Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to gently let my DD know that it's okay by me if she's gay?

138 replies

Anindexoftheliesihavetold · 23/02/2024 08:40

I have NC for this

DD is 16. She's had some low level struggles with her emotional wellbeing for a few years. Over that time we've gone from thinking it's shyness, low mood, the perils of adolescence, social media, social anxiety, neurodiversity, etc etc. She's had some therapeutic interventions with some degree of success. Now she's started 6th form she's definitely in a better place, although anxiety over the next steps after school is high. We have told her that we will be fully supportive of a gap year while she works out which direction she wants to take.

Anyway. She's never had any interest in boys, and some of the walls in her room are covered in a selection of 4 or 5 females artists' photos. She pretty much only listens to female artists. A couple of years ago she had a friendship with this girl, and I found out indirectly that they were 'together', as the mother of a common friend of both saw something on social media. I never said anything to my DD about it.

Her dad and I are of the belief that people's sexual preferences are their business and their business only, and that 'coming out' is a peculiar concept in itself. However, I have started to believe that perhaps getting this out in the open at home and letting DD know that we are completely supportive of who she is and that we sort of 'know' and we're fine with it, might alleviate some of her anxiety over who she is. But I also worry that this is none of my business and I'd be stepping over boundaries.

Please don't be too harsh, I genuinely don't know if I am getting this wrong, but I want advice as I want to get it right. Thanks.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WildBear · 25/02/2024 22:50

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 23:00

At least there's an easy way to identify the arseholes 👍 here's one!

And an easy way to identify the unfunny bores.

UnimaginableWindBird · 25/02/2024 07:20

I've just always tried to include various options with my children when talking about relationships, so talking about a possible future husband or wife etc.

Anindexoftheliesihavetold · 25/02/2024 07:02

Thank you all again. I am grateful for all the responses. A lot of people have commented on the bit where I said 'coming out' is a peculiar concept in itself, that this might be a dismissive stance which may fail to appreciate the enormity of it for others. This has given me a lot of food for thought. So thank you for that also.🙏

OP posts:
AliCB · 24/02/2024 20:49

My daughter told me out of the blue she was pansexual and had started dating a girl. I said great and asked if she would like to bring her over from a meal. I have always been a liberal parent and have talked about most things with my daughter. A year and a half later and now she is single again and thinks she prefers boys now. In the teenager years, they are still learning about who they are.
Do you talk about sex, or sexual orientation? If not then just introduce it into the conversation, or if something comes up on the TV about sexual orientation, it would be a natural conversation to be had. I hope this helps a little bit 😊

JayJayEl · 24/02/2024 20:31

Agree with many PPs - all these posts along the lines of "straight people don't have to come out," "this shouldn't be a big deal," etc are quite frustrating. It really downplays what a huge, brave and constant thing coming out is. You don't just come out once. You have to come out to family and friends, and then work colleagues, if you change a job, new neighbours, medical staff, your child's teachers...the list is endless. It would be amazing if society worked in a way that meant coming out wasn't necessary, but unfortunately that's not the case. So the act of coming out should not be downplayed. At all.

And just to add - you can only come out if you feel safe! I have been in many a situation where someone has assumed I am straight, but I've been too uncomfortable (and sometimes felt too unsafe) to correct them. And fck me that is HARD. It essentially feels like being shoved back in to the closet!

Anyway, that's not the original point of the thread. @Anindexoftheliesihavetold , there are some excellent suggestions here! Hopefully they've provided you with guidance that is suitable for you and your daughter.

And the handful of posters who suggested that your daughter not yet discussing this with you is somehow down to you and your parenting are being ridiculous. Two of the closest people in the world wouldn't be okay with telling one another every last thing about themselves. Especially if they themselves hadn't yet got their own head around it. X

JayJayEl · 24/02/2024 20:28

innerdesign · 24/02/2024 18:16

If people are going to insist on derailing the thread - I can't speak for everyone, but I think it is a common experience not to want to disappoint your parents and to worry what they think of you (given that it's sort of the point of this whole thread). There have been threads on the MNers without Children forum showing that these sorts of comments from parents do cause a lot of hurt, guilt and pressure later in life. Regardless, if there's a chance it could be hurtful, why say it to your own child?

Surely there is a chance that almost anything you ever say could be hurtful? So why say anything at all?

SarahAndQuack · 24/02/2024 18:31

reluctantbrit · 23/02/2024 23:25

Sorry, but no.

I said, I don't care with whom she has a relationship, I said I care that she is happy.

The discussion went a lot further and this quote was just a short part of it. It went even further into demi, ace, pan, adult entertainment and lots more than I want to add here.

Isn't being happy what you want from your child regardless with whom she has a relationship?

And, no, I don't have an in-depth discussion why she thinks lavender is a nice colour for her room. I asked her if she is happy with the colour she chose. Because that is the only important thing for me - she is happy.

No, I don't believe sexuality is a matter of choice, you don't choose if you are gay or straight or whatever. Remember, the discussion was before she told me she identifies as bi. I wanted to ensure her I wouldn't care about her orientation because I never expected her to be straight, she is what she is and I can't change this.

She very well understood that I dont' care what sexuality her partner/partners have but that I care that she is happy in whatever relationship type she enters in the future.
That is why she just added a pride flag to her birthday wishlist withouth any further comment or told me at dinner one day that she has a crush on her best friend. Because she knew I wouldn't care that her crush is a girl or a boy or a person. I would care about her feelings to this girl and we could talk about it.

Unfortunately "normal" in our society still means straight. I worry the impact on her life if she would enter a lesbian relationship for example and wants children, the whisper, the scrutiny, the judgement. Because these things hurt.
I have/had several gay colleagues, all in commited relationships. I know how they changed their behaviour when being in countries gay marriage wasn't recognised or when their own grandparents weren't happy with them marrying another man.

In an ideal world we wouldn't have this discussion. In an ideal world we would just take on any person our child chooses as a partner. But we are not living in an ideal world so these discussions are coming up. Therefore non-straight people still have to "come out" all the time to their parents, work, friends and so on. One of my colleagues was very private, it took years for him to openly say husband instead of partner. He wouldn't correct a new colleague who spotted his wedding ring and innocently said "I hope you and your wife had a nice holiday". I don't want that, I want to ensure that DD is able to be open and proud.

Why do you think there is still a huge drama about any celebrity "coming out", especially male sport stars? Why do they have to do press releases about it? There was no major press release that Harry Kane has a girlfriend/wife. But the fact that a football or rugby player is gay meant media chaos for days.

Sorry, but no. I said, I don't care with whom she has a relationship, I said I care that she is happy.

Yes, and I am making the point that starting your reply with 'I don't care' might come across as if you think it's not important. She might want you to care both that she is happy, and about her sexuality?

No, I don't believe sexuality is a matter of choice, you don't choose if you are gay or straight or whatever. But you've just said you told your DD But we support you whatever you choose.

Unfortunately "normal" in our society still means straight. Does it? Depends which meaning of 'normal' you're going with, and it matters. Yes, of course, it is statistically more common to be straight, and yes, our society normalises heterosexuality as a cultural practice. But there is a long, long history of people using 'normal' in the context of sexuality to mean 'not aberrant, not perverted'. If you look up 'normal' in a dictionary, synonyms might include 'natural' or 'not aberrant,' and therefore, when you talk to someone who isn't straight about their sexuality, 'normal' packs quite a punch. It isn't a neutral term.

In an ideal world we wouldn't have this discussion. In an ideal world we would just take on any person our child chooses as a partner. But we are not living in an ideal world so these discussions are coming up. Therefore non-straight people still have to "come out" all the time to their parents, work, friends and so on. One of my colleagues was very private, it took years for him to openly say husband instead of partner. He wouldn't correct a new colleague who spotted his wedding ring and innocently said "I hope you and your wife had a nice holiday". I don't want that, I want to ensure that DD is able to be open and proud.

Why do you think there is still a huge drama about any celebrity "coming out", especially male sport stars? Why do they have to do press releases about it? There was no major press release that Harry Kane has a girlfriend/wife. But the fact that a football or rugby player is gay meant media chaos for days.

I'm very well aware of why people come out, thanks. But I was responding to you saying I hate the idea that a person has to justify why she/he is in love with someone not the normal opposite sex. Nobody is "coming out" as straight so why should it be a big announcement if you are gay/bi/any other letter of the alphabet. Obviously, you do know why people have to come out. But your earlier post that I'm quoting here makes it sound as if you disapprove of gay people coming out and making a 'big announcement' - and your snotty phrase 'any other letter of the alphabet' sounds really dismissive of your DD. Perhaps you didn't mean to sound that way, and you really do get why people have to come out, as you say in this second post. But, keep in mind: your DD may not want to be 'open and proud'. She might be quite private. She might want to shout it from the rooftops. Fine. We're all different.

innerdesign · 24/02/2024 18:16

theduchessofspork · 24/02/2024 17:29

They aren’t hurtful at all to a lot of child free people

If people are going to insist on derailing the thread - I can't speak for everyone, but I think it is a common experience not to want to disappoint your parents and to worry what they think of you (given that it's sort of the point of this whole thread). There have been threads on the MNers without Children forum showing that these sorts of comments from parents do cause a lot of hurt, guilt and pressure later in life. Regardless, if there's a chance it could be hurtful, why say it to your own child?

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/02/2024 17:30

When Dd was about 14 or 15 we had a chat about staying over at parties and I explained why I didn't think it was ok. She acussed me of not wanting her to have sex and ( rightly) pointed out she could be having sex with her girlfriends with whom she had sleepovers regularly. I simply said " I don't care who you have sex with as long as it's sex that you want to have". She has said that was one the best and most supportive things I ever said. So I thought I'd share it here, in case it is helpful.

BrokenBonesStixStones · 24/02/2024 17:29

My friends parents said something similar to him, and although he wasn’t ready to say anything to them at that time, he did feel comforted by the fact they would be supportive. He came out to them a few months later.

theduchessofspork · 24/02/2024 17:29

innerdesign · 23/02/2024 09:09

@ExtraOnions *Her “you do know I’m gay
Me “don’t be using that as an excuse not to give me grandchildren”

All in good humour of course.*

Wow. I know you say it's good humour/'lighthearted' but comments like this are very hurtful to childfree/childless people, regardless of sexuality. Please rethink these sort of comments in future.

They aren’t hurtful at all to a lot of child free people

shellyleppard · 24/02/2024 17:26

Op sending the biggest of hugs. My 18 year old son is bi sexual but didn't know how to tell me. Was worried about how I would react. I gave him the biggest hug and we both cried. I told him at the end of the day he's still my son and I will love him no matter what x

reluctantbrit · 24/02/2024 17:19

2mummies1baby · 24/02/2024 14:39

@Shabooboogaloo Who made the comment you quoted at the beginning?

That was me.

Depending with whom you speak and where you live, I unfortunately still see it happening that way.

And I am still sure that people are hurt by often careless and thoughtless comments.

@Shabooboogaloo

I am not a Brit by birth, I lived here for over 2 decades and still am hurt when I read racist comments or comments about immigration because I can't believe that people's opinions have gone back instead of forward in the 21st century.

Read up on opinions in the US, especially the Bible Belt. I wouldn't want DD to live there as a gay/bi person. Do you?

2mummies1baby · 24/02/2024 14:39

@Shabooboogaloo Who made the comment you quoted at the beginning?

Shabooboogaloo · 24/02/2024 11:05

‘Unfortunately "normal" in our society still means straight. I worry the impact on her life if she would enter a lesbian relationship for example and wants children, the whisper, the scrutiny, the judgement’

being gay is normal for many, and society is beginning to realise this. I am gay and I had kids with DP. I know lots of gay women who have had kids with their wives/partners.

I have always been out and open /!: quite frankly if there is ‘the whisper’ I would ignore it. And I don’t give a flying fuck who may or may not judge me- I don’t have these people in my life and don’t care about their opinion!
Just as any straight person who is divorced wouldn’t care about the opinion of someone who thought that was wrong, or any straight person who is in a mixed race relationship wouldn’t care about the opinion of racists or any straight person in an interfaith marriage wouldn’t care…

you get the idea. If she’s gay then she’s gay… will get on with it and not give a monkeys about what anyone else thinks about it. The most important thing is her parents don’t care. When you have the love and acceptance and support of your family the outside world matters very little…

Shimmyshimm · 24/02/2024 10:02

I had the same issue with DS, now 23, I had talked around the issue for years letting him know it was fine and I also had some very close gay friends.
When he was 16 and in the car, we were again talking around the issue when I said are we going to address the elephant sitting in the back seat?
We both started to laugh and acknowledge that we both knew the other knew but hadn't actually spoke about it. It's now a really nice memory and I think we were both glad to get it out in the open.

Combattingthemoaners · 24/02/2024 09:50

SGBK4862 · 24/02/2024 09:48

Happy to stand corrected! Thanks for the article, will have a good read.

Combattingthemoaners · 24/02/2024 09:46

serin · 24/02/2024 08:19

One of our DS's started seeing his BF at 16, there was no coming out that I remember. We've never assumed the sexuality of any of our DC.
They're 22 now and still together.

This is also really important. Use terms like “partner” or when you have a “boyfriend or girlfriend” from a really young age. I think some people still frown upon this as they see it as “pushing” homosexuality onto children but they will be gay regardless, it isn’t a choice! They just won’t have as much self loathing as children from families where heterosexuality is the norm and enforced.

Combattingthemoaners · 24/02/2024 09:43

Nat6999 · 24/02/2024 02:21

My ds told me he was gay when he was 12, lots of tears from him, but I told him I would love him whatever he was. He met his dh when he was 18 & got married last summer. There is a lot of incidence of same sex relationships in SEN children, most of ds friends who are LGBT have SEN. Just let her tell you in her own time, but make it clear you love & care for her whatever she chooses to be.

There is absolutely no link between sexuality and SEN. I find it odd that you’ve even mentioned it? Like it’s some sort of consequence of being ND.

TeaGlouriousTea · 24/02/2024 09:26

I wouldn’t say anything specifically about her because it is a sort of confirm or deny scenario. I would when the time was ok such as a lesbian couple was on tv say I’m glad people can be together as a same sex couple now not like when I was young sort of thing. I am straight but had a workmate who was a lesbian and I used to go out with her and her mates sometimes so DS knew it was all good.

SavetheNHS · 24/02/2024 09:02

I personally couldn't bear the thought of my child suffering and spending years building up to telling me they were LGBTQ+, not knowing of we would still love them or accept them.
Like pp, we've always said "boyfriend or girlfriend" and discussed issues such as same sex marriage being legalised as a really positive thing. I still think it can be nerve wracking for a young person to come out. Personally I would just come out and say directly to them (or send a text) that "btw after reading a recent social media post I just wanted to let you that we love you and whether you are gay or bi or straight we will always love you and see you just the same. I know that not all teens know that their parents would still love and accept them so I wanted to make sure you knew we would. You don't have to tell me your sexuality but if you ever do, know you will have instant acceptance and our constant support". Or something like that. Anyway, best of luck to you both.

serin · 24/02/2024 08:19

One of our DS's started seeing his BF at 16, there was no coming out that I remember. We've never assumed the sexuality of any of our DC.
They're 22 now and still together.

Eviebeans · 24/02/2024 05:50

In my experience what a young person sees from their parents regarding different types of relationships doesn’t always come into play when it relates to them because it then becomes personal and that feels very different.
it may not be as simple as “coming out” as ……. (which I also think is unnecessary). But they may not know what they “are” right now which must be so unsettling for them to say the least.
Being young now is so much more complicated than it used to be.