Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to gently let my DD know that it's okay by me if she's gay?

138 replies

Anindexoftheliesihavetold · 23/02/2024 08:40

I have NC for this

DD is 16. She's had some low level struggles with her emotional wellbeing for a few years. Over that time we've gone from thinking it's shyness, low mood, the perils of adolescence, social media, social anxiety, neurodiversity, etc etc. She's had some therapeutic interventions with some degree of success. Now she's started 6th form she's definitely in a better place, although anxiety over the next steps after school is high. We have told her that we will be fully supportive of a gap year while she works out which direction she wants to take.

Anyway. She's never had any interest in boys, and some of the walls in her room are covered in a selection of 4 or 5 females artists' photos. She pretty much only listens to female artists. A couple of years ago she had a friendship with this girl, and I found out indirectly that they were 'together', as the mother of a common friend of both saw something on social media. I never said anything to my DD about it.

Her dad and I are of the belief that people's sexual preferences are their business and their business only, and that 'coming out' is a peculiar concept in itself. However, I have started to believe that perhaps getting this out in the open at home and letting DD know that we are completely supportive of who she is and that we sort of 'know' and we're fine with it, might alleviate some of her anxiety over who she is. But I also worry that this is none of my business and I'd be stepping over boundaries.

Please don't be too harsh, I genuinely don't know if I am getting this wrong, but I want advice as I want to get it right. Thanks.

OP posts:
wandawaves · 24/02/2024 05:29

JustWoww · 23/02/2024 11:49

I would not say anything to her - you never know her relationship with a girl might have been purely platonic or she was experimenting or she is bi....once you bring it up you are bringing up a label she feels she needs an answer to.
Just continue to be supportive of other people's relationships outside of the home / on media etc so she knows you are accepting of different choices.

I once thought my teen daughter was gay for years because of her choices including she would repeatedly not let male doctors examine her for a debilitating condition she needed medication for but could only get after an examination - she eventually told me herself she was not gay.

I once thought my teen daughter was gay for years because of her choices including she would repeatedly not let male doctors examine her for a debilitating condition she needed medication for but could only get after an examination - she eventually told me herself she was not gay.

Ermm... what?? WTF are you on about? Do you think that people are only comfortable with medical professionals that they can be sexually attracted to? What a bizarre comment.

Minimili · 24/02/2024 04:28

ExtraOnions · 23/02/2024 09:25

Erm no … I know my daughter, and I know the context. Don’t be projecting your own issues, the world does not revolve around you.

I’m childless and I read your post and it made me smile because that’s the kind of banter I had with my mum.
I bet it’s a lovely moment to look back on and don’t let anyone make you think otherwise, why would anyone possibly be offended about a conversation you had between you?

Isthismyforever · 24/02/2024 02:31

Honestly, I wouldn't do anything. My ds never actually 'came out'. He just waited until he was in a relationship & then told me about the relationship, not that he was gay. Don't make a big deal of it. I actually asked him if he had been scared to tell me as he didn't know how I would react - he said of course not. He didn't think it was something he needed to even tell me. My other ds didn't 'tell me' he was straight. Maybe she feels there's no need for a big announcement? Just be there if & when she decides to open up to you.

Nat6999 · 24/02/2024 02:21

My ds told me he was gay when he was 12, lots of tears from him, but I told him I would love him whatever he was. He met his dh when he was 18 & got married last summer. There is a lot of incidence of same sex relationships in SEN children, most of ds friends who are LGBT have SEN. Just let her tell you in her own time, but make it clear you love & care for her whatever she chooses to be.

YankSplaining · 24/02/2024 00:58

*Accidentally looking really naive

YankSplaining · 24/02/2024 00:56

juniorspesh · 23/02/2024 09:52

Her dad and I are of the belief that people's sexual preferences are their business and their business only, and that 'coming out' is a peculiar concept in itself.

In my experience when people say stuff like this they often mean well, but it's minimising how important it is for people to open up to those close to them, and to feel seen and understood.

Maybe try and unpack about what "their business and their business only" feels like in a world where to be gay was recently illegal, followed by several decades where public opinion was grudgingly like "well it's fine as long as they don't shove it in our faces", keeping people in the miserable closet. I don't think you want to be that guy, OP.

Yeah. I don’t think I’ve ever heard anyone gay or bi say this, either - it tends to be something some straight people say when they’re trying to show how accepting they are, but end up accidentally really naive.

Treehuggingmutherfunkin · 24/02/2024 00:37

I think let her come out on her own

Bobbotgegrinch · 24/02/2024 00:31

We're in a similar situation with our 16yo DD.

I'm 95% sure she's gay, and she sounds similarly anxious about anything like this to your daughter @Anindexoftheliesihavetold

Luckily we've been watching Buffy the vampire slayer over the past year or so, and the Willow / Tara relationship has been a perfect opener to conversations about same sex relationships without directly having to discuss DD.

I'm bi, which DD wasn't aware of until recently, because I've been in a heterosexual relationship with her mum for 18 years. Buffy helped us broach that conversation, along with conversations about coming out in the 90s Vs now, and how my parents reacted, which allowed me to talk about how I'd react differently to how my parents did.

I'm not suggesting you to watch Buffy, because it's 80 odd episodes before you'll get to that bit, so unless you're playing the long game it's probably not a great timeline.

But TV and film can certainly be good conversation openers, a way of talking about your acceptance without your daughter needing to out herself.

whiteboardking · 24/02/2024 00:16

takemeawayagain · 23/02/2024 09:19

Yes I agree with the 'now you're getting older if you ever want to bring a boyfriend or girlfriend home for dinner then they'd be very welcome' type thing.

This. Ours are younger but we always talk about friends / boyfriends / girlfriends etc all being equally welcome regardless of gay / straight

mimp · 24/02/2024 00:01

My son came out to me at 17. I didn’t really suspect before than but when he told me the first thought was “oh now it all makes sense”
He struggled for a long time with who he was etc before he spoke to me. His friends all knew and told him to talk to us. He told me as he simply knew I’d tell his dad. It’s one of the strangest but sweetest memory I have involving my son.
in the end him coming to me and trusting me was really important to him. We gently told him not to put himself in a box and be open. Letting it out for him removed all the emotional angst and he could finally breathe again.
8 years on he’s content and happy and growing into the most sweetest man ever. He’s also still gay but after talking to us was happy to not stew himself out by trying to figure out who he was. It happened naturally as he’s matured.
I personally think there is to much pressure on young kids to have it all figured out and really they just need to be…
Just love your child at the end of the day that’s what she needs. Let the rest flow at her pace and when she’s ready.

Happyface246 · 23/02/2024 23:57

I could have written your post a couple of years ago. Dd has always been anxious and is under Cahms for possible autism diagnosis. When she was in the 6th form she wrote a note saying that she liked a girl in her class and wanted to let us know. First thing I did was gove her a hug, reassure her that that was ok and that all I cared about was that she was happy. She ended up going out with her girlfriend for 6 months before they naturally went their separate ways. Just be there for your dd and build on that great relationship that you already have xx

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 23:56

Changeusernameseeusernamehistory · 23/02/2024 23:33

She said this In the context of her relationship with her daughter, and it seems they were both saying things in good humour.

private conversations don’t also need to be weighed on whether they may upset someone who is not in the room. equally, Other people’s lives may upset us any number of reason but they can still talk about their lives.

As long aa they are not inherently offensive/discriminatory/criminal

I can't believe I'm having to explain this, but I obviously didn't mean PP had to moderate her speech for the sake of people who weren't in the room, but for the sake of her 17yo daughter. PP describes a conversation where she told the daughter she wants grandchildren to take to Disney, and not to be using her sexuality as an excuse not to provide what she wants. Nobody is entitled to grandchildren, it's a selfish thing to say. PP might think this conversation was lighthearted, but if her DD turns out to be childfree, she will remember this conversation 20 years down the line and it will sting. Lots of things our parents say as we're growing up stay with us. I think parents should be mindful of that. It really does sound like PP is assuming her DD will have kids, and that's just not something anyone should assume.

Okki · 23/02/2024 23:47

My parents randomly sat my brother and I down one day and told us they loved us both unconditionally and we were never to be worried about who we loved and if we were gay, that would be fine with them. We've always told our children that all that matters is they're in a mutually kind and respectful relationship.

Maybe just tell her you love her and will.love whoever she loves.

Changeusernameseeusernamehistory · 23/02/2024 23:33

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 09:09

@ExtraOnions *Her “you do know I’m gay
Me “don’t be using that as an excuse not to give me grandchildren”

All in good humour of course.*

Wow. I know you say it's good humour/'lighthearted' but comments like this are very hurtful to childfree/childless people, regardless of sexuality. Please rethink these sort of comments in future.

She said this In the context of her relationship with her daughter, and it seems they were both saying things in good humour.

private conversations don’t also need to be weighed on whether they may upset someone who is not in the room. equally, Other people’s lives may upset us any number of reason but they can still talk about their lives.

As long aa they are not inherently offensive/discriminatory/criminal

reluctantbrit · 23/02/2024 23:25

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2024 21:13

@reluctantbrit, the thing is, your post actually says to your DD:

'I don't care' about your relationships.

But, your DD might want you to care about more than that bare minimum (that she's not being mistreated, is happy etc.). She might want you to be interested in her life.

Think about it like this: if your DD wanted to paint her bedroom blue, I take it you wouldn't care. You're not blue-phobic. But you might still enter into discussions about whether periwinkle is a nicer shade than ocean, and you might discuss what it is she loves so much about ocean in the first place, and so on. You probably wouldn't say 'DD, I don't care if it's blue, green, or rainbow magenta, so long as you do it'.

Also - and here's where my paint colour analogy falls down - do you really believe sexuality is a matter of choice? And that it's not 'normal'?

Coming out isn't 'a big announcement if you are gay/bi/any other letter of the alphabet'.

Sorry, but no.

I said, I don't care with whom she has a relationship, I said I care that she is happy.

The discussion went a lot further and this quote was just a short part of it. It went even further into demi, ace, pan, adult entertainment and lots more than I want to add here.

Isn't being happy what you want from your child regardless with whom she has a relationship?

And, no, I don't have an in-depth discussion why she thinks lavender is a nice colour for her room. I asked her if she is happy with the colour she chose. Because that is the only important thing for me - she is happy.

No, I don't believe sexuality is a matter of choice, you don't choose if you are gay or straight or whatever. Remember, the discussion was before she told me she identifies as bi. I wanted to ensure her I wouldn't care about her orientation because I never expected her to be straight, she is what she is and I can't change this.

She very well understood that I dont' care what sexuality her partner/partners have but that I care that she is happy in whatever relationship type she enters in the future.
That is why she just added a pride flag to her birthday wishlist withouth any further comment or told me at dinner one day that she has a crush on her best friend. Because she knew I wouldn't care that her crush is a girl or a boy or a person. I would care about her feelings to this girl and we could talk about it.

Unfortunately "normal" in our society still means straight. I worry the impact on her life if she would enter a lesbian relationship for example and wants children, the whisper, the scrutiny, the judgement. Because these things hurt.
I have/had several gay colleagues, all in commited relationships. I know how they changed their behaviour when being in countries gay marriage wasn't recognised or when their own grandparents weren't happy with them marrying another man.

In an ideal world we wouldn't have this discussion. In an ideal world we would just take on any person our child chooses as a partner. But we are not living in an ideal world so these discussions are coming up. Therefore non-straight people still have to "come out" all the time to their parents, work, friends and so on. One of my colleagues was very private, it took years for him to openly say husband instead of partner. He wouldn't correct a new colleague who spotted his wedding ring and innocently said "I hope you and your wife had a nice holiday". I don't want that, I want to ensure that DD is able to be open and proud.

Why do you think there is still a huge drama about any celebrity "coming out", especially male sport stars? Why do they have to do press releases about it? There was no major press release that Harry Kane has a girlfriend/wife. But the fact that a football or rugby player is gay meant media chaos for days.

SpryAmberSeal · 23/02/2024 23:08

My ds is gay, I don't really know when he 'came out' I think it just kind of evolved and it's never been a big deal. In your shoes I think I would just do it. No game playing, no beating around the bush, just a look I know this might be awkward for us both and there's no obligation on you to talk to me about it but it's been playing on my mind and I have to say it.

Mine are teens and I think the whole watch a TV show about gay people or going about it in a round about way just makes it more awkward for everyone. They are teens, not stupid. If I feel I have to say something I just say it but make it clear that I'm not forcing them into a conversation but am here if they need to talk by text or in person. Mine sometimes prefer to get things out over text then talk in person later.

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 23:00

WildBear · 23/02/2024 22:30

If only there was a way to identify and round-up the perpetually offended and ship them all off to a deserted island somewhere 🤔

At least there's an easy way to identify the arseholes 👍 here's one!

Frangipanyoul8r · 23/02/2024 22:41

My mum came straight out and said “if you’re a lesbian you know I would support you and love you just the same”. I’m not gay but really respected her little speech and knew she had my back whatever choices I made.

WildBear · 23/02/2024 22:30

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 09:09

@ExtraOnions *Her “you do know I’m gay
Me “don’t be using that as an excuse not to give me grandchildren”

All in good humour of course.*

Wow. I know you say it's good humour/'lighthearted' but comments like this are very hurtful to childfree/childless people, regardless of sexuality. Please rethink these sort of comments in future.

If only there was a way to identify and round-up the perpetually offended and ship them all off to a deserted island somewhere 🤔

Catza · 23/02/2024 22:24

2mummies1baby · 23/02/2024 20:10

I disagree- the age-gap is very problematic!

I think this is just a choice of actors. There wasn't that much of a gap between them in a book.
In any case, we cannot censor what children see. I find it is best to have a conversation about it rather than try to limit exposure.

Lurkerusually · 23/02/2024 22:20

Anything you do will be cringe. That’s cause you’re a parent and they are a teenager. Just let them work it out for themselves.

Combattingthemoaners · 23/02/2024 22:19

Coming out isn’t peculiar. It’s what has to happen when you are gay over and over again throughout your whole life to every new person you meet. When people stop assuming heterosexuality is the norm then people can stop having to come out.

woooaaaahhhhh · 23/02/2024 22:15

I'd try to find an opportunity to talk about gay people generally in a positive manner. Or next time she brings a girl mention how great she is and they would look good as a couple.

ChihuahuasREvil · 23/02/2024 21:20

Being same-sex attracted is not a preference, just like being opposite sex attracted isn’t a preference.

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2024 21:13

@reluctantbrit, the thing is, your post actually says to your DD:

'I don't care' about your relationships.

But, your DD might want you to care about more than that bare minimum (that she's not being mistreated, is happy etc.). She might want you to be interested in her life.

Think about it like this: if your DD wanted to paint her bedroom blue, I take it you wouldn't care. You're not blue-phobic. But you might still enter into discussions about whether periwinkle is a nicer shade than ocean, and you might discuss what it is she loves so much about ocean in the first place, and so on. You probably wouldn't say 'DD, I don't care if it's blue, green, or rainbow magenta, so long as you do it'.

Also - and here's where my paint colour analogy falls down - do you really believe sexuality is a matter of choice? And that it's not 'normal'?

Coming out isn't 'a big announcement if you are gay/bi/any other letter of the alphabet'.