Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBUngrateful to inlaws/grandparents

60 replies

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 16:19

My inlaws weren‘t bad parents(not abusive), but we‘re leaning on no longer initiating contact. Sorry, long post.

MIL relied heavily on her mum financially and for childcare(lived in GMILs house). She not only thought that she‘d worked enough despite being years away from retirement since i first met her(early - mid fifties) but also frequently asked DH/us for help. She learned in therapy to put her own needs first and won‘t do anything that inconveniences her. She likes to visit frequently but not to help out with babysitting, just to talk about her favorite topics like her digestion.
I was fine with that until she guilttripped us into going on a vacation with her, where she falsely accused me of lying and treated me horribly(ignored me for 2 days, didn‘t let me explain an innocent misunderstanding). According to DH that is normal behavior for her.

FIL was a „not even every second weekend“ distant parent after their divorce. Him and SMIL invite us for Xmas and sometimes for their birthdays and come to our birthdays but don’t stay long and only SMIL interacts with DC(2 and 8months). Only „no reason visit“ ever was after DH tried to guilttrip them into seeing DC1 a year ago, nothing since despite a few invitations from us. He told them that we‘re really struggling with DC1+full time work+ me being pregnant again and they took DC1 to the playground ONCE for an hour and apparently it was easy and fun.
DH helped FIL renovate his new house on several occations. FIL volunteered to help us a couple of times with our newly bought house, chosing(!) to do hard physical labour on hot days. He‘s not unfit.
They live close by, but SMIL and FIL still work 4 days per week.

DH says we don’t have to feel bad for not visiting(often) when they‘re actually old and really need our help.
Are we ungrateful? Do we expect too much?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Toffifee1 · 23/02/2024 12:08

Moneybum · 23/02/2024 09:38

It’s going to vary wildly though isn’t it in terms of what that “care” looks like.

If it were my father, putting myself in the OPs DHs shoes, and they didn’t show any interest in my kids and had been distant during my upbringing I probably wouldn’t be racing round when they were old and the accidentally unprogrammed their telly or whatever minor “emergency” arose that day (as can happen as people get older and small things become catastrophes). Became demented / started to become unsafe at home / terminal illness - yes I’d help sort out a care package for them and make sure their basic needs were met.

at all other times, see them when suited me at a frequency I thought right. Going round daily / weekly or whatever - no, not from a sense of duty.

Exactly what i meant.
For my parents, i‘d drive half the night to sort their telly if my brother was vacationing or whatever. For them, i wouldn‘t inconvenience myself. Although they called last week on the way to their vacation because they‘d forgotten to lock the front door and guess who jumped..

OP posts:
Toffifee1 · 23/02/2024 12:03

Luxell934 · 23/02/2024 07:49

Sorry but what kind of sick individual would withhold care of an elderly parent just because they didn’t provide childcare on a Sunday afternoon when they haven’t even been formally asked to. Your DH sounds lovely.

Edited

Please read before commenting.

Noone is withholding care. They can go to a nusing home and we‘ll visit on birthdays only like they do.

We did repeatedly invite them to visit and we also asked for babysitting in emergencies/because we had a lot to do.

FIL doesn’t seem to care about the kids or DH/rarely calls/doesn’t visit. MIL does visit but not to help, only to be entertained/drink tea/coffee.

example:
I was once severely sick with D&V while 8 months pregnant, i could not leave the bathroom and DC1 was healthy again but not allowed to go to nursery yet.
MIL was supposed to come around for a visit in the afternoon and i asked her if she could come in the morning because i‘d spent the night on the bathroom floor and DH had an important meeting at work.
She didn‘t want to come because she had planned to go to the gym(which is also open in the afternoon when DH could be back from work).

OP posts:
Moneybum · 23/02/2024 09:38

It’s going to vary wildly though isn’t it in terms of what that “care” looks like.

If it were my father, putting myself in the OPs DHs shoes, and they didn’t show any interest in my kids and had been distant during my upbringing I probably wouldn’t be racing round when they were old and the accidentally unprogrammed their telly or whatever minor “emergency” arose that day (as can happen as people get older and small things become catastrophes). Became demented / started to become unsafe at home / terminal illness - yes I’d help sort out a care package for them and make sure their basic needs were met.

at all other times, see them when suited me at a frequency I thought right. Going round daily / weekly or whatever - no, not from a sense of duty.

Luxell934 · 23/02/2024 07:49

Sorry but what kind of sick individual would withhold care of an elderly parent just because they didn’t provide childcare on a Sunday afternoon when they haven’t even been formally asked to. Your DH sounds lovely.

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 20:23

Luxell934 · 22/02/2024 20:11

It’s not tit for tat though. I assume your FIL raised your husband and provided for him etc for 18 years so it’s not a case of oh DH helped clear out his dads garage so now they owe us some childcare. Either ask them specifically or just accept they don’t want to do it.

tit for tat is kind of my question.
Do i compare caring for DH until he was 18(FIL was not an involved parent either though), which is kind of the must-do job of a parent to now owing them help as they‘ll age or do i compare them letting us down now by not helping when they‘re not obligated to help to us not being obligated to look after them in the future? Thats DHs conclusion not mine. I am disappointed in my inlaws, too, but DH is the one who drew the conclusion to not help them in return.

OP posts:
bluebird3 · 22/02/2024 20:20

Moneybum · 22/02/2024 17:26

I think you are getting a very hard time here, OP. I think it does hurt when ILs don’t seem to want to be close to their grandkids, including doing the odd babysitting session every now and again. That’s a way of showing love, assuming they still have the confidence and capability to be able to look after little kids. And when you are in the pit and could do with a hand it just proves who is willing to show up for you. It’s hard to accept when that’s not family doing that for you.

I would reflect on my relationship, like you are, and think about my choices going forward. It is a 2 way street and if they aren’t there for you as a family, steel yourself about being there for them. Like you say you are reducing contact not cutting contact - I think that’s more than fair to avoid your own disappointment. The door is always open for them to reach out.

I agree with all of this.

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 20:15

Milkmani · 22/02/2024 20:08

@Toffifee1 I am lucky to have good parents and in-laws but my grandmothers provided childcare for myself and cousins when we were children. I have done a lot for in-laws and parents over the years and although I don’t expect childcare (I have told my mum she can stop whenever she finds it too much) it’s called looking after your family. I worked pt to help look after in-laws in their final years, obviously I wasn’t expecting childcare in return or anything financial - there was nothing financial to gain, they had no assets. It’s about the type of family you’re from and many realise life is too short for selfishness. I would stick to your parents and give up on the others, it will be less disappointing for your children in the long run.

Thank you.
my parents unfortunately live quiet far away and my husband wouldn‘t be able to find a job there.
You‘re right, the kids won‘t even know what they‘re missing and won‘t be dissppointed. Its just us comparing to our grandparents and my parents-niece relationship.

OP posts:
Luxell934 · 22/02/2024 20:11

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 18:11

I am moaning that he‘s not interested in his grandkids. At all.
DH has helped him a lot more over the years.

It’s not tit for tat though. I assume your FIL raised your husband and provided for him etc for 18 years so it’s not a case of oh DH helped clear out his dads garage so now they owe us some childcare. Either ask them specifically or just accept they don’t want to do it.

Milkmani · 22/02/2024 20:08

@Toffifee1 I am lucky to have good parents and in-laws but my grandmothers provided childcare for myself and cousins when we were children. I have done a lot for in-laws and parents over the years and although I don’t expect childcare (I have told my mum she can stop whenever she finds it too much) it’s called looking after your family. I worked pt to help look after in-laws in their final years, obviously I wasn’t expecting childcare in return or anything financial - there was nothing financial to gain, they had no assets. It’s about the type of family you’re from and many realise life is too short for selfishness. I would stick to your parents and give up on the others, it will be less disappointing for your children in the long run.

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 19:41

Milkmani · 22/02/2024 19:35

No they saw them weekly before they died (only weekends) and would take to the park, for lunch etc in occasion but mainly just playing with them at home. Couldn’t do much more as they were elderly, but they would have liked to if more fit and well. My parents see them weekly, my dad died last year and mum still provides childcare. I find it odd when grandparents aren’t bothered by their grandchildren.

You seem to have a good relationship with your parents and are expecting the same from in-laws. But you husband is making it clear they’re not the same and he wants to cut back the effort you make. I imagine they were the type of parents to you husband as they are their grandchildren - people who can’t be bothered. I find it sad when grandparents aren’t interested in their grandchildren but it seems there’s a lot of them out there.

Okay i misunderstood the part about before they died. Sorry for your loss.
i assume you know how lucky you are to have/have had (grand)parents like that after reading posts like mine.
i also find it odd. My parents find it odd, too. Thank you for finding it odd. Helps to read that.

OP posts:
Milkmani · 22/02/2024 19:35

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 19:16

Do you mean they wanted to see their grandchild only ONCE before they died??

(and yes, i would love babysitting and once a months was not to be taken literally but just an example, but obviosly not like a paid babysitter just for babysitting but for geneal family time)

No they saw them weekly before they died (only weekends) and would take to the park, for lunch etc in occasion but mainly just playing with them at home. Couldn’t do much more as they were elderly, but they would have liked to if more fit and well. My parents see them weekly, my dad died last year and mum still provides childcare. I find it odd when grandparents aren’t bothered by their grandchildren.

You seem to have a good relationship with your parents and are expecting the same from in-laws. But you husband is making it clear they’re not the same and he wants to cut back the effort you make. I imagine they were the type of parents to you husband as they are their grandchildren - people who can’t be bothered. I find it sad when grandparents aren’t interested in their grandchildren but it seems there’s a lot of them out there.

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 19:29

Octavia64 · 22/02/2024 18:13

Most grandparents do care for their grandkids at some point.

82% have at some point.

www.informationnow.org.uk/article/grandparent-issues/#

That would include your SMIL and FIL taking them for an hour.

So one in five grandparents don't look after their grandkids ever.

So there are quite a few people like you.

Interesting article. We do pay for our kids to go to nursery. We could afford to pay a babysitter but wouldn’t feel comfortble leaving DCs with a stranger just yet so we have only been out together as a couple when we visited my parents once and on vacation with my parents. We only sk my parents to come for emergencies like DC2s birth as it is a long drive.

OP posts:
Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 19:23

wizzywig · 22/02/2024 18:16

I think this is the first time I've read on MN that within a problem situation is a husband that is backing up the wife. Go with it op!

Hahaha. He‘s actually the one who‘s more disappointed and i‘m going to convince him to just drop it after what i‘ve larned here.

OP posts:
Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 19:16

Milkmani · 22/02/2024 18:58

When I read the post I think she means initiate contact to see the grandchildren rather than just providing childcare. Yes having a regular once a month afternoon of childcare would be nice for the OP but I think she would rather the in-laws were interested in seeing the children, like normal grandparents? It seems rather odd to me that they’re not bothered about seeing them. But then my in laws wanted to see their GC before they died as did my parents. Guess it depends on the type of family you’re from.

Do you mean they wanted to see their grandchild only ONCE before they died??

(and yes, i would love babysitting and once a months was not to be taken literally but just an example, but obviosly not like a paid babysitter just for babysitting but for geneal family time)

OP posts:
Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 19:10

Octavia64 · 22/02/2024 18:50

It is perfectly reasonable to ask for childcare.

But if they won't give it there is not a lot you can actually do.

They may not want or need your care when they are older.

Yeah, i wish everyone a humane and quick end but as someone who has helped care for grandparents and an aunt in their last years..Caring family does make a difference(unless you have money for above average care).

OP posts:
Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 19:03

SushiMayo · 22/02/2024 18:43

No one should be guilt tripping anyone

I don’t feel bad for trying to initiate contact with the grandparents.

OP posts:
Milkmani · 22/02/2024 18:58

Luxell934 · 22/02/2024 16:59

No longer initiating contact because they don't provide adequate enough childcare for you? Only on Mumsnet.

When I read the post I think she means initiate contact to see the grandchildren rather than just providing childcare. Yes having a regular once a month afternoon of childcare would be nice for the OP but I think she would rather the in-laws were interested in seeing the children, like normal grandparents? It seems rather odd to me that they’re not bothered about seeing them. But then my in laws wanted to see their GC before they died as did my parents. Guess it depends on the type of family you’re from.

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 18:53

Moneybum · 22/02/2024 17:26

I think you are getting a very hard time here, OP. I think it does hurt when ILs don’t seem to want to be close to their grandkids, including doing the odd babysitting session every now and again. That’s a way of showing love, assuming they still have the confidence and capability to be able to look after little kids. And when you are in the pit and could do with a hand it just proves who is willing to show up for you. It’s hard to accept when that’s not family doing that for you.

I would reflect on my relationship, like you are, and think about my choices going forward. It is a 2 way street and if they aren’t there for you as a family, steel yourself about being there for them. Like you say you are reducing contact not cutting contact - I think that’s more than fair to avoid your own disappointment. The door is always open for them to reach out.

Thank you for this reply. I was genuinely asking for outside opinions as i am used to much closer knit families and a lot of our friends have invested (grand)parents.
Seems like we don‘t. And although i‘m getting an unreasonable to „stop initiating“ (as in reducing and not actively pursuing contact, giving up on my dream that my kids could have a loving relationship with their grandparents like DH and I had) vote, comments like yours help me realise that i am not unreasonable in my plans, only in my expectations.

OP posts:
Octavia64 · 22/02/2024 18:50

It is perfectly reasonable to ask for childcare.

But if they won't give it there is not a lot you can actually do.

They may not want or need your care when they are older.

SarahC50 · 22/02/2024 18:44

@Toffifee1 I'm really sorry you find yourself in this position but I speak from bitter experience. It won't change and they won't suddenly be interested in a relationship with your kids. Don't be me burning myself out to force contact on disinterested grandparents. It will destroy you. Your mil sounds a nightmare. Put in firm boundaries when dealing with her.

Try and focus on your own wee family. I truly understand the pain and upset of disinterested grandparents but it won't change and it will only cause you pain.

Focus on yourself and your family. No longer be available to help and in the future when they need help or care, it sure as hell won't be you offering it. You reap what you sow xcx

SushiMayo · 22/02/2024 18:43

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 18:24

True. But guilttripping into a sunday afternoon visit to the playground is not like guilttripping someone into a weeklong vacation.

No one should be guilt tripping anyone

HelloMiss · 22/02/2024 18:41

So just accept that they aren't as into small kids as you would want??

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 18:37

Octavia64 · 22/02/2024 17:24

Not going to comment on Mil, but if FIL and step MIL are still working four days a week, and have come and helped work on your house in return for DH working on their house then I think they are offering to you the same as you are offering to them.

I don't think it's fair to expect childcare from people who are still working (close to) full time and are returning favours in other ways.

Thank you for your thoughts.
They do however have 4 3 day weekends every months and one sunday afternoon out of those 4 weekends seems to be too much to ask according to mumsnet. I visited my grandparents every weekend as a child and DH spent every afternoon at GMIL. FIL lives 12 minutes away.
when they do come for birthdays 2-3 times per year FIL ignores the grandkids.

..
We will also still be working 5 days per week when they‘re older and need help.

OP posts:
Butterdishy · 22/02/2024 18:33

Just stop putting in more than you get out. There's no use being disappointed or trying to manipulate people into the kind of relationship you want, it doesn't work. If they want a superficial relationship, give them a superficial relationship.

Toffifee1 · 22/02/2024 18:26

Charlie2121 · 22/02/2024 17:19

My parents and PIL do nothing for us. Not a
minute of childcare or any financial
support. We’re OK with that but in return don’t see that any care they may need in later life to be our problem to resolve not least because we have siblings who do receive huge support from them.

We don’t have a very close relationship with either my parents or PIL and see them only very occasionally but that’s OK. We’ve very much grown apart over the years so it doesn’t feel like a big issue anymore.

That is unfortunate. I‘m sorry for you and your children but glad you made peace with it. Thanks for sharing.

OP posts: