Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to gently let my DD know that it's okay by me if she's gay?

138 replies

Anindexoftheliesihavetold · 23/02/2024 08:40

I have NC for this

DD is 16. She's had some low level struggles with her emotional wellbeing for a few years. Over that time we've gone from thinking it's shyness, low mood, the perils of adolescence, social media, social anxiety, neurodiversity, etc etc. She's had some therapeutic interventions with some degree of success. Now she's started 6th form she's definitely in a better place, although anxiety over the next steps after school is high. We have told her that we will be fully supportive of a gap year while she works out which direction she wants to take.

Anyway. She's never had any interest in boys, and some of the walls in her room are covered in a selection of 4 or 5 females artists' photos. She pretty much only listens to female artists. A couple of years ago she had a friendship with this girl, and I found out indirectly that they were 'together', as the mother of a common friend of both saw something on social media. I never said anything to my DD about it.

Her dad and I are of the belief that people's sexual preferences are their business and their business only, and that 'coming out' is a peculiar concept in itself. However, I have started to believe that perhaps getting this out in the open at home and letting DD know that we are completely supportive of who she is and that we sort of 'know' and we're fine with it, might alleviate some of her anxiety over who she is. But I also worry that this is none of my business and I'd be stepping over boundaries.

Please don't be too harsh, I genuinely don't know if I am getting this wrong, but I want advice as I want to get it right. Thanks.

OP posts:
Dogdilemma2000 · 23/02/2024 09:47

ReadingLight · 23/02/2024 09:43

No, definitely don’t watch All of Us Strangers with a sensitive teenager in order to get her to realise you’re fine with her sexuality — it’s brilliant, but gut-wrenchingly sad, and while the main character tells his parents things have moved on since their AIDS-era ideas about gayness, the two gay characters are both profoundly isolated, and even leaving aside the ending, Paul Mescal’s character is isolated from his family. But mostly it’s just terribly, terribly sad. The entire cinema was in tears when I saw it.

What about something like Booksmart (on Netflix, I think?)

Or Modern Family? Cam is hilarious and best character ever. His and Mitch’s relationship is beautiful

ReadingLight · 23/02/2024 09:43

Anindexoftheliesihavetold · 23/02/2024 09:23

Thank you. You've all been so kind and have offered really good feedback and advice. I guess we sort of missed the boat to have general conversations about gay marriage, etc, and my DD smells bullshit from miles away. If I start now she'll give me her raised brow that translates into 'really, mum??' However, the idea of that movie @chrispychilli has suggested might work. I'll have to bribe DD with sweets and snacks or there's no chance she'll sit with her father and I to watch anything!

No, definitely don’t watch All of Us Strangers with a sensitive teenager in order to get her to realise you’re fine with her sexuality — it’s brilliant, but gut-wrenchingly sad, and while the main character tells his parents things have moved on since their AIDS-era ideas about gayness, the two gay characters are both profoundly isolated, and even leaving aside the ending, Paul Mescal’s character is isolated from his family. But mostly it’s just terribly, terribly sad. The entire cinema was in tears when I saw it.

What about something like Booksmart (on Netflix, I think?)

LonePineHQ · 23/02/2024 09:42

I wouldn't say anything because it can pressurise them either way.

My dd has been telling me for several years that she won't be getting married to a man and won't have children. She's early 20s now.
At Christmas she had a new niece, and she commented "don't expect me to have the next one, I'm going to stick with my career until I'm in my 30s". Which was a total turn around to even admit the possibility that she might one day have children.
And now I've noticed that a certain boy's name is coming up very frequently, and she's doing an awful lot with him, and he's taking a lot of time to "help" her. I don't know there's a relationship developing there, but I have my suspicions. I will wait for her to say something if it is.

I've always said I don't care who it is as long as my dc are happy and safe. And that's the position where I will stay.

Sorry I missed my point: I think if I'd had a conversation with her about it being okay if she was gay, then she'd feel more awkward about having a boy friend, as though it was making a big thing about it. That's my dd though.

TooraLoora · 23/02/2024 09:34

@Anindexoftheliesihavetold Im in a similar position with my DD15 and have been trying to make sure she knows that whatever her sexuality is it's fine with me. She's autistic and has ADHD though and isn't very good at picking up on subtleties.

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 09:33

ExtraOnions · 23/02/2024 09:25

Erm no … I know my daughter, and I know the context. Don’t be projecting your own issues, the world does not revolve around you.

Erm yeah, my parents thought they knew me and the context too... Just trying to educate you, never said the world revolved around me (or the millions of other CF people)

Pouringsky · 23/02/2024 09:30

I’m joining the very small number of people telling you just to have a gentle conversation and tell her it’s OK with you . Hopefully she will just say ‘yes Mum I know’ .

Bigotry is still alive and well in this world and I would not risk my child being in any doubt of my 100% support .

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 23/02/2024 09:30

Love it or list it have a lesbian couple on it this series. If you watch any TV together you could watch that episode as a possible conversation starter. Or any similar program where the relationship isn’t the focus, it is just there in the background.

A lot of teens feel awkward taking to their parents about relationships and as a society we are still very much heterosexual oriented (due to percentages), which adds on to that. So combined she just feels a bit uncomfortable with the topic.

ExtraOnions · 23/02/2024 09:25

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 09:09

@ExtraOnions *Her “you do know I’m gay
Me “don’t be using that as an excuse not to give me grandchildren”

All in good humour of course.*

Wow. I know you say it's good humour/'lighthearted' but comments like this are very hurtful to childfree/childless people, regardless of sexuality. Please rethink these sort of comments in future.

Erm no … I know my daughter, and I know the context. Don’t be projecting your own issues, the world does not revolve around you.

Beamur · 23/02/2024 09:23

I think it's helpful - especially if your child is anxious, that you are pretty explicit about this. DD gave me the opportunity to chat with her about this a few years ago (turned out she was wrestling with some complex feelings). In the course of the conversation I told her that for starters she has no obligation to tell us everything about her private life, but our love and support wasn't conditional or has any expectations. What we want for her is a partner who she loves and who treats her with kindness love and respect. We talked about the hetero normative narrative - under representation of same sex relationships in books/TV etc which can make it harder for young people to see themselves reflected etc and to talk about their feelings. Plus parents don't always respond as you might fear, more are accepting than not but they may be anxious about how being gay will be for you - especially if they have little experience themselves.

Anindexoftheliesihavetold · 23/02/2024 09:23

Thank you. You've all been so kind and have offered really good feedback and advice. I guess we sort of missed the boat to have general conversations about gay marriage, etc, and my DD smells bullshit from miles away. If I start now she'll give me her raised brow that translates into 'really, mum??' However, the idea of that movie @chrispychilli has suggested might work. I'll have to bribe DD with sweets and snacks or there's no chance she'll sit with her father and I to watch anything!

OP posts:
takemeawayagain · 23/02/2024 09:19

Yes I agree with the 'now you're getting older if you ever want to bring a boyfriend or girlfriend home for dinner then they'd be very welcome' type thing.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/02/2024 09:19

Startingagainandagain · 23/02/2024 09:16

Why do people still expect someone who is attracted to the same gender to 'come out'?

Equally why would you have to confirm to her that it is OK to be gay or bi? because it implies that gay people should still worry about not being accepted at home.

Surely we should have moved on to a place by now where gay relationships are like any other relationships and that there is no need to make a big deal out of it?

You sound like a great mum so I don't want to be seen as having a go at you but just let her be, continue to love and support her and if she decides to bring a girlfriend home just treat it as you would any teenager bringing someone they are dating home.

Because as a society they still do have to. Which yes obviously is ridiculous. I'd hope my boys would just come home and be like there's a boy I really like at school Mom, how do I ask him to prom? Mom Steve asked if I can go to the movies Saturday, do I have to take anything on a date?

But if they don't ever talk about it because it's never come up and they don't really mix with other families etc she might just not know for sure, because teenagers are bags of insecurity wrapped up in a need to be loved and accepted.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/02/2024 09:16

AndThatWasNY · 23/02/2024 08:52

I was just talk openly about gay relationships in a normal manner. I always have said to my kids things like "if you have a girlfriend or boyfriend I wonder if they will ...like dogs/love your nose as much as I do/find the way you eat as disgusting as I do ..

The problem is, and I do similar to you, is it's a weird thing to start doing at 16 without it feeling pointed.

Op is go with a more open and general "now you're getting older, if you ever want to bring anyone special home to meet us, boy or girl, we'd love to meet them"

Startingagainandagain · 23/02/2024 09:16

Why do people still expect someone who is attracted to the same gender to 'come out'?

Equally why would you have to confirm to her that it is OK to be gay or bi? because it implies that gay people should still worry about not being accepted at home.

Surely we should have moved on to a place by now where gay relationships are like any other relationships and that there is no need to make a big deal out of it?

You sound like a great mum so I don't want to be seen as having a go at you but just let her be, continue to love and support her and if she decides to bring a girlfriend home just treat it as you would any teenager bringing someone they are dating home.

chrispychilli · 23/02/2024 09:14

Have you seen All of us strangers yet? The parents in that understandably express views from their time that we have thankfully moved on from but this could make starter conversation along the lines of 'I was quite shocked to hear their views and am so glad everything moved on now ' I also find these conversations are helped when driving - no eye contact seems to make things easier sometimes

Durdledore · 23/02/2024 09:11

Oops! I have skewed your AIBU results by pressing the wrong button 🤦‍♀️. I pressed YABU by mistake!

You sound really loving, supportive and warm. Do whatever comes naturally to you, being guided by those natural qualities you have.

Hope your DD feels stronger soon. It can be a tough age eh? Lots of transitions. Seems they’ve only just chosen their A-Levels before they have to choose the next step. ❤️

pizzaHeart · 23/02/2024 09:10

I would start with general positive mentioning of gay couples from TV. I know it’s surprising for many people but as a family we haven’t been at any gay wedding, none of our close friends are gay but we only have a few friends. So tbh TV is my only opportunity for indirect comments.
Plus what other people say about how you are commenting regarding her future.

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 09:09

@ExtraOnions *Her “you do know I’m gay
Me “don’t be using that as an excuse not to give me grandchildren”

All in good humour of course.*

Wow. I know you say it's good humour/'lighthearted' but comments like this are very hurtful to childfree/childless people, regardless of sexuality. Please rethink these sort of comments in future.

ExtraOnions · 23/02/2024 09:07

My 17 year old DD told me she was gay last year. I had noticed some years ago that she wasn’t really invested in boys (though she did like someone from a Korean boy band). I wasn’t bothered in the slightest, she only told me because I was talking about wanting grandchildren one day to take to Disney:
Her “you do know I’m gay
Me “don’t be using that as an excuse not to give me grandchildren”

All in good humour of course.

We should be so past “coming out”, should be that one day your child tells you they have a partner, at at that point they may produce someone of the same sex, or, the opposite sex.

Tooshyshy78 · 23/02/2024 09:07

I would just speak in a generic way about it and refer to her friends and other people her age who are exploring their sexuality. That’s what I’ve done with my kids. They would be mortified if they thought I was trying to label them with sexual preference so I have made it clear that i think it’s fine to like whoever they like regardless of someone’s gender. They still don’t tell me anything. But I’ve said it now and I truly believe what I’m saying and I think they know this. So hopefully when they are ready they feel they can be open with me.

AttaThat · 23/02/2024 09:06

Worldgonecrazy · 23/02/2024 09:00

@AttaThat Can I challenge your use of the word ‘celebrate’? Would you ‘celebrate’ if your child was heterosexual? There is a lot of pressure on young gay males in particular to ‘celebrate’ their sexuality in a way that can have negative long term effects on them.

I don’t mean literally throw them a party. I mean positively acknowledging who our children are as independent people.

I often see parents (online, so who knows whether it’s reality) out competing one another in the “not giving a shit” stakes. Videos where the child has worked themselves up to come out and the parent says “what are you on about, I’ve always known you were gay, we’re having lasagna for dinner”. And they often come across as very dismissive of the fact that this is a big moment in that child’s life.

Wheresthescissors · 23/02/2024 09:03

I would talk about other people. Oh did you see the two women getting married in (tv programme) wasn't that lovely. I'm so glad gay people can get married now.
(doesn't have to be that but you get my point - rather than saying "I hope you know we're fine with you being gay" you could talk about gay people in a way that makes it 100% clear you would be happy.)

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 09:01

Just want to say, don't make any assumptions. My first teenage 'relationship' was with my female best friend. I've only ever been in male relationships since, now married to a man, and I consider myself straight. Sexuality is fluid. She might not even consider herself bi.

Worldgonecrazy · 23/02/2024 09:00

@AttaThat Can I challenge your use of the word ‘celebrate’? Would you ‘celebrate’ if your child was heterosexual? There is a lot of pressure on young gay males in particular to ‘celebrate’ their sexuality in a way that can have negative long term effects on them.

Anindexoftheliesihavetold · 23/02/2024 09:00

@EverySporkIsSacred, yes, I feel that from my own point of view it should be obvious that I love her no matter what, but she is extremely sensitive to rejection (more frequently than not, perceived, rather that actual), so I worry that she has internalised a sense that she is not okay by us just as she is.

OP posts: