Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone give some ideas to say to a 12 year old boy who is refusing to go into school?

116 replies

Louise000000 · 23/02/2024 07:50

Some ideas that I may not have thought of, refusing school because it’s boring, he doesn’t care if he gets a job he just wants to play video games and stream all day.

not my ds but a good friends ds and i said id help as i have a career advisor background and he also has a good relationship with me. She’s at the end of her tether with him.

I know as an adult why he needs to go into school and why it’s important but any ideas that would translate to a 12 year old?
thanks

OP posts:
Mumz0612 · 23/02/2024 15:29

This is my youngest hasn't been to school since January said it's boring, then has a massive break down telling me she's been getting bullied by her so called friend and was scared of telling me as she knew I'd put a stop to it

LaPalmaLlama · 23/02/2024 15:24

Honestly I think people who think there must be more to it than he just wants to stay at home gaming are being hugely naive. I’ve sat in meetings where gaming companies explain just how addictive their games are ( and that’s a good thing because addiction =$$$$ for them and the shareholders). They don’t say addictive though. They say engaging because it sounds better. Look at the number of tech bros who don’t let their own kids have access to this stuff. Given the choice between gaming and school or even gaming and home school, the vast majority of teens will choose gaming. It’s just instant gratification and an immediate dopamine hit.

Honestly, tell your friend to take away the tech. If he’d still rather stay home and be totally bored than go to school or if he starts finding stuff to teach himself, then yes there’s probably something else going on at school but address the most obvious likelihood first- if you hear hooves you don’t think zebras, do you?

Toastcrumbsinsofa · 23/02/2024 14:25

I’d remove all games, consoles and screens as a starting point until he has been attending school on a regular basis for a few months. Wi-Fi should be switched off overnight. If he needs an alarm to wake up, he can have an old fashioned alarm clock. His parents need to be far more strict about enforcing rules. He will probably kick off if he is forced to stop gaming and reduce screen time but it’s important for his well-being and his future that his parents persevere. Going to school shouldn’t be optional.

Scarletttulips · 23/02/2024 13:58

DS did this and I removed all his gadgets - so he found out what being really board actually meant.

It also reset his sleep.

I would speak the teachers - I mean they know what they are doing - but he has to be there to engage.

If he wants a gaming career call a local office and see if they have any advice on how to become xyz - it might make a diffence.

YouJustDoYou · 23/02/2024 13:58

I loathed school too, wasn't being bullied, school was just an absolute drain of life and horrid shitshow. But you went because you had to. He doesn't have a choice; he goes to school, or all his gaming rights and priviledges get removed, no ifs or buts.

InsaneInTheMamBrain · 23/02/2024 13:53

Careers advice may help him, especially if it was with an aim to helping him plan manageable short and long term goals for working in the gaming industry. It is amazing how disengaged students often start making an effort as many are, like adults, money motivated and want help to get on a path. Careers advice is woeful in schools; not their fault.

Aiming to take a qualification they are interested in early- Yr 9- can also focus students in KS3 when they sometimes lose their way, although you may have to find tutoring and an exam centre outside school to support his interests.

I would also find out if one subject is particularly dull for him and speak to the teacher and ask if there are opportunities for group work, IT brought into the lesson, individual project time, more speaking and listening opportunities - whatever it is that he enjoys most (or dislikes least) about classroom learning. Teachers are often open to trying different methods of engagement if they can. It’s about meeting in the middle, rather than forcing him to bend to the rules.

Bribery may also work…

birdglasspen2 · 23/02/2024 13:49

Remove all video games and screen time. Or allow it only on a Saturday. That’s it. Simple.

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 13:47

RosieAway · 23/02/2024 13:17

Nope, you’ve got no interest in the other children struggling at school as you have the means to try and make it better for your own.

I actually care about all children and have empathy for all those families struggling. You are lucky and privileged you are able to step out of the system.

And instead of answering how a single mum who is a cleaner can home educate, you’ve chosen to say I’m projecting my own issues.

Just admit the playing field isn’t equal. I despair of the attitudes of this country; everyone should care

Please, I live in Merseyside. I don't need anybody giving me a lecture on inequality. We have more food banks than food shops in our area.
I didn't realise I was supposed to give a 'how to guide' specifically a single mum, who's a cleaner, to be able to home educate. I do have two close friends who home educate, who are single and in low paid jobs. One has older children, who can be left. She works as a lunch time assistant in a school, so sets her kids tasks while she's out. Then works in a pub when her ex has the kids.
Another has a younger child who can't be left, so started a dog walking business and has a business doing party balloons and buffets. Her ex isn't in the picture.
I care about all kids, which is why I volunteer so much of my time to them and also help the children who come out of the school system completely traumatised. But that doesn't mean I'm personally going to take on the responsibility of reforming the school system, of which I have no personal business. I've done my part in highlighting it and taking the strain off of it.

Daylightsavingscrime · 23/02/2024 13:36

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 13:04

Education is not an option. How that education is delivered is.

Well not necessarily. A single parent who works will not be able to home school. Two parents may not be able to if they both need to work.

Can the child just not go to
school? Tucking them away in a bubble where nothing is challenging or not their cup of tea is not really a permanent solution as that will (presumably) stop
once they’re an adult.

Obvioulsy if there are MH issues or something like bullying going on then that would need to be addressed.

Louise000000 · 23/02/2024 13:27

Some great advice here I’m going to read it all through later on!!
yes to those who said I’m coming in as more a friend for him to open up to and I want to help make going to school better for him.

the school are involved and have sent staff round for him etc he will eventually go in then maybe have a good spell then it starts again.
there is definitely gaming allowed till late so this would explain tiredness in the morning and no motivation and that’s something his mum will have to change at home.

ive tried to angle about his interests with the idea that say if he was into outdoor activities or a sport, I could find a young role model type person to chat with him and tell him he could be doing this as a job if he gets his school done and dusted, but unfortunately his only interest is gaming which is totally out of my expertise.

OP posts:
Daylightsavingscrime · 23/02/2024 13:25

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 09:10

It's interesting that the general consensus is to find a way to force him into school, when he is telling his parent that the education he's receiving there isn't sufficient or engaging him. Is the point of education not to inspire? If his love of learning has been squashed, it needs to be reignited. That can't be done by force or control.
Does forcing an unengaged child into school result in X amount of GCSEs at a good grade and put them onto a career path that will be both fulfilling and lucrative? Looking at the majority of the population, I'd say not.
Lecturing a child about what they need to do now, for the benefit of their adult self, rarely ignites passion for learning. Why would they make themselves unhappy now, for the sake of an unknown future?
I would investigate his passions now and taylor his education accordingly.

Well if he has any passionate interests (beyond gaming) then yes these should be encouraged but ultimately when he’s an adult he’ll need to get a job and refusing to engage with education will hamper that I expect.

Not just due to lack of qualifications but “disengages if not sufficiently interested” doesn’t sound like a good bet for an employee

RosieAway · 23/02/2024 13:17

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 13:03

I don't think I've been patronising at all. You were literally telling me the type of people who home educate, when I know from a lot of first hand experience that you are wrong and explained as much. You also said I must live in an affluent bubble, which is also very wrong. So who was patronising who?
By pointing out that half of home educators are doing it not through choice or privilege, but because schools aren't meeting their childs needs, wasn't me saying "If you really cared, you'd find a way" That's you bringing your own issues and sensitivities into the discussion. It's also patronising of you to say how laughable it is to suggest certain types of people can offer their kids an adequate education!
I haven't tried to say that home ed is an easy choice. I've said that there are many different ways to do it and that lots of different kinds of people make it work. Lots who've had no other choice.
There is no reason for me personally, to make efforts to reform the school system. My kids aren't in it through choice. Surely, the people who should push for reform are the stakeholders. The teachers and the parents of school children. However you could say home ed families like mine, are contributing to make the school system better, because it would cost millions if they all went back to school. We have also caused much discussion in wider circles and the press, which has caused more people to question how fit for purpose, the school system is. Now you just need parents and teachers to grab that momentum and push for change.

Nope, you’ve got no interest in the other children struggling at school as you have the means to try and make it better for your own.

I actually care about all children and have empathy for all those families struggling. You are lucky and privileged you are able to step out of the system.

And instead of answering how a single mum who is a cleaner can home educate, you’ve chosen to say I’m projecting my own issues.

Just admit the playing field isn’t equal. I despair of the attitudes of this country; everyone should care

Shabooboogaloo · 23/02/2024 13:05

All devices would go in a big lock box for starters, to be earned back.
schools not supposed to be exciting every second, it is boring to learn subjects you don’t have an affinity with!

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 13:04

GenerousGardener · 23/02/2024 10:08

@Fionaville he went to school. He tried it again a few days later with the same result. He goes to school now without protest because he knows the outcome if he refused. School is not an option.

Education is not an option. How that education is delivered is.

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 13:03

RosieAway · 23/02/2024 11:47

Thanks for this patronising reply. I am fully aware of what home schooling is, who is doing it in my area and the myriad reasons why I am unable to and many others in my less fortunate circumstance aren’t. There IS an element of privilege, given many would desperately wish to yet can’t which you seem keen to deny. Also you seem keen to hammer home your superior understanding of HS. Of course I know it’s not teaching them algebra all day in front of a blackboard. So. Patronising. But even if it’s an hour or two a day, what’s the single mum who’s a cleaner out in jobs meant to do with DC the rest of the day?

Given we are essentially on the “same side” re school, I actually despair at your “if you really wanted to and really cared about your child, you’d find a way”
attitude.

The long-term answer isn’t pulling all the kids out BTW, it’s reform of the mainstream which how exactly are you contributing to?

Edited

I don't think I've been patronising at all. You were literally telling me the type of people who home educate, when I know from a lot of first hand experience that you are wrong and explained as much. You also said I must live in an affluent bubble, which is also very wrong. So who was patronising who?
By pointing out that half of home educators are doing it not through choice or privilege, but because schools aren't meeting their childs needs, wasn't me saying "If you really cared, you'd find a way" That's you bringing your own issues and sensitivities into the discussion. It's also patronising of you to say how laughable it is to suggest certain types of people can offer their kids an adequate education!
I haven't tried to say that home ed is an easy choice. I've said that there are many different ways to do it and that lots of different kinds of people make it work. Lots who've had no other choice.
There is no reason for me personally, to make efforts to reform the school system. My kids aren't in it through choice. Surely, the people who should push for reform are the stakeholders. The teachers and the parents of school children. However you could say home ed families like mine, are contributing to make the school system better, because it would cost millions if they all went back to school. We have also caused much discussion in wider circles and the press, which has caused more people to question how fit for purpose, the school system is. Now you just need parents and teachers to grab that momentum and push for change.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 23/02/2024 12:41

I'm pretty sure he is being bullied.
Children are often to scared and or ashamed to speak out

Ggttl · 23/02/2024 12:40

He is probably struggling socially and/or anxious about academics/school life. You have to work out the cause and then attempt to solve it. Schools aren’t very easy places to be in. They are noisy, crowded, lots of demands on children, regular feedback about how to improve, lots of rules, poor behaviour, quite a few mean kids, stressed adults… it is amazing how many children do agree to go in!

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/02/2024 12:36

@Beryls I'm envious of you being so secure in your knowledge that your child (or the OPs) is an NT, popular, confident lad with friends and sporting / musical / drama talent that means school is not really a challenge or scary and he's genuinely only not going because he can't be arsed. Thank goodness you don't have to consider mental health concerns that can and do lead at best to autistic burnout and worst to self harm and suicide attempts. You may be right, maybe he does just need a stern talking to and tough love but, as has been suggested elsewhere, maybe just consider there might be other issues going on?

All these posts about resilience and real life etc..real life as an adult, or even a 16+ now can include studying and working from home in a secure and controllable environment or in a workplace that has a legal requirement to make reasonable adjustments. At no other point than 5-16 do we insist that people MUST come to a specific place, do specific things in specific ways and ONLY that way and we can criminally prosecute their parents if they don't / can't. I'm a teacher and a parent of ND children with EBSA in various forms. I am education's biggest fan and until about three years ago was much more on the "tough love" bus. Then I learned what EBSA was and what it can do to a child. Again, not saying that IS the case here, but the flippant "obvious" replies are depressing in the current climate of what I thought was growing understanding.

OttolenghiSimple · 23/02/2024 12:07

Most likely there is something going on at school which he is not telling them about.

Flabbergasted at PP suggesting a parent “grey rocks” a young boy. Wtf is wrong with you?

Beryls · 23/02/2024 12:03

I'd probably approach the situation very carefully and gently by saying something along the lines of "Get to school you lazy little sod" and taking away his games consoles.

RosieAway · 23/02/2024 11:47

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 11:21

I'm afraid that your opinion about home educating being full of privileged, middle class people is misinformed and outdated.
Roughly half of home educators now are doing so because their SEN child's needs are not being met in mainstream school. A large proportion of children are also being home educated because they've have been badly bullied and/or traumatised in school. Do you honestly think that all of those people are well off?
We are in the North West of England. Our network compromises of some of the most deprived areas in the country, which are also counted as some of the most thriving home ed communities. I've never known a more diverse bunch of people, who all have the same goal.
It works for lots of working parents. Again, you are misinformed. Home education is not a parent standing in front of their children all day teaching them algebra, like a school teacher. Parents facilitate learning and give their children the tools to learn and develop their passions. Not to replicate the whole national curriculum. It isn't laughable that a parent who scraped through school, can home ed their own children. We are living in a time when thousands of resources are available to us. It's outdated to think that children can only learn if an adult talks at them all day.
I will defend home education because I am properly informed on it and know many parents from all socio-economic situations, who are doing it successfully.

Thanks for this patronising reply. I am fully aware of what home schooling is, who is doing it in my area and the myriad reasons why I am unable to and many others in my less fortunate circumstance aren’t. There IS an element of privilege, given many would desperately wish to yet can’t which you seem keen to deny. Also you seem keen to hammer home your superior understanding of HS. Of course I know it’s not teaching them algebra all day in front of a blackboard. So. Patronising. But even if it’s an hour or two a day, what’s the single mum who’s a cleaner out in jobs meant to do with DC the rest of the day?

Given we are essentially on the “same side” re school, I actually despair at your “if you really wanted to and really cared about your child, you’d find a way”
attitude.

The long-term answer isn’t pulling all the kids out BTW, it’s reform of the mainstream which how exactly are you contributing to?

Delatron · 23/02/2024 11:46

The not gaming and the no WiFi seems so obvious that surely she is not allowing him to stay at home all day and game?

Delatron · 23/02/2024 11:45

Kitkatfiend31 · 23/02/2024 10:18

School not being an option is definitely what he needs to learn. Society gives children so much more choice and control than they used to have that they assume it applies to all situations. Most of us over 45 would never have openly questioned what our parents told us to do. We got up and did as we were told until allowed to escape out to play with friends. And we all knew we wouldn't be allowed out if we hadn't done as we were told!

This is true. School is not optional. We knew that growing up. Unless there’s a very good reason (and it sounds like he just wants to stay at home and game). Then she makes him go.

My parents used to tell me if I ever skipped school they would get sent to jail! Not sure that is the usual tactic but I guess it made me realise it was not optional.

Icedlatteplease · 23/02/2024 11:30

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/02/2024 10:23

Unless the op can get to the bottom of the issue of why he really doesn't want to go, there is no "right" response. All the "kick up the arse" commentators might like to pop onto a couple of the EBSA threads going at the moment to educate themselves. There are other options than mainstream school. Education is necessary, school may not be. But until they know why this lad isn't going (almost certainly not just preferring gaming ..when everyone else is at school it's pretty dull and lonely) , there's no way to know what approach is right.

I have a child who has been out of education for a very long time, been very ill CAHMS and all sort. Now returning to "school" through an EOTAS package, there's no TV until the "schoolwork" is done for the day and theres no access to computers for the time being. I'm not coming from a place of inexperience.

Yes you need to build in support. But no kid is going back into education, whatever form that Education takes, until you have put the gaming back in the box.

You need both approaches running concurrently.

Fionaville · 23/02/2024 11:21

RosieAway · 23/02/2024 10:27

@Fionaville well thanks, but I’d love to know how single parents who need to work during the day are managing to homeschool DC effectively? And also it IS the educated classes home educating… as clearly those with a very bad education can’t often then offer their DC better than what they know? Sounds like you are in a bit of a bubble… nice area etc. Where I am is one of the most socio-economically deprived areas in the SE and to imagine the majority of people who are uneducated themselves and on benefits to then have the capacity to somehow home school is laughable. Sadly. Also DA and DV against children would increase if they were at home all the time. Sorry but that’s the reality.

Still, my heart is absolutely breaking with all these comments about forcing children to go to school, giving them no voice etc - essentially the equivalent of sending them to an institution the equivalent of prison for many IMO.

I don’t know what the answer is for those who aren’t privileged - educationally or financially, locationally, emotionally etc. But would like to find one for my DC soon

I'm afraid that your opinion about home educating being full of privileged, middle class people is misinformed and outdated.
Roughly half of home educators now are doing so because their SEN child's needs are not being met in mainstream school. A large proportion of children are also being home educated because they've have been badly bullied and/or traumatised in school. Do you honestly think that all of those people are well off?
We are in the North West of England. Our network compromises of some of the most deprived areas in the country, which are also counted as some of the most thriving home ed communities. I've never known a more diverse bunch of people, who all have the same goal.
It works for lots of working parents. Again, you are misinformed. Home education is not a parent standing in front of their children all day teaching them algebra, like a school teacher. Parents facilitate learning and give their children the tools to learn and develop their passions. Not to replicate the whole national curriculum. It isn't laughable that a parent who scraped through school, can home ed their own children. We are living in a time when thousands of resources are available to us. It's outdated to think that children can only learn if an adult talks at them all day.
I will defend home education because I am properly informed on it and know many parents from all socio-economic situations, who are doing it successfully.