Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance vs working hard and never getting anywhere

208 replies

Anonymouseky · 22/02/2024 15:57

I know people will probably pounce on me for feeling like this, but I need to vent. I’ve always been very supporting and happy for other people when good things happen to them, but I am starting to feel really resentful over something.

I work really hard and have a stressful job (teacher). I tried hard at school and have always given my best in everything I have done. I always imagined that one day my hard work would pay off and I would be able to afford a decent standard of living. That is unfortunately not the case. I am a single parent and have no family nearby to help with childcare, so the wages don’t go far. Their dad does contribute, but with the cost of living… well, I’m sure many of you can see what I mean.

I’ve never been a jealous or resentful person and haven’t compared myself to others. In fact, I’ve always been quite happy plodding on. However, in the last few years, I’ve started to feel a bit resentful as all of my closest friends have been given large sums of money/ inheritance from relatives (some of them multiple handouts). I’ve had lots of back handed compliments about my ‘little house’ and outright nasty ones about how crap modern houses are (mine is modern and was all I could afford at the time). They will openly brag about their large character properties and discuss how they can work reduced hours or not at all due to inheritance and partner’s income. One of my friends hasn’t worked for years and has just been gifted another several hundred thousand pounds so can now afford to buy several other houses. Meanwhile I can’t afford to buy one outright.

I work so bloody hard and never seem to catch a break. I’ve never been given anything monetary like my friends have. One day I may inherit but my father has decided to look after his long term partner first and foremost, so I may never actually inherit. It’s not about the money in that case, as if he spent it all enjoying his inheritance I would be understanding and supportive. Rather, it’s about feeling like an after thought/ not important/ not a priority/ etc.

Anyway, I just want to vent. I feel like I’m destined to slog my guts out, never receive a helping hand like my friends have, and have my nose rubbed in it in the process. I know life is unfair (believe me I know that acutely due to other life/ health events). Just seems unfair that I work the hardest out of all my friends (and I don’t say that lightly) and yet seem to have the hardest time.

OP posts:
lemmefinish · 22/02/2024 19:18

Many people who inherit from parents do so because their parents have worked hard and been prudent. My parents married in the late 50s and scrimped and saved to buy a family home. Very few luxuries, no fancy holidays, no car, no phone line, no eating out at restaurants. Things that most folk take for granted nowadays.
The money has been earned and taxed and sacrifices made.

But loads of people just got lucky from buying property at the right time & right place. If you pay 50k for a house that is later worth 1m how have you been taxed on that?

laclochette · 22/02/2024 19:18

Unfortunately the gap we now have between house prices and incomes in this country means that the distinction between the inheritors and the non-inheritors is bigger and bigger. It works in two ways - firstly, it's harder to buy a home without and inheritance than it has been in decades, because the average house costs many more times the average income. Secondly, if you are the heir of someone who owns property, your inheritance is now vast compared to what most people earn.

It really is a terrible situation and if it continues we will very much be back in a sort of Victorian society I think, whereby there are upper middle and upper classes who are prosperous and secure because they are the property-owning class, and everyone else is in a much more precarious position, with little chance of escaping it, because the gap between that state and the property-owning state is so vast that no amount of hard work can bridge it. You are either born into it or not.

Your situation is an expression of that OP and you're right that it is awful.

LakeTiticaca · 22/02/2024 19:14

Many people who inherit from parents do so because their parents have worked hard and been prudent. My parents married in the late 50s and scrimped and saved to buy a family home. Very few luxuries, no fancy holidays, no car, no phone line, no eating out at restaurants. Things that most folk take for granted nowadays.
The money has been earned and taxed and sacrifices made.
So instead of bashing those who have inherited money fairly and squarely, OP, just find some different friends who dont rub your nose in it

Daisylookslost · 22/02/2024 19:13

Ohanotherflippingcold · 22/02/2024 16:28

Oh I hear you.

We are living hand to mouth with no savings whilst others enjoy numerous holidays and drive fancy cars. It's my DC I feel sorry for mainly as I feel they miss out compared to their friends.

Having said that, I can't help ' totting up' what I might get in heritance when mine and my partners parents pass away..it could be eye watering. It's a horrible way to think, and I mainly get a bee in my bonnet about why they don't bung us a couple of grand so we can take their grandaughter on holiday, instead of sitting on it like Scrooge McDuck until they aren't here anymore.

Absolute charmer aren't I 😀

😅 well you have a point

Exhausteddog · 22/02/2024 18:50

I think its hard and I say that as someone who has received my parents inheritance in my early 40s. Obviously I'd much rather they were still here (i feel really envious when i see people enjoy christmas and special occassions with their parents or grandparents attend school events or even graduation)
.... but I also know that without the money they left, we'd struggle for DD to go to uni.
We are in a more comfortable financial position now than say 10 years ago and I often feel guilty about that when lots of people are struggling with the COL and I don't take it for granted.

greenbeansnspinach · 22/02/2024 18:46

@Silverbirch7 if you are paying enough inheritance tax that it would be enough to buy a house worth say £200k, then if you had one parent who also benefited from the residence allowance, ie they were able to leave £500k before IHT kicks in at 40 per cent, you will have inherited around maybe £700k or a bit more, which seems reasonable. If two parents, then potentially double this sum.

thebestinterest · 22/02/2024 18:46

Ilovegoldies · 22/02/2024 16:42

I wish people would stop saying 'I wish Aunt Enid was still here of course' when they get an inheritance. Do people who don't get an inheritance not grieve the same? A few k softens the blow of ones passing..

😂😂😂

littleburn · 22/02/2024 18:45

Inherited/generational wealth makes for such a difference in outcomes and it does feel very unfair. There's been a few threads about it recently. You have your peer group of friends and colleagues, you have a decent job, you work hard and it all feels pretty meritocratic. Often it's only when you start buying homes and having kids that you realise just how many of your peers are backed up by generational wealth, and the difference in lifestyle and greater range of options that brings.

I agree it's crap OP, but not much we can do but suck it up - or marry very well!

MumMumMumMumMumMumMum · 22/02/2024 18:44

They're not your friends. They're mean, thoughtless and snobby to make such remarks. I agree it's hard when you just can't catch a break and everyone else around you seems to be doing better off but you don't need friends like that.

Bananasandtoast · 22/02/2024 18:44

If your friends had no inheritance it would make zero difference to your life.
If your friends stopped making you feel bad about it, that would make a difference. Are they being mean though, or are you just perceiving it that way because of how fed up you are with your own lot?

thebestinterest · 22/02/2024 18:44

Wizardo · 22/02/2024 16:04

I can’t disagree with your post. It’s not fair. Teaching should be better paid, or less arduous. Inherited wealth should be taxed more at the upper end. Modern houses shouldn’t be so crap (I’ve lived in some poorly built boxes).
my advice is ditch your friends. They sound especially unpleasant. You can definitely do better.

Why should inheritance be taxed more heavily?

thebestinterest · 22/02/2024 18:42

Anonymouseky · 22/02/2024 15:57

I know people will probably pounce on me for feeling like this, but I need to vent. I’ve always been very supporting and happy for other people when good things happen to them, but I am starting to feel really resentful over something.

I work really hard and have a stressful job (teacher). I tried hard at school and have always given my best in everything I have done. I always imagined that one day my hard work would pay off and I would be able to afford a decent standard of living. That is unfortunately not the case. I am a single parent and have no family nearby to help with childcare, so the wages don’t go far. Their dad does contribute, but with the cost of living… well, I’m sure many of you can see what I mean.

I’ve never been a jealous or resentful person and haven’t compared myself to others. In fact, I’ve always been quite happy plodding on. However, in the last few years, I’ve started to feel a bit resentful as all of my closest friends have been given large sums of money/ inheritance from relatives (some of them multiple handouts). I’ve had lots of back handed compliments about my ‘little house’ and outright nasty ones about how crap modern houses are (mine is modern and was all I could afford at the time). They will openly brag about their large character properties and discuss how they can work reduced hours or not at all due to inheritance and partner’s income. One of my friends hasn’t worked for years and has just been gifted another several hundred thousand pounds so can now afford to buy several other houses. Meanwhile I can’t afford to buy one outright.

I work so bloody hard and never seem to catch a break. I’ve never been given anything monetary like my friends have. One day I may inherit but my father has decided to look after his long term partner first and foremost, so I may never actually inherit. It’s not about the money in that case, as if he spent it all enjoying his inheritance I would be understanding and supportive. Rather, it’s about feeling like an after thought/ not important/ not a priority/ etc.

Anyway, I just want to vent. I feel like I’m destined to slog my guts out, never receive a helping hand like my friends have, and have my nose rubbed in it in the process. I know life is unfair (believe me I know that acutely due to other life/ health events). Just seems unfair that I work the hardest out of all my friends (and I don’t say that lightly) and yet seem to have the hardest time.

Luck of the draw, OP…

No matter how hard you work and how well you save your money… you’ll never get far as a single parent. The odds are massively against you, specially single mums, who are paid less than men to begin with.

I’m currently in the middle of a fascinating read titled “the two-parent privilege” look it up, highly recommend it.

Essentially, single mothers are FUCKED.

KittySmith1986 · 22/02/2024 18:40

Who wants to be friends with braggart’s? I think you need to change your friends, quite honestly. If they're bragging about their homes and criticising yours then they are not nice people! Also, if they’ve inherited because a family member has died and they’re choosing to boast about money/property inherited because of that then that’s just a bit, well, distasteful.

I don’t think the issue here is you, I think your friends sound like boastful, arrogant people. Most people are not like this, they don’t brag about stuff like that. I would honestly find more grounded folk to be with.

BronwenTheBrave · 22/02/2024 18:34

The UK is changing from a cash-based economy to an asset-based economy. In brief, the wealthy have assets that can generate an income. The non-wealthy rely on an income stream from work. However it is increasingly hard for salary incomes to buy assets like houses. As a result, the wealthy get wealthier, and the non-wealthy become increasingly less rich. The gulf between the wealthy and the non-wealthy is increasing, and this wealth disparity will increasingly cause breakdowns of our society.

ssd · 22/02/2024 18:31

No inheritance has a ripple effect too. I've been saving to try to help my dc eventually get on the property ladder, but saving £50 a month, which is what we can afford, doesn't add up very quickly. Dc is renting, he pays an awful lot and cant save much per month towards a deposit either. He studied to phd level, really put in the work at school and moved away to try to gain experience to get better paid work. His friend messed about at school, left at 16, has been in minimum wage jobs ever since. Hes recently inherited a house from his grandparents which he sold and has bought a lovely modern city centre flat. Ds is in a rental which is pretty basic, miles out of town.
So much for telling your kids to stick in at school.

Shatandfattered · 22/02/2024 18:30

I live in a shithole council house, on benefits because my two sons are autistic and every job I've had has resulted in disciplinary procedures due to having to walk out of shifts to collect them having meltdowns in school. I love in a drug rife council scheme in Scotland and my family have worked all their lives but not enough to even have small savings never mind inheritance to pass on. I know unless I win the lottery then my life will always be this

unsync · 22/02/2024 18:28

Life is unfair, if you want money and a comfortable life, you need to have a career in a sector that pays decent money. That's an active choice that people can make.

In addition, the loss leading to inheritance is often devastating. I would much rather have my loved one here now. Inheritance is pretty much an accident of birth over which one has no control.

flatmop · 22/02/2024 18:25

Rialoulou · 22/02/2024 16:05

I'm not sure inheritance = catching a break. Usually someone has died in order to receive it. You're entitled to feel jealous of other people though.

To be fair to the OP, most people experience the same bereavements but just don't have anything to inherit

Sunshineandrainbow · 22/02/2024 18:20

I feel your pain, I work full time and have to do 2 evenings to top this up as a single parent.
Have rented for 28 years and feel guilty I will have nothing to leave my kids despite working so hard.

Travelsweat · 22/02/2024 18:17

YANBU to be frustrated, and to be honest stories like yours will only become more common over the next 5-10 years as wealth inequality gets worse in western society. Increasingly, how you do in life has less to do with how hard you work or what job you do (partly because income from work is taxed more heavily than income from wealth) and more to do with how much your family has to pass down.

I’m sorry your friends are unkind. I think it would be a good idea to find some new friends who build you up instead of putting you down.

SummaLuvin · 22/02/2024 18:17

lemmefinish · 22/02/2024 18:08

Personally I far rather lose a relative & inherit then lose one & receive nothing…

true, but I think inheriting when a loved but elderly relative passes away not unexpectedly is worlds away from inheriting at 19 because the one parent who you have a relationship with dies - which was the situation for a friend of mine.

It's classic give and take, yes you inherit a sum of money that you can use to propel your life forward, get on the property ladder, retrain, spend more time with your own kids... but at what cost? Financial gain but lifelong implications and damage from losing someone far too early.

Norahsbooks · 22/02/2024 18:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

lemmefinish · 22/02/2024 18:08

Personally I far rather lose a relative & inherit then lose one & receive nothing…

lemmefinish · 22/02/2024 18:06

Inheritance has become a big divider in society in large part due to the massively inflated property market.

Yes & it’s wrong that hard work & high earnings can’t propel you forward any more. Obviously wages have stagnated & housing costs are huge so social mobility is going backwards.

I had help to buy in London, none of my peers bought without help & a fair few had high 6 fig help.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 22/02/2024 18:02

I’ve received 2 lots of inheritance over the past few years. I’d prefer that I hadn’t tbh and that the people who had earned it had longer to enjoy it for themselves.

You need better friends