Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to gently let my DD know that it's okay by me if she's gay?

138 replies

Anindexoftheliesihavetold · 23/02/2024 08:40

I have NC for this

DD is 16. She's had some low level struggles with her emotional wellbeing for a few years. Over that time we've gone from thinking it's shyness, low mood, the perils of adolescence, social media, social anxiety, neurodiversity, etc etc. She's had some therapeutic interventions with some degree of success. Now she's started 6th form she's definitely in a better place, although anxiety over the next steps after school is high. We have told her that we will be fully supportive of a gap year while she works out which direction she wants to take.

Anyway. She's never had any interest in boys, and some of the walls in her room are covered in a selection of 4 or 5 females artists' photos. She pretty much only listens to female artists. A couple of years ago she had a friendship with this girl, and I found out indirectly that they were 'together', as the mother of a common friend of both saw something on social media. I never said anything to my DD about it.

Her dad and I are of the belief that people's sexual preferences are their business and their business only, and that 'coming out' is a peculiar concept in itself. However, I have started to believe that perhaps getting this out in the open at home and letting DD know that we are completely supportive of who she is and that we sort of 'know' and we're fine with it, might alleviate some of her anxiety over who she is. But I also worry that this is none of my business and I'd be stepping over boundaries.

Please don't be too harsh, I genuinely don't know if I am getting this wrong, but I want advice as I want to get it right. Thanks.

OP posts:
reluctantbrit · 23/02/2024 21:04

DD is bi. Long before she actually said it, I once said in a discussion about love and relationships "I don't care if you have a girlfriend, boyfriend, are in a threesome or with a non-binary person.

I said: "I only care that you your partner(s) treat you well, you are happy and everything is consensual. I worry if you have to struggle with society's expectations if you relationship is outside of norms. But we support you whatever you choose."

I hate the idea that a person has to justify why she/he is in love with someone not the normal opposite sex. Nobody is "coming out" as straight so why should it be a big announcement if you are gay/bi/any other letter of the alphabet.

Jesusmaryjosephandtheweedon · 23/02/2024 20:52

Startingagainandagain · 23/02/2024 09:16

Why do people still expect someone who is attracted to the same gender to 'come out'?

Equally why would you have to confirm to her that it is OK to be gay or bi? because it implies that gay people should still worry about not being accepted at home.

Surely we should have moved on to a place by now where gay relationships are like any other relationships and that there is no need to make a big deal out of it?

You sound like a great mum so I don't want to be seen as having a go at you but just let her be, continue to love and support her and if she decides to bring a girlfriend home just treat it as you would any teenager bringing someone they are dating home.

I think this is a little unfair. I dont think it's implying that gay people SHOULD still worry about not being accepted at home. And agreed it shouldn't have to be something that's confirmed as being ok but unfortunately a large percentage of gay people will have that worry. And feeling supported no matter what at home could help to allay those fears.

Jesusmaryjosephandtheweedon · 23/02/2024 20:49

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 09:01

Just want to say, don't make any assumptions. My first teenage 'relationship' was with my female best friend. I've only ever been in male relationships since, now married to a man, and I consider myself straight. Sexuality is fluid. She might not even consider herself bi.

Similar here. Some experimenting with female friends when younger but have never been in a female/female relationship.

Never considered myself bi or anything other than straight.

We have quite a few gay relationships in our extended family and my grandad always said to my sister, settle down with a nice boy....or.girl...whatever you choose and so I use that with my dd's when I'm talking about relationships. They are all still only single digits but they talk about crushes in school and I say ooh is it a girl or a boy? Just so they know it's OK no matter who you love. Love is love. Maybe frame it that way to her.

Foxblue · 23/02/2024 20:45

I just want to say for anyone reading this thread, if you are thinking 'why do people come out, it's not a big deal'
Your intentions are in the right place, and I love that, but please understand that to some kids it's still a big deal, and if your child has been chewing it over enough to announce you, then please please please recognise that everyone is different, and some kids want/need to announce, and that's not a reflection on you or your parenting, and sometimes we need to give kids a reaction we wouldn't naturally give.
It's about them, and feeling supported - so if your kid sits you down and says mum, I'm gay. Clearly to them it's important, so let's support them by saying 'thank you for telling me' and giving them a hug, not going 'okay, but you didn't need to announce it, I'm fine with it' it will cost you nothing and make them feel good about it.
For the love of God, don't make it about you 'well why didn't you tell me sooner?' Or 'why do you think id have a problem with it?'
If you ARE concerned, let the heat die off, days weeks whatever, and go to them with an attitude of curiosity, not of defence.
'Hey, I just wanted to check, did you announce you were gay because I've done something to make you feel worried about doing so in the past? Just wanted to check, so I don't put my foot in it again'
Then you can have an open conversation - you may have done nothing, or you may have done or said something that you have entirely forgotten and was not meant with any malice, but if it put a worry in your child's head its good to be able to go 'oh, sorry, absolutely not my intention' without getting into a big argument about it.

Unfortunately there are still PLENTY of people out there who are 'fine' with gay people but then say things like 'ugh. Not got a problem with it, but why does he have to be all camp' so just be mindful that evening you yourself are supportive, it's understandable lots of people might feel a little on edge due to the dickheads out there.

Remember it's about the bigger goal - did you kid feel supported and loved when they came out. That's the bit that gets remembered. You getting prickly because 'people don't need to come out' or getting defensive over being mistakenly perceived as a homophobe just turns it into a stressful memory for no reason, when it doesn't matter - what matters is that your kid was stressed and needed to feel loved.

Best of luck to all the parents out there - do it with love, and you'll be doing your best.

Catshaveiteasy · 23/02/2024 20:40

I don't think you should be over direct. It's up to her to let you know when she feels ready. I don't think over-demonstrating your 'tolerance' is a good idea either. Generally you should show that you are tolerant of all sexualities, but it's her life and she may feel more awkward if you keep trying to make it clear how cool you are.

One of my dds used to say she thought she was lesbian. She had some intense friendships with other girls, though there was only one that felt it could be a relationship. I did end up asking her, only as I felt it was potentially coercive, but she said it wasn't sexual.

She never showed any interest in boys until the day she told me she had a boyfriend. They've just broken up after nearly 3 years together.

My other dd at 14/15 told me her entire friendship group, including her, were bisexual and talked a lot about lgbt issues. A few years later, it became clear she was quite obsessed with boys and she never mentions it now.

I'm not saying your dd isn't gay but not everyone is clear about their sexuality as a teen.

I'd say just be interested in her life, listen to her if she wants to talk and let her tell you, if she wants to, when she is ready.

Savemykitchen · 23/02/2024 20:37

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2024 20:16

I'm a terrible person and I read the first ten posts then cracked.

The whole 'coming out is peculiar' thing is homophobic. I'm sorry, but it is.

Of course people have to come out. Most people are straight. Unsurprisingly, most people assume most people are straight. So, if you are not straight, you generally do have to tell people.

When I hear someone say 'coming out is ridiculous' or 'straight people don't have to come out!' what I hear is 'how attention-seeking the gays are!' or 'what a fuss about nothing!'. That may not be what you mean, personally - but it's how it comes across.

Your child's sexuality is probably something they do feel is important.

Came onto agree. She's not told you, because she doesn't feel like it's a welcome environment to be honest. That's the crux of it

I have relatives who "love gays" have many gay acquaintances and yet still don't agree they should marry... But they're not homophobic Hmm. Acceptance is acceptance, it doesn't come with clauses or ifs and buts.

How much queer culture is there in your life? Is it a topic of conversation or dismissed? You don't have to go to Pride, but do you ever listen to music, read or watch programmes by queer creatives. What about when topics are in the news?

SausageRollsWithMustard · 23/02/2024 20:28

Agree with PP, mention both boyfriend and girlfriend in conversation.

It worked for a boy I know who was scared of sharing that he is bi.

He actually cried with relief. 🙂

YireosDodeAver · 23/02/2024 20:28

It seems a bit weird that you've waited this long to communicate to your DD that love is love and the combination of MF/FF/MM is immaterial.

I think my DS was about 7 or 8 when we first started having conversations which included such concepts in an age-appropriate way.

When we see family friends who are in same-sex relationships we are clear that they are wife&wife or husband&husband not just "friends who live together"

Whenever we talk about the future and it's relevant to speculate about what life might be like in the family in 30 years time we use gender-neutral language about any theoretical partner DS might end up with.

Acceotance of all sexual orientations isn't a concept you wait until age 16 to introduce!

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2024 20:25

It's so great! Grin

2mummies1baby · 23/02/2024 20:25

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2024 20:22

On this subject, 'Never Have I Ever' is a TV series but has a fabulous lesbian secondary character (I know; I know - we need Heartstopper for the girls, but we don't have it, so ...).

Yes! Love that show.

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2024 20:22

2mummies1baby · 23/02/2024 20:19

Lots of people are recommending films which focus on gay men- don't get me wrong, I love a good gay romance, but probably more relevant for OP's daughter to watch something with a lesbian focus if you want to go down that route! Nina's Heavenly Delights and DEBS are both lesbian romances which a teenage girl could watch with her parents without dying of embarrassment.

On this subject, 'Never Have I Ever' is a TV series but has a fabulous lesbian secondary character (I know; I know - we need Heartstopper for the girls, but we don't have it, so ...).

Heeely87 · 23/02/2024 20:21

When the subject of boyfriends or girlfriends comes up in our house. (Not at that point yet). I always mention both, and say it's up to you! And the kids laugh 😂

2mummies1baby · 23/02/2024 20:20

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2024 20:16

I'm a terrible person and I read the first ten posts then cracked.

The whole 'coming out is peculiar' thing is homophobic. I'm sorry, but it is.

Of course people have to come out. Most people are straight. Unsurprisingly, most people assume most people are straight. So, if you are not straight, you generally do have to tell people.

When I hear someone say 'coming out is ridiculous' or 'straight people don't have to come out!' what I hear is 'how attention-seeking the gays are!' or 'what a fuss about nothing!'. That may not be what you mean, personally - but it's how it comes across.

Your child's sexuality is probably something they do feel is important.

100% this.

RoseProseccoini · 23/02/2024 20:19

Haven’t RTWT. My DD told me that she ‘liked girls not boys’ at 13. I just said ‘the most important thing you can be in life is yourself and know that you are very loved’.

She is 18 now and said the other day that she was so grateful that I knew she knew her own mind and didn’t patronise her by assuming it was ‘a phase’.

Not sure that that is helpful or not but I think you just need to get across that love and support is not dependent on anything as a parent.

A couple of my very best friends are gay, DD knew that there would be no judgement from me.

2mummies1baby · 23/02/2024 20:19

Lots of people are recommending films which focus on gay men- don't get me wrong, I love a good gay romance, but probably more relevant for OP's daughter to watch something with a lesbian focus if you want to go down that route! Nina's Heavenly Delights and DEBS are both lesbian romances which a teenage girl could watch with her parents without dying of embarrassment.

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2024 20:18

(Oh, and ... I would just talk about 'coming out' in a normal way. I wouldn't call it 'peculiar'. I would just accept it is something that is probably already in your daughter's life, and will continue to be for the foreseeable future if she is gay.)

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2024 20:16

I'm a terrible person and I read the first ten posts then cracked.

The whole 'coming out is peculiar' thing is homophobic. I'm sorry, but it is.

Of course people have to come out. Most people are straight. Unsurprisingly, most people assume most people are straight. So, if you are not straight, you generally do have to tell people.

When I hear someone say 'coming out is ridiculous' or 'straight people don't have to come out!' what I hear is 'how attention-seeking the gays are!' or 'what a fuss about nothing!'. That may not be what you mean, personally - but it's how it comes across.

Your child's sexuality is probably something they do feel is important.

Bellaboo01 · 23/02/2024 20:16

It sounds like your Daughter has many issues. Why would you think that whoever she is attracted to is the reason for her issues.
Posters in the room etc is a bit of a reach.

2mummies1baby · 23/02/2024 20:14

Caerulea · 23/02/2024 11:22

Coming to say this! Always did that with my 3 boys, so it was totally normalised. As a result, youngest (now nearly 15) actually forgot he'd not told us he was gay, it was only cos he was worried about seeing MIL & her reacting badly so he sounded off to me in the car. I didn't say I didn't know (I mean, we all did), he mentioned it months later with 'did I actually ever tell you I'm gay?' & I was like 'nope' & we laughed about it. He was 11 at the time.

OP - maybe drop something around the gap year about meeting a girlf/boyf or going travelling with girlf/boyf' etc. Just be very normal & very very boring about it.

That is adorable. I'm so glad that so many kids these days have that kind of experience of coming out... or not, as the case may be!

2mummies1baby · 23/02/2024 20:10

Catza · 23/02/2024 11:09

Call Me By Your Name is a wonderful movie - very positive with a little bit of age-appropriate heartbreak

I disagree- the age-gap is very problematic!

chrispychilli · 23/02/2024 18:44

Anindexoftheliesihavetold · 23/02/2024 10:01

@ReadingLight, thank you for that. I have looked more into the movie and you're absolutely right!

So sorry OP- I should have been more clear - I wasn't suggesting watching it with her , not only is it terribly sad it's also potentially quite embarrassing to watch with your mum - it was more of a conversation starter about outdated attitudes.

Lovingitallnow · 23/02/2024 14:04

I saw the cutest thing on instagram the other day. A woman's father had died a few years ago and his anniversary was coming up and she suggested to her sister that they watch broke back mountain together to commemorate him. Because it was his favourite movie. The sister was like wtf are you on about. He never mentioned it once. At which point the woman realised it was because she was gay and he wanted her to know he was cool with it and then it grew legs and they just ended up watching it whenever they were together. Maybe go find your Brokeback mountain.

danesch · 23/02/2024 13:56

Broadly agree with the consensus on here, which seems to be to be to check and modify your language and behaviours if they are heteronormative, and to take opportunities which present themselves in conversation. Watching First Dates/Modern Family both seem like really good opportunities to me.

I think there are (thankfully) real generational differences in how much of a 'big deal' sexual orientation is and people's attitudes to it. I'm late-40s and, as well as some outright homophobia, a general squeamishness about non-straight sexuality was very much around when I grew up and it's important to check in with ourselves about how that's affected us. I think some of your anxiety about doing the right thing here stems from wanting to show that you don't hold any of those attitudes yourself maybe? (I think I felt a bit like that when I found out my DD was a lesbian - I was very conscious that I didn't wanted to do or say anything that would imply my own shame or disappointment. I feel and felt neither of those things, but I still felt anxious to convey to my daughter that I didn't feel them and I think that's a hangover from the environment I grew up in.)

I am glad I have always talked about partners/'boy or girlfriends' etc with my children and I would advise any parents of young children on the thread to do so from an early age.

BreatheAndFocus · 23/02/2024 13:23

When I started to suspect she might be I stopped talking about her future exclusively in terms of a husband or a boyfriend

But why would you assume anything like that anyway? The way to communicate to your DC that being gay or bisexual is fine, is to raise them in an atmosphere that makes that clear by the way you talk: “When you grow up and meet someone you love…” , “If you have a partner….”, etc.

It’s not hard and it greatly reduces any problem if your DC does turn out to be gay or bi. When I was in my teens and thinking of telling my parents, all I could think about was a) their assumptions about me meeting a man, having a husband, etc; and the implicit shame around being gay when I heard it whispered about (“She’s a lesbian, you know”).

OP, it might be better to communicate your acceptance indirectly rather than talk to your DD directly. I’d have cringed hugely if my DPs had come up and merrily started chatting about it. I’d also probably have lied - because I wasn’t ready. Make a point of making subtle comments about gay and lesbian people like “Kate is lovely, isn’t she, and she and her girlfriend are always so helpful”, “What a lovely photo! Dave and Andy look so happy together” etc.

Finally, I don’t agree with encouraging people to label themselves too early. If they do, then that can lead to shame and embarrassment if they later find a partner of the ‘wrong’ sex. Keep things light. Avoid labels.

Shabooboogaloo · 23/02/2024 13:19

‘She is 16 ,her tastes could change ‘

flipping hate when straight people say that.
No-one ever talks straight teens out of dating the opposite sex.

Swipe left for the next trending thread