Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should just trust each other’s intuition on here?

38 replies

Moltenpink · 23/02/2024 10:07

Whenever there’s a thread on here where an OP has no concrete proof, but has been getting bad vibes or senses things are a bit off (whether that be in a new relationship, job, from a stranger, etc). There always seem to be posters defending the other party and suggesting the OP has it wrong.

Should we not just assume the OP most likely has the correct gut feeling? Intuition is a powerful thing. It’s quite harmful for posters to take the “oh you might have it wrong… just be kind” approach.

OP posts:
MewMame · 23/02/2024 10:30

There isn’t a one-size-fits-all perfect response. Some people have OCD about their own ‘intuitions’ which are actually just an ordinary passing thought or feeling, other people never trust their instincts or don’t know what they are, some people do and are usually right, other people do and are just creating drama wherever they go.

OrlandointheWilderness · 23/02/2024 10:28

@Eyesopenwideawake that is golden, I'm saving that 😂 😂

Eyesopenwideawake · 23/02/2024 10:26

This just sprang to mind;

"Her Diary:

Tonight, I thought my husband was acting weird. We had made plans to meet at a nice restaurant for dinner. I was shopping with my friends all day long, so I thought he was upset at the fact that I was a bit late, but he made no comment on it. Conversation wasn't flowing, so I suggested that we go somewhere quiet so we could talk. He agreed, but he didn't say much. I asked him what was wrong; He said, 'Nothing.' I asked him if it was my fault that he was upset. He said he wasn't upset, that it had nothing to do with me, and not to worry about it. On the way home, I told him that I loved him. He smiled slightly, and kept driving. I can't explain his behavior I don't know why he didn't say, 'I love you, too.' When we got home, I felt as if I had lost him completely, as if he wanted nothing to do with me anymore. He just sat there quietly, and watched TV. He continued to seem distant and absent. Finally, with silence all around us, I decided to go to bed. About 15 minutes later, he came to bed. But I still felt that he was distracted, and his thoughts were somewhere else. He fell asleep - I cried. I don't know what to do. I'm almost sure that his thoughts are with someone else. My life is a disaster.

His Diary:

Motorcycle won’t start…can't figure out why."

Gallowayan · 23/02/2024 10:26

I think you are right. Using the analogy of counselling I understand that for the counsellor the clients (subjective) view of their own situation as the 'reality' they work from.

As far as the OPs situation goes, we only have what they think and feel to go on; we are obviously not witnesses.

ancienticecream · 23/02/2024 10:24

I think gut instincts shouldn't be dismissed but should be challenged.
I agree with this statement. By and large, follow your gut, but don't be afraid to question it.

Pirelli · 23/02/2024 10:23

I think it's a bit like how you can tell if someone has moved something on a desk that you use every day. You don't know what exactly has moved, nor why, but you know something is different.

Eyesopenwideawake · 23/02/2024 10:20

It depends. Intuition is a powerful sense and we unconsciously pick up on changes that's are imperceptible to anyone else. However there's a lot of people who projection previous experiences onto current situations (which is completely normal) but, as the ads say, "Past performance is no guarantee of future results."

DysmalRadius · 23/02/2024 10:19

It depends - sometimes sometimes 'defending' poor behaviour can hit on an explanation that the OP might not have considered and that is genuinely likely, and can reassure them that there could be an innocent explanation. Those who tie themselves in knots to defend someone's shitty behaviour sometimes just prove that the OP's intuition is right. If you find yourself easily dismissing all the possible alternatives, it can reaffirm what you thought you knew.

But it is hard to tell who just needs reassurance and who is genuinely questioning their own perception - very hard to tell on here.

susiedaisy1912 · 23/02/2024 10:18

Undeterminedtartan · 23/02/2024 10:17

I disagree. I think gut instincts shouldn't be dismissed but should be challenged. When I was much younger I worked with a woman who inducted me and told me she had bad feelings about particular people and to be wary, she seemed genuine and looking out for me. I mainly had phone or email conversations with these people so it took me a couple of months before I clocked all the people she had bad gut instincts about were not white. I.e out of 20 people, 3 she had bad feelings about and and they were the only non white team members.

Obviously not saying all gut instinct is based on bigotry and it can be very powerful. But some instincts are based on prejudices maybe even unconsciously.

What does annoy me is the insistence the OP must be lying or has got something wrong when they are clear they haven't.

But that wasn't your gut instinct, it was someone else telling you that they didn't like certain people but dressing it up as her gut instinct.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 23/02/2024 10:18

Moltenpink · 23/02/2024 10:07

Whenever there’s a thread on here where an OP has no concrete proof, but has been getting bad vibes or senses things are a bit off (whether that be in a new relationship, job, from a stranger, etc). There always seem to be posters defending the other party and suggesting the OP has it wrong.

Should we not just assume the OP most likely has the correct gut feeling? Intuition is a powerful thing. It’s quite harmful for posters to take the “oh you might have it wrong… just be kind” approach.

I agree, but some people just don’t have the ‘antennae’ to pick up ‘off’ vibes, so they think anyone who does must have imagined it.

Undeterminedtartan · 23/02/2024 10:17

I disagree. I think gut instincts shouldn't be dismissed but should be challenged. When I was much younger I worked with a woman who inducted me and told me she had bad feelings about particular people and to be wary, she seemed genuine and looking out for me. I mainly had phone or email conversations with these people so it took me a couple of months before I clocked all the people she had bad gut instincts about were not white. I.e out of 20 people, 3 she had bad feelings about and and they were the only non white team members.

Obviously not saying all gut instinct is based on bigotry and it can be very powerful. But some instincts are based on prejudices maybe even unconsciously.

What does annoy me is the insistence the OP must be lying or has got something wrong when they are clear they haven't.

Pirelli · 23/02/2024 10:15

I agree with you OP based on my personal experience.

AstralSpace · 23/02/2024 10:13

Yes. I believe that often posters are looking for reassurance that their intuition is correct