will have it hanging over you. If you aren't up to it on the day then cancel but don't try guessing how you will be feeling. I think it's better to be more relaxed about it and see how things go. It doesn't need to be so scripted and rigid. It's impossible to know what you will be feeling like.

New babies are amazing so I understand why they want to see the baby as soon as possible.