Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told him he can't buy it?

161 replies

peachpearplums · 23/02/2024 08:40

I live with my bloke- long term relationship but not married. We do not have joint finances but have a mortgage together.

I earn more than him and pay about double what he does into the household pot. Recently, I've been having to top the joint account up even more (winter fuel bill, cost of groceries etc) and he is still only putting in the same amount, saying he can't afford more. (He works much less than full time, so could pick up more work... but doesn't want to.)

Now, he's been looking at a new PC and talking about how 'cheaply' he can build it. I've categorically told him no, he cannot buy a new computer when we're barely staying in the black in our joint account. His current PC is absolutely fine and more than high powered enough to do whatever he needs to do.

Either he can't afford to pay more into the joint account, so he can't afford a new computer... or he CAN afford it, and is lying to me about not putting more into the joint account.

I'm getting fed up with all my money going into joint expenses, and him paying a paltry amount to have a good quality of life, then wanting to spend his extras on fripperies.

YABU- I'm being controlling and unfair
YANBU- I did the right thing in telling him no

OP posts:
NoMoreLifts · 23/02/2024 12:50

peachpearplums · 23/02/2024 11:41

@Workawayxx , you're right about the resentment. It has been slowly creeping in. I get that, as a higher earner anyway, it's only fair for me to pay more. But his contribution only cover half the mortgage, let alone the food bill, council tax, gas, electric and water etc.

He worked almost full time when he lived by himself, and I've not really paid much attention to how he's quietly dropped increasing hours until relatively recently.

His earnings are inconsistent, so it's really hard to pin down how much he actually earns.

Tax return is your friend there, assuming it's honest!

Nicole1111 · 23/02/2024 12:43

A spreadsheet is needed. He sounds self employed so presumably he keeps all his earnings recorded for the tax man. This way you can get him to evidence his earnings and work out if you’re paying a fair proportion.

Superscientist · 23/02/2024 12:37

First priority is paying into the family pot.

He doesn't value what you do to financially support the pair of you and thinks you will always step in the fill the gap. He is treating you as a cash cow and isn't behaving as a partner

We have had a few periods where one of us has earned less than the other. One these occasions we have rejigged the financed accordingly and adjusted our lifestyle to the budget of the person on a lower income. Currently I'm on 80% hours and a significant proportion of my income is bonus linked and it's not a guarantee how much or even if I will get the bonus. A good bonus puts me around the same my partner and we have calculated my contribution as if I get a low to average bonus. I think our current split in to the current account is 45:55 and if I do get a good bonus I make a one of payment to make it 50:50 over that 12 month period. It leaves both with a reasonable amount of leftovers at the end of the month. If we need to top up the joint account or if we do work on the house those costs are split 50:50.

His priority has to be being able to make every mortgage payment on time. His next priority is to contribute to the family pot equally so any additional costs that crop up from month to month. Only then do hobbies come into play.

JungsWordTest · 23/02/2024 12:24

Well, he's totally regressed, hasn't he? You've become his mother, and you do the adulting, while he becomes increasingly comfortable in the role of the child.

Nah. I wouldn't stand for that.

BobbyBiscuits · 23/02/2024 12:22

Could you say, well OK, you want this thing. You will need to go without x,y,z as I'm not making up the difference in household expenses.
If he doesn't seem to get it, tell him he needs to take on more hours as that's the only way he can afford stuff without disadvantaging you.

StripeyDeckchair · 23/02/2024 12:20

AllotmentTime · 23/02/2024 08:54

YANBU. He's a cocklodger, point out to him that you're subsidising his PT work and if he doesn't buck his ideas up, get rid.

I'm assuming that he's not doing a vast share of the household chores to compensate but I know you're going to say he sits gaming at home while you work, right? Hence the new PC?

This

Being on the same page re finances is far more important than most people acknowledge.

Tight people, people who don't pull their weight, people who lie about their finances, people who work part time or not at and watch their partner struggle & worry about money are all deeply unattractive and very rarely improve.

DancingFerret · 23/02/2024 12:18

peachpearplums · 23/02/2024 11:41

@Workawayxx , you're right about the resentment. It has been slowly creeping in. I get that, as a higher earner anyway, it's only fair for me to pay more. But his contribution only cover half the mortgage, let alone the food bill, council tax, gas, electric and water etc.

He worked almost full time when he lived by himself, and I've not really paid much attention to how he's quietly dropped increasing hours until relatively recently.

His earnings are inconsistent, so it's really hard to pin down how much he actually earns.

I'm wondering why you think as the higher earner, it's only fair that you should pay more?

My view of a partnership, especially with a joint mortgage, is all outgoings are tallied up and then split equally between the partners with the higher earner keeping their surplus to spend as they wish - whether that involves treating their partner, saving, or whatever, depending on the dynamics of their relationship.

JonVoightBaddyWhoGrowls · 23/02/2024 12:10

The bit I'd struggle with the most is that he's happy to let you work full time and take on the financial burden while he's sitting around working part time, contributing less than half and gaming.

Don't get me wrong, I have no issue with one partner working less than the other for any reason that works for a couple or their dynamic, but NOT when money is an issue and the higher earner is struggling as a result while the lower earner is working less and spending spare money on fripperies. That's just wrong.

MarnieMarnie · 23/02/2024 12:04

I just don't understand how you have any respect for this person. You're effectively supporting an adult who is capable of working but cant be arsed, how do you find that attractive?

Riverlee · 23/02/2024 12:03

Yes, I’d be annoyed if you’re topping up everything g and he suddenly wants to spend pounds on a new computer.

Hopefully this is the wake up call you need and has made you realise he has dropped his hours. In one sense, he’s not totally to blame, as you’ve both let this situation to happen.

Time to grasp the situation by the horn and to make changes. Get him to up his hours or get a new full time job.

Workawayxx · 23/02/2024 12:03

I think you need to have a big discussion with him about finances, prompted by the computer situation but not really about that. I assume you don't have a spare £1000 (?) to spend on fun stuff!

Either he needs to be more transparent and contribute fairly or the end of your relationship altogether. He should know how much he earned April 22-23 at the very least, for tax/HMRC purposes. That might be a good place to start.

I'd also work out how things would look for yourself if you ended the relationship - could you buy him out of the house or downsize?

egowise · 23/02/2024 11:57

Leave him, sell the house or buy him out.

He's taking the piss.

greasypolemonkeyman · 23/02/2024 11:50

peachpearplums · 23/02/2024 11:31

No, we each get paid into our personal accounts then transfer money. That in itself is an issue- I get paid at the end of each month, he gets paid at any point after a piece of work is done. So sometimes he can't put his amount into the joint account on time for the mortgage to go out, so I have to top it up then too. He doesn't save, so there's no contingency.

He doesn't save. How did you assured to buy the house? Where did the deposit come from? When you bought the house how did you register ownership? Did you ring fence YOUR deposit?

peachpearplums · 23/02/2024 11:41

@Workawayxx , you're right about the resentment. It has been slowly creeping in. I get that, as a higher earner anyway, it's only fair for me to pay more. But his contribution only cover half the mortgage, let alone the food bill, council tax, gas, electric and water etc.

He worked almost full time when he lived by himself, and I've not really paid much attention to how he's quietly dropped increasing hours until relatively recently.

His earnings are inconsistent, so it's really hard to pin down how much he actually earns.

OP posts:
Needapadlockonmyfridge · 23/02/2024 11:41

Cocklodger.
CF to boot.

I would be reconsidering my future with him.

Workawayxx · 23/02/2024 11:36

YANBU to switch things up. Are you really willing to subsidise this man for the rest of your lives? It sounds like there's a huge lack of transparency as well around what he earns. Do you know how much "spare" money he has in comparison to you?

I (very heavily) subsided my ex and it ended up feeling like I was living with my overgrown teenage son. Not to mention the resentment when he went down the pub yet again and I couldn't afford the odd new pair of jeans or whatever.

peachpearplums · 23/02/2024 11:31

No, we each get paid into our personal accounts then transfer money. That in itself is an issue- I get paid at the end of each month, he gets paid at any point after a piece of work is done. So sometimes he can't put his amount into the joint account on time for the mortgage to go out, so I have to top it up then too. He doesn't save, so there's no contingency.

OP posts:
Nicole1111 · 23/02/2024 10:52

Do you have a joint account so you can see exactly what he gets paid and whether he truly is as stretched as you are financially.

Mrsttcno1 · 23/02/2024 09:56

GrumpyPanda · 23/02/2024 09:43

That's all very well, but given the specifics OP has outlined either calculation should be based on the full-time equivalent of each partner's income. OP has no moral obligation to subsidize her "D"P sitting on his ass gaming.

Well, no. It should be calculated each month based on the actual wages that each person has earned that month because that is the ACTUAL money available. It’s absolutely pointless calculating it based on what could be. BUT if there isn’t enough money coming into the household then they as a couple need to be having a serious conversation about him increasing his hours.

GrumpyPanda · 23/02/2024 09:43

Mrsttcno1 · 23/02/2024 09:17

How did you calculate who is paying what amount into the joint account?

The fairest ways to do it (if you don’t have joint finances) is either:

A) you both contribute the same % into the joint account, so say you both put 60% of your wages into the joint account. Yes your 60% will be more money than his 60%, but you are both left with 40% of your wages to spend as you wish. If you are doing this method then you are unreasonable to ask him to put more in because you both have the same % of money to spend as “fun money”.

B) you work out what the joint bills are, add both of your salaries together and deduct the bill amount, then split what is left in half. This way yes you’ll be contributing more to the joint account but you are both left with the same amount of “fun money”, so again, you can’t complain about what he chooses to spend his on.

You need to work out exactly what each person is earning and exactly what portion of the bills is “fair” to leave you both with the same or similar amount of fun money.

That's all very well, but given the specifics OP has outlined either calculation should be based on the full-time equivalent of each partner's income. OP has no moral obligation to subsidize her "D"P sitting on his ass gaming.

Blobblobblob · 23/02/2024 09:35

He can't afford to work part time. You're paying him to sit on his arse gaming.

He should be paying 50%, I don't agree that his percentage should be reduced just because he chooses to earn less.

Olika · 23/02/2024 09:30

I would ask him how he is planning on paying his share of monthly expenses as you cannot afford paying more on his behalf.

SpeedyDrama · 23/02/2024 09:22

His hobby isn’t an issue as long as it’s not affecting pulling weight and being a good partner. How he spends his money is not an issue as long as it doesn’t affect paying the essentials. Obviously the latter is a problem. He is an adult and paying bills is the priority. Instead of saying no, would it be possible to sit down and go through both your in/out goings, maybe it would show him that he’s getting a bit of a free ride?

LittleOwl153 · 23/02/2024 09:17

Unless he has health issues or small children to care for,I would tell him as from April he needs to be upping his contribution to household costs. I would base that increase on him increasing his hours to full time. If he chooses not to that is his issue not yours to subsidise. After that I'd be looking at buying him out of the house/selling and calling it quits. Why would you support someone to sit around all day gaming because the choose to whilst you work your ass off to cover the bills.

Mrsttcno1 · 23/02/2024 09:17

How did you calculate who is paying what amount into the joint account?

The fairest ways to do it (if you don’t have joint finances) is either:

A) you both contribute the same % into the joint account, so say you both put 60% of your wages into the joint account. Yes your 60% will be more money than his 60%, but you are both left with 40% of your wages to spend as you wish. If you are doing this method then you are unreasonable to ask him to put more in because you both have the same % of money to spend as “fun money”.

B) you work out what the joint bills are, add both of your salaries together and deduct the bill amount, then split what is left in half. This way yes you’ll be contributing more to the joint account but you are both left with the same amount of “fun money”, so again, you can’t complain about what he chooses to spend his on.

You need to work out exactly what each person is earning and exactly what portion of the bills is “fair” to leave you both with the same or similar amount of fun money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread