Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should pedestrian have right of way or car?

38 replies

nurserycarrun · 22/02/2024 12:58

I'll try and be brief - I'm the car. NC because I don't want to be bashed a mean bully car driver that hates pedestrians.

I was pulling out of a side road onto the busier main road. I was turning right. I'm the blue car with red arrow.

I did see two men (yellow) walking up the road but presumed they would use the zebra crossing right behind where my car was (orange)

Just as I was about to turn onto the road they walked in front of my car. One sort of threw up his arms in a 'watch where you are going' jesture.

Was I in the wrong? I'm in Ireland, google tells me "Ireland has a jaywalking law that says that if you are within 50 metres of a pedestrian crossing you must use it to cross." now I actually didn't know that until I googled it. But surely common sense would mean as a pedestrian you shouldn't walk in front of a car about to turn?

As a pedestrian I always walk behind the 1st car waiting at a junction

YABU - Pedestrian was right
YANBU - Pedestrian should walk behind the car

Should pedestrian have right of way or car?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Yazo · 22/02/2024 21:38

There are some men that just love to have a go at a woman, no-one was hurt and you obviously saw them, it's very weird to cross infront of a car turning right at a junction. Not that long ago I was turning into a side road, there was a man crossing but he was most of the way across when I pulled into the road very slowly/crawl and he went crazy at me shouting and telling me to read the highway code. There was no need! Don't worry

notthatkindofFatCat · 22/02/2024 21:26

MargaretThursday · 22/02/2024 16:53

Here lies the body
Of William Jay,
Who died maintaining
His right of way.
He was in the right
As he walked along,
But he’s just as dead
As if he’d been wrong.

As a car or a pedestrian you should be checking first and not assuming right of way or anything else.
But the only time I've been in an accident was at traffic lights that weren't working, and I stopped because a pedestrian stepped out in front of me, and the car behind went into my back. It was classed as the car behind's fault.

I was always told it by my mum as:

This is the story of Daniel Day who died defending his ROW
His rights were clear, his will was strong
and he's just as dead as if he'd been wrong.

(Clearly wouldn't be telling it to someone who'd had an accident or a bereaved family but then you never suggested one might either)

nurserycarrun · 22/02/2024 19:18

So this evening about 20 teenagers (must have been something on late in school) crossed the road while I was waiting to go onto the main road. Not 1 of them walked around the car in front, they all walked behind the front car.

@mathanxiety he did give me a smarmy grin sort of look as well which I think is why this stuck in my mind. I've had people run across the road in front of me, had people absently walk out in front of me, cars pull out without warning etc. As a pedestrian I once grabbed someone who staring at their phone nearly walked out in front of a bus! I think that's why I've posted and that's why it bothered me.

Anyway, I'm going to park it 😏legally I don't know who would have been wrong, morally if I had kept going after realising they were going to walk in front of me would have been abhorrent, common sense though I think they should have walked behind my car which was moving at the time. As a pedestrian with a desire to live that's what I'd do.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 22/02/2024 17:18

YANBU.

The men were being aggressive with a female driver, showing you who owns the road (hint, not you).

They should have gone behind your car and used the pedestrian crossing. But my guess is that that approach lacked the attraction of getting a rise out of a female driver and would have made them feel inferior to you.

Everyone using a road has a responsibility to use it safely.

Rosestulips · 22/02/2024 17:17

ZebraPensAreLife · 22/02/2024 17:07

I think that was the point ditalini was trying to make!

yes I think you might be right 😂 sorry😊

ZebraPensAreLife · 22/02/2024 17:07

Rosestulips · 22/02/2024 17:05

It says right there in the OP that driver is in Ireland.

I think that was the point ditalini was trying to make!

Rosestulips · 22/02/2024 17:05

ditalini · 22/02/2024 16:24

YABU for not putting I'M IN IRELAND WHERE THE UK RULES OF THE ROAD AS DETAILED IN THE HIGHWAY CODE DON'T NECESSARILY APPLY as an image attachment with flashing lights for the MN "I only read the title" crowd.

It says right there in the OP that driver is in Ireland.

RWEnough · 22/02/2024 16:55

MargaretThursday · 22/02/2024 16:53

Here lies the body
Of William Jay,
Who died maintaining
His right of way.
He was in the right
As he walked along,
But he’s just as dead
As if he’d been wrong.

As a car or a pedestrian you should be checking first and not assuming right of way or anything else.
But the only time I've been in an accident was at traffic lights that weren't working, and I stopped because a pedestrian stepped out in front of me, and the car behind went into my back. It was classed as the car behind's fault.

Would you say that poem to the family of the woman who died in this accident?

https://www.itv.com/news/meridian/2023-10-11/man-who-hit-devoted-grandmother-on-pedestrian-crossing-jailed

Victim blaming horseshit, as usual.

MargaretThursday · 22/02/2024 16:53

Here lies the body
Of William Jay,
Who died maintaining
His right of way.
He was in the right
As he walked along,
But he’s just as dead
As if he’d been wrong.

As a car or a pedestrian you should be checking first and not assuming right of way or anything else.
But the only time I've been in an accident was at traffic lights that weren't working, and I stopped because a pedestrian stepped out in front of me, and the car behind went into my back. It was classed as the car behind's fault.

Slanabhaile · 22/02/2024 16:49

ditalini · 22/02/2024 16:24

YABU for not putting I'M IN IRELAND WHERE THE UK RULES OF THE ROAD AS DETAILED IN THE HIGHWAY CODE DON'T NECESSARILY APPLY as an image attachment with flashing lights for the MN "I only read the title" crowd.

Perhaps this on all posts by a poster in Ireland???

St Patricks Day Illustration GIF by Curtains Cool
Slanabhaile · 22/02/2024 16:46

Isthisexpected · 22/02/2024 14:27

The UK government decided not to pay for a public awareness campaign so most people don't know this and continue to beep their horns when I say it's my right of way (as the pedestrian).

YABU not to read the highway code

IRELAND 🇮🇪 is a different country and is NOT part of the UK. There is no highway code to read.
@Isthisexpected YABU to not know this, or not read the op to understand this.

ditalini · 22/02/2024 16:24

YABU for not putting I'M IN IRELAND WHERE THE UK RULES OF THE ROAD AS DETAILED IN THE HIGHWAY CODE DON'T NECESSARILY APPLY as an image attachment with flashing lights for the MN "I only read the title" crowd.

nurserycarrun · 22/02/2024 16:18

Mixed bag, and I do take on board what people are saying. The road is right by a secondary school, this was outside school time and they were adults not teens.

The dark black is the path from the town.

Green is the school with an island where parents can pull in to park for drop off.

Also added in some black blocks between the road and the zebra crossing - these are big square concrete planter things, to keep the cars going around the island correctly I guess but also block it to lead the pedestrians to the crossing. I know it's normal to take the shortest route so they probably walked over the island and through the planters. There is a correct word for that, like the little paths your see through grass around places instead of using the built path

@TeresaCrowd as a pedestrian that is exactly what I do, I go behind the 1st car and cross there. The junction can be difficult to get out at, and normally that's what people do, go behind the 1st car. Not actually walk out on the main road to go around the car moving into the main road. And thanks, for noticing I did observe them and stop, of course I would never want to hit anyone. Some people are making it out like I was there revving my engine aiming to mow down people!!

Zebra crossings have been springing up everywhere around here the last few years but many people still don't use them.

Anyway, I've go use that road again!

Should pedestrian have right of way or car?
OP posts:
Createausername1970 · 22/02/2024 15:58

I am both pedestrian and car user. I know there are times that as a pedestrian I have right if way, but my entire attention is on what the car is doing. I also know that as a driver my attention will be split between looking at what the traffic is doing and looking at what the pedestrian is doing.

So it might have the right of way as a pedestrian but I usually chose to waive it and let the car go and get out of my way, unless I have made eye contact with the driver and know they have seen me and are aware of what I am doing.

Having right of way doesn't mean you shouldn't take sensible precautions.

Personally, those pedestrians in the diagram should have crossed behind the car.

TeresaCrowd · 22/02/2024 15:48

Technically once they step foot in the road the pedestrian has priority however you'd be dumb not to cross at the crossing.

What I will say though is that where I am, there are drop kerb crossings at most junctions, with enough room for the first car to fit ahead of the crossing (so you cross between car 1 and car 2 in the queue to pull out) which makes sense to me because the car pulling out needs to be paying more attention to both lanes of moving traffic etc whereas car 2 is still just trying to not hit the car in front of it so can be even more watchful of pedestrians, yet so many 'car 2's' pull right up the arse of car 1 and block the space for the people to cross rather than leaving the drop kerb clear. I am stubborn so I'll probably force myself infront of the car, but if it was someone with a wheelchair waiting, or a cyclist (most are shared use paths here) waiting then you'd be stuck. Again it just comes back to situational awareness of the person in the car, which in many many cases is sadly lacking nowadays. (not saying in your case OP, you were doing exactly what I'd do, and you didn't hit the people either due to your observation)

(this does not absolve car 1 of having to look for peds etc before I get jumped on, just that if you can move most of that traffic away from the actual junction it makes sense)

Bluevelvetsofa · 22/02/2024 14:43

JM = jam.

Bluevelvetsofa · 22/02/2024 14:43

Yes, the pedestrian has priority, but, as there was a zebra crossing very close by, it would have been sensible to use that.

The problem with allowing priority to pedestrians when, as a driver, you are entering a side road from a main road, is that the main road has more traffic and stopping on the main road to allow someone to cross means that you have to rely that the cars behind you are observant. Otherwise, that causes a JM or an accident.

DamnSpots · 22/02/2024 14:33

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 22/02/2024 14:32

Presumably the Highway Code still applies there?
It says clearly pedestrians should be given priority. You were in the wrong.

Why would the Highway Code, for the UK, apply in Ireland where the OP is?

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 22/02/2024 14:32

Presumably the Highway Code still applies there?
It says clearly pedestrians should be given priority. You were in the wrong.

Dearg · 22/02/2024 14:30

Don’t know about rules in Ireland, but I am in Scotland and, in common with England, pedestrian is always given priority. Even if they are not being logical.

Isthisexpected · 22/02/2024 14:27

BellaPoldark · 22/02/2024 13:37

In the UK, updates to the Highway code made in 2022 give the pedestrian right of way in this instance: https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/advice/legal/new-highway-code-rules-what-you-need-to-know/

The UK government decided not to pay for a public awareness campaign so most people don't know this and continue to beep their horns when I say it's my right of way (as the pedestrian).

YABU not to read the highway code

Lifeinlists · 22/02/2024 14:25

People do just wander in front of cars etc without really paying attention. And behind when you're reversing.
Of course the driver needs to be alert always but I can see why it irritated you.

Some people seem to lack the self preservation gene so you have to grit your teeth and wait.

Barneysma2 · 22/02/2024 14:18

In my eyes the pedestrian was at fault. Yes there are more rules now about giving way but like someone else has said, pedestrians need to take some responsibility for their own safety. Common sense just seems to be lacking these days. What normal person would think oh i know I will walk out in front of this car that is quite clearly about to move off any second into the main road. They should have used the crossing. Not once when I have been out walking and seen a car pull up at a junction do I think I will just walk in front of it how stupid. I always walk behind it.

dazzlingdeborahrose · 22/02/2024 14:11

Changes to the highway code require drivers to give way more often but don't absolve the pedestrian of responsibility for their own safety. In this case the pedestrians walked in front of a car already manoeuvring and already in the main road forcing them to stop. As a driver I would gave waited to see what they were going to do. As a pedestrian I would have used the crossing provided. The OP shouldn't have assumed but the pedestrians shouldn't have crossed in the way they did. I'd rather be wrong and alive than right and dead.

midgetastic · 22/02/2024 13:54

The car should be stopping for the junction anyway ?

So the person sitting on their arse should wait for the person walking

Swipe left for the next trending thread