Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone give some ideas to say to a 12 year old boy who is refusing to go into school?

116 replies

Louise000000 · 23/02/2024 07:50

Some ideas that I may not have thought of, refusing school because it’s boring, he doesn’t care if he gets a job he just wants to play video games and stream all day.

not my ds but a good friends ds and i said id help as i have a career advisor background and he also has a good relationship with me. She’s at the end of her tether with him.

I know as an adult why he needs to go into school and why it’s important but any ideas that would translate to a 12 year old?
thanks

OP posts:
orangesareblue · 23/02/2024 09:26

I work with children and teens who have EBSA (emotionally based school
avoidance) and about 95 percent of them
have ASD/ADHD/both.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 23/02/2024 09:25

"Get your arse up and move it, now!"

Jellycatspyjamas · 23/02/2024 09:24

It's interesting that the general consensus is to find a way to force him into school, when he is telling his parent that the education he's receiving there isn't sufficient or engaging him

What he’s actually saying is staying home and gaming is more fun, which it is.

Jellycatspyjamas · 23/02/2024 09:23

It's interesting that the general consensus is to find a way to force him into school, when he is telling his parent that the education he's receiving there isn't sufficient or engaging him

What he’s actually saying is staying home and gaming is more fun, which it is.

Bluevelvetsofa · 23/02/2024 09:19

I doubt that it’s because it’s boring too. That’s what children often say, when they’re hiding the real reason. Even if it is boring, they go for the social side, meeting up with friends etc.

Perhaps there’s something else going on then. Is the work difficult? Does he have friends? Is he being bullied? Neurodiverse?

It’s important to find out what the root cause is. Gaming is masking the reasons, because it takes his mind off things.

He may well just be opting out, but he may be using this refusal to mask something else going on.

Kitkatfiend31 · 23/02/2024 09:13

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 09:10

It's interesting that the general consensus is to find a way to force him into school, when he is telling his parent that the education he's receiving there isn't sufficient or engaging him. Is the point of education not to inspire? If his love of learning has been squashed, it needs to be reignited. That can't be done by force or control.
Does forcing an unengaged child into school result in X amount of GCSEs at a good grade and put them onto a career path that will be both fulfilling and lucrative? Looking at the majority of the population, I'd say not.
Lecturing a child about what they need to do now, for the benefit of their adult self, rarely ignites passion for learning. Why would they make themselves unhappy now, for the sake of an unknown future?
I would investigate his passions now and taylor his education accordingly.

Most people don't have the luxury of being able to devote their time to this or have the resources. Most parents have to work, as will this lad, to pay bills. Boring but realistic.

OutOfTheHouse · 23/02/2024 09:11

I think a lot of people don’t understand how addictive games can be. They are cleverly designed to give tiny little wins every few minutes to keep you playing. They can be as addictive as gambling. He’s not going to be getting this constant thrill at school, so no wonder he finds it boring, he’s addicted to this constant thrill.

Ask any teacher, they are battling against this all day.

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 09:10

It's interesting that the general consensus is to find a way to force him into school, when he is telling his parent that the education he's receiving there isn't sufficient or engaging him. Is the point of education not to inspire? If his love of learning has been squashed, it needs to be reignited. That can't be done by force or control.
Does forcing an unengaged child into school result in X amount of GCSEs at a good grade and put them onto a career path that will be both fulfilling and lucrative? Looking at the majority of the population, I'd say not.
Lecturing a child about what they need to do now, for the benefit of their adult self, rarely ignites passion for learning. Why would they make themselves unhappy now, for the sake of an unknown future?
I would investigate his passions now and taylor his education accordingly.

Kitkatfiend31 · 23/02/2024 09:10

Because you have to go to some education by law. Everyone is bored at times, that's normal life!
As everyone has said gaming needs to be drastically reduced. Look into gaming addiction. Maybe find a doctor who will talk to him about it. Certainly no WiFi in the day if not at school. And after that it needs to be limited.
She needs to work with him on creating a healthier lifestyle with more activities than just gaming. Sports of some kind and social interaction that isn't on line.
My son loved his gaming but also played table tennis, had climbing lessons and went to scouts.
Gaming is a worry for a parent and needs to be monitored.

Jellycatspyjamas · 23/02/2024 08:55

I doubt it’s because it’s boring.

Why would you doubt that? Many young people find school boring, formal education is often not that exciting and early high school is very different to primary school, learning that you need to buckle down and do the work can come as quite a shock.

There may well be other issues at play, no one here can possibly know that, but a 12 year old boy finding school boring is hardly unusual.

tomago · 23/02/2024 08:53

Ask why he doesn't like going?

NeedAnUpgrade · 23/02/2024 08:52

Like other PP have said, if you have a good relationship with him then try to find out if there’s more going on other than he’s just bored.

If it is just that then there’s far more work that goes into online streaming than just playing games. Ask him how he intends to make money, what’s going to make him successful over the thousands of other teenagers that want to do exactly the same thing. There’s probably some value to find in some of the subjects he does at school which will put him ahead of others wanting to do exactly the same.

Jellycatspyjamas · 23/02/2024 08:51

If it’s just that it’s boring, we all have to do things that are boring, getting an education gives you choices later on about how you spend your time and how much you get paid for it. I’d be making time at home boring too - no games, to or WiFi access.

I’d also be explaining that spending your days on a screen isn’t acceptable, introducing chores in exchange for screen time and start making the link between responsibilities and things we want to do.

If there’s a wider reason eg feeling overwhelmed, not coping in class etc he needs to explain what that is so the parents can work with the school to address this.

Lumiodes · 23/02/2024 08:51

You need to find out why he doesn’t want to go. I doubt it’s because it’s boring. There’s probably a deeper issue here. Bullying, struggling with work, learning difficulties, anxiety, etc. Also game time needs to be rationed and even stopped entirely if he isn’t going to school.

Tiggermom · 23/02/2024 08:47

The other thing about games is that they play with their friends - so lots of fun at home - when I was at school 60s/70s you only socialised at school (country area) so to be with your pals having a laugh you had to be at school. Nothing at home then tv limited and no online.

Comedycook · 23/02/2024 08:45

A lot of these kids are actually addicts...they're addicted to screens and gaming. They don't want to go to school because it takes them away from them.

Icedlatteplease · 23/02/2024 08:44

Tiggermom · 23/02/2024 08:28

My DGS was bored on holiday but I think it's becuase he is usually super driven by playing online games all day everyday.
It changes their brain to expect constant excitement and thrills - no wonder school is 'boring'.

Yes this is spot on. ALSO...

Chances are all the computer games your child is playing are designed to make you feel strong, powerful and successful. Particularly the violent and console ones. If you fail you go back to a past save and all is fine. The female NPC will fall at your feet etc etc

(The Games that will beat you mercilessly and repeatedly are few and far between and somewhat old fashioned now)

School repeatedly tells you the opposite, especially if you don't find learning easy. You need to work harder, you need to do better, you are not the best, you need to behave better, you'll won't succeed if you don't....

Whilst in the long run this is much better for your child in the short time the first makes your child feel far better.

It's a double whammy, not only is the game providing constant excitement, it is consistently blowing smoke up your child's arse.

Comedycook · 23/02/2024 08:44

If they don't go to school, I'd cut off all screens. No phone, no games console.

LakieLady · 23/02/2024 08:42

What to say depends on why he's refusing, so that's what needs to be explored.

Is he being bullied, or picked on by a particular teacher? Excluded by peers? Really struggling with a particular subject?

I assume this is his first or 2nd year at secondary. Is he school refusing because he finds the environment of a big, noisy school difficult? It can be a culture shock for some kids, especially if they've been to a small primary. (Friend's son couldn't handle secondary school, the noise and busyiness completely overwhelmed him. He was finally diagnosed autistic at 16). Is he generally anxious?

Once bullying, MH or additional needs are discounted, then it's time to turn off internet access during school hours and get tough.

My DB had a school refusing phase at secondary. DM told him that parents get sent to prison if their kids don't go to school, and then he'd have to go into care, as our DF was working overseas! Not advocating that for a second, but it worked.

UnlimitedCake · 23/02/2024 08:41

Could he be neurodivergent? Is there anything else going on at school that he’s not saying? Career wise - as he’s interested in gaming and IT could you chat to him about jobs in the video game industry such as game designer, video game developer, coding jobs etc? Then talk about what steps would need to be taken to achieve this.

Icedlatteplease · 23/02/2024 08:29

Be cautious about stuff like reduced timetables. Whilst they have a place, every bit of learning you child misses makes it harder for them to engage and be in the classroom the next day as they simply do not know what happened previously, they don't have the knowledge to build on.

If he has had time out the classroom he absolutely will need catch up. If you have a school who posts work online that is immeasurably helpful. Otherwise start by working through the CGP guide, consider returning to school at a start of a topic not midway through

Tiggermom · 23/02/2024 08:28

My DGS was bored on holiday but I think it's becuase he is usually super driven by playing online games all day everyday.
It changes their brain to expect constant excitement and thrills - no wonder school is 'boring'.

Needmorelego · 23/02/2024 08:28

He's 12. Is there any 14+ schools (UTCs) or college schemes near where they live?
They tend to be STEM based. Going on the streaming idea (which will probably fizzle out but if he is interested in tech a STEM based education might be better in general) tell him he needs to know filming and editing skills etc.
If he has the incentive of being able to go to a specialist 14+ school he might be more keen on getting through the next couple of years of "boring" school to get there.
He could also join gaming clubs where playing the games is more monitored and done in a safe way.
I believe in embracing interests where possible.
(Or..... there's something more going on at school and he needs to be listened too)

Icedlatteplease · 23/02/2024 08:22

Change the WIFI. Remove gaming consoles, phone, maybe TV, ideally out the house. Do not tell ds where.

To DS- "If is normal to have a job to pay for things like WiFi. It is normal to get basic qualifications to get a job for pay for the things you need like housing electronics and WIFI. It is normal for parents to prepare their children for adulthood. Atm you are aiming at an adulthood that does not have these things therefore you won't have them now."

Repeat grey rock style

Even if he is unhappy at school the above is still true.

But yes also check out the reasons for school refusal. If you can facilitate alternative education arrangements (home schooling, EOTAS) look into to those and talk to school. Have all these on hand when you have these conversations.

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 23/02/2024 08:19

he just wants to play video games and stream all day.

well I would be stopping this for a start.