Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone give some ideas to say to a 12 year old boy who is refusing to go into school?

116 replies

Louise000000 · 23/02/2024 07:50

Some ideas that I may not have thought of, refusing school because it’s boring, he doesn’t care if he gets a job he just wants to play video games and stream all day.

not my ds but a good friends ds and i said id help as i have a career advisor background and he also has a good relationship with me. She’s at the end of her tether with him.

I know as an adult why he needs to go into school and why it’s important but any ideas that would translate to a 12 year old?
thanks

OP posts:
momonpurpose · 23/02/2024 10:40

Bigearringsbigsmile · 23/02/2024 07:53

I would sell all the gaming consoles and change passwords to the WiFi.
School is not a choosing activity - you have to do it.

She needs to come down on this like a ton of bricks.

Agreed. No games no wifi . If he's allowed to spend his days missing school playing video games all day why would he want to go to school. Your friend needs to not pander to this and parent this kid

lateatwork · 23/02/2024 10:34

Been there. What's worked for us:

Recognise gaming is a sport. It can be social and positive. Talk to the child and be interested in what they are playing - in the same way you would be if they were into a traditional sport like football or gymnastics.

Just like anything other sport. Getting that top seat is rare. Explain what traditional pro sport is like - cut throat and that everyone has a plan B.

School has to be part of plan B.

Draw parallels between school and gaming. Eg sometimes you don't do so well. Sometimes you find your opponent annoying. Sometimes you find the game boring.

Sleep hygiene is essential and impacts on gaming performance. (Also benefits school performance but we emphasize positives to gaming)

Get Out card. They have one of these per semester. No questions asked, don't have to go to school. But only if attendance was 100% to that point. Gives some control back. Makes them think when it should be used.

My child is on pathway for ASD- have seen improvement in mood and school engagement since switching to non adversarial approach.

Jeannne92 · 23/02/2024 10:33

He is only 12; it's not too late to change these bad habits.

Jeannne92 · 23/02/2024 10:33

He is addicted to computer games and this needs to be treated.

Try some activities at home that require greater concentration / stamina e.g. Lego, cooking, DIY, and also get him outdoors, maybe sign him up for a sport club.

Perhaps he could do some 'work experience' to understand that careers are interesting and require academic studies.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 23/02/2024 10:29

Ok so he is either completely taking the piss or there is something much more serious going on.

I would start by limiting gaming to two hours per day at the weekend only.

Then go from there, I have a school refuser so I know how hard it is but sometimes kids just can’t be arsed and that’s not acceptable. You need to work out which type of refuser he is!

RosieAway · 23/02/2024 10:27

@Fionaville well thanks, but I’d love to know how single parents who need to work during the day are managing to homeschool DC effectively? And also it IS the educated classes home educating… as clearly those with a very bad education can’t often then offer their DC better than what they know? Sounds like you are in a bit of a bubble… nice area etc. Where I am is one of the most socio-economically deprived areas in the SE and to imagine the majority of people who are uneducated themselves and on benefits to then have the capacity to somehow home school is laughable. Sadly. Also DA and DV against children would increase if they were at home all the time. Sorry but that’s the reality.

Still, my heart is absolutely breaking with all these comments about forcing children to go to school, giving them no voice etc - essentially the equivalent of sending them to an institution the equivalent of prison for many IMO.

I don’t know what the answer is for those who aren’t privileged - educationally or financially, locationally, emotionally etc. But would like to find one for my DC soon

BlackeyedSusan · 23/02/2024 10:24

Look at the ebsa support thread?

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/02/2024 10:23

Unless the op can get to the bottom of the issue of why he really doesn't want to go, there is no "right" response. All the "kick up the arse" commentators might like to pop onto a couple of the EBSA threads going at the moment to educate themselves. There are other options than mainstream school. Education is necessary, school may not be. But until they know why this lad isn't going (almost certainly not just preferring gaming ..when everyone else is at school it's pretty dull and lonely) , there's no way to know what approach is right.

Kitkatfiend31 · 23/02/2024 10:21

The current school obsession with results and zero tolerance is wrong but learning to work within a system is also a life skill. Unless there is a massive change in government and ethos we are stuck with it and will have to manage within it.

Kitkatfiend31 · 23/02/2024 10:18

GenerousGardener · 23/02/2024 10:08

@Fionaville he went to school. He tried it again a few days later with the same result. He goes to school now without protest because he knows the outcome if he refused. School is not an option.

School not being an option is definitely what he needs to learn. Society gives children so much more choice and control than they used to have that they assume it applies to all situations. Most of us over 45 would never have openly questioned what our parents told us to do. We got up and did as we were told until allowed to escape out to play with friends. And we all knew we wouldn't be allowed out if we hadn't done as we were told!

GenerousGardener · 23/02/2024 10:08

@Fionaville he went to school. He tried it again a few days later with the same result. He goes to school now without protest because he knows the outcome if he refused. School is not an option.

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 10:04

GenerousGardener · 23/02/2024 10:02

My grandson did this. He refused point blank to go to school. His mother phoned the school and told them what was going on. The head teacher came and got him.

And how did that work out in the end?

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 10:03

RosieAway · 23/02/2024 09:55

It’s absolutely diabolical and yes, terrifyingly outdated.

I am painfully aware of this and yet I’m not in the position financially (single parent) and in other ways (don’t drive so couldn’t access a lot of the enrichment activities, have an only child and not many socialising opportunities, etc)

Tragically home schooling is the preserve of the comfortable middle class, or alternative people with family money. That’s just the truth of it. Private and alternative schooling is out of reach for most - yes a sad state of affairs, but it’s not us parents doing!

Your comment does nothing but double down on my despair and guilt to be honest.

Edited

I'm sorry that my comments have made you feel that way.
As a home educator, I can assure you that it is not solely for the middle class or people with money. Our groups are full of people from every socio-economic class. We have working, single parents. We have families on benefits, working and not. We also have rich people and everyone in between.
From the outside looking in, I'd like to see radical changes in the school system. That's not going to happen though, if parents and other adults keep repeating the same mantras. That school is the best place for kids. It needs to change.

GenerousGardener · 23/02/2024 10:02

My grandson did this. He refused point blank to go to school. His mother phoned the school and told them what was going on. The head teacher came and got him.

RosieAway · 23/02/2024 09:55

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 09:43

No, you don't get it by allowing gaming all day, which is why I'm not suggesting it.
It's a sad state of affairs if most parents don't have the time, capacity or ability to facilitate education at home. Time is a factor, but there are lots of ways around that. If most are lacking in capacity or ability, what does that say about the school system they themselves have been through? That they don't have the ability to facilitate the education of a 12 year old? It's not the best argument for why all kids should be forced into school.
We need to change this mindset that the current school system is fit for purpose. It wasn't designed for modern times.

It’s absolutely diabolical and yes, terrifyingly outdated.

I am painfully aware of this and yet I’m not in the position financially (single parent) and in other ways (don’t drive so couldn’t access a lot of the enrichment activities, have an only child and not many socialising opportunities, etc)

Tragically home schooling is the preserve of the comfortable middle class, or alternative people with family money. That’s just the truth of it. Private and alternative schooling is out of reach for most - yes a sad state of affairs, but it’s not us parents doing!

Your comment does nothing but double down on my despair and guilt to be honest.

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 09:43

Jellycatspyjamas · 23/02/2024 09:31

You also don’t get it by allowing your 12 year old to sit at home gaming all day. The school system doesn’t suit most kids but most parents don’t have the time, capacity or ability to fully home educate to a high standard.

No, you don't get it by allowing gaming all day, which is why I'm not suggesting it.
It's a sad state of affairs if most parents don't have the time, capacity or ability to facilitate education at home. Time is a factor, but there are lots of ways around that. If most are lacking in capacity or ability, what does that say about the school system they themselves have been through? That they don't have the ability to facilitate the education of a 12 year old? It's not the best argument for why all kids should be forced into school.
We need to change this mindset that the current school system is fit for purpose. It wasn't designed for modern times.

Spendonsend · 23/02/2024 09:43

There is lots to unpick here to get the right advice.

My son says 'boring' to mean something is too difficult and he cant keep up.

What would happen if there was a no gaming during school hours rule - would he find a different reason to avoid school or would he decide he might as well go to school.

Advice400 · 23/02/2024 09:40

My son who was a early riser started lying in and being tired for school. We identified that he was playing games...quietly...until the early.hours.

My husband found the WiFi settings for the hub ...some sort of online account I think....and got it to turn off every night at 9.

Bit annoying for me but it did the trick.

RosieAway · 23/02/2024 09:37

So hard and so common. Because he’s right, school is boring! Even though I’m sure there’s many other reasons he suddenly won’t go but doesn’t feel he can say it maybe it’s hard for him to voice.

Frankly the whole system is f@cked and outdated and needs reform to stop treating kids like automatons. Anyway a different argument and not helpful here.

Sounds like you could be a friend to him here, someone who isn’t his mum whom he may feel freer to talk to honestly to get to the bottom of what he’s really not liking.

Additionally think gaming changes how the brain functions and focuses… making school feel harder maybe. But equally, if that’s what brings him comfort… a tricky one.

Jellycatspyjamas · 23/02/2024 09:31

You also don’t get it by allowing your 12 year old to sit at home gaming all day. The school system doesn’t suit most kids but most parents don’t have the time, capacity or ability to fully home educate to a high standard.

Littlemisscapable · 23/02/2024 09:31

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 09:10

It's interesting that the general consensus is to find a way to force him into school, when he is telling his parent that the education he's receiving there isn't sufficient or engaging him. Is the point of education not to inspire? If his love of learning has been squashed, it needs to be reignited. That can't be done by force or control.
Does forcing an unengaged child into school result in X amount of GCSEs at a good grade and put them onto a career path that will be both fulfilling and lucrative? Looking at the majority of the population, I'd say not.
Lecturing a child about what they need to do now, for the benefit of their adult self, rarely ignites passion for learning. Why would they make themselves unhappy now, for the sake of an unknown future?
I would investigate his passions now and taylor his education accordingly.

While this is an nice ideal how does this relate to most people's real world...assuming the parents work and aren't loaded their child has to go to school. Post covid there is definitely a change of mindset that school is optional and parents wfh also confuses the issue (to a child). The education system will take decades to become more flexible so I don't think this advice is helpful. Instead stop the gaming except at weekends in exchange for school attendance...meet with school and express concerns and ask for support and see if there are any other issues.

TeaGlouriousTea · 23/02/2024 09:31

What game does he play? If I was that parent I would be seeking therapy for gaming addiction which is now classed as a MH disorder in the DSM 5. It’s a growing issue.

Hardly anyone makes it as a streamer. Funnily enough I do know a relatively successful streamer and this is a gaming household. My DS was offered sponsorship to be in an E sports team but I pointed out it’s a short career. By the time they hit mid twenties their twitch reflexes are much slower. So they have to be a very engaging person.

SpeedyDrama · 23/02/2024 09:29

OutOfTheHouse · 23/02/2024 09:11

I think a lot of people don’t understand how addictive games can be. They are cleverly designed to give tiny little wins every few minutes to keep you playing. They can be as addictive as gambling. He’s not going to be getting this constant thrill at school, so no wonder he finds it boring, he’s addicted to this constant thrill.

Ask any teacher, they are battling against this all day.

There’s another side to it as well. I’m not internet diagnosing the child, but finding school boring and video games stimulating could be a flag for ADHD at least. Gaming requires a lot of brain power, problem solving skills, working mechanics. Sitting in a classroom being understimulated and not concentrating can have very harmful effects on academic achievement. It’s not about being ‘addicted’, it’s finding the best stimulation that schools simply don’t provide post primary. School as an entire system needs to change, this ‘one method suits all’ way of educating is failing children and they get blamed for not being able to partake in school.

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 09:29

Jellycatspyjamas · 23/02/2024 09:23

It's interesting that the general consensus is to find a way to force him into school, when he is telling his parent that the education he's receiving there isn't sufficient or engaging him

What he’s actually saying is staying home and gaming is more fun, which it is.

Sitting at home alone on a game, shouldn't be more fun though, especially not for a 12 year old. So the school system is failing to inspire.

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 09:26

Kitkatfiend31 · 23/02/2024 09:13

Most people don't have the luxury of being able to devote their time to this or have the resources. Most parents have to work, as will this lad, to pay bills. Boring but realistic.

The resources have never been more readily available. The education of a 12 year old, shouldn't be approached with future bill paying in mind. The creative thinkers and self starters of the world are what drives it. That's what the work force needs now and will need even more of in the changing world. You don't get them by forcing unengaged children into an education system that kills creativity.

Swipe left for the next trending thread