Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of the police!!

416 replies

Noangelbuthavingfun · 22/02/2024 18:39

Yet another one .... rapist ..before He even joined the force. WTAF is going on ?
You can't trust the very people that you are supposed to ! Add to that the failings of the police "force" dealing with Grace and Barnaby case recently and the awful disrespectful texts that we heard about .... and you just think what de hell is going on !! Unforgivable!

OP posts:
Silverbirchtwo · 26/02/2024 18:04

There are bad apples everywhere, police, doctors, etc included. And the police are not always in the position to play polite, 'You have to go that way', rather than 'If you don't mind we'd prefer you to go that way'. They have to show strong often to get the necessary effect, I generally give them the benefit of the doubt.

HatThatWearsYou · 26/02/2024 17:58

RosieTheChi · 26/02/2024 17:52

@HatThatWearsYou Which poster do you mean that you have told before?

Damned and I have crossed paths in FWR about the police before, and I've said I didn't think she actually was a police officer.

RosieTheChi · 26/02/2024 17:52

@HatThatWearsYou Which poster do you mean that you have told before?

HatThatWearsYou · 26/02/2024 17:47

TheChippendenSpook · 26/02/2024 15:19

I actually do understand that, I really do. It just gets my back up that there have been a few police officers on this thread that have tried to tell people that they're not all one big corrupt mess. There are officers who do want to help and want to make a difference but there are people on here who don't take a blind bit of notice of them. Instead they shout louder and say 'nope, I don't believe you.'

The police have a long way to go to build trust in people, I do realise that but there are people on here who won't listen to actual officers who are trying to stick up for themselves and who go out and do a damn near impossible job, day in day out. Officers have told them of the good they are trying to do and they still don't care.

I don't know how they can even begin to change it when people are unwilling to listen.

Thank you but don't worry, I have told that poster before that I am not convinced she is what she says she is.

I do think it's important to apologise when I get it wrong, and I do feel like it was deserved the other day. I was so sure I remembered correctly and I really didn't!

I know you mentioned the emery board but I was definitely replying to Damned's post below yours replying to that poster as well.

I believe any decent police officer must really feel the frustration right now, and I'm quite sure that's a massive understatement on my part.
The thing is that even if you are one of the really, really good ones, there are still some really worrying things going on as far as the public, and women in particular, are concerned about.

You need to be able to separate it out so you aren't getting frustrated with us. We all know that it's not every police officer. We know there are good ones out there. But when trust is so low getting angry at people and arguing that there are good ones, or that you're one of the good ones isn't helpful.
Understandable, but not at all helpful.

DriftingDora · 26/02/2024 17:23

TheChippendenSpook · 26/02/2024 15:19

I actually do understand that, I really do. It just gets my back up that there have been a few police officers on this thread that have tried to tell people that they're not all one big corrupt mess. There are officers who do want to help and want to make a difference but there are people on here who don't take a blind bit of notice of them. Instead they shout louder and say 'nope, I don't believe you.'

The police have a long way to go to build trust in people, I do realise that but there are people on here who won't listen to actual officers who are trying to stick up for themselves and who go out and do a damn near impossible job, day in day out. Officers have told them of the good they are trying to do and they still don't care.

I don't know how they can even begin to change it when people are unwilling to listen.

This is what I posted earlier and which I stand by:-

The attitude of most (not all) of the police officers on here has reinforced the conclusion that they are part of the problem. Reading them over, you can well see how and why the public have lost respect for them - with their "we know best, so do what we say, shut up and don't be so silly" methodology. And they wonder why the public have such a low opinion of them! But of course it's the public's fault. Yeah, right..

If you read what many of them have written on here, they seem unable to comprehend that adopting this kind of attitude is neither helpful or reassuring, nor does it do anything to take away the public's concerns that many police officers are somewhat (very) arrogant and in the job primarily for the power it gives over the general public and the opportunity to throw their weight around. And therein lies one of the problems that has led the police forces (not just the Met) into the mess they are currently in - a belief that they are untouchable. There are, of course, other things wrong - extremely poor management at the top and the training obviously is not fit for purpose either. The whole set-up needs a complete overhaul - but this will never happen. And so the problem will continue.

TheChippendenSpook · 26/02/2024 15:19

RosieTheChi · 26/02/2024 15:04

@TheChippendenSpook I can understand the other posters viewpoint though. I don't think I would call the police for anything these days unless something extremely serious was happening.

Myself and DH have said we will sort issues ourselves as not much gets done otherwise.

Sorry. It's just how I feel.

I actually do understand that, I really do. It just gets my back up that there have been a few police officers on this thread that have tried to tell people that they're not all one big corrupt mess. There are officers who do want to help and want to make a difference but there are people on here who don't take a blind bit of notice of them. Instead they shout louder and say 'nope, I don't believe you.'

The police have a long way to go to build trust in people, I do realise that but there are people on here who won't listen to actual officers who are trying to stick up for themselves and who go out and do a damn near impossible job, day in day out. Officers have told them of the good they are trying to do and they still don't care.

I don't know how they can even begin to change it when people are unwilling to listen.

RosieTheChi · 26/02/2024 15:04

@TheChippendenSpook I can understand the other posters viewpoint though. I don't think I would call the police for anything these days unless something extremely serious was happening.

Myself and DH have said we will sort issues ourselves as not much gets done otherwise.

Sorry. It's just how I feel.

DriftingDora · 26/02/2024 14:44

Sdpbody · 22/02/2024 21:34

I find these threads so frustrating. We can't bash teachers, or doctors, or firefighters, but Police Officers are fair game. There are 10,000s of officers, the majority are good people, who want to help and work hard.

Just stopped myself chortling at this....can't bash teachers? You have got to be joking - teachers should even pick up the slack if the kid doesn't brush their teeth, according to some on here who think teachers are a cross between social workers and Norland nannies.

manipulatrice · 26/02/2024 12:34

I don't think you are able to explain procedure @damnedwhatever because I'm fairly confident you are not who you claim to be, and it concerns me greatly.

TheChippendenSpook · 26/02/2024 11:23

And @HatThatWearsYou this will probably get deleted but I want to save you from wasting your time and apologising to people unnecessarily... I'd take some of what you read on here with a pinch of salt.

TheChippendenSpook · 26/02/2024 11:20

HatThatWearsYou · 25/02/2024 23:46

I'm aware I'm making myself an unintentional liar twice in two days by coming back, but @damnedwhatever I hope you don't mind my saying that your reply to the anxious poster would have been a really good opportunity to try some of the things I had suggested to you yesterday.

The poster isn't silly to be afraid, or to want to be able to defend herself, but you've already framed her in your mind as being ridiculous. That's a really unhelpful perspective for a police officer to start from don't you think?

You could try to understand where the fear is coming from and start from the perspective that it is valid. Then you could realise that there are times other than an emergency that the poster might not contact the police because of that fear.

You could have tried to dispel some of the fear with something like a previous poster mentioned about explaining procedure. Maybe having more information would help reduce some of the fear, I think it would for me at least a little anyway.

Maybe you could help reassure instead of just tell her she's being silly.

I agree about weapons being used against the carrier, but again maybe you could have signposted to any resources you might have on self defence classes for women or something?

You could use these posts as an opportunity to learn and be a constructive force for the public view of the police, but only if you really listen to the posters and without starting from the "you're being silly" perspective.

It was me that called the poster ridiculous. I haven't stated on this thread whether I am a police officer or not but it is a bit silly to want to carry a weapon with you because you would rather try and defend yourself, instead of calling the police because you don't trust any officer to help you against somebody who is trying to hurt you.

DriftingDora · 26/02/2024 09:28

HatThatWearsYou · 26/02/2024 05:06

Ok. It might not actually be what that poster needs, it was just one suggestion I had made for practical things you could do to help when faced with people who have fears about the police. Is that really all you took from that?

I think you've entirely missed the point I was making.

Your attitude is part of the problem.

You began from the perspective that the poster was Wrong, then were dismissive and a little aggressive in your response to her.

Who benefits from responses like that? How does it help public perception of the police? Does it help build trust?

(Spoiler: No one. It doesn't. It does the opposite.)

The attitude of most (not all) of the police officers on here has reinforced the conclusion that they are part of the problem. Reading them over, you can well see how and why the public have lost respect for them - with their "we know best, so do what we say, shut up and don't be so silly" methodology. And they wonder why the public have such a low opinion of them! But of course it's the public's fault. Yeah, right...

HatThatWearsYou · 26/02/2024 05:06

damnedwhatever · 26/02/2024 03:03

I'd happily explain procedure .

If the poster wants to know anything please ask and I'll explain it to the best of my ability.

Ok. It might not actually be what that poster needs, it was just one suggestion I had made for practical things you could do to help when faced with people who have fears about the police. Is that really all you took from that?

I think you've entirely missed the point I was making.

Your attitude is part of the problem.

You began from the perspective that the poster was Wrong, then were dismissive and a little aggressive in your response to her.

Who benefits from responses like that? How does it help public perception of the police? Does it help build trust?

(Spoiler: No one. It doesn't. It does the opposite.)

damnedwhatever · 26/02/2024 03:03

I'd happily explain procedure .

If the poster wants to know anything please ask and I'll explain it to the best of my ability.

HatThatWearsYou · 25/02/2024 23:46

I'm aware I'm making myself an unintentional liar twice in two days by coming back, but @damnedwhatever I hope you don't mind my saying that your reply to the anxious poster would have been a really good opportunity to try some of the things I had suggested to you yesterday.

The poster isn't silly to be afraid, or to want to be able to defend herself, but you've already framed her in your mind as being ridiculous. That's a really unhelpful perspective for a police officer to start from don't you think?

You could try to understand where the fear is coming from and start from the perspective that it is valid. Then you could realise that there are times other than an emergency that the poster might not contact the police because of that fear.

You could have tried to dispel some of the fear with something like a previous poster mentioned about explaining procedure. Maybe having more information would help reduce some of the fear, I think it would for me at least a little anyway.

Maybe you could help reassure instead of just tell her she's being silly.

I agree about weapons being used against the carrier, but again maybe you could have signposted to any resources you might have on self defence classes for women or something?

You could use these posts as an opportunity to learn and be a constructive force for the public view of the police, but only if you really listen to the posters and without starting from the "you're being silly" perspective.

damnedwhatever · 25/02/2024 23:05

Yeah I think teachers get it as bad as cops on here !

CarrotOfPeace · 25/02/2024 22:24

Sdpbody · 22/02/2024 21:34

I find these threads so frustrating. We can't bash teachers, or doctors, or firefighters, but Police Officers are fair game. There are 10,000s of officers, the majority are good people, who want to help and work hard.

You can "bash" teachers? Who's saying you can't?

damnedwhatever · 25/02/2024 22:02

Ironfloor269 · 24/02/2024 23:23

I feel so scared that I might one day in a position where my young daughter or I might need the police's help but i would potentially be putting ourselves in even more danger than I was originally in....

I now think about ways of protecting ourselves without depending on the police I.e carrying pepper spray or similar, nail file

I genuinely advise not doing this - for one most weapons carried end up being used on the carrier .

Do you genuinely think if you ever need police in an emergency you're going to get people who put you in danger ?

Would you go to the doctors if Ill? What about Harold shipman ?

Would you stay in hospital if needed ? What about nurses who have been convicted of murder ?

The chances of
Yku getting some killer rapist cop if ringing 999 is as negligible as finding Harold shipman is your gp.

I get there is public distrust but this is a bit silly . You think you're going to defend yourself with a nail file ? Please don't be silly .

Ironfloor269 · 25/02/2024 10:41

TheChippendenSpook · 25/02/2024 08:34

How ridiculous! And besides, what are you going to do with an emery board? Scratch someone with it?

Not the emery board kind of nail file. The old fashioned metal kind. Because that's the closest to a knife you're legally allowed to carry.

TheChippendenSpook · 25/02/2024 08:34

Ironfloor269 · 24/02/2024 23:23

I feel so scared that I might one day in a position where my young daughter or I might need the police's help but i would potentially be putting ourselves in even more danger than I was originally in....

I now think about ways of protecting ourselves without depending on the police I.e carrying pepper spray or similar, nail file

How ridiculous! And besides, what are you going to do with an emery board? Scratch someone with it?

damnedwhatever · 24/02/2024 23:54

Hat

I really appreciate what you've said and it's food for thought without a doubt.

I'm so sorry so many people feel so let down .

It's definitely an issue that need to be addressed by all forces .

I can't thank you enough for being so honest and gracious in what you said . I'm really not an uncaring person- I care . I care how we are thought of as a big homogeneous group of people. I know there's loads of work to do to regain public trust . That's not lost on me .

But you've been lovely and I thank you sincerely. We got off on the wrong foot and that's my fault . I'm sorry for that .

X

Ironfloor269 · 24/02/2024 23:23

I feel so scared that I might one day in a position where my young daughter or I might need the police's help but i would potentially be putting ourselves in even more danger than I was originally in....

I now think about ways of protecting ourselves without depending on the police I.e carrying pepper spray or similar, nail file

HatThatWearsYou · 24/02/2024 22:54

damnedwhatever · 24/02/2024 22:07

Hat

Thank you. I am really upfront about my job because when I first started posting years and years ago the climate here was different.

Thank you for your apology, that's really gracious of you and I appreciate it.

I don't give advice anymore for the record . I wouldn't do that now . I did used to sit up all night with people who'd posted that they'd just had their oh arrested or whatever- I don't do that now either .

Thank you x

I appreciate you accepting my apology after all I've said, I appreciate that it can't be pleasant to read my posts to you sometimes.

Even with all I've said upthread, I genuinely don't mean you any personal harm or offense, although I can appreciate why anyone I'd said those things to would be offended.

I really am kicking myself for getting that about the work laptop so very wrong, I am actually really sorry about that, it was a complete misunderstanding on my part entirely. @RosieTheChi and others here will hopefully read my retraction too, I'd hate to leave posters with misinformation about it.

I think that's a good idea not to give advice over PMs anymore. I think it's probably the safest option for you in the long run not only for professional standards reasons, but for your own mental wellbeing too - It can take it out of you being that kind of support for people.

I don't think anyone would have reason to complain if you wanted to signpost advice seekers to the relevant services within their threads where appropriate, that would be a lovely thing to do if you have the means at your disposal.

As a final thought, I would like to thank all those in the police force who are trying to hold to the standards those on this thread expect, we do know you have an incredibly hard job to do, as some of you have outlined here. For all of those of you who have reacted badly to this thread however, please remember people have valid reasons for complaint, and they have valid cause for concern about police conduct on a systemic scale.

Don't get angry at the people who see the issues, get angry that the issues do sadly exist. It really isn't a personal indictment to any one of you to point them out, what it should do (ideally) is give you a look into how the public sees the police as a whole and realise that maybe it would be a good idea to genuinely listen, take on board the complaints, and try (as a whole service) to fix those issues.

I am going to go away for good now, I promise ha ha!

damnedwhatever · 24/02/2024 22:07

Hat

Thank you. I am really upfront about my job because when I first started posting years and years ago the climate here was different.

Thank you for your apology, that's really gracious of you and I appreciate it.

I don't give advice anymore for the record . I wouldn't do that now . I did used to sit up all night with people who'd posted that they'd just had their oh arrested or whatever- I don't do that now either .

Thank you x

HatThatWearsYou · 24/02/2024 21:49

damnedwhatever · 24/02/2024 21:11

Hat

You are wrong . I have never ever used my work laptop for anything other than work . I'd happily surrender it to psd for analysis because yku drew that conclusion- and you are wrong.

How stupid do you think I am ? I would never and have never used a work device for personal use.

I have my phone and an iPad for personal use. My work equipment is kept absolutely separate.

I'd like to apologise to you. You are absolutely right.

I wondered, so I had a quick search of your old user name with the key word 'laptop' and I can see now that you've offered to "fire up your laptop for PMs", but I can't see where you ever said it was your work laptop.

I am genuinely sorry for getting that totally and completely wrong.

I think the confusion came about because you have been very upfront in a lot of those threads looking for advice about being a police officer and either offering or agreeing to advice via PM to people. I think my brain supplied a connection that wasn't actually there - give advice + laptop = work laptop. I am sorry about that!

At the risk of taking away from the apology somewhat, I do still think it's inappropriate of you to be offering advice via PM after telling people you are a police officer. Both for the other reasons I've outlined in my other posts, as well as the professional boundary iffy-ness that could come from it.