Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told him he can't buy it?

161 replies

peachpearplums · 23/02/2024 08:40

I live with my bloke- long term relationship but not married. We do not have joint finances but have a mortgage together.

I earn more than him and pay about double what he does into the household pot. Recently, I've been having to top the joint account up even more (winter fuel bill, cost of groceries etc) and he is still only putting in the same amount, saying he can't afford more. (He works much less than full time, so could pick up more work... but doesn't want to.)

Now, he's been looking at a new PC and talking about how 'cheaply' he can build it. I've categorically told him no, he cannot buy a new computer when we're barely staying in the black in our joint account. His current PC is absolutely fine and more than high powered enough to do whatever he needs to do.

Either he can't afford to pay more into the joint account, so he can't afford a new computer... or he CAN afford it, and is lying to me about not putting more into the joint account.

I'm getting fed up with all my money going into joint expenses, and him paying a paltry amount to have a good quality of life, then wanting to spend his extras on fripperies.

YABU- I'm being controlling and unfair
YANBU- I did the right thing in telling him no

OP posts:
TwylaSands · 24/02/2024 10:59

NettleTea · 24/02/2024 10:03

Perhaps you should base his contribution on what he was earning full time. That way he makes a choice as to whether he wants time off, or wants extra money for toys. But either way you are basing your contributions on an eaqual footing. Im sure youd love to be working part time too

This

Nanny0gg · 24/02/2024 10:57

peachpearplums · 23/02/2024 11:31

No, we each get paid into our personal accounts then transfer money. That in itself is an issue- I get paid at the end of each month, he gets paid at any point after a piece of work is done. So sometimes he can't put his amount into the joint account on time for the mortgage to go out, so I have to top it up then too. He doesn't save, so there's no contingency.

Why WHY why are you putting up with this?

How do you see your future?

Bollindger · 24/02/2024 10:40

Work out a spreadsheet of the last 12 months paid by each if you.
Lay it down in front of him.
Tell him going forward it is being done on a fairer amount.
Right now he owes the account x amount.
Once he is equal with you on payments he can do as he pleases.
That one big job should sort it all out.

Summerlovin24 · 24/02/2024 10:04

Definitely YANBU
Taking the piss. End of
My ex DH would buy stuff HE wanted leaving me to pick up the slack and make sure bills were paid and kids had school shoes etc
Man child. Yours sounds the same.
When we separated he waltzed off with his expensive items. I had nothing.
Sort it out immediately or he will carry on.
It also shows a lack of respect.

NettleTea · 24/02/2024 10:03

Perhaps you should base his contribution on what he was earning full time. That way he makes a choice as to whether he wants time off, or wants extra money for toys. But either way you are basing your contributions on an eaqual footing. Im sure youd love to be working part time too

Naunet · 24/02/2024 09:42

WandaWonder · 24/02/2024 09:11

Well if it is a women choosing not too then it is different it seems

Really? Please do show us a thread where a woman is simply choosing not to work, has no kids, only does at best 50% of the housework and is told by posters here that she should not pay bills that month but treat herself to a computer and her partner can cover her share of the bills. I can’t wait to see.

FreebieWallopFridge · 24/02/2024 09:37

“He worked almost full time when he lived by himself, and I've not really paid much attention to how he's quietly dropped increasing hours until relatively recently.”

Ah. Got yourself a cocklodger there.

44PumpLane · 24/02/2024 09:33

Sorry I've only read OPs posts and not full thread so may have been suggested many times.

If there are no medical issues to his part time work, and he's not substantively pulling his weight by picking up all the household stuff (which it seems he's not from your posts) then I'd be tempted to split bills in line with his full time salary versus your full time salary.

So let's say you earn 2000 by working full time, and over the last 12 months he's averaged 1000 a month for the equivalent of 50% FTE then you should both contribute as if you were earning 2000 as he is ACTIVELY CHOOSING to reduce his income, that doesn't mean you should have to subsidies him. If he can't afford to be part time then he shouldn't be!

AmberSeal · 24/02/2024 09:22

You are sharing a life together. Finances should be more evenly spread. You said that you have a joint mortgage but you are paying the most into it. Please be aware that if something happens and you have to sell, he is entitled to 50% of any profit. Consider that too. Your future together doesn't seem healthy at this point. It could also be construed as financial abuse.

AgentJohnson · 24/02/2024 09:20

Congratulations on being mum to a grown arse man. Behaviour is a language a d he’s clearly telling you that you that he doesn’t feel financially responsible because the buck stops with you.

The balls in your court, stop subsidising him! He contribution should be prportanal and if he wants a new PC, he can save for one.

Start as you mean to go on, if you don’t want to be his mum, don’t act like it.

Coldupnorth7 · 24/02/2024 09:18

Does he intend to remain PT?

How does he plan his retirement?

If he has MH issues, is he happy to address them?

A bit of reverse engineering is a good way to get perspective.

Coldupnorth7 · 24/02/2024 09:16

I have a friend who's partner gave up work suddenly 20 odd years ago. He's not addressed any of the issues, so remains not working. Somehow they got married a few years ago, she's now doing all the employed work, he seems not to be even doing stuff at home and if she divorces him, he's entitled to her pension.

I'm always careful to comment on these types of threads as I "sat on my arse" at home for a long time but in reality, I did a lot of things that have benefitted us as a couple over the long term (set up a business & looked after my MH, which that means I'm much healthier than if I worked FT) but it's really all about intent. DH then got to retire earlier due to the business, so his MH has also benefitted.

If he wants to game and not have savings and pensions, it's not good in the long term.

WandaWonder · 24/02/2024 09:11

TwylaSands · 24/02/2024 09:10

The fairest way is percentage based so
the fairest way isnt percentage based when one person is choosing not to work because they dont want to.

Well if it is a women choosing not too then it is different it seems

TwylaSands · 24/02/2024 09:10

woooaaaahhhhh · 24/02/2024 05:05

I would sit down and look at finances together (prompted by bills increasing to avoid arguments)

The fairest way is percentage based so -

Write down all joint outgoings
Write down each income
Minus any personal expenses from each income
Add the two incomes (less personal expenses) together and minus the outgoings from the total
Divide the remaining figure by two
That's what each of you should have left over after you have paid your bills

Then if he wants to spend his on a computer he can at least he will be paying fairly.

You can also decide if you want to save jointly or separately.

The fairest way is percentage based so
the fairest way isnt percentage based when one person is choosing not to work because they dont want to.

TwylaSands · 24/02/2024 09:07

BookwormDadUK · 24/02/2024 09:00

MN: C*nt is so offensive, it reduces us to a part of anatomy.
Also MN: Cocklodger Cocklodger Cocklodger.

Baffling logic.

OP YANBU

Cunt is used over and over again on mns. Where have people said it is so offensive it reduces women to
a body part?

BookwormDadUK · 24/02/2024 09:00

MN: C*nt is so offensive, it reduces us to a part of anatomy.
Also MN: Cocklodger Cocklodger Cocklodger.

Baffling logic.

OP YANBU

Toffifee1 · 24/02/2024 08:47

peachpearplums · 23/02/2024 11:31

No, we each get paid into our personal accounts then transfer money. That in itself is an issue- I get paid at the end of each month, he gets paid at any point after a piece of work is done. So sometimes he can't put his amount into the joint account on time for the mortgage to go out, so I have to top it up then too. He doesn't save, so there's no contingency.

Ugh, i‘d be so annoyed. DH and i used to have seperate accounts before we got married and each contributed the same amount to household bills and rent despite earning very different amounts. We simply lived in a small rental flat that both of us could afford.
He should pay half of the bill and a certain amount of rent and you should pay the mortgage and be the owner of the housw/flat or downsize to something both of you can afford.

ScarlettSunset · 24/02/2024 07:53

tryingtogetinshape · 23/02/2024 22:03

What if he told you that you cant buy something with your own money.
There would be a whole lot of different replies.
If its his money than thats no yours.

It's not his money though is it?
OP would essentially be paying for it because she's covering the shortfall he's created.
He says he can't afford the contribution he should rightly be expected to make, while at the same time wanting to spend on his hobby. That shortfall still has to be met, and so it's falling on the OP, meaning she is spending HER money when she shouldn't have to.
If it was the other way round, my opinion would still be exactly the same. Any person who chooses to work less, forcing the other person to pay for their slacking should be binned off.

Mumofferralkid3 · 24/02/2024 07:49

Option B is not at all fair.
If OP earns 2000 and DP earns 1000 and they add it together to create 3000. If bills are 1500, and they split the remainder. DP would ens up with 750 fun money. So will have paid a substantial amount less in bills.

OP don't let this man take you for granted. He needs to grow up.

Mumofferralkid3 · 24/02/2024 07:43

Option b doesn't work out fairly. OP could earn a lot more and if you shared remainder after bills, some of her money could end up in his fun pot. She shouldn't be at all disadvantaged. She already earns the bread and does her fair share of house work.

Man child needs to up his hours if he wants better toys.

TempleOfBloom · 24/02/2024 07:23

I'm getting fed up with all my money going into joint expenses, and him paying a paltry amount to have a good quality of life,

Are you paying a greater share of the mortgage and in effect buying equity in your house for him? While he sits on his arse gaming?

If he had equal earning potential I would put a stop to that.

I wonder if you can seek legal advice as to whether you can adjust the Deed that says how much if the house you each own?

Otherwise you are literally paying for him to own a big chunk of your house that he hasn’t paid for.

Telling him not to buy the computer doesn’t get to the root of the problem.

Takenoprisoner · 24/02/2024 06:38

Blobblobblob · 23/02/2024 09:35

He can't afford to work part time. You're paying him to sit on his arse gaming.

He should be paying 50%, I don't agree that his percentage should be reduced just because he chooses to earn less.

This
why are you subsidising this man child? It would be over for me as I wouldn't feel attracted to him anymore

LoveSkaMusic · 24/02/2024 05:05

Whatever you do, do not have children with this man. He will let you down.

He will never step up. The only time I'd expect one partner to not pay their fair share of the bills is when a child is born, in which case the partner steps up while the mother works less (or not at all).

woooaaaahhhhh · 24/02/2024 05:05

I would sit down and look at finances together (prompted by bills increasing to avoid arguments)

The fairest way is percentage based so -

Write down all joint outgoings
Write down each income
Minus any personal expenses from each income
Add the two incomes (less personal expenses) together and minus the outgoings from the total
Divide the remaining figure by two
That's what each of you should have left over after you have paid your bills

Then if he wants to spend his on a computer he can at least he will be paying fairly.

You can also decide if you want to save jointly or separately.

Murdoch1949 · 24/02/2024 04:05

He's taking the mickey and you're letting him. He needs to match your hours in work, even though it is a salary mismatch. It is unacceptable for him to not put the same hours in as you, and he knows it. Maybe he can't believe he's getting away with being a leech on you. Maybe he has no work ethic. You need to have an honest discussion with him, warning him that it's upcoming so he's not blindsided. Explain what is your bottom line, what you are contributing and what you need him to contribute. If he is unwilling to change then you have to part ways, he's no long term prospect.

Swipe left for the next trending thread