Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of the police!!

416 replies

Noangelbuthavingfun · 22/02/2024 18:39

Yet another one .... rapist ..before He even joined the force. WTAF is going on ?
You can't trust the very people that you are supposed to ! Add to that the failings of the police "force" dealing with Grace and Barnaby case recently and the awful disrespectful texts that we heard about .... and you just think what de hell is going on !! Unforgivable!

OP posts:
damnedwhatever · 23/02/2024 21:19

Can I make it very clear that the police do not have the power to decide on a charging decision other than for common assault .

All other offences and all domestic violence offences are referred to the crown prosecution service for a decision on whether to charge .

damnedwhatever · 23/02/2024 21:16

Gbh is defined by the cps as a wound which goes through all 8 layers of skin . So a stabbing - gbh . Section 18 assault - either with intent or not .

Abh- that's a black eye or a tooth knocked out

Common assault- a push or shove without injury .

damnedwhatever · 23/02/2024 21:12

RosieTheChi · 23/02/2024 21:03

Can I ask a question to the officers on the thread?

How come Police pick and choose what to arrest someone for and/or charge them? Even when someone has been harmed long term, possibly permanently (GBH), they don't want to know.

Was just curious if there was some rationale I'm not understanding.

I can't answer that because you give no circumstances.

Gbh is a section 18 assault - one down from manslaughter. If indeed a gbh is recorded as a crime the police CANNOT pick or choose whether to interview. There are two ways to
Obtain evidence by questioning however - pace 12 - arrest and interview or pace 9 , interview under caution as a voluntary attendee.

Then the matter would be referred to the crown prosecution service for a charging decision. Police do t decide what to charge with . The cps do that - not us .

RosieTheChi · 23/02/2024 21:09

@Devilshands From a legal perspective, it is impossible for a woman to commit the offence of rape.

RosieTheChi · 23/02/2024 21:03

Can I ask a question to the officers on the thread?

How come Police pick and choose what to arrest someone for and/or charge them? Even when someone has been harmed long term, possibly permanently (GBH), they don't want to know.

Was just curious if there was some rationale I'm not understanding.

Lightnose · 23/02/2024 21:01

The thing that really bothers me is the way it always turns out "everyone" knew what a bad egg they were and nothing was done. So you can say it's not all of them, I'm sure it's not, but the "good" ones aren't doing what's needed either.

HopelessBlue192 · 23/02/2024 20:58

Why don't you go and join then if you know how easy it would be to be a good police officer?

damnedwhatever · 23/02/2024 20:56

And I do understand the comparison drawn - so we have couzens - a serial rapist .

Couple of cops over the last 20 years gone down for murder .

Is that not comparable with nurses and doctors who kill ? Allot, shipman, letby.

A nurse at prison has just got 11 years for drug dealing to the inmates and having a relationship with one of the inmates who organised the drugs . Was caught with hundreds of thousands of pounds worth in ribena bottles .

What about the teachers who get sent down for assault - local one here just got a lengthy sentence for raping a 12 year old . Twice .

Dont hear about that on the bbc though do we ?

My point is for some reason - the police get slated as a group for the few who do wrong . That doesn't happen in other professions.

Desmondo2021 · 23/02/2024 20:54

I am a senior leader within the Police Force and I too feel incredibly saddened to read these threads. I understand the widespread lack of trust and I am as horrified as any civilian with the many horrible stories of Police Officers who have committed crimes and abused their position. Equally I am saddened that our media are just so intent on furthering the lack of trust at every opportunity and, as is evidenced by this thread, so many people are just so easily led by what they read online or see on Facebook! But what makes me most sad is the belief and narrative portrayed by so many that every individual officer is corrupt. What about the 24 year old on my team who escorted a mother to hospital an hour away yesterday at 11pm to get her there quickly to be with her daughter who had been in a serious collision and then when the worst happened stayed supporting her until the husband got there so she wasn't alone, ending her shift at 3.30am when she had to get up for a school run at 7am before doing it all over again today. Or the detective on my team who put in a 22 hour shift on Tuesday to get a dangerous rapist charged and remanded, missing his sons birthday party. What about when you were tucking into Christmas dinner last year and I was counselling a young member of my team who had just spent 3 hours with a 5 year old who had found her mum hanging (having also cut down the poor woman and tried her best to save her life ). This job is slowly killing me, the demand is intense, the pressures and trauma we face absolutely unimaginable, we are all breaking a bit more each week to do our individual best to keep our communities safe. There are bad eggs, there are failings and things need to change but PLEASE don't make this personal to each and every one of us.

Rainbowstripes24 · 23/02/2024 20:53

damnedwhatever · 23/02/2024 20:28

Not one of colleagues is not disgusted by police officers who are exposed as being criminals , abusers ,. The majority are not bad apples or corrupt . The majority do their best working the confines of the law .

What about the group of criminals gf duty cops who ran to the aid of a man being attacked with a machete and a dog , and without any personal protection equipment tackled him and detained him ?

No body takes into account the good that police do . They see only the bad . Yes I'm angry that the likes of couzens and their ilk are in the job at all - but they ARE being exposed now and weeded out .

I think the bbc particularly is very focused on being anti- even the investigation into Nicola bullock's disappearance was criticised by armchair detectives who knew nothing .

Most of my colleagues are diligent, if overworked and underpaid. Yes sometimes people don't do the best job - I've just picked one up that wasn't dealt with properly probably because the response officer just wanted to clear their massive crime list .

I'm not frontline and I still have 22 investigations on my crime list . Frontline regularly get given 60+ to deal with in the space of one set - 6 days ! It's impossible.

I'm not asking for sympathy. I chose the job and I'm proud to do it . The focus however , out of 44 forces and thousands of officers , is those very few that get investigated.

I don't think many people understand the amount of work that's put onto one officer.

Balhammom · 23/02/2024 20:40

Hereyoume · 23/02/2024 09:55

The police in the UK are understaffed, have no equipment, very little training and are expected to fix any problem, immediately, without even stopping for lunch.

What on earth do you expect?

Most are just trying to do their best, but they have been given an impossible job.

Let's be brutally honest here. The police are just people, they're not special, they're not Saints in uniform, they are just people. Their pay is a joke. You run away from the criminal with the knife, but expect the police to run towards them, risking their life for £2500 a month!

Are you fucking serious?

Would you risk not coming home to your family for that salary?

How about being dragged to death behind a car, left lying naked on the side of the road, dying, all because you went to stop some thieving cunts breaking into someone home.

Oh, let me guess, the sexist, misogynistic (potential rapist) of an officer deserved it did he!

But no! Let's call them all rapists and abusers instead, that's much more fun!

They are criticised if they make the slightest mistake. They are abused by both the criminals and the wider public. If one person, who works as a Police Officer does something wrong, all officers are blamed and told that they are also a rapist, murderer, abuser or any other thing. But we don't do that when a people in other professions commit crimes or make mistakes.

Most of us cause our own problems and then blame the police when they don't sort out the mess we have chosen to create.

Most of the posts on this thread are just police bashing nonsense.

If you want to criticise the police, you need to fix them first. Because blaming a person who is overworked, underpaid, badly trained, woefully equipped and relentlessly abused, is not a credible position.

Also, there are numerous forces in the UK who are run by female chief Constables, overseen by a female PCC, so we aren't any better as women.

The job of the police should be to dealing with crime, not mental health, not social work, not relationship counselling, no child care, not sorting out the problem you created for yourself.

Great post. Couldn’t agree more!

Meadowfinch · 23/02/2024 20:40

There are 170,000 police officers in the UK, and they will represent society so the chances are you will get rapists and thieves and racists among that number.

You would hope that the training would weed out a lot of those, and it does but inevitably a few get through.

On the disrespectful comments or texts, police have to deal with a lot of awful things, and one way of coping is with black humour that can so easily be misconstrued. I'm not saying being disrespectful is right or acceptable, but sometimes that is how people cope with what they have to deal with.

That is not to be mistaken for racist or sexist nastiness, totally different thing.

Namechange1253467 · 23/02/2024 20:33

Noangelbuthavingfun · 23/02/2024 20:30

Thanks. I guess they won't reveal what was said.

Noangelbuthavingfun · 23/02/2024 20:30

Namechange1253467 · 23/02/2024 20:29

Can someone give me a source to the original complaint? Who did what?

Who said what about the grace and Barnaby case?

Here is one article ... many more.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-nottinghamshire-68335865.amp

Ian Coates, Barnaby Webber and Grace O'Malley-Kumar

Police disciplined for 'crude' WhatsApp message - BBC News

The mum of one of the Nottingham attacks victims says it was an "abhorrent" way to conduct an inquiry.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-nottinghamshire-68335865.amp

OP posts:
Namechange1253467 · 23/02/2024 20:29

Can someone give me a source to the original complaint? Who did what?

Who said what about the grace and Barnaby case?

damnedwhatever · 23/02/2024 20:28

Not one of colleagues is not disgusted by police officers who are exposed as being criminals , abusers ,. The majority are not bad apples or corrupt . The majority do their best working the confines of the law .

What about the group of criminals gf duty cops who ran to the aid of a man being attacked with a machete and a dog , and without any personal protection equipment tackled him and detained him ?

No body takes into account the good that police do . They see only the bad . Yes I'm angry that the likes of couzens and their ilk are in the job at all - but they ARE being exposed now and weeded out .

I think the bbc particularly is very focused on being anti- even the investigation into Nicola bullock's disappearance was criticised by armchair detectives who knew nothing .

Most of my colleagues are diligent, if overworked and underpaid. Yes sometimes people don't do the best job - I've just picked one up that wasn't dealt with properly probably because the response officer just wanted to clear their massive crime list .

I'm not frontline and I still have 22 investigations on my crime list . Frontline regularly get given 60+ to deal with in the space of one set - 6 days ! It's impossible.

I'm not asking for sympathy. I chose the job and I'm proud to do it . The focus however , out of 44 forces and thousands of officers , is those very few that get investigated.

Treehuggingmutherfunkin · 23/02/2024 20:24

I've had terrible issues with police in the past when I was harassed by a neighbour. The leaking of information was something else and that get a slap on the wrist

MenArePeopleToo · 23/02/2024 19:25

DriftingDora · 23/02/2024 18:54

Yes and many of the opinions come from people who DO know police officers and have worked for the police, also people who have had very troubling experiences in interaction with police officers.

but I wonder where this same energy is for other professions where abhorrent crimes are committed

Other professions where they have the same power over people's lives? So what other professions are you talking of? And does the fact that other professions may have 'bad apples' of their own make the police seem any better? Don't think so. But maybe you think it's a race to the bottom?

My opinion comes from me, I am a police officer so I'm naturally going to offer it on a thread like this when I have a different perspective. No it isn't a race to the bottom, the professions I'm talking about are basically any other profession, anyone is capable of causing harm to someone else. Would you prefer I left the police or me and people like me stayed and did what we could to make things better? Genuinely asking, not being goady.

DriftingDora · 23/02/2024 18:54

MenArePeopleToo · 22/02/2024 20:45

It's not my experience of it, I work my bum off everyday because I love what I do and the people I'm surrounded by are lovely. I do exceptionally well for myself in my career and I will always try my best in what I do. I know a lot of people who have a lot of heavy opinions and have never worked for the police in any capacity, it's difficult not to disagree when your lived experienced for over a decade is extremely different. I'm not denying anything people hear about in the news but I wonder where this same energy is for other professions where abhorrent crimes are committed.

Yes and many of the opinions come from people who DO know police officers and have worked for the police, also people who have had very troubling experiences in interaction with police officers.

but I wonder where this same energy is for other professions where abhorrent crimes are committed

Other professions where they have the same power over people's lives? So what other professions are you talking of? And does the fact that other professions may have 'bad apples' of their own make the police seem any better? Don't think so. But maybe you think it's a race to the bottom?

DriftingDora · 23/02/2024 17:55

FatPrincess · 23/02/2024 10:13

If the police went on strike for a few weeks people would change their tune very quickly!

They are not allowed to strike. And in case it's escaped anyone, they are paid to do a job and need to be accountable for their mistakes - the same as anyone else who is in a job, most of whom lack the power over people's lives that the police have. Heaven knows the police have made more than enough mistakes over the past few years, with no visible signs of improvement. And would people change their tune if the police DID go on strike? I strongly doubt it; for one thing the police don't turn out for much crime anyway and for another the rot has gone too deep - the majority of the public (with good reason) do not trust the police.

The main problem is that 'accountability' seems to be a word the Police Force has never heard of. Get some of that, weed out some of the criminals and power abusers they employ and they might just get a bit of respect back.

DriftingDora · 23/02/2024 14:10

Ostagazuzulum · 23/02/2024 05:28

I'm curious - What does everyone think needs to be done to improve things?

Statements like this need to be made constructive.

How do they improve?

I think someone suggested getting rid of police which just can't and won't happen. If that shopkeeper has armed people in his store trying to rob him, who does he call? If there is a man with a knife running along street jumping on cars threatening people, who do they call? We can't just ignore them and hope they go away.

So it's fine to have an opinion and say how poor you think police are but maybe back it up with a realistic idea of what should be done to improve it.

It might help if they went through their records (ha! ha! ha! What records?) and checked how many of their officers have criminal records. Getting rid of a few of those might be a start. The latest one (on the Grace, Ian & Barnaby case) had a record before he even joined. What knobhead was responsible for allowing him in? And will said knobhead lose their job? Answer = no.

DriftingDora · 23/02/2024 14:06

LakieLady · 23/02/2024 09:30

I wonder if the culture varies much between forces?

I live in a (mostly) rural county, and have had quite a lot of dealings with the police, mostly professionally, but also personally. I have always found the police here to be respectful, reasonable and supportive.

Completely different from when I lived in London, and had to deal with the Met.

I wonder if the culture varies much between forces?

I strongly doubt it.

medianewbie · 23/02/2024 13:27

Iwasafool · 23/02/2024 12:31

How can you say there is no accountability when we know of these cases because officers have been arrested, prosecuted and in some cases imprisoned?

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/mar/25/police-england-wales-deleting-outcomes-misconduct-hearings
Because the MET is still routinely deleting misconduct outcomes from their own site. Because hardly any cases get that far anyway. Because the IPPC was anything but independent. Because of my own lived experience, both personal & professional (I worked with Police Scotland during my time with Women's Aid). Because improving accountability is a more positive approach than denying a (well documented) problem exists.

LakieLady · 23/02/2024 12:41

PurpleBugz · 23/02/2024 10:14

I'm fairly sure there is research showing the police are abusive partners in higher proportion than the general public. I can't reference it but a woman on my freedom program had a terrible abusive police husband and the group facilitator said it's a well known fact in domestic abuse charities and the research backs this up. It's as a pp said, it's a job that attracts people who like to have power

I recall some research along those lines, but this was back in the late 80s/early 90s.

Iwasafool · 23/02/2024 12:34

PaintInColour · 23/02/2024 09:30

That’s horrific. But on a thread specially about police, why on earth bring up abusive nhs workers? Does that make police brutality ok? The whataboutery weakens the debate.

Anyway I agree there are abusive nhs workers. And lazy and incompetent ones. And I would say so on a thread about that, with examples. And have done. I wouldn’t say there, ‘but but police are worse!’. Raise your standards and expectations.

If you look back I wasn't the one who brought them up, someone else did and were told it wasn't as big a problem. I was commenting on that. If you've got a problem with NHS workers being brought up maybe mention it to the person who brought them into the discussion.

Telling someone who is disclosing sexual abuse when they were a child is pretty bloody low. How low are your standards?