Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU it's nearly impossible to break into IT industry if you don't have previous experience?

61 replies

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 12:20

I'm a project manager working in engineering/manufacturing. I want to switch to IT as it's easier to commute to London where most of the IT sector jobs are offered and would appreciate flexible hybrid working hours which is very common in IT.

But since I started looking at the job boards on several websites, nearly every single job post in IT requires:

  • either experiences in software development
  • or certain particular technology/software/platform, some specific skills

I just don't see how it's possible even to be considered for a chance. Am I wrong?

I'm very capable in what I'm doing in my current industry. But even with the experience to manage technical (engineering) contents, I can't see how I could even go through the first stage screening just by key words and the lack of those particular skills.

Thinking back previous job hunting experiences, I often had similar impression. The particular "basic requirements" are very specific to meet unless you are already at that level within that environment. It seems more so in the IT.

My understanding is that maybe the talent pool in IT is vast and people constantly move around. So maybe because of this, the employers are always able to find enough right candidates who meet those criteria?

Stretching the truth can be an option to reach the interview stage. But then what? If I don't have the experience, then I don't. I feel very uncomfortable to bend the truth. But then for all those jobs out there, are all viable applicants good matches?

OP posts:
Shivermetimbers0112 · 22/02/2024 15:09

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 14:49

You stated I was jumping down OP's throat - and I said that... guess you can't be bothered to read whatever you're replying to.
In all honesty, I'm not sure why you're even on this thread. You gave a generic comment about professional occupations - looks like you don't know anything about being a PM in the IT industry. You then proceeded to reply to my posts. Whatever you think of my manner, I work in this industry and am giving OP actual useful advice.
Maybe actually contribute something useful too, or find some other thread to comment on? :) Have a good day.

I suggest you read your original post again and reflect on its tone. And I’ll comment on any thread I choose to thanks. You have a lovely day too.

ancienticecream · 22/02/2024 15:04

What about a product manager? You'll still be within IT and working with software engineers. IT experience is a bonus, not an essential.

Requirements aren't always requirements, don't let it put you off. Why not approach a recruiter for a company and have a chat?

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 14:58

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 14:35

Sorry if I over-reacted. I just think it's a bit unfair to say I just thought I could walk across the sector barriers with ease. I didn't, I was aware of it. My original post did not point out I have been dreading it for ages, just because I'm aware it wouldn't be easy to start at least even if I get an offer.

Points are taken and appreciate the suggestions and insights.

Ultimately OP, IT is difficult because of the double edged sword of having no standards. That means anybody can enter. But also, new entrants don't know what they have to do! I'll be honest most people who change successfully have inside knowledge. Not by contacts getting them a job. But their knowledge is drawn from others' personal experience , demonstrating an understanding of what the job is actually like. That's why I am focusing on you talking to current PM's.

Even for 'technical' roles skills inflation is very common. Sometimes the JD's are written by HR, who don't really know what is needed, so put a lot of buzzwords in. Other times, hiring managers don't know what the market is like, or are greedy and want a unicorn, etc etc.

If you understand what the job requires, you will understand whether a certain skills is there for decoration, or something you can pick up on the job. Defining your application strategy is a key, also how much you're willing to move for, etc.

Also, there's nothing stopping you from applying now, maybe with Indeed/LinkedIn (forgot which) Easy Apply. What have you got to lose? You might even get an interview. Nothing ventured, nothing gained. The key for me was your original question was were you U to wonder about these jobs having these requirements. Because, well, there is no PM job in the world that's going to be generic, is it? Again, thinking of your own job. If you reverse the situation... what would your idea of an 'IT PM' need to do your job?

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 14:49

Shivermetimbers0112 · 22/02/2024 14:32

Where exactly was I getting “emotional” Opal? You seem to be the one taking umbrage.

You stated I was jumping down OP's throat - and I said that... guess you can't be bothered to read whatever you're replying to.
In all honesty, I'm not sure why you're even on this thread. You gave a generic comment about professional occupations - looks like you don't know anything about being a PM in the IT industry. You then proceeded to reply to my posts. Whatever you think of my manner, I work in this industry and am giving OP actual useful advice.
Maybe actually contribute something useful too, or find some other thread to comment on? :) Have a good day.

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 14:35

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 14:26

I'm not sure why you and @Shivermetimbers0112 are getting very emotional. PP is trying to defend you from me 'jumping down your throat' and you think I'm upset... you need to have a thicker skin to work in IT. Especially as, many technical people don't like project managers.

You've also ignored the actual advice I gave which is that. Project management in IT is vast. Not just that, the field of 'non-technical' roles that utilise project management skills, is also very big. A PP mentioned buzzwords, which is true. But also, there are a lot of roles with similar job titles which do vastly different things.

As I mentioned, transformation manager is one example, governance is another. A PP mentioned 'project office' but not all firms have it, or even if they do, call it another name.

Using your DH connections isn't wrong. It's an effective way to get what you want. And, you are not asking for a job, just an insight from people actually working in the industry. If you want to 'make your own way', then go to MeetUps, message people on LinkedIn. But you really need to talk to those in the industry. Just reading JD's won't be of any use, as we don't know what specific type of project management job in IT it is, that you're looking for.

If you want to post some here happy to comment.

Sorry if I over-reacted. I just think it's a bit unfair to say I just thought I could walk across the sector barriers with ease. I didn't, I was aware of it. My original post did not point out I have been dreading it for ages, just because I'm aware it wouldn't be easy to start at least even if I get an offer.

Points are taken and appreciate the suggestions and insights.

OP posts:
Shivermetimbers0112 · 22/02/2024 14:32

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 14:26

I'm not sure why you and @Shivermetimbers0112 are getting very emotional. PP is trying to defend you from me 'jumping down your throat' and you think I'm upset... you need to have a thicker skin to work in IT. Especially as, many technical people don't like project managers.

You've also ignored the actual advice I gave which is that. Project management in IT is vast. Not just that, the field of 'non-technical' roles that utilise project management skills, is also very big. A PP mentioned buzzwords, which is true. But also, there are a lot of roles with similar job titles which do vastly different things.

As I mentioned, transformation manager is one example, governance is another. A PP mentioned 'project office' but not all firms have it, or even if they do, call it another name.

Using your DH connections isn't wrong. It's an effective way to get what you want. And, you are not asking for a job, just an insight from people actually working in the industry. If you want to 'make your own way', then go to MeetUps, message people on LinkedIn. But you really need to talk to those in the industry. Just reading JD's won't be of any use, as we don't know what specific type of project management job in IT it is, that you're looking for.

If you want to post some here happy to comment.

Where exactly was I getting “emotional” Opal? You seem to be the one taking umbrage.

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 14:26

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 14:18

Again, what you said it's an ideal scenario. I've seen enough in my employment years of people who are not right for the job - more than 50% I'd say. The higher it goes, the more it's true.

I was willing to learn previously because of genuine interest. I wasn't sure and still not sure I can migrate the same passion to IT. Thanks to other helpful shared experiences, I do realise if I don't want to learn about technology or a certain aspect of it, I'd better stay out of it.

Is it my acknowledgement of this upsets you?

Why kept mentioning my DH? He's a type of people thinking entirely differently than me and he's a firm believer of learning adapting. So he believes I do do well if I get a chance. I prefer to find my own way without using his connections if I can.

I'm not sure why you and @Shivermetimbers0112 are getting very emotional. PP is trying to defend you from me 'jumping down your throat' and you think I'm upset... you need to have a thicker skin to work in IT. Especially as, many technical people don't like project managers.

You've also ignored the actual advice I gave which is that. Project management in IT is vast. Not just that, the field of 'non-technical' roles that utilise project management skills, is also very big. A PP mentioned buzzwords, which is true. But also, there are a lot of roles with similar job titles which do vastly different things.

As I mentioned, transformation manager is one example, governance is another. A PP mentioned 'project office' but not all firms have it, or even if they do, call it another name.

Using your DH connections isn't wrong. It's an effective way to get what you want. And, you are not asking for a job, just an insight from people actually working in the industry. If you want to 'make your own way', then go to MeetUps, message people on LinkedIn. But you really need to talk to those in the industry. Just reading JD's won't be of any use, as we don't know what specific type of project management job in IT it is, that you're looking for.

If you want to post some here happy to comment.

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 14:18

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 14:10

And your very intelligent point is...?
The OP is in a good position. As her DH works in the industry she has a golden opportunity to talk to those in the field. All she's spoken about so far is looking things up online, and asking on MN.
She has also said that she doesn't want to learn things from scratch. Where does that leave us?

OP stated that she learnt on the job. That's fair enough if she worked her way up. But her post makes it seem that she wants to move sideways, not downwards.

I was in PMO, and then a PM before I became an engineer and unlike in , say civil engineering anybody can enter the industry. My colleagues came (and still do) from all sorts of backgrounds. Including manufacturing! But it needs the right role. Obviously a 'technical PM' who needs to know what they're doing is difference from a general 'PM' role whose job mainly involves chasing people and updating stakeholders.

None of us here can give general advice unless it relates to a specific job description. There are also 'related' things like Change Management, Transformation management etc etc that would utilise a PM skillset.

Edited

Again, what you said it's an ideal scenario. I've seen enough in my employment years of people who are not right for the job - more than 50% I'd say. The higher it goes, the more it's true.

I was willing to learn previously because of genuine interest. I wasn't sure and still not sure I can migrate the same passion to IT. Thanks to other helpful shared experiences, I do realise if I don't want to learn about technology or a certain aspect of it, I'd better stay out of it.

Is it my acknowledgement of this upsets you?

Why kept mentioning my DH? He's a type of people thinking entirely differently than me and he's a firm believer of learning adapting. So he believes I do do well if I get a chance. I prefer to find my own way without using his connections if I can.

OP posts:
Shivermetimbers0112 · 22/02/2024 14:17

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 14:10

And your very intelligent point is...?
The OP is in a good position. As her DH works in the industry she has a golden opportunity to talk to those in the field. All she's spoken about so far is looking things up online, and asking on MN.
She has also said that she doesn't want to learn things from scratch. Where does that leave us?

OP stated that she learnt on the job. That's fair enough if she worked her way up. But her post makes it seem that she wants to move sideways, not downwards.

I was in PMO, and then a PM before I became an engineer and unlike in , say civil engineering anybody can enter the industry. My colleagues came (and still do) from all sorts of backgrounds. Including manufacturing! But it needs the right role. Obviously a 'technical PM' who needs to know what they're doing is difference from a general 'PM' role whose job mainly involves chasing people and updating stakeholders.

None of us here can give general advice unless it relates to a specific job description. There are also 'related' things like Change Management, Transformation management etc etc that would utilise a PM skillset.

Edited

Simply pointing out that you were effectively jumping down her throat when others had already made the substantive points and she’d acknowledged them….

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 14:11

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 13:53

YABVVU to be shocked that an IT PM requires 'IT' skills. Do you think that you should be able to walk into, say a construction PM job without any knowledge of the required skills?

IT is the easiest field to break into but you need to be willing to learn and start at a lower level. You however want a job commensurate with your 'experienced PM' status. Of course, you can just apply, but unless a company's desperate I don't see why they should hire you. Think about your current job - can you simply be replaced with an IT project manager?

I'm a software developer and 'project management' is vast. There are technical PM's, those focused on delivery, others on governance, etc. As a PP said there's also PMO, which does risk and finances, separate from the PM's who are interfacing with various stakeholders in order to get things going.

Your 'DH' should have explained all this surely? Or have contacts? talk to them

Edited

Thanks for the harsh comments.

You are right, everyone has to start somewhere. Sometimes, it means lower levels or overlapping fields, like PO suggested by someone.

No need to bash me for being unrealistic😅. Some poster has already suggested those without certain IT experience do exist. We live in a real world where a lot is involved to have someone hired. And sometimes they may not be the right candidate, even if they have the right CV.

I wrote this thread to understand the situation and I'm glad I did, as I learned a lot first hand information. I'm grateful.

OP posts:
ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 14:10

Shivermetimbers0112 · 22/02/2024 13:56

It’s not a long thread to read and the Op has clearly been listening to and thinking about the advice suggested to her……

And your very intelligent point is...?
The OP is in a good position. As her DH works in the industry she has a golden opportunity to talk to those in the field. All she's spoken about so far is looking things up online, and asking on MN.
She has also said that she doesn't want to learn things from scratch. Where does that leave us?

OP stated that she learnt on the job. That's fair enough if she worked her way up. But her post makes it seem that she wants to move sideways, not downwards.

I was in PMO, and then a PM before I became an engineer and unlike in , say civil engineering anybody can enter the industry. My colleagues came (and still do) from all sorts of backgrounds. Including manufacturing! But it needs the right role. Obviously a 'technical PM' who needs to know what they're doing is difference from a general 'PM' role whose job mainly involves chasing people and updating stakeholders.

None of us here can give general advice unless it relates to a specific job description. There are also 'related' things like Change Management, Transformation management etc etc that would utilise a PM skillset.

Shivermetimbers0112 · 22/02/2024 13:56

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 13:53

YABVVU to be shocked that an IT PM requires 'IT' skills. Do you think that you should be able to walk into, say a construction PM job without any knowledge of the required skills?

IT is the easiest field to break into but you need to be willing to learn and start at a lower level. You however want a job commensurate with your 'experienced PM' status. Of course, you can just apply, but unless a company's desperate I don't see why they should hire you. Think about your current job - can you simply be replaced with an IT project manager?

I'm a software developer and 'project management' is vast. There are technical PM's, those focused on delivery, others on governance, etc. As a PP said there's also PMO, which does risk and finances, separate from the PM's who are interfacing with various stakeholders in order to get things going.

Your 'DH' should have explained all this surely? Or have contacts? talk to them

Edited

It’s not a long thread to read and the Op has clearly been listening to and thinking about the advice suggested to her……

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 13:53

YABVVU to be shocked that an IT PM requires 'IT' skills. Do you think that you should be able to walk into, say a construction PM job without any knowledge of the required skills?

IT is the easiest field to break into but you need to be willing to learn and start at a lower level. You however want a job commensurate with your 'experienced PM' status. Of course, you can just apply, but unless a company's desperate I don't see why they should hire you. Think about your current job - can you simply be replaced with an IT project manager?

I'm a software developer and 'project management' is vast. There are technical PM's, those focused on delivery, others on governance, etc. As a PP said there's also PMO, which does risk and finances, separate from the PM's who are interfacing with various stakeholders in order to get things going.

Your 'DH' should have explained all this surely? Or have contacts? talk to them

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 13:39

Ifailed · 22/02/2024 13:36

@jobsearching2024,
in my experience the Project office (or PMO), was not directly involved in the delivery of a project, but rather they oversaw how projects were running, would keep track of the plan v actual both financially and deliverables. There had a role to act as a hub for project oversight, governance, and support, ensuring that projects are executed according to that organisations methodology etc.

It was quite common for people to start of in the Project Office and then move into project management or business analysis as they became familiar with the jargon, culture etc.

Thanks for taking the time to explain! Sounds interesting. I will look it up!

OP posts:
jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 13:38

arejcenencehche3uh9f3 · 22/02/2024 13:28

I was a software developer for over 20 years and came across a lot of project managers who didn't have IT experience (and most of them weren't very good), but that was mostly in one job where the company business was healthcare. My other jobs have been working for tech or defence companies and it was rare to encounter PMs without IT experience there.

Then again in my last job, the development manager had no software development experience, which was a first.

I understand it can be disheartening to have someone who's suppose to organise and support what you do, but is lack of the experience.

Sometimes, it can be made up if they are willing to make the efforts to learn and make the right decision by truly establishing a solid relationship with their team and others. I came a long way from a completely different field and went through quite a different disciplines in business. When I started working with engineerings, I had absolutely zero technical knowledge. But I reached out to learn proactively and I found engineers are the easiest to get along with and they don't judge when they "mentored" me from the basic. I truly enjoyed the experience of my own development to where I am today.

But I know unfortunately, what drives each individual is different. A lot would rather hide their lack of knowledge and try really hard to establish their authority/image. It can be very detrimental to the team's result.

I don't want to be one of those and I'm not sure I still have the capacity to learn everything in IT from the basic. With engineering/manufacturing, funnily, I didn't start from scratch. as I had what I learned from school to back me up - physics, chemistry and maths! 😆

OP posts:
Ifailed · 22/02/2024 13:36

@jobsearching2024,
in my experience the Project office (or PMO), was not directly involved in the delivery of a project, but rather they oversaw how projects were running, would keep track of the plan v actual both financially and deliverables. There had a role to act as a hub for project oversight, governance, and support, ensuring that projects are executed according to that organisations methodology etc.

It was quite common for people to start of in the Project Office and then move into project management or business analysis as they became familiar with the jargon, culture etc.

arejcenencehche3uh9f3 · 22/02/2024 13:28

I was a software developer for over 20 years and came across a lot of project managers who didn't have IT experience (and most of them weren't very good), but that was mostly in one job where the company business was healthcare. My other jobs have been working for tech or defence companies and it was rare to encounter PMs without IT experience there.

Then again in my last job, the development manager had no software development experience, which was a first.

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 13:27

Ifailed · 22/02/2024 13:22

OP, have you tried looking for roles in the Project Office of other sectors?

Can you articulate a bit more please? Do you mean IT department within an organisation or PO is some more particular IT domain?

OP posts:
ExtraOnions · 22/02/2024 13:26

I recruit into Digital … you need to cast your net a bit wider, and look at Digital Project Manger roles. You don’t always need a specific technology, just have strong PM skills.

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 13:24

Anameisaname · 22/02/2024 13:22

Hey OP. I've 30 years in the IT industry and I recruit a lot of PMs and lead IT projects.

Although some of the skills are transferable, I've found that non IT PMs are not great at managing IT projects if I'm honest. So yes I always look for IT experience in honesty.

The best bet is to see if you can try to get involved in an IT project in your field of expertise. That's a great way to start as ypu bring the expertise from your sector

Edited

Thanks for the confirmation of what I thought. It's good to hear it from someone who has the first hand experience of hiring.

Also a good suggestion of getting involved in IT projects within my field. Next time, I'd volunteer to be part of the development team if they allow me!😝

OP posts:
Ifailed · 22/02/2024 13:22

OP, have you tried looking for roles in the Project Office of other sectors?

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 13:22

Ifailed · 22/02/2024 13:21

PRINCE2 is not just used in IT. However as PP have pointed out lack of knowledge of the jargon of a particular industry, such as IT, can be a barrier.

Yes, I do have the cert. It's the barrier of basic knowledge and the jargons that I fear. Probably even a bit of lack of passion...

OP posts:
Anameisaname · 22/02/2024 13:22

Hey OP. I've 30 years in the IT industry and I recruit a lot of PMs and lead IT projects.

Although some of the skills are transferable, I've found that non IT PMs are not great at managing IT projects if I'm honest. So yes I always look for IT experience in honesty.

The best bet is to see if you can try to get involved in an IT project in your field of expertise. That's a great way to start as ypu bring the expertise from your sector

Ifailed · 22/02/2024 13:21

PRINCE2 is not just used in IT. However as PP have pointed out lack of knowledge of the jargon of a particular industry, such as IT, can be a barrier.

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 13:21

Toadonaroll · 22/02/2024 12:37

Could you move sideaways within your own industry? We would recruit admin and similar staff into business analysis etc roles if they showed an interest in IT and were logical and organised e.g. in user testing, or working with analysts on processes and development of new software. From this rather would gain exposure to IT skills.

That would be a good suggestion years ago. At one point, I did consider it seriously and thought I'd enjoy the contents of responsibility. But I think I passed that point to start from business analyst.

I did enjoy PM in industrial environment and I think I will keep looking for one that offers a better life/work balance. Hopefully not too difficult...

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread