Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance vs working hard and never getting anywhere

208 replies

Anonymouseky · 22/02/2024 15:57

I know people will probably pounce on me for feeling like this, but I need to vent. I’ve always been very supporting and happy for other people when good things happen to them, but I am starting to feel really resentful over something.

I work really hard and have a stressful job (teacher). I tried hard at school and have always given my best in everything I have done. I always imagined that one day my hard work would pay off and I would be able to afford a decent standard of living. That is unfortunately not the case. I am a single parent and have no family nearby to help with childcare, so the wages don’t go far. Their dad does contribute, but with the cost of living… well, I’m sure many of you can see what I mean.

I’ve never been a jealous or resentful person and haven’t compared myself to others. In fact, I’ve always been quite happy plodding on. However, in the last few years, I’ve started to feel a bit resentful as all of my closest friends have been given large sums of money/ inheritance from relatives (some of them multiple handouts). I’ve had lots of back handed compliments about my ‘little house’ and outright nasty ones about how crap modern houses are (mine is modern and was all I could afford at the time). They will openly brag about their large character properties and discuss how they can work reduced hours or not at all due to inheritance and partner’s income. One of my friends hasn’t worked for years and has just been gifted another several hundred thousand pounds so can now afford to buy several other houses. Meanwhile I can’t afford to buy one outright.

I work so bloody hard and never seem to catch a break. I’ve never been given anything monetary like my friends have. One day I may inherit but my father has decided to look after his long term partner first and foremost, so I may never actually inherit. It’s not about the money in that case, as if he spent it all enjoying his inheritance I would be understanding and supportive. Rather, it’s about feeling like an after thought/ not important/ not a priority/ etc.

Anyway, I just want to vent. I feel like I’m destined to slog my guts out, never receive a helping hand like my friends have, and have my nose rubbed in it in the process. I know life is unfair (believe me I know that acutely due to other life/ health events). Just seems unfair that I work the hardest out of all my friends (and I don’t say that lightly) and yet seem to have the hardest time.

OP posts:
lemmefinish · 22/02/2024 21:04

Is also like to know why those who earn larger sums (£100k +) seem to only pay 22% tax as both the PM and Labour Leader paid last year.

Because there income is not all PAYE & different sources has different rates.

Isitovernow123 · 22/02/2024 20:55

Kendodd · 22/02/2024 20:48

Right so you think a fairer system (that we pretty much have now anyway as under 5% od estates are big enough to pay IT) is that people who work long hard hours for their money pay more tax so that others who recieve a massive great windfall of free money, that they have done absolutly nothing to earn, should pay no tax on it?

Because I have to admit, I don't think that's fair. I also think big Lottery wins should be taxed as well btw.

There are lots of people who work long hard hours doing all types of jobs. Some people are
lucky and inherit some money and/or property that allows them to work less, but the majority of us won’t get anything. Unfortunately, in my opinion, that’s just life. No point getting all het up over it - just carry on with what you’re doing.

As for the Lottery, and these big property raffles, yes they should be taxed.

Is also like to know why those who earn larger sums (£100k +) seem to only pay 22% tax as both the PM and Labour Leader paid last year.

Kendodd · 22/02/2024 20:48

Isitovernow123 · 22/02/2024 20:39

And? They paid tax on it. What about those who have purchased gold and paid no tax whatsoever on it including VAT? That’s increased significantly in value to.

This ‘needs to be taxed’ is just pure jealousy. I’m not going to inherit anything. And wouldn’t expect to, but I don’t begrudge anyone receiving gifts from family.

Right so you think a fairer system (that we pretty much have now anyway as under 5% od estates are big enough to pay IT) is that people who work long hard hours for their money pay more tax so that others who recieve a massive great windfall of free money, that they have done absolutly nothing to earn, should pay no tax on it?

Because I have to admit, I don't think that's fair. I also think big Lottery wins should be taxed as well btw.

lemmefinish · 22/02/2024 20:46

This ‘needs to be taxed’ is just pure jealousy. I’m not going to inherit anything. And wouldn’t expect to, but I don’t begrudge anyone receiving gifts from family.

And you can’t acknowledge economic policy which has inflated assets & devalued wages may be an issue? I say this as someone who did get a leg up.

Nosleepforthismum · 22/02/2024 20:41

Yeah I think you need new friends. I’m truly surprised that you have so many with such enormous inheritances and that they all brag about it to you.

I don’t have a clue if any of my friends have received an inheritance. Probably some of them have as grandparents/parents have passed away but I’ve never asked and they’ve never offered the information. Some have much nicer houses than others but again, no idea who’s got mortgages or not. It’s not something that’s deliberately avoided but I don’t know anyone who discusses their finances so openly with people other than their partner.

Isitovernow123 · 22/02/2024 20:39

Kendodd · 22/02/2024 20:34

This is a rubbish argument, for one, for the most part it hasn't been taxed, it's growth in house prices, two, loads of things are taxed twice.
Sales tax
Council tax
Road tax
Air Passenger tax
Etc, etc, etc.
All these taxes are for the most part paid out of money people
have worked hard for and have that they have to spread increasingly thinly. IT
is a massive great windfall people have done absolutely nothing to earn and
they get hundreds of thousand before they have to pay a single penny of tax.

And? They paid tax on it. What about those who have purchased gold and paid no tax whatsoever on it including VAT? That’s increased significantly in value to.

This ‘needs to be taxed’ is just pure jealousy. I’m not going to inherit anything. And wouldn’t expect to, but I don’t begrudge anyone receiving gifts from family.

Kendodd · 22/02/2024 20:34

Isitovernow123 · 22/02/2024 20:07

Why should inheritance be taxed when it has already been taxed at source?

This is a rubbish argument, for one, for the most part it hasn't been taxed, it's growth in house prices, two, loads of things are taxed twice.
Sales tax
Council tax
Road tax
Air Passenger tax
Etc, etc, etc.
All these taxes are for the most part paid out of money people
have worked hard for and have that they have to spread increasingly thinly. IT
is a massive great windfall people have done absolutely nothing to earn and
they get hundreds of thousand before they have to pay a single penny of tax.

Rosestulips · 22/02/2024 20:32

I hear you, I feel the same. Hope things gets easier for us all soon

Coconutter24 · 22/02/2024 20:31

Your life sounds like millions of others, not everyone gets handouts and inheritances. All you can do is keep working hard to provide for your family, don’t compare what you have to others and maybe start to look for new friends who don’t make comments about your house.

orangetriangle · 22/02/2024 20:30

I am 55 and have an inheritance but I have no mum or dad
I know I am lucky to have the inheritance but I would give it all up to have mum and dad back
Unfortunately life can be unfair
I do try not to keep putting things on fb I am mindful not everyone is in the same position u fortunately you get a number of people on fb who.dont think about other people's situations when they post their holidays days out meals etc on there
I think people need to be much more mindful that not everyone is in the same position

Tiredalwaystired · 22/02/2024 20:29

I’m sure this has been said before (not read the thread) but I had to lose both my parents when I was relatively young to get my inheritance.

I would swap it in a heartbeat for my children to have spent time with their grandma.

BreakingAndBroke · 22/02/2024 20:28

I think you have a skewed sample size. Inheriting several hundred thousand pounds is incredibly rare amongst the general population. One third of UK adults have less than £1000 in savings to their name.

Plan5studentloanSLAVERY · 22/02/2024 20:16

@Kendodd I agree everyone dies. We all know what it feels like to lose a loved one. I find these comments so crass.

OP did you grow up in an affluent area? DH and I grew up in poverty. Especially DH he didn’t have enough food to eat when he was a kid. Got into the local grammar school and was bullied mercilessly.

I don’t have this inheritance envy as I know we will never get one so I’ve always lived my life with this in mind.

A friend of mine inherited over £1 million in her forties because of an accident and a relative of hers dying prematurely. It didn’t change her personality.

I’ve worked in healthcare and when I was in my teenage years as a student I looked after patients in their twenties who died of cancer. I was so young and it really shaped how I viewed my life.

I have never been into a flashy lifestyle. I am a member of a country club gym because it is close by and it offers blue light discount so it is reasonable. It’s also opposite a very prestigious hospital. Many of the Consultants and their wives use the gym and they are all loaded but lovely. However, a few business people who are mega loaded also use the gym and they are just so intolerable. When they go into the steam room or sauna everyone else leaves because all they go on about is their money and politics. It is so obvious when it happens too.

Make new friends. Their inherited gilded lives have become very small and insignificant if all they can do is judge others and talk about their own inherited wealth. They’re better off sticking to others like them.

Another little snippet into the life of inherited wealth. My son was the only state kid on a revision course. All the others were from private schools. My son was so amused by the fact that all the private school kids (apart from one from our neck of the woods) wanted to compare who paid the most for their private school tuition fees. They were getting so competitive and when they tired of this they went onto how much their houses cost. You get my drift. The irony was my son utilised the excellent tutor the most out of all of them as my son realised the 1k course fee was not just pocket change for us.

The world is unfair. You only have one short life. Stop letting other people put you down.

Anonymouseky · 22/02/2024 20:15

Thank you all for the comments, support and understanding. It has actually really helped and it has actually been emotional reading some of the comments (in a good way). It makes me sad to hear of so many people going through something similar though. It shouldn’t be the way of things, and things should be easier for people who work hard.

For a bit of context, my mum died very young and she worked hard to give me every opportunity she never had. She would hate to see me struggle now and would have looked after me and the grandchildren in a way that my dad won’t. As a mother, I am determined to help my own children to have an easier life if I can, whilst still instilling in them the importance of hard work and doing something useful to society.

I’ve wanted to be a teacher since I was tiny. I’ve toyed with other careers and actually did have a job in a financial based role. Had I stuck to that and not returned to education, I may well be better off (financially). But my heart wasn’t in it, and I really believe that passionate teachers should remain teachers if they can. Not ebough people want to do the job and that is becoming a crisis. It does upset me that teachers, nurses etc aren’t paid as well as they should be for the stress and hours worked though. I’m honestly not money motivated though. I just want to be able to buy my house in full and have a decent quality of life. My pension projection isn’t looking great due to having a few years out to support ex husband’s career. I also don’t get school holidays due to my teaching contract. I know that’s my career choice though.

The most worrying thing of all is that there are some serious health issues in the family and my children may need life saving surgery one day. The lack of financial stability is terrifying due to the knock on implications. Heaven forbid we ever lose the NHS and I have to find the cost for surgery myself. Anyway, I’m possibly catastrophising, but money certainly can bring security and peace of mind. It’s never been about being showy or flash for me.

If anything, this whole situation is making me more determined to find a way to build financial security. I am proud of what I have achieved and for ‘doing my bit’, although it might not seem that way. I hope my children grow up and realise the hard work I’ve put in and the sacrifices made. My friends have shown a different side since their inheritances, which has felt disrespectful and distasteful at times. One did actually say to me, ‘I don’t know how you do it’ and ‘you’re doing a great job’ so she’s not all bad, but then has boasted about the latest round of inheritance money recently. I know there is insecurity there though and she feels bad for not working (not enough to return to the world of work though).

Anyway, thank you for listening to my moan/ rant and I’m sorry to hear of so many other people struggling. I’m not sure what the answer is, but I do think policies need to be put in place re housing and the exploitation of the working masses.

OP posts:
Isitovernow123 · 22/02/2024 20:14

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 22/02/2024 20:10

Because it's free money.

It’s not free money. It’s been taxed in numerous ways since it was initially paid to an employee. Just because it’s going to the next generation, that doesn’t make it free money. It’s a gift. The person who died owned that money. They’ve gifted it to someone.

If it’s free money, let’s start taxing donations to charities, school fetes etc……

strawberryandtomato · 22/02/2024 20:11

Received an inheritance very young. Had to watch my mum die by the time I was 24 though. Still work full time as does my partner. We have 2 kids. Very lucky to be in the position we are. But it came with a massive loss too.

It's shit OP I get it. Teachers should be paid more.

But I don't brag about what I have at the ripe old age of 34. Why would I. All my friends are different ages and come from all walks of life. Some are in better positions than others.
Get better friends

5thCommandment · 22/02/2024 20:11

Anonymouseky · 22/02/2024 15:57

I know people will probably pounce on me for feeling like this, but I need to vent. I’ve always been very supporting and happy for other people when good things happen to them, but I am starting to feel really resentful over something.

I work really hard and have a stressful job (teacher). I tried hard at school and have always given my best in everything I have done. I always imagined that one day my hard work would pay off and I would be able to afford a decent standard of living. That is unfortunately not the case. I am a single parent and have no family nearby to help with childcare, so the wages don’t go far. Their dad does contribute, but with the cost of living… well, I’m sure many of you can see what I mean.

I’ve never been a jealous or resentful person and haven’t compared myself to others. In fact, I’ve always been quite happy plodding on. However, in the last few years, I’ve started to feel a bit resentful as all of my closest friends have been given large sums of money/ inheritance from relatives (some of them multiple handouts). I’ve had lots of back handed compliments about my ‘little house’ and outright nasty ones about how crap modern houses are (mine is modern and was all I could afford at the time). They will openly brag about their large character properties and discuss how they can work reduced hours or not at all due to inheritance and partner’s income. One of my friends hasn’t worked for years and has just been gifted another several hundred thousand pounds so can now afford to buy several other houses. Meanwhile I can’t afford to buy one outright.

I work so bloody hard and never seem to catch a break. I’ve never been given anything monetary like my friends have. One day I may inherit but my father has decided to look after his long term partner first and foremost, so I may never actually inherit. It’s not about the money in that case, as if he spent it all enjoying his inheritance I would be understanding and supportive. Rather, it’s about feeling like an after thought/ not important/ not a priority/ etc.

Anyway, I just want to vent. I feel like I’m destined to slog my guts out, never receive a helping hand like my friends have, and have my nose rubbed in it in the process. I know life is unfair (believe me I know that acutely due to other life/ health events). Just seems unfair that I work the hardest out of all my friends (and I don’t say that lightly) and yet seem to have the hardest time.

Life is hard and life is unfair. But I think you need a pick-me-up.

I'd be dead proud of my daughter if she had achieved what you have, a family, your own home, a stable career with a good pension.

The thief of joy is envy. Try not to compare your position to others, things could be vastly different in 20yrs, they may not have pensions. You should be sorted. That's rather joyous. You also have a varied and social job and that makes it fun. I do understand the job is hard though, not trying to diminish that at all.

But let's also remember everyone generally admires teachers, I am grateful for your service, I couldn't do it, I don't have the patience and it's a fundamentally key worker role training the next generation.

Those with more money may have had a relative die in order to receive it as well. So the circumstances can be heartbreaking for them. There will always be one that gets handed an easy life though, doesn't mean it's a good life, a fulfilling life.

Keep your chin up, I think you're doing remarkably well - fully self made. What a roll model, Well done and kick on and just remember you'll have 25yrs of comfortable retirement. You'll appreciate that a lot when it arrives.

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 22/02/2024 20:10

Isitovernow123 · 22/02/2024 20:07

Why should inheritance be taxed when it has already been taxed at source?

Because it's free money.

laclochette · 22/02/2024 20:09

@Isitovernow123 To prevent massive inequality from developing in society. Taxation is a tool to achieve certain societal outcomes. It can work however it we want it to, depending on the outcomes we seek as a society.

lemmefinish · 22/02/2024 20:09

@Isitovernow123 how have property gains been taxed at source?

IloveAslan · 22/02/2024 20:08

Incidentally, in my small friendship group we have very different financial situations. It doesn't cause hassle because we don't go on about it, and I as a lower earning person in the group don't feel judged at all.

This. I have been renting for the past 21 years, and although I have inherited some money it's too late for me to get a mortgage, and not enough to buy anything outright. All my local friends own property, one is quite wealthy and the others have done very well, but I don't feel judged by them. I'm single, they are all married with families. No-one ever discusses finances.

You need better friends OP. Your current ones sound very unpleasant.

Being jealous of what others have is not a good thing, life isn't fair, but it never has been. We have to work with what we have.

Isitovernow123 · 22/02/2024 20:07

Wizardo · 22/02/2024 16:04

I can’t disagree with your post. It’s not fair. Teaching should be better paid, or less arduous. Inherited wealth should be taxed more at the upper end. Modern houses shouldn’t be so crap (I’ve lived in some poorly built boxes).
my advice is ditch your friends. They sound especially unpleasant. You can definitely do better.

Why should inheritance be taxed when it has already been taxed at source?

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 22/02/2024 20:06

Charlie2121 · 22/02/2024 16:52

Inheritance has become a big divider in society in large part due to the massively inflated property market.

I’ve worked hard to reach a point where I earn a decent 6 figure salary however I have friends of a similar age who are retired, live in far larger houses, have expensive cars and holidays yet have never worked in anything other than low wage jobs.

They are able to do this due to inheritance.

Is it fair that they have a more comfortable life than me? Of course not but unless inheritance tax is 100% it is completely unavoidable.

That said, it is slightly galling that despite working hard to be in the top 1% of earners I am nowhere near the top 1% in terms of spending power, not even close.

Someone on a low wage who inherits a modest property in London will likely be in a better lifetime position financially than someone who earns 100k+ yet never inherits anything.

But you were lucky enough to be born with a good brain, which has enabled you to earn a high salary but also gives you other advantages.

laclochette · 22/02/2024 20:03

@Chanxex that's the wrong comparison.
If I offered someone £1m for their relative to die I would hope nobody would say yes.
But that's not the comparison.
It's, Your relative is going to die. Would you rather they died and left you £1m, or £0. Of course the former is better.

laclochette · 22/02/2024 19:59

@Greenshrub Of course teaching has never been a choice for those who aim to earn the megabucks, but it used to be a profession which offered a secure lifestyle. My mum was a teacher all her life and not even in management because she wanted to stay in the classroom. Her parents were dirt poor and never owned a home. Yet she could buy a house before she was 30. In a crappy bit of London, yes, but all the same, if she were 28 now and a teacher without family money - no chance!

Swipe left for the next trending thread